Every time I see Roy, I am reminded of 'Hatred in the Belly: Politics behind the Appropriation of Dr. Ambedkar's Writing' by Round Table India. It changed the way I think about Roy and the "radicals" of the Indian left. The book is so poignant and well-written.
Azaadī chants cannot be removed from the context they originated in: the anti-occupation resistance of Kashmiris against the Indian state. Quite similar to the Israeli occupation of Palestine.
But y'all love to gloss it over when you imagine things like 'South Asia.'
Stop pathologizing Hamas, please.
Yes, most of the people in the armed resistance are orphans, and the reality they grew up in was a violent reality of occupation and settler-colonialism. But the pursuit of justice and liberation from an occupier is a very noble struggle.
I pray and wait for the day when I'll see the children and women of your country, irrespective of caste and ideological affiliation, go through the same that my people have gone through. May you get tired of picking up corpses, tending to the injured, and building ruined
If terrorists try to enter India, they will be shot. That’s why the Indian Army is deployed at the Line of Control.
If more terrorists try to enter, more will be shot. If all terrorists try to enter, all will be shot.
#FoxtrotOscar
The full veil—more often than not associated with the armed resistance—was quite commonly worn in the region, as the archival photographs suggest, and has been deliberately erased from the descriptions of Kashmiri women, perhaps. The memoirs and novels written by the Kashmiri
Sheikh Abdullah, addressing a rally.
The banner reads: Naya Kashmir ki aurat'un ke charter ko amal mai laya jaway, Hum assembly ke aiwaan mai puri numayind'gi chahte hain.
Howard Sochurek (1951)
What a fine read from
@AsadRahim
, as always.
‘Ehtesab pehlay, intikhab baad mein,’ they roar, a cry straight from 1978. (Time is indeed a flat circle: the PML-N lion has gone back to being General Zia’s house-kitten).
You've done nothing, absolutely nothing, for Palestinians,
@GovtofPakistan
@ForeignOfficePk
No medical aid, no diplomatic support, not even a coherent statement of condemnation. A literal disgrace.
Bhutto's father was the Dewān of Junagadh and was actively involved in pre-independence politics. After partition, the Bhutto family hosted Iskander Mirza (multiple times) and Ayub Khan in their ancestral home, al-Murtaza.
Either you do not know the meaning of grassroots
Bhutto may have been a populist, but he was a grass-roots political leader in Punjab, not a top-down middle-class populist like Imran. If you can grasp this distinction, you'll understand why Bhutto led a political party that has lived on, and why PTI lives and dies with Imran.
'Don't speak ill of the dead' works for a relative who was an alcoholic or an aunt who had a habit of eavesdropping; not for a military dictator, who was responsible for the miseries and suffering of the people of Pakistan.
Two videos everyone should watch:
1. Sumit Samos and Shashi Tharoor speaking on Ambedkar at JLF; Samos is eloquent and well-informed and speaks on Ambedkar in a passionate, engaging way unlike Tharoor who speaks as he writes: in rambly, detached sentences.
My father, who lives in Muzaffarabad, tells me that people are not going inside, saying there will be aftershocks, and it was Ramadan when the 2005 earthquake hit the region.
Some wounds never heal.
Arresting him the day after the Faisal Naseer fiasco by barging into the Islamabad High Court in the Al-Qadir Trust Case, lmao.
The farce called democracy, the rule of law, and constitutionalism.
Islam has no clergy means the absence of an institution like papacy; it does not mean that people who cannot string together a sentence in Arabic, who have not read a single classical text of Fiqh or usool can pass judgment on the Islamic jurisprudence.
It is not a reactionary movement, neither a revenge of 'angry' young Muslim men. It is the fulfillment of a religious obligation — to not oppress and not be oppressed.
Hussain Bibi, a volunteer for the Bostan Force that later became the Azad Kashmir Regiment, joined the armed resistance on 3rd October 1947 to throw out the Dogra forces and to avenge the killings of her husband and children.
The skin of our Kashmiri prisoners in New Delhi's Tihar Jail is peeling off quite literally due to heat. They keep towels dipped in water on their heads to survive. High voltage bulbs are kept on all day that also emit additional heat and you are not allowed to turn them off.
