Short-term let owners and operators gathered in
#Edinburgh
on Tuesday to rally against new rules they say will “wipe out” the sector and destroy businesses.
#SaveSC
The ASSC welcomes this judgment from Lord Braid which not only has profound implications for Edinburgh, but short-term let policy across Scotland.
@ASSCnews
@SaveSCScotland
1/6
This is a crisis of political incompetence, hubris & unwillingness to listen at any stage to the concerns of professional self catering operators who repeatedly flagged failings.
#SaveSC
@scotgov
@Edinburgh_CC
2nd unlawful ruling for
@Edinburgh_CC
'drives coach & horses through council crackdown'. Councillor Phil Doggart said in light of the decision the licensing scheme should be paused completely “before we do something else ridiculously stupid.”
#SaveSC
1/ Voters are being fed a tall tale that destroying
#Edinburgh
's proud tradition of self-catering 'will solve affordable housing'. It won't.
@CllrChasBooth
& Green claims need to be properly critiqued. Imaginary economics will not solve a housing crisis.
#SaveSC
Your grassroots support got us here: you've donated over £300,000 to the legal fighting fund challenging
#Edinburgh
City Council's effort to exterminate its local
#selfcatering
sector & people who rely on it. Thank you.
#SaveSC
@st_alliance
@ASSCnews
@PLACEEdinburgh
If by achievement you mean job losses & price rises, bringing in foreign ownership of city brownfield for aparthotels not homes & a bunker oil-burning ship to sail away with the cash this summer, it's a bullseye.
#SaveSC
@Mike_Blackley
Has it not occured to
@theSNP
that we are no longer permitted in
#Scotland
to give use of a spare room without necessary health & safety checks & a licence? The law covers everyone & everything except aparthotels & docked bunker oil burning boats & campervans
#SaveSC
@ASSCnews
Why do people in public office think it's ok to reinterpret recent history to totally change events to suit their narrative? Let's work on facts, not fantasy.
#SaveSC
@AlysGreens
this is either based on ignorance of the S/C sector's many efforts to constructively engage with both the
@Scotgov
&
@edinburgh_CC
which were repeatedly brushed off, or you are trying to reinvent history.
#SaveSC
After claiming
#Scotland
's capital was overrun with S/C
@susan4leithwalk
quotes a number approx 1/10th of past numbers yet seems determined to see every local operator put out of business. What's her master plan for Edinburgh,
@edfringe
, tourism & temp workers?
#SaveSC
#business
Looks like
@cllrcammyday
has had his wrist slapped. Shame. Finding compromise when you're killing off an entire sector isn't, we feel, a bad option, especially when you're making taxpayers liable for millions in loss of earnings actions.
#SaveSC
Interesting how few houses
@Edinburgh_CC
has built whilst claiming it cares about the affordable housing crisis. Maybe stop allowing brownfield to go to aparthotels/student flats & build affordable homes instead.
#SaveSC
#Hypocrisy
@cllrcammyday
1/ What are the 14 Red Flags recently highlighted when the
@ASSCnews
met with
@PaulMcLennan7
at the
@Scotgov
... Clarify planning is where a material change of use has occurred, unless in a Planning Control Area, & not applied retrospectively
Just remember
@edinburgh_CC
is now a hotel operator & in bed with aparthotel operators in council owned estate. There is always a driver behind decisions being made. Follow the money.
#SaveSC
@cllrcammyday
@scotgov
Ralph speaks about short stay accommodation arguing it will have no measurable impact on affordable housing. That will only be solved by building affordable homes; 130k in the next 7 years. Will the
@Scotgov
achieve it?
#SaveSC
Short-let licensing is a high-stakes experiment, nothing more - Andy Fenner. Next month a grand experiment will be unleashed in Scotland as an enormously expensive licensing scheme for short-term lets comes into force.
#SaveSC
@scotgov
@PaulMcLennan7
It's clear
@edinburgh_cc
is using the cloak of
#planning
in bad faith to retrospectively axe nearly all existing local S/C operators in the city. Game plan hiding in plain sight.
#SaveSC
In a sensible country, the plan at the heart of this legal challenge would be paused until the outcome was known, especially as it could cause a huge financial headache for LAs if they are sued after the fact of loss of earnings. Just saying...
#SaveSC
Short term lets decision “must be appealed”
If appealed it will almost certainly fail & cost taxpayers yet more money that should be spent on affordable homes & bringing the 7,600 properties in disuse back into
@Edinburgh_CC
housing stock.
@EdinReporter
@DickinsEdin
@scotgov
Lets focus on the issues before us and not the individuals. Thousands of local Scottish S/C & B&B operators are on the brink of being axed or forced out of their livelihoods by draconian legislation. That's the issue at debate.
