Increasingly feel that anyone not assigning full books is fundamentally unserious and lacks respect for their students. Too much reading? Shut the fuck up and have this 600 page novel read by next week. If that’s too much then the class isn’t for you.
I assign books because no one remembers articles. Ask a student if they remember the author and argument of an article they read five years ago. I want this stuff to stick with them. Also, what will happen to academic publishing when we never assign books?
@MrHWM
I thought I was inured to this sort of thing, since I grew up smack dab in the rust belt. But it all seems to have gotten so much worse over the last few years. I didn’t think it was possible, but Youngstown is somehow even rustier.
because spending your life reading and talking about books/movies sounds like a much better way to live than being an accountant. That’s literally it. Anyone who says otherwise is either lying or deluded about what they do.
@matthiasellis
What's the point of studying those books and movies if you believe they can be rendered meaningless in the face of nuclear annihilation?
@_ryanruby_
There’s a great and heartbreaking essay by Leslie Fiedler about visiting him in Idaho just before his death. He talks about how much H would posture about critics being useless know-nothings, but upon further examination it was clear he’d read everything ever written about him.
Today is a good day to go watch/listen to some of John Barth’s old interviews with Michael Silverblatt on Bookworm. There are moments in those conversations where he almost seems like an American Borges. A wizard of the word.
@focusfronting
Ian Miles Cheong? The coke dealer I bought from in Malaysia a few years back who had a picture of the king on his wall he used as a dartboard?
@johannawinant
Had a very old professor back in the day who told me the common read for freshmen at queens college in the early 60s was the brothers karamazov, and that there was a huge social penalty for not doing the reading
@_ryanruby_
I don’t understand, though! Why would literature professors assign his epochal book of literary criticism and not his polemic on Palestine (which is very good but is very much of its 90s moment)????? This doesn’t make any sense!!!!!!
this person is clearly unwell and I hope they get the help they need, but my god there’s such a weird kind of narcissism on display here. to map your own depression onto geopolitical conflict is such a particularly American behavior, I feel like. and a very online one.
I have contemplated self-immolation more in the past two months than I’ve thought about going to see Renaissance and I sobbed in utter confusion at how anyone is able to achieve any sense of normalcy while all of these people are being killed en masse.
Interesting thing happening where the “it” book of the year in theory/criticism is being roundly dismissed by every smart grad student I know, with great specificity, while simultaneously being praised by tenured mid career faculty - in incredibly vague, buddyish language.
I don’t often share very personal things on here, but Ezra was my adviser and a very, very special man. Attached is something brief I was asked to write in remembrance of him. I’ll miss his magic tricks.
I'm just heartbroken to find out
@ezratawil
passed away last month. We organized a group of untenured early Americanists in NYC in the early 00s and read each other's stuff. He was warm, funny, generous, and so so smart.
@MrHWM
This was the case for the college freshman English class I had to teach while working on my PhD. It’s what prompted me to make that post about reading assignments that everyone yelled at me about. It’s a fucking disaster, and it’s administratively enforced.
I’m not exactly averse to controversial opinions about academic but this is the one that gets me in the most fights - and it’s a hill I will always die on.
@tonalplexus
Every time I realize this guy exists and that his overblown prose, which is so purple it makes Barney look beige, somehow merited an editorial position at a reputable mag I get so fucking depressed
Another teacher gone, and too early: my high school English teacher, George. The first one to notice I was a reader and began to throw books at me left and right at 16. Whatever I am now as a reader and writer, it’s because of him. Nothing in life prepares you to lose a teacher.
It's important to recognize how reactionary JCO is being, actually. The idea that a rare exception (a billionaire widow) or, differently, this or that example of someone abusing "welfare," are used to dismiss or downplay the obligations we have to each other
@_ryanruby_
Not to do an armchair analysis, but I usually just try to gloss his takes like this - which are patently wrong - as reflective of a profound terror about how much of himself he may have revealed in his work
@MrHWM
I’ll never forget when I had to sit through a meeting with some Cornell professors and they blathered on for literally a half hour about how radical it was that they had changed their dept name to “literatures in english.” The Ivy League is not sending their best.
@g_shullenberger
I’ve never read a single review of ALC’s that amounted to more than a temper tantrum about not personally liking the author, dressed up in faux-philosophical language. Absolute charlatan. The Zadie Smith review in particular was impressively incoherent.
@ambernoelle
The overlap between these dudes and trad Catholics who think divorce rates are responsible for the decline of society will never cease to mystify me.
I honestly don’t know how anyone who has spent ten minutes with 3+ grad students in the last decade could doubt for a second that this story was true lol
This whole ordeal was not simply stupid, it was positively Trumpian. The journalists and media types who not only decried this anecdote as fake news without evidence, but who made baseless accusations of editorial malpractice, should be flat out embarrassed. And should apologize.
@sillynous
It’s called a provisional attempt. I don’t believe any 19 year old can really “get” Portrait of a Lady on a first run-through. But I think a familiarity from a quick read and then lecture about it might set them up to read it more substantively later on, when they need it
this take was inevitable, and honestly it’s kind of quaint. like a return to stupid literary twitter of 2017. good for her - we all love a little nostalgia of stupider times.
being a PhD student and most of my friends being MFA students meant constant mediation between these spheres, and I still feel traumatized by attempting such a futile task
disagree! i think Chalamet is a fine actor, particularly in the role of "somewhat silly and acutely self-conscious boyish man with ideas and impulses that are bigger and more human than he has the intellectual capacity to understand or fully integrate."
@TheLincoln
Not a novel thought, but I really do think we’re just gonna have to bring back handwritten short answer responses. I know that poses its own problems but I don’t see any way around it.