The thought that ‘in-our-lifetime’ might be a reality translates to alternative, beautiful imaginations and possibilities not only for Palestine but also for Kashmir.
This is a day to be remembered, recalled, and relived. The invincibility and invulnerability of the gods
@roshaney_
He has a very good sense of humor, too. And what I really find radical, unlike the other JNU-DU-dafli radicals, is his ability to think beyond the nation-state paradigm. And his unwavering support for Kashmir, without any ifs and buts.
Civilians dying on both sides is tragic.’
No, it is not. The sight of corpses of the Israeli settlers, supportive of the crimes of the Zionist regime, does not invoke empathy - only disgust.
The only tragedy is the occupation of Palestine that Palestinians live through.
I have a very "Shi‘a" full name because my second name is Fatima. All my sisters, except one, have the same second name.
The reason: my father believed that Sunnis need to start giving their children the names of ahlul-bayt a little more. The thought, hence, that went into
I love the thought that Muslim parents put into naming their children.
What is the meaning of your name? Was there a significant person in the past you were named after? Is there other significance to your name?
Your state used white phosphorus a few days ago. It would have affected civilians and little children, too.
The response to your Israel-esque religious tourism on an occupied and besieged land makes sense.
"There will come a time when each and every Bhutto and all their cultists will be dragged by the neck through the streets of Sindh until they beg for mercy that will be denied to them the same way they have denied it to us.
I hope I get to witness it."
If you cannot fathom how a group uses corrective violence to overturn the spatial and material terms of power and occupation, it is you who has naturalized the psychic, incessant violence of the state.
The liberal sections of this country cannot grow out of this romanticization of the pre-BJP, secular, Nehruvian India—which Shahrukh Khan is a symbol of—and the exceptionalization of Modi-ruled, bigoted, violent India.
Can someone that did psychology, sociology, gender studies or anthropology please help me understand why they do this. The Nazis also did this. What is the reasoning behind it?
All we had with the state of Pakistan, like all the political subjects in the country, was a social contract, built on the promise of Pakistan, the liberation of the Indian-occupied Kashmir, and an unconditional support - material, financial, and diplomatic - for the Tehreek.
With the world, around us, falling apart and melting into thin air, I remember and pray for the Palestinian women surviving a genocide and holding onto their faith and land; the Kashmiri women like Asiya Andrabi, Fehmeeda Sofi, and Nahida Nasreen, among countless others,
Since people are questioning the intellect and comprehension skills of Pakistanis, and rightfully so, I would like to remind you all that Saba Mahmood, Ovamir Anjum, SherAli Tareen, and Salman Sayyid are all Pakistanis.
The three martyrs that lost their lives in the statist brutality — Saqib Mir, Azhar, and Waqar — belonged to Bararkot, Muzaffarabad.
May Allah accept it from them. Please recite surah Fātiha for them.
India has not voted against a fascist. Had the ethical sensibilities of an average Indian been this morally correct, it would have reconfigured the very political formation which makes it an Indian. Rather, what we see is the material reality overriding the narrative.
The Indian state is an occupation force and a settler-colonial regime. It checks all the boxes for even the most rudimentary, textbook definitions of colonialism.
When will academia move on from the absurdity that unless you're not a Brit, you cannot occupy a country?
Newsflash: How are you, an academic, using the word occupation and colonization? These words are not your mid-day snack. India DID NOT occupy Kashmir in 1947. It has done many things wrong but it did not “occupy” Kashmir. Occupation and colonization have very specific meanings.
India isn't the India of Nehru or Gandhi anymore. It's the India of RSS. While those of older times may have criticized us because they us as brothers with whom they disagreed, now they criticize us because they hate us. That's what's wrong with J Akhter sahabs remarks.
diaspora writers almost always seem to posit pherans and bandanas as the quintessential Kashmiri dress—worn by Muslims and Hindus alike—as opposed to the veil and burqa, which was worn by a minority under the 'Salafi' or 'Islamist' influences (no explanations of these terms are
All forms of clothing have regulation and coercion, internal or external. This form of external coercion is exceptionalised and problematized because it ruptures the process of participation of women in the neoliberal essentiality of consumption and performance.