#SaveSC
There's an obsession with using 'Airbnb' in every headline yet it's local people running local businesses not a remote wealthy corporation untouched by ill thought, now unlawful, licensing legislation. We are S/C operators, not landlords.
#SaveSC
@ASSCnews
@PascUK
@ISCFederation
"So, the hotel lobby got rid of the little short term lets, self-catering and the like to create demand for their new hotels. How many back handers were involved in this?"
#SaveSC
@brianjaffa
Brian all the data is in... real data. You have been wrong on every point of fact & simply aided in making Edinburgh's festivals more untenable for performers, visitors & temp workers who can ill afford hotels.
#SaveSC
@ASSCnews
@ETAG_UK
@EdFringeSociety
The SNP is launching draconian new rules for landlords. So what, you say? Just wait till you go to book that lovely B&B again for next summer... and find it shut for good
#SaveSC
@newsandpics
How absolutely tragic. Another pension / livelihood lost to
#STL
legislation. Another property lying empty for family and friends. No demonstrable benefit whatsoever.
@SaveSCScotland
@ASSCnews
@ScotBandBassoc
"There are 3x as many empty homes as short-term lets in Edinburgh but the latter have always been used as a convenient scapegoat despite substantially benefiting the local economy & helping the Festivals be the undoubted success they are"
#SaveSC
@AngusRobertson
produces a work of fiction. This is why Scottish short-stay tourism is in crisis - no-one bothered to gather truthful data before legislating. We are basing policy on smoke & mirrors.
#SaveSC
"For the first 48 years we put
#Scotland
first ... Now we are bedfellows with a party that disapproves of what many if not most of our people do for a living, & wish to decimate our economy whilst increasingly controlling our lives"
#SaveSC
@PaulMcLennan7
Policy Adviser Simon Ovenden shares his frustrations relating to
@Scotgov
’s
#STL
licensing legislation & the potential damage awaiting not just the short-term lets sector in Scotland, but potentially the whole tourism offering across Scotland.
#SaveSC
@SaveSCScotland
@Edinburgh_CC
This quote says it all.
And, practically speaking, how on earth was an already-stretched planning department supposed to cope with the extra work? Registration and a code of conduct are sensible, but “pay us thousands to refuse you” is nonsense. No wonder so few applied.
"...completely unnecessary pain inflicted upon the Scottish business sector by
@scotgov
, which from the beginning of October is set to be at a massive competitive disadvantage compared to the rest of the United Kingdom"
#SaveSC
What happened to joined-up thinking? Wiping out a few thousand S/C operators, vital to tourism & a mobile workforce will make no difference to affordable housing yet do huge economic harm. This will actually make things far worse than they already are.
#SaveSC
@ASSCnews
@scotgov
August 31st 3,192 licenses granted - 9.2% of (one of many
@Scotgov
) estimated STLs. A further 3,131 tied up in planning, CRB checks, neighbour objections, Council systems crashing, various different floor plan requirements … it's a mess.
#SaveSC
This is an example of the quite unnecessary overreach embodied in
#STL
Licensing. The fault for its lack of timely course correction falls to the
@scotgov
's
@PaulMcLennan7
@RichardLochhead
who had ample opportunity to resolve this but to date have refused to act.
#SaveSC
Disabled with a live in carer? From 1st Oct you need a short term let license for your property.
Thanks to recent legislation many Scots are now at risk of being fined and criminalised by these poorly thought out laws.
A council admitting the burden of STL licensing is just too high a mountain to climb & police. But mixed messaging means no one knows they need to get an exemption!
#SaveSC
@oldtownrez
@SaveSCScotland
@scotgov
Worrying times ahead. We employ around 30 cleaners for short let cleaning business.. So if our clients are all closed down due to this licensing, that's 30 professionally trained cleaners all out of work. Government Growing our economy???? I think not!
It's a slap in the face to locally run businesses that
@Edinburgh_CC
gave a prime council-owned venue on the Royal Mile to three foreign-domiciled businessmen for aparthotel accommodation when actively axing local S/C operators in the city.
#hypocrisy
#SaveSC
@ASSCnews
@ETAG_UK
At a Holyrood debate 7th June, Jackie Baillie said "We must remember that this is the legislation that the
@Scotgov
has already delayed by six months to allow for dialogue with the sector, so that problems and concerns could be ironed out". Still waiting.
#SaveSC
It does seem very odd that we're hearing about the
@scotgov
Minister changing his tune when only months ago he was emphatic that everything & everyone was included in the
#STL
legislation. Is it or is it not health & safety
@PaulMcLennan7
?
#SaveSC
This is a crisis of political incompetence, hubris & unwillingness to listen at any stage to the concerns of professional self catering operators who repeatedly flagged failings.