Read this story tonight by
@MrHWM
and was completely blown away. Like I told a friend, shades of early Roth in the beginning (and he can match Roth’s humor) but quickly becomes its own deeply unnerving thing. I’ll be thinking about and rereading this one for a long time.
@pourfairelevide
I honestly thought Hugh Kenner put this shit to bed with his writing about the timetables of the trolleys in Ulysses. At least Kenner was an interesting writer.
the hysteria is starting to tonally ramp up. I’m excited to see where this ends for him. Probably holed up in a suburban ranch house with several assault rifles and stuffed animal hostages, who he keeps screaming at about how good the economy is
Hundreds of braindead leftists retweeting this because they think “25% is greater than 20%” is some kind of incredible math insight and completely miss that REAL EARNINGS ARE GOING UP
@saintsoftness
I’d honestly be crestfallen if a teacher I respected enough to ask for a letter of rec did something like this. It would feel like a knife in the gut.
I’ve been kind of disappointed that all the chatter about Zone of Interest hasn’t sparked a Martin Amis revival. I know he had some duds, but when he was at his best there was no better writer of sentences in English.
the only reason this guy has a career in “journalism” is because his dad sold out his friends and wrote a book-length gossip column about far more intelligent people than him. That’s literally it. And this joke of a family has been coasting off his father’s rotten soul ever since
It might not be politically correct to say, but I think it's time we started asking whether the contemporary right is capable of assimilating into American culture.
@__AustinAdams
The knee-jerk reaction to him is just the same old resistance to anything one was forced to read in high school. Discovering Nine Stories in college really helped me appreciate just how damn good he was.
hey Becca Rothfeld is a great reader and Lauren Oyler is a very okay writer. The review is fine. Im sorry, I know Oyler is very clever on Twitter and that’s all that matters to most of you, but you’re gonna have to grow up and fucking deal with it. A bad book is a bad book.
@AmericanGwyn
I know I’m supposed to say “The Dead,” but the Joyce story that moved me the most, to this day, is “Araby.” So much packed into just a few pages.
deleted my post about The Discourse. Trying to stop wading into those things. But Jon is a great guy and the accusations of misogyny seem really unfair and like big reaches.
remember when flannery o’connor said that it’s true everyone has a novel inside them, but in most cases that’s exactly where it should stay? This poem is gonna make me feel that way about poetry
@ThankUBayesGod
@sillynous
I have a friend who, upon rereading portrait, worked up the courage to admit her husband was abusing her and to take the kid and leave.
Done with the weird bitches. Gonna meet a normie girl on hinge. 27 or so with a boring professional email job. Likes to go to brunch. Has a “doggo.” Dyed blonde hair. Goes to the gym and does meme workouts to make her ass bigger. Has never felt real pain in her life.
When people tell me there hasn’t been a cultural decline I just point to something like this, or to Bellow’s Herzog becoming such a phenomenon. It’s really hard to not think something profoundly bad has happened to the reading public.
Insane to think that Umberto Eco's "Name of the Rose" was an international bestseller in 1980. People were reading books then, like really reading them.
The pug in Lynch's Dune makes perfect sense. Just like Paul, it's the product of generations of selective breeding that should have made genetic perfection, but it's kind of just a little freak
@ThankUBayesGod
@sillynous
I don’t really know what to tell you. I started reading Henry James at about 19, before I’d experienced much as an adult, and returning to it over the years in difficult moments has been incredibly helpful for me
@yakabikaj
The indigineity discourse is like creationism in America. There’s a whole fabricated discourse with its own esoteric facts, designed to serve as gotchas for opponents, that ultimately just serve to distract people who think “displacement of millions is wrong.”
@monicabyrne13
This is a particularly funny form of misogyny too because, as much as I love Bellow and Roth, they also wrote mostly about the vagaries of relationships lol
the only actual instance of punching down I’ve seen in my life has been progressives with graduate degrees making fun of working class people who eat at Olive Garden
You can really see this kind of accelerationism taking shape on the left, with increasingly manic attacks on Biden, seemingly because they sense blood in the water and think if they make him a vessel for everything they hate, whoever replaces him will be everything they want
@saintsoftness
The sweatpants thing is so real. I cannot comfortably write in the pants I wear out and about. Reminds me of John Cheever, who apparently used to dress up in a suit, ride the elevator down to the boiler room, and strip down to his undies to write.
@bartleby_era
Grad school and the English PhD helped me in a lot of ways and I am mostly grateful for it but I mostly look back on the warnings I received from profs like this warmly, and feel they were right to have said what they did.
Great review of
@dan_sinykin
’s book. Love that it attends to that piece on CM. I admit I had a skepticism of data-driven approaches to lit scholarship, but he really sold me here on how, by analyzing on a macro level, we can understand how art is strangled by conglomeration
Big Fiction is a fresh intervention on the forces shaping the art and media we consume, principally due to the richness of the context Dan Sinykin provides and the impressively broad array of evidence he marshals, writes
@scottwstern
.
@AmericanGwyn
@MrHWM
I picked up a copy of Galveston at a used bookstore in Sweden not too long ago and am hoping to dig in soon. I didn’t know it existed so it was a nice discovery.
@jonathanbfine
this guy’s obsession with trans people is incredible. he wakes up and just lunges for the phone to start tweeting about them, and doesn’t stop until he goes to bed.
The best man I ever knew in academia, my dissertation adviser, died today. If you had a good mentor in the hell that is grad school, please let them know how much you appreciate them. The world feels lonelier today.
@MrHWM
There’s also something about the way he emphasizes “everything - we are open to EVERYTHING” that makes me think the FBI should check his hard drives
@MrHWM
One bright spot, though, was that the students, at least in my case, were not happy about this. Like I said, it came more from the admins. The students were annoyed they didn’t have better and longer reading assignments.