Anyone who believes in accountability on the day of judgment should shudder at our complicity, intentional or unintentional, in the oppression of Ahmadis.
To stop a community from professing their faith and uprooting them from the faith-tradition they have habituated
May those who have enacted this genocide, directly (through their policies, actions, and words) and indirectly (through their silence and cowardice) go through the same.
May you see your loved ones, your families, and your communities get reduced to pieces of flesh.
2. Hina Rabbani Khar speaking at the WEF with Ravi Shankar. Having Rahul Kanwal as the moderator, this video is a telling metaphor for India's present condition: clownery, lies, and sheer stupidity governing the Indian social and political spheres.
The rage and sorrow people have in Muzaffarabad since yesterday. The more people I talk to in Garhi Habibullah, Chatter Kalas, Patikka, Plate, and Upper Adda, the more I realize how awful it was to call off the protests.
The Affective Turn in Pakistan Studies (aka decentering the subject of consciousness & rationalist conceptions of the public sphere in studying contemporary Pakistani politics and culture)
maybe I’ve missed a monograph or two
@nosheenali
@SKhojaMoolji
@kasmani_o
@mariarshd
@gabeeno
True. In CMH, the civillians and JCOs/ORs keep waiting, and the karnal, brig, general ki biwi comes and gets checked. Women wait from 5 am for the ultrasound and kisi ki biwi comes and gets her ultrasound done in a minute.
Ammar (both Ammars, actually. Ammar Ali Jan and Ammar Rashid) has had very principled and cogent responses to the recent events. You haven't seen them, or you're being dishonest. I'll assume the former — in good faith.
I was part of 2 previous Aurat Marches & 2 Ammar Jan led Student Marches.
Used to bribe my friends to join me.
But as women were dragged, jailed - students were killed in last week, these groups abandoned them on political lines.
What a disillusionment. And indeed, a sad one.
@DilrabaWishList
She's an upper-caste Indian, who's said to have appropriated the anti-caste cause by Ambedkarite circles and anti-caste organizations like the one I mentioned above. Her writings are meant to provoke, but not disrupt and alter the dominant, statist ideology.
"Indian Muslim Kashmiris" shows your knowledge and concern for Kashmir, Sabahat.
This decision or any other decision in and about Azad Kashmir does not need the commentary of the likes of you.
There's one side in this equation of occupation that is fighting for and protecting the sanctity of Life and God's creation. That side is of the Palestinians — the masses and the resistance forces.
The epistemology of the body, to paraphrase Talal Asad, is crucial to the teleology of modernity; in the context of the Indian nation-state, the epistemology of the body becomes more important as it serves a dual purpose: a. to invalidate the Islamic foundations of the Kashmiri
The day any Indian political leader — Dalit, communist, or Muslim — advocates for the release of incarcerated Kashmiris — imprisoned or disappeared — will be the day you can pin your hopes on people's movements and electoral politics. Till then, raw defiance over cooperation.
In Arabic, there are three terms: mukhannath, khanith, and mutarajjila.
1. The non-congenital mukhannath (al-mukhannath ghair al-khilqi) is someone who adopts feminine affectations out of choice.
2. Khanith is a biological male who adopts the gender identity of a female.
There is a word for "transpersons" in Urdu and Arabic both.
If there is no word for "transphobe" in these languages, then maybe its the transphobes that are the western import.
‘The question of whose lives are worth grieving is an integral part of the question of whose lives are worth valuing. And here racism enters in a decisive way.’
Judith Butler on Palestine and Israel:
I'm so tired of this horseshit.
Pakistan has four provinces and two administered territories. Some parts of Sindh and Punjab have cultural and linguistic similarities with Sindhis, Punjabis, and 'Multanis' in India. Rest of what constitutes Pakistan does not share any major
literally the most funniest thing on this planet is indians and paxtanis fighting with each other on how different they’re like shut up y’all are same from language, skin color, food, culture, misogyny, corruption, to bottling ICC trophies
So true. Islam needs mujāhideen. Glory to them and all those who live and die for their faith, land, and justice.
These voices embody the spirit of Toofān al-Aqsā. Brimming with possibility, potentiality, and an alethic existence.