#SaveSC
@scotgov
@Edinburgh_CC
@brianjaffa
You have got to be joking! Not once in 4 years has anyone in
@scotgov
or
@edinburgh_cc
given S/C operators the time of day. But self appointed anon groups & fictions are fine. It's chaos you have championed. Well done. The festival city thanks you.
#SaveSC
It's evident that
@edinburgh_cc
misled Lord Braid at the Court of Session only a few months ago. The Council isn't honest & equitable with stakeholders, clearly favouring some over others. It's also commercially compromised in hotel deals.
#SaveSC
This is what the City of Edinburgh Council told the Court of Session about Short Term Lets in the city.
If this is the case, then why is the council now saying that it expects 80% of the STLs in Edinburgh to close?
Just to remind that the entire premise upon which this
#STL
Licensing is predicated is based on fictions & hearsay. S/C has never had a problem with ASB.
#Myths
#SaveSC
Isn't it just a little bit odd how hotels & newer aparthotel owners managed to weasel themselves out of any
@scotgov
STL laws which might impact their ability to trade & in many cases siphon profits offshore? Nothing to see here. Follow the money.
#SaveSC
In Kingussie alone - a wee Highland village - four guest houses have already pulled the plug, with a fifth about to follow suit. The effect on local pubs, restaurants, cafes, shops and tourist attractions will be devastating.
#SaveSC
In Kingussie alone - a wee Highland village - four guest houses have already pulled the plug, with a fifth about to follow suit. The effect on local pubs, restaurants, cafes, shops and tourist attractions will be devastating.
The SNP & Greens are destroying Scotland …
This is the real reason that
@scotgov
& many other politicians deflect from the issue of affordable homes, instead implying a few self catering units are some sort of sticking plaster solution whilst doing huge harm to the sector. Smoke & mirrors.
#SaveSC
Interesting to note that
@cllrcammyday
in a
#BBC
interview today 3x asked for a delay to the
#STL
Licensing deadline & to 'online attacks'. We agree with the former but wonder what he refers to on the latter? Defending our right to exist is not an attack.
#SaveSC
@PaulMcLennan7
Yet another brownfield in the capital for exclusive hotel as politicians wring their hands & talk of a housing crisis. Anyone spotting the trend? Local S/C is being killed off & it's not to help put people in affordable homes.
#SaveSC
@Edinburgh_CC
@PaulMcLennan7
@cllrcammyday
With a total of 1800 f/t secondary let applications in
@edinburgh_CC
it's pretty obvious that S/C was never anything more than a distracting sideshow & has little material impact on wider housing issues of the last 40 years. Smoke & Mirrors. Follow the money.
#SaveSC
Edinburgh short-term lets: Licensing scheme condemned for including B&Bs and spare rooms but delay bid fails
Short-term lets licensing scheme criticised in Scottish Parliament as heavy-handed
#SaveSC
In Holyrood, 7th June Edward Mountain said, "Only a fool would kill the goose that lays the golden egg. We have heard from the chief executive of the Scottish Tourism Alliance that Government policies 'will do limited good and risk maximum harm'."
#SaveSC
@scotgov
@PaulMcLennan7
@TheScotsman
@_KateForbes
must understand that the last two years has seen massively damaging red tape for Short term lets & the conflation of licensing & planning causing the hemmorrhaging of domestically owned/operated S/C in Scotland. It's killing a key sector.
#SaveSC
@donturvLDR
@LivingRent_Edi
@eilidhwashere
This has no basis in reality. Claims were based on proven fictions. There are fewer than 1200 registered S/C units in
#Edinburgh
& this has been confirmed by the recent
#STL
licensing application deadline. Pursuing this line is not helping those needing affordable homes.
#SaveSC
“If the government is intent on threatening law-abiding self-caterers with criminalisation after October 1, you would expect them to have established criteria and enforcement plans to be in place. But they have failed to do so."
#SaveSC
"... it’s not too late to find a solution.
@Edinburgh_CC
needs to build bridges with a sector that is vital to our visitor economy – a sector whose trust it has stretched to breaking point through its ill-considered licensing & planning schemes"
#SaveSC
If the
@scotgov
chooses to proceed on the path it is on, it may well be to blame for hundreds if not thousands of these businesses closing, with the resulting impacts on other local businesses such as retail & hospitality also needing to be factored in.
"...the
@scotgov
’s legislative challenge on unregulated holiday homes is having a bottom trawling effect on existing businesses, & pushing some to quit the industry rather than be swept up in a new wave of bureaucratic expense"
#SaveSC
There is now a thriving unlicensed black market swamping social media & no one is policing it to protect the health and safety of visitors. Own goal the
@scotgov
was repeatedly warned would happen.
#SaveSC