In these hard times, I need you to know that folks are doing life saving work in the U.S. to end mass incarceration and build a world beyond punishment. For this giving season, here are 10 orgs that can do a lot with your $ to create a better future.
WOW how did I not know about this? There's a team at JSTOR with formerly incarcerated leadership that combs through historical prison newspapers and writes interesting stories about them. You can read them all here. I love this so much.
It's truly mind boggling how supposedly respectable news outlets print totally false things - things we can easily check by looking at public data - about crime. And people swallow it, because they never expect the
@nytimes
to completely misrepresent something as basic as this.
I don’t know how else to say this, but
@AliWatkins
@nytimes
MURDERS IN NEW YORK DID NOT DOUBLE this year or last year or ever. THIS DID NOT HAPPEN. NOT EVEN CLOSE. YOU ARE LYING TO YOUR READERS. What a goddamn disgrace.
Let the lesson of Cincinnati sink in. Cutting incarceration and arrests can Reduce crime. How? Fewer people cycling through dangerous and debilitating
#jail
and
#prison
stays. Fewer kids growing up with missing parents. Less $$ on cops and cages and more on housing and treatment.
When Cincinnati closed a jail in 2008, it reduced the city's jail capacity by more than a third. The police were forced to make fewer arrests, causing people to worry violent crime would increase. It didn't. In fact, it fell by 38.5%.
Thread: Dear weary twitter, I'm here to tell you that there is So much fresh work happening on the ground on justice issues, and there were a lot of wins tonight that we can all be really excited about. Here's a few:
"If a white man wants to lynch me, that's his problem. If he's got the power to lynch me, that's my problem. Racism is not a question of attitude; it's a question of power." Stokely Carmichael.
Some people are upset that we don’t have more police officers. They think adding a couple hundred more in a city like San Francisco will end garage robberies and other bad stuff.
So, I got curious: if you wanted to *police* your way to zero street crime, how much would it cost?
For anyone who cares about ending mass incarceration, this 🧵 is for you. How did we fare in yesterday's elections? Some great results, some bad results, and others inbetween. Here's what we know:
Thread: A lot of people are asking me where to give $ in this moment (I direct criminal justice giving at Open Philanthropy). I've compiled a list of recs for police accountability, including shrinking their budgets; decarceration; and transforming systems. /1
This is so embarrassing. Why is the governor of *New York* going to the mat for an anti-abortion, anti-labor chief judge? And what’s with the gas lighting about justice?
Judge LaSalle has pursued fairness and justice throughout his career, and he deserves the same as the State Senate considers his nomination.
I nominated Judge LaSalle because I know his experience and vision for the court will expand justice for all New Yorkers.
😱
For everyone celebrating
@RepJeffries
for his alphabet song — this is your guy backing an anti-choice, anti-labor, conservative chief judge for the state of New York
"Judge Hector Lasalle is highly qualified to be the chief judge of the state of New York. Period. Full stop,"
@RepJeffries
says, adding LaSalle should be given the same rights as every other chief judge nominee to get a vote in the Senate.
A Guardian investigation found that private companies have made $100million clearing homeless encampments in California. Highly recommend you read the piece.
Per Politico: “Bonta’s fight... could be the most consequential contest in the deep-blue state — a bellwether of Democratic voters’ commitment to criminal justice reform.” The voters have now spoken! Bonta finished in first place with a a *36 point* lead.
Does this seem like an absurd result to you? This is what folks mean by "we can't police our way out of crime." Many scholars have written brilliant things on this.
Safety is a cultural production. A safe society takes care of people!
Diana Becton, CA's only Black elected prosecutor, won reelection in Contra Costa county (population 1.1 million), surviving an attack from a pro-punishment challenger.
Caleb Smith ordered online what he thought was Adderall to help him study. His girlfriend asked to try it. She died from an overdose. It turned out the substance was fentanyl. Prosecutors charged Caleb with “drug-induced homicide." Then he killed himself.
Important thread, worth a read.
Translation: three people who have been organizing to pay bail for activists in Atlanta have been arrested in their homes on ridiculous charges.
This is "movie about the scary old days but it's real and it's now."
This morning, APD raided The Teardown House and arrested three organizers with
@ATLSolFund
.
The Solidarity Fund provides legal defense and bail support for first amendment protected activities in Atlanta and the surrounding area.
Not only is this awesome and humane, it's also one of the best ways to shrink the criminal legal system! “Medicaid expansion produced a 20–32% negative difference in overall arrests rates in the first three years."
I think this gigantic result has been drowned out: South Dakotans voting (56% to 44%!) to expand Medicaid will make tens of thousands of people newly eligible for the public insurance.
And SD joins many other red states that expanded Medicaid via referendum: NE, UT, ID, MO, OK.
WIN on Oregon measure 110: thanks to great leadership from
@Kassandra_Fred
and the whole
@DrugPolicyOrg
family, plus great partner organizations on the ground, possession of All drugs is now decriminalized in Oregon.
Anne Marie Schubert, the retrograde, anti-reform prosecutor from Sacramento (who never filed charges in 72 killings by police) who stepped down to challenge progressive AG Rob Bonta in the California Attorney General race, failed miserably in her effort. She got 7.5%.
In the article, the only evidence of 'doubling' is a quote from a professor saying that the caseloads for shooting "literally doubled overnight." Sounds like exaggeration, first of all. Then a terrible editor (with an agenda?) mangled the statement into a totally false headline.
Civil rights attorney Pamela Price was the top vote getter in Alameda County (Oakland), ahead of the regressive former-DA's deputy, and goes to a runoff in the fall.
WIN in the Washington state senate --
@tarrasimmons5
will be a state senator. She led with the fact that she served time in prison, ran a brilliant campaign, and garnered a lot of great endorsements.
We just made
#herstory
in WA State! Beyond grateful to my team, volunteers and donors who made the impossible happen. From the Big House to the State House...We Do Recover!
#LetMyPeopleRun
#EndMassIncarceration
An Alabama woman, accused of stealing $40, died in jail from pneumonia. Instead of taking her to a hospital, jail staff treated her with an anxiety protocol that "includes suggestions like taking walks and yoga classes."
@AmyKingsley4
@aldotcom
What's the ROI on dollars spent on police vs. eviction protection / trauma recovery centers / vastly expanded mental health support / guaranteed income / mentorship for kids and more? I don't know.
But I bet spending $25billion a year on that stuff > hiring 50,000 police.
I have zero student loan debt. I am OVERJOYED that 20 million borrowers will see full student debt relief, 23 million partial, and others will face much better conditions going forward. Education is a basic necessity, not a luxury item. Thank you
@POTUS
and
@StrikeDebt
!
This is evil.
In the future, ICE agents will be put on trial for crimes against humanity. They will say they were just following orders. They should be convicted.
NEW: A Miami resident married to a U.S. citizen says he lost his wallet & that hours later, someone called to say he found it and to come to a highway rest-stop to get it back. He says that when he arrived, the "good samaritans" were really ICE agents:
Thread: on how the Ohio Dept of Ed stopped an author with many-years-old convictions from coaching sports at school. When they discovered he’s a big deal, 11 months later, the approval magically happened.
Got this extremely infuriating letter from the Ohio Department of Education yesterday. I haven’t been public about the saga that lead to this letter, because I don’t generally handle these type of things publicly. But this has me fed up and angry. So here's a thread:
Our
#prison
system perpetuates industrial levels of child separation and then inflicts brutal trauma. This is not safety: this is perverse and we can end it.
A guard telling a child he'd rape his mother then beating him with his radio, a 15-year-old boy raped by a corrections officer, children placed in solitary confinement 55,000 times in 2 years at 1 facility - tales of abuse in juvenile jails across the US.
BREAKING: On Monday, our
@kira_lerner
reported on the Chicago court system's use of ankle bracelets that listen to & record child defendants. Today, they contacted Kira to say they will stop using the monitors' communication ability pending further review.
Alabama put to death a man tonight using an untested method, possibly torturous, after a judge *overrode* the jury to give him a death sentence. Judges are more likely to override in favor of death to boost votes in their reelection campaigns.
Alabama’s Guinea pig, Kenny Smith—you can’t even say he was sentenced to death by a jury of his peers. The jury voted 11-1 FOR LIFE. The judge overrode it and imposed death—something that isn’t allowed in any state in the Union today. He shouldn’t be executed at all.
Also in L.A., Sheriff Villanueva will finish with by far the worst primary result of any incumbent sheriff in county history, failing to avoid a runoff; every single other candidate ran against him, and their voters will likely consolidate against him in the general election.
Projected WIN in L.A. County (10 million people!!), where
@GeorgeGascon
is up 10 points to be the next DA. We won't know full results for a week, but if this holds, this is massive. Here is
@OsopePatrisse
talking about the terrible incumbent
Here's a useful brief gathering lots of research on what has worked to reduce crime (spoiler, it's basically about giving people health, housing, and money):
The DA Chesa Boudin recall won w/ 60%. Opponents threw everything at him: over $7mil, relentless lies about crime rates, a hostile Mayor, major Repub donors pouring $ in, and Fox news piling on. Bright side: they had to work very hard to get this win. The tides are against them.
@BlerdMommy
According to the article, the plaintiffs alleged that at least 170,000 students were harmed, overcharged by hundreds of millions of dollars. The settlement amount divided by that number gives about ~$80 per student, if everyone makes a claim. It somehow seems.... inadequate.
A Black professor who studies housing discrimination had his house appraised: $472,000.