Guys I've stumbled upon a gem!
A video filmed by a fighter, documenting the Qassam Brigades on their way to storm the Netivot settlement on October 7,
They were literally marching to their deaths with glee and confidence, even making jokes!
@DrSyedMustafaA1
#Hamas
is not revolutionary. Violence for the purpose of establishing a right-wing theocracy amounts to one right-wing force against another. Except they’re not concerned with Israel’s government being right-wing. They want to sterilize the region of Israelis and Jews.
Our festivities and celebrations remain haunted, in a Derridean manner, by the lives that were not lived, by the roads not taken, by the sacrifices that enlivened our existence.
May God accept what we send his way in whatever broken and battered forms. Eid Mubārak.
and destroyed homes and schools.
I'll wait for the day the Indian colonial state dismembers and mercy will be denied to you the way it is denied to us.
Encampments, protests, sabbaths, and art exhibitions are all nice and cool, but they operate within the framework, language, and import of sovereignties. When the entire global order is orchestrating a genocide, it needs to be disrupted and uprooted.
rendered). The ascendance of the practice of veiling is connected in most of these recollections with the activism of Dukhtaran-e-Millat, who purportedly 'coerced' women into modest clothing.
More than 17.2 million people in Afghanistan face acute food insecurity. More than 6 million are one step away from famine. Pakistan, after evicting half a million people last year, is now "repatriating" over 800,000 Afghans after Eid.
Literal sewer rats running this country.
The month we are entering into is, more than anything, an exercise that reorients and decenters. It shakes us out of the sleepwalking, automated mode of existence, where we worship and tend to the self.
With Gaza, all that was holy is being, and has been, profaned;
If a white woman wrote the things Fatima Mernissi has written about Islam and the veil, we'd be in an uproar.
Yet, she continues to be read and recommended, when we have a better female scholarship.
Brilliant, as always, from
@AsadRahim
"All said, elections must be held, and within 90 days. In his verdict, Justice Jawad quoted Warren Burger, that “…delay will drain even a just judgement of its value”.
We yet hope."
The retellings mired in anticipation and yearning to return to the 'traditional' Kashmiri attire not only establish and reinforce the myth of Kashmiriyat—seeking to blur the lines between Hindus and Muslims—but also serve as disciplinary modes of governance and control by
The divinity of neoliberalism seeks to forge the state, public life, and human subjectivity into the image of the market.
Ali S. Harfouch on how the divine power of neoliberalism seeks to reconstitute Islam:
Fasting, much like obligatory prayers, is a commandment from God that has to be fulfilled.
Stripping an obligation of its religious component and limiting it to the purported physical advantages or disadvantages changes the orientation from ākhirah to dunyā.
Fasting doesn't make any sense. In the worst-case scenario, it can result in vitamin and mineral deficiencies, muscle breakdown, and diarrhea. Sensible people should refrain from it and consume healthy food.
With all that has happened since the last year - the robbery of the public mandate, removal of subsidies, installation of a puppet government, and the ongoing statist violence - the project of Pakistan is being undone in Kashmir, hour by hour, day by day.
The promise of secularism of making religious differences inconsequential and unrelated to politics and the matters of governance is built on a contradiction: the religious subjectivities of the minority are monitored, regulated, and privatized, but the majority's religious
The hallowed altar of Indian statehood has rendered the lives of the Kashmiri leadership so expendable that they do not punctuate the discourse on fascism even momentarily.
There is a food tradition in Azad Kashmir around beef and Eid al-Adha. There's pakeyra (minced beef roasted on the walls of mud stove with mint, salt, and pepper). There's beef qeema pulao. There's namkeen gosht.
Beef is the superior, widely-eaten meat.
On the subject of cow slaughter, I find it interesting that people in Pakistan (at least around me) don’t really eat beef very often, or at all. In my house the only time we had beef was as qeema matar/aloo/shimla mirch and that would be like maybe once every two months.
Aisha bint Abu Bakr (ra) was an incredible woman who dedicated her life to the Prophet ﷺ and the ummah.
Last week, we learned about how her sacrifice led her to greatness. Explore part 2 of The Firsts with Dr.
@omarsuleiman504
tonight at 8 PM CST: