Molly Przeworski Profile Banner
Molly Przeworski Profile
Molly Przeworski

@molly_przew

8,708
Followers
570
Following
20
Media
1,361
Statuses

Population Genetics, Columbia University

New York, NY
Joined June 2014
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Pinned Tweet
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 months
Stream or attend a conference on Frontiers in Human Genetics at Columbia University (Oct 10 & 11), by registering here:
Tweet media one
1
26
76
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
11 months
The @eLife board has decided to fire the editor-in-chief for expressing his personal political opinion, in this case his concern about the bombing of civilians.
@mbeisen
Michael Eisen
11 months
I have been informed that I am being replaced as the Editor in Chief of @eLife for retweeting a @TheOnion piece that calls out indifference to the lives of Palestinian civilians.
4K
19K
69K
111
1K
5K
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
11 months
I have therefore made the unhappy decision to resign as senior editor at @eLife , after ten years working for the journal.
74
429
2K
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
11 months
This decision is both discriminatory and a dangerous precedent; it is also a violation of @eLife ’s own code of conduct, to be "respectful of differing opinions, viewpoints, and experiences.”
10
182
1K
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
I keep reading versions of the statement that genetic differences within a human population have no implications for genetic differences between populations, alongside strong statements about what we know about the causes of differences within a population. 1/n
22
309
879
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
Everything you have ever wanted to know about evolutionary quantitative genetics and GWAS but were afraid to ask, by Guy Sella and Nick Barton
3
271
612
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 years
Congratulations to Deborah Charlesworth for her election to the National Academy of Sciences. Long, long overdue.
5
57
367
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Hiring a postdoc with a strong statistical or computational background, interested in polygenic scores, their interpretation and their generalizability. Email me if interested. Starting date flexible but can be immediate. Thanks in advance for RT.
3
365
338
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
Wonderful collaboration with @ziyue_gao @moorjani_priya & @GuyAmster on human germline mutation. Our surprising findings: 1/4
6
155
276
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
4 years
I am looking to hire a postdoc at Columbia U., for a project modeling mutation processes. Applicants must have a strong quantitative background (in theoretical pop. gen., statistics or applied math/physics). Starting date flexible. If interested, email me. Grateful for RT.
4
390
262
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Hiring a postdoc with quantitative training and an interest in population genetics & evolution. Many possible topics. More about the lab here: If potentially interested, email me. Thanks for RT.
1
297
241
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Cool experimental results on patterns of mutation accumulation in human somatic tissues: Abascal et al. find a linear increase of mutations with time in post-mitotic neurons and “similar rates and signatures to some mitotically active tissues” 1/n
5
74
233
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
But most of the time, we don’t mean something all that precise. As the quip goes “An academic discipline is a set of individuals who agree not to question the same assumption” For population genetics, that assumption is a population. 6/n
3
27
228
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 years
In many contexts in human genetics, it is useful to know how deleterious the loss of a gene copy is likely to be. Hence the many, widely-used genic measures of “intolerance to mutation”.
2
38
194
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
I have been following the discussion around how best to represent and label human genetic variation, and thought it might also be worth discussing an aspect of the broader context. 1/n
3
58
162
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
So a population is a convenient abstraction that can obscure a key issue: When interpreting trait differences, we are forced to make comparisons among humans who experience different sets of environments without being able to control for them well. 25/25
8
29
157
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
I think there may be a miscommunication here
@Grey_Monroe
Grey Monroe
3 years
"A fundamental tenet of evolutionary biology is that mutations are random events...the likelihood of any particular mutational event is independent of its specific value to the organism" Lenski & Mittler, 1993
2
0
15
1
41
152
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 years
Over the past decade, it has become clear that different types of germline mutations accumulate with maternal and paternal ages at somewhat different rates, see, e.g.,
3
51
148
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
In the real world, the distinction between “within” and “between” populations is illusory. There is a giant family tree of humanity, and people who share more ancestral paths through it than others, and more similar environments than others. 7/n
2
23
140
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Immensely happy news: my former postdoc Molly Schumer will be joining the Biology faculty at Stanford.
3
10
138
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 months
For those in the NY area, SAVE THE DATE (& register) for a Symposium on Human Genetics at Columbia University: Oct 10-11 2024. Talks will also be streamed.
Tweet media one
1
47
143
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
To date, most of the discussion about polygenic scores has focused on differences (allele frequencies, LD) driven by population structure and implicitly reduced the question of portability to a population genetics problem.
2
66
131
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
@bvhalldorsson @moorjani_priya Hey @bvhalldorsson @sciencemagazine , this is not consistent with what is stated in the paper "The crossover and DNM data used in this work are available in the supplementary materials."
4
17
126
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
But none of these observations make mutation non-random *with regard to the outcome*, which is what these quotes are about.
10
12
126
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
Privileged and delighted to announce on @ziyue_gao Ziyue Gao’s behalf that she will be joining the Genetics faculty at UPenn as of May 2020.