He then did a “whitewashing experiment,” removing indications of Blackness, and had a white colleague — another professor — stand in.
The appraisal? $750,000.
Let’s do the math on a no-holds-barred police budget to defend every corner of San Francisco and all the garages in between!
Number of intersections in SF: 6399
At 2 officers per intersection, we need 12,798 officers on duty around the clock
Good morning! Today I’m thrilled to share that I am launching a new venture: Just Impact, a grantmaking and donor advisory group devoted to creating cascading momentum for ending mass incarceration. /1
Doing the math, our hypothetical new budget giving Full Policing Coverage On Every Corner of San Francisco, is a sweet $25.8 billion per year, roughly twice the current entire city budget.
But wait, there's more!
People: have you donated yet to the fund to unseat Senator Collins of Maine if she chooses to confirm
#Kavanaugh
, who will haunt our dreams for generations as he tramples on women's rights and more? In America, money is speech, so speak up!
In L.A., 4 progressive candidates for judge will go to a runoff, + candidates for city council and others who ran as strong justice reformers came 1st or did very well (Mejia, Gill, Hernandez, Yaroslavsky, Darling, Soto-Martinez, Sandoval).
4 judicial candidates formed an informal progressive slate while running for judge in Los Angeles County, saying they were running to decrease mass incarceration. (3 are public defenders.)
All 4 are grabbing a spot in their runoffs so far.
Context:
Alana Matthews came up short w/ 40% of the vote in the Sacramento DA race. The winner, Thien Ho, will be better than Schubert who left the seat to run for AG. He emphasized drug and mental health treatment, rehabilitation, and equity in his campaign. So, directionally good.
Did you know that one of the best ways to cut crime is giving access to health care? Similarly, cutting health care increases crime by a lot! Multiple studies have found large effects.
Projected WIN on Measure J in Los Angeles, which will send $300million+ to rehabilitation and health - the things that prevent people from going to jail. Amazing work by
@LADefensx
,
@OsopePatrisse
and many others on the ground.
WIN in CA: prop 20, which would have undone years of reform, went down in flames. Too many great people worked on this to name. Suffice to say, the organizing and advocacy bench in CA is strong!
Projected WIN:
@Eric4LakeCounty
will likely be the next DA of Lake County, IL, just north of Chicago. He campaigned as a progressive prosecutor focused on addressing inequalities in the justice system.
@jduffyrice
“The death penalty is not about whether people deserve to die for the crimes they commit. The real question of capital punishment in this country is, Do we deserve to kill?”
― Bryan Stevenson, Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption
After yesterday's primaries, Iowa's biggest county will likely see a big jump from a tough-on-crime prosecutor who aggressively targeted BLM activists, to a progressive who says it's important to look outside of policing and prosecution for public safety.
How many total officers we need to have 12,798 covering every intersection? Couldn't find it on google; I'm guessing at least 4x that number to account for shifts, vacations, sick time. Maybe more?
At 4x, we'll need 51,192 officers on the force just to cover those intersections.
What about non-street crime? Murders, domestic violence, child abuse, theft from employees, and a lot of other illegal stuff often happens behind closed doors. So we’re going to need a Much larger investigative division to cover all that ground. Add another $5billion? More?🤷♀️
Here's the "evidence" for their scary assertion:
-Burglars were once heard "speaking Spanish."
-3 years ago, 1 burglary had ties to a car rented by someone visiting from Chile
-Two other police depts said some burglaries were connected to "South America."
LOL what
THREAD. Last night, the San Francisco Chronicle published an alarming article with an alarming headline that sounds really scary. The fear-mongering headline was based entirely on police sources. Let's unpack the actual evidence and why it matters.
New message from Pope Francis: "Do you know what comes to mind now when, together with popular movements, I think of the Good Samaritan? Do you know what comes to mind? The protests over the death of George Floyd. 1/3
Right now, San Francisco has about 1500 officers on the force (down from 1800 in 2019).
To cover every intersection, we need to grow the force to at least 51,192 officers, a 34x increase.
The current police budget is ~$760 million.
@stan_okl
@RottenInDenmark
Many residents share the analysis in the second image. Unfortunately, few Americans ask the questions he poses in the third.
Regressive DA Todd Spitzer, who had a huge campaign war chest, won his battle to stay in office in Orange, though he is now damaged goods (with less statewide and national influence), after several scandals broke during the campaign.
Today, the
@washingtonpost
released a series on Reimagining Safety. I am honored to share my commentary featuring the outstanding work of Los Angeles organizers and more.
.
@AndrewYang
this your moment! Universal basic income should be dropped in immediately to avoid a major crash of shift workers, hospitality workers etc. You're in a great position to put this on the agenda!