4
16
123
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 years
Along with co-organizers @asiepel and Carolin Kosiol, delighted to announce that #probGen23 , the eighth meeting on Probabilistic Modeling in Genomics, will be held March 8-11 2023 at the Cold Spring Harbor labs.
2
45
115
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
It got me thinking about how that distinction is not well defined, for many reasons: principally because (i) “populations” are an abstraction and not a real thing and (ii) that abstraction hides huge amounts of environmental variability… 2/n
4
6
105
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Without controlled environments or experiments, heritability estimates are not informative about causes of trait variation, as Lewontin pointed out long ago: 22/n
1
19
98
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
Hiring a postdoc in population genetics: . If interested, email me, or come find me at Biology of Genomes?
0
148
89
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
New work by Ipsita Agarwal: She uses rare variants in GnomAD as proxies for de novo mutations and different “compartments” of human X and autosome to tease apart the factors (biochemical, life history) that shape the mutation spectrum. 1/n
1
53
76
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
These considerations motivate the recent turn from a standard GWAS--which picks up indirect effects, assortative mating, and population stratification effects—back to family designs: . 17/n
3
8
76
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
A population genetics perspective on measures of "intolerance to mutation" used in human genetics: . Work with @zl_fuller @JeremyJBerg @Hakha_Most and Guy Sella.
0
53
75
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
So it’s not about whether comparisons are made within vs between hypothetical populations. It’s about all the confounders that exist in the absence of the ability to do experiments and how well we can measure and control for them. 16/n
1
3
74
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Delighted for Priya Moorjani, who will leave my group to join the faculty of MCB at UCBerkeley Jan 2018.
0
6
73
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
and it is therefore misleading to imply there is a qualitative difference between ‘within-population’ and ‘between-population’ comparisons…” 9/n
3
5
71
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Biological Sciences at Columbia U. is hiring an Assistant Professor in Genomics: Please RT.
0
182
67
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
1 year
Reading @chrishwiggins & Matthew Jones' How Data Happened & liked their succinct statement: "Few scientific claims should be viewed with more suspicion than claims to innate difference that just happen to reflect our current social arrangements."
2
14
70
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
We can try slicing and dicing it into bins, but in fact, as @magnusnordborg writes: “Natural populations are never homogeneous, … 8/n
1
3
64
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
And between-group comparisons are often hopelessly confounded by these environmental differences. 11/n
1
2
63
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
We find that the ratio of paternal to maternal mutations is already ~3:1 by puberty and remains stable with increasing parental ages => spermatogenesis does not underlie the male bias in human mutation 2/4
3
29
62
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Critically, however, the limits imposed by not controlling environmental effects also apply to comparisons among individuals within the study group, not just between groups. Hence the problem of environmental confounding in GWAS: 15/n
1
6
63
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
Congratulations to Dr. Hakhamanesh Mostafavi @Hakha_Most and best of luck at Stanford and beyond. Very sad to see him leave...
Tweet media one
7
6
61
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Since humans are never compared in an experimental setting, nothing ensures that environmental effects are identical across groups. 14/n
3
2
59
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
...that correlate in unknown ways with genetic ancestry. Also bc (iii) it’s often unclear if people are talking about direct genetic effects only, or all the signals that can be picked up in a genome-wide association study (GWAS) 3/n
1
4
58
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
What people often mean to emphasize, I think, when they make the distinction “within” vs “between population” is something different: It’s that learning about genetic effects on human traits is incredibly difficult, because humans grow up & live in distinct environments. 10/n
2
6
58
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
It's well known that there are many modifiers of mutation rates, including methylation levels, replication timing and transcription rates.
1
5
55
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
@lkhayward and Guy Sella derive mathematical results for how phenotypic distribution and allele frequencies behave when the optimum value of a trait under stabilizing selection suddenly changes:
1
32
53
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
While these factors certainly matter, our results show they are not the only factors, and maybe not even the biggest factors, that influence the prediction accuracy of polygenic scores.
1
17
52
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
The newly anointed Dr. Felix Wu @FWuBiology , with the hat to prove it...
Tweet media one
6
2
50
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Moreover, the model under which heritability is estimated is one in which genetic and environmental effects are assumed to be separable (in addition to which there may be a specific interaction term). 23/n
2
4
49
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Population genetics offers operational definitions of populations with which we model genetic variation: a set of individuals that draw their allele frequencies from the same set of distributions, say (e.g., ). 5/n
2
4
47
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
4 years
A new thread about @arbelharpak and my paper on the evolution of group differences in changing environments, now out in @PLOSBiology : 1/n
@arbelharpak
Arbel Harpak
4 years
. @molly_przew & I wrote about how many complex traits may evolve under selection to maintain trait values in the face of changing environments. This scenario has implications for interpreting genetic signals of adaptation and combating racist arguments.
6
85
169
2
31
49
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Family designs such as sib GWAS can help tease apart direct genetic effects from all these other factors. (Precisely because family designs only include direct genetic effects, their prediction accuracy can be much lower than that of standard GWAS.) 18/n
1
4
49
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
…Once we leave an experimental setting, we are effectively skating on thin ice, and whether the ice will hold depends on how far out we skate.” 13/n
1
3
47
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
2 years
Many thanks for all the good wishes & kind messages.
2
0
46
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
Congratulations to the newly minted Dr. Yuval Simons! @yuvalsim
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
Tweet media three
4
2
46
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
for our sampling choices to be sound, and because otherwise we run the risk of conveying the false impression that human biology somehow works differently in different socially defined ancestry categories. 8/n
3
3
46
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Whether that model is truly applicable to traits that arise mostly (entirely?) from interactions with the social environment, such as behavior, is not clear to me. 24/n
3
4
45
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Congratulations to my postdoc Priya Moorjani and to @Kelley__Harris for being awarded a 2017 BWF Career Award:
0
8
45
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
We have known for over half a century that most of the genetic diversity found in humans is found within any ancestry grouping, and have confirmed it many, many times over. 4/n
2
4
43
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Thoughtful review on selection pressures shaping lactase persistence in humans, by @lsegurel :
1
25
42
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Evolutionary and quantitative geneticists learn about heritability as informing the expected increase in a trait in response to selection in one generation. 20/n
1
3
39
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
6 years
Thanks for featuring our results. Actually, our main finding--that the ratio of male to female mutations is already 3:1 by puberty and stays pretty stable with parental ages--is not subtle and is seen across data sets (Fig S2) 1/2
@gnxp_posts
Gene Expression blog et al.
6 years
The mutation accumulation controversy continues….
Tweet media one
2
16
32
2
10
38
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Consider the claim that polygenic scores (PGS) can be useful (if noisy) predictors within a population but don’t “port” well to other populations. What is a population here? 4/n
1
3
38
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
9 months
Congratulations to Dr. Carla Hoge!
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
Tweet media three
1
0
38
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
10 years
Our review on human germline mutation is officially out: http://t.co/hWmf2J04K8
2
50
35
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Quoting @magnusnordborg again: “With respect to confounding by population structure, the key qualitative difference is between controlling the environment experimentally, and not doing so… 12/n
1
2
36
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
8 years
Priya Moorjani, Ziyue Gao and my review on "human germline mutation and the erratic molecular clock":
0
39
36
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
4 years
Congratulations to @iagarwal2 , now Dr. Ipsita Agarwal!
Tweet media one
3
0
34
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
8 months
A reminder that abstracts for the annual meeting on Probabilistic Modeling in Genomics ( #ProbGen24 ) are due in a week (Feb 15). In Vienna this year, April 10-12 2024. Speakers and other information here:
0
11
36
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
Truly interesting paper suggesting that the "end-of-lifespan somatic mutation burden" doesn't differ much across mammals with very different lifespans (at least in the tissue considered).
@ATJCagan
Alex Cagan
3 years
I am incredibly excited to share our preprint ‘Somatic mutation rates scale with lifespan across mammals’In this paper we provide an unprecedented description of somatic mutation across mammals. An illustrated tweetorial…[1/17]
Tweet media one
38
538
1K
1
4
36
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
And it's worth considering if that is because of selection on the modifiers.
1
1
36
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Congratulations to Molly Schumer and 14 other recipients of the inaugural Hanna Gray HHMI fellowship:
0
7
35
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
The fuzziness around the concept of population also has other implications, for example for how we interpret heritability, a concept that is defined within a population. 19/n
1
3
33
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
5 years
On that basis, we argue that the question of where polygenic scores apply is broader than ancestry, and inextricably linked to questions about the importance of GxE on direct and indirect effects.
1
7
32
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
11 months
Helpful description of the choices of population designators in gnomad:
1
10
32
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
8 years
Looking for a postdoc interested in germline mutation and its evolution: . Please RT.
2
116
32
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
3 years
That those may result in lower mutation rates in some regions of the genome than others is interesting (*which* regions seem to differ among species).
1
2
32
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
However, it is not the case that we need to diversify study participants because there is some big reservoir of genetic variants out there that we would miss if we did not sequence every socially defined ancestry grouping. 3/n
4
3
31
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
Daniel Hooper on chromosomal inversion differences among passerine birds:
1
30
31
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 years
What PRDM9 does and does not do in vertebrates -- work by @zachTWbaker & Molly Schumer & @shevayuki2778 :
1
37
31
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
The appropriate study design obviously depends on the question. For some questions, studying a wide range of ancestries will be important. For others, it will not. Understanding, and spelling out, when population designators matter to science and medicine is important: 7/n
3
6
31
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
7 months
Registration is now open for the 2024 New York area Population Genetics meeting, organized by @bendesky . Keynote talks by @lindymcbr and @CedricFeschotte . At Columbia U, May 17, 2024. Register (free) and submit abstracts for talks or posters here:
0
14
28
@molly_przew
Molly Przeworski
8 years
Our new results on the evol. of PRDM9 and recombination in vertebrates, @ZachTWBaker , Molly Schumer, @shevayuki2778 :
0
35
28