8/n There will be hardship especially among the vulnerable. We need to consider financial assistance; first aid through existing programs then perhaps a bigger supplemental. Many people can’t easily absorb missed work, closed schools. We must assist them for the measures to work
WIN in Orlando:
@MoniqueHWorrell
is going to be the new State's Attorney! Recruited and supported by movement, including
@FLRightsRestore
and
@Dreamdefenders
, Monique will be one of two Black elected prosecutors in Florida, alongside newly elected Harold Pryor.
Yesterday, thanks to incredible organizing by the
@JusticeLANow
coalition, L.A. county (largest jailer in the U.S.) voted to kill a $2 billion
#jail
project and built a mental health treatment center instead. More left to fight, but for now, WOW.
Closing the loop on the point above: if your aim is to police your way to zero crime, adding 300 officers to a 1500 person police force is laughably insufficient. Try 15,000, 30,000, 50,000 more officers! Full coverage is not an incremental change.
People get used to characters like DeSantis being terrible and they stop paying close attention. This man is abusing his office to remove political opponents. That’s really, really bad. Where does it end? Will he remove every Democrat in office in Florida?
Sigh. I love twitter and have learned so much in this space. I'm not going anywhere but the building is starting to shake and ceiling tiles are falling down so.... I'm not sure how long this thing is going to stand. I really appreciate everyone who's shared info and beauty here.
Projected WIN in Oakland county Michigan: thanks to awesome work by
@MILiberation
,
@kdmcdonald2020
will likely be the next DA in a major Detroit suburb. She leaned heavy on progressive values.
A sweet WIN: check out today's plunge in stock prices for two of the biggest private prison companies! Google these companies -- they are so, so bad. And follow
@WorthRises
for more info about the evil prison industry. CoreCivic (NYSE:CXW) -17%. The GEO Group (NYSE:GEO) -12%
This is from an
@seiu1000
brief arguing that the California Correctional Center can't be shut down due to all the people whose wealth and home values depend on prisoners there:
Thanks
@ScottHech
for telling this story and pulling together so many examples from around the country of police lying to crime victims, saying they "can't investigate" or that it's pointless etc. Appears to be a coordinated strategy by police.
THREAD: This is a story about how police are frontline propagandists. It starts with a violent robbery at a men’s clothing store in Manhattan. It ends w/ NYPD responding, but refusing to investigate. Then lying that no one would face any consequences bc of “reform.” Read on:
Today Mayor Adams, talking to a right-wing radio host, agreed that Tiffany Cabán should be blacklisted from city services for criticizing the NYPD. This is an anti-democratic attempt to silence CM Cabán, and plays into a long history of redbaiting and blacklisting socialists
Twitter friends: I'm looking for a report/memo/brief that summarizes historical data on clemency, showing how commonplace it was in previous decades (60s and 70s in particular), including examples of mass clemency. Any leads?
A quick 🧵of devastating accounts from lawmakers who visited
#RikersIsland
jail yesterday and witnessed the gruesome conditions there. Bottom line: the jail is overstuffed.
@GovKathyHochul
, elected DAs, the city council and others must shut this place down.
@prisonculture
Keep building up from the ground. And ideally, mass marches to force the senate's hand (if at all possible?) to release stimulus. The very bad economy tsunami is still coming and they are going to try to make it as bad as possible.
The Bronx DA after a wrongful murder conviction is overturned: “What they did was not necessarily wrong — that is the way things were done then. For 1989 that was standard practice for the N.Y.P.D., but now we know better.”
Charmaine McGuffey (Dem) has *won* the sheriff's race in Hamilton County (Cincinnati). She beat the incumbent (a Dem sheriff who attended a Trump rally, cooperated with ICE, & more) in the primary, but then the incubment endorsed the GOP nominee. McGuffey won anyway.
WIN: Jose Garza will be the next DA in Austin. He campaigned on a strong progressive platform. Don't sleep on Texas! Great things brewing! Congrats to
@workersdefense
and others on the ground who made this happen!
NYC is a lot safer than small town America, by the way, if what you care about is whether you're going to die (as opposed to 'feeling scared' which is a whole nother thing).
What do Americans think about crime and what we should do about it? This is a substantive and a political question, and the two are often heavily mixed up. I looked at some fascinating polling that imho should be informing our discourse. 🧵
Really important 🧵— read it all. For the safety of police and everyone else, don’t send police into a situation where social workers have the best tools for the situation.
THREAD: As more details emerge about NYPD officer Jason Rivera's tragic death, I'm thinking about whether police were the right ones to respond at all. A verbal argument between mom/son over food. What if mom had a different option than to call 911? More:
Dems this fall flipped the capital county of Pennsylvania, arguably nation's key swing state.
For first time since Civil War.
How? An activist pastor, fired by his church for pro-LGBTQ message, who ran very unconventional campaign.
Your Sunday read: