Clinging to the phrase "a woman is anyone who identifies as a woman" is to tacitly admit that you can think of nothing that trans women share in common with natal females.
@Pinko69420
Also, that is literally a bad faith response.
The question is not asked in bad faith, it is asked in good faith, as a criticism of your position.
@Slatzism
Biotrans is real
They're trans trans. A woman trapped in the body of a man trapped in the body of a woman.
Gender scientists doing extra advanced biology expect to discover tran trans trans by the end of the decade.
@strongerpotions
Singular "they" is indefinite.
This is an indefinite use.
"You must call Sam Smith 'they'" is not indefinite.
To express surprise here is shockingly ignorant.
@Pinko69420
Why would you dodge what is, presumably, a question of profound importance?
If it's significant enough that a "trans girl" would suicide over being told he is not one, then it would behove you to be able to treat it with some degree of seriousness.
@JohannaMellis
@zaelefty
How do you imagine the dignity of the female athletes is maintained if they have to grin and bear the fact that their own exceptional performance & dedicated training regime is outclassed by far less remarkable male athletes?
All while being told the parody represents their sex?
@MalesOfReddit
Have to love the complete lack of accountability.
Predatory behaviour of the troon in question is why he is now "homeless". This is as clear a case of victim blaming as one could hope to find.
@whatever
This is the same principle at work as in the "you are not hookup material" post.
Many women are completely clueless as to the implications of mating strategies between choosy and chasey sexes, and thus their own behaviour and what men value and think.
In part because society
@JeannaHoch
@KnownHeretic
@COTimesRecorder
@HeidiBeedle
Weird how every time a trans rights activist is celebrated they inevitably commit or have already committed some heinous act.
But somehow everyone is supposed to believe that despite not being able to identify predators, its proponents are able to accurately identify trans kids.
@DatCatDer
@RexDraws
It is actually worse than it appears.
They did not walk out in response to anything Heying had said. They had a pre-determined time they decided to walk put and it just happened to coincide with that.
Their decision was based entirely in tribal logic, not even a reaction.
@jeffspolitics
Why did you ever think it was a worthwhile story?
There is something deeply broken if you think otherwise. Every such story has been shown to be nonsense. In particular instance you had to believe a 6 month pregnant woman started a confrontation with 5 fighting age males, worse.
@reddit_lies
Tens of millions of traffic stops per year...
13.6% of the population
~200 deaths per year
This definitely adds up, most informed predditor
@WhiningGimmicks
@Discord_Lies
Racially motivated murder...
Of white guys?
By a white-ish guy?
And then there's the whole "self defense" thing, and that Rittenhouse was putting out fires when he was ambushed soooo
@JohannaMellis
@zaelefty
Competition, not affirmation, is the very nature of competitive sports, by definition. What are you asking?
What "human dignity" is not afforded by sex segregated competitions?
How do you propose sport based scholarships are handled?
How about safety in contact sports?
@SanKelLee
@kim_siever
@WHnevermisses
The IBA must be thanking their lucky stars that of all the people they chose to unilaterally disqualify over non-existent tests turned out to actually have a DSD, right?
@GhawinRiver
Dawkins tells you exactly why they do not count - they produce visually unambiguous males and females.
Whereas Fauto Sterling's "typology" is males, females, herm males, herm females, and neutrois.
Are you on glue?
@datepsych
It is not about "sharing" it is about an industry takeover for each of them.
The incursion of ideological nonsense by people who do not consume them.
You are correct they are toys but radically misrepresent the complaint.
@phemoid
'Transphobic' literally means "normal" or "holds normal views" when used in context.
E.g. it is perfectly normal to not think there are male women, that men should not compete in women's sports, etc.
And those are the things that are decried as 'transphobic'. QED
@MYST_MX9
It straight up does not follow that a constant dose of hrt will cause "cycling"
But they have to tell themselves these things to affirm their erotic aspirations.
@wanyeburkett
It's pretty funny, given what preceded it was the kid hectoring Kirk about Trump and election results while Kirk says "please leave me alone, I am here to watch"
Then Kirk asks the question and the kid wigs out.
Even if you misconstrue Kirk as bad faith, it is absurd to attempt
@n4ski37
@Pinko69420
What a strange way to try and change the topic.
Why do you not have a good answer to an important question? Why do you, even now, try to change the topic (however ineptly) to avoid giving one?
@MalesOfReddit
An interesting case, an exact demonstration of the phenomena described by Blanchard, Bailey and Cantor:
Heterosexual sex for the AGP is a fulfilment of a view of what it means to be female, the sex is a product of that desire, not a bona fide same sex attraction.
@CovfefeAnon
People laughed at Peterson when he said that these people were angry at his for the crime of existence...
But what is this, if not complaining to society with regard to their resentments as there were an umpire to whom they could appeal?
@theserfstv
If this was done without cause, that is outrageous.
But two things:
1. That is unlikely, and if it was it will be reversed
2. Where was your outrage when your political opponents were summarily suspended with what was, unquestionable, without cause?
@yyeahsure
@Pinko69420
You are simply not using bad faith in any meaningful sense.
You can be assured that any response, earnestly given would be interesting and analysed for its implications and logical relations to other positions it's proponents might hold.
Don't use words you do not understand.
@TaylorAdvocate
It is not meant to communicate something, but instead to demoralise you by forcing you to repeat or stay silent in response to a phrase that makes no sense.
Being forced to lie, even by omission, is paychological poison.
@Howlingmutant0
Vitiligo is the ultimate blessing from the eye of history.
It means you can be white (beautiful, privileged) and black (virtuous, oppressed) without being murdered/dismembered by Africans looking for sorcery ingredients/boner pills (albino)
@sleepy_devo
@P_vonOberstein
This is a just so story, "transition" is an essentially unevidenced intervention. Studies that find a benefit are underpowered or methodologically flawed.
Well constructed studies find it is at best neutral.
...
@shengokai
Singal is one of the few members of the comentariat who both has some degree of credibility and has an accomodationist position on the "trans" issue.
He is the very opposite of a transphobe and you discredit yourself with such a claim.
@SCHIZO_FREQ
This is why it is not aexual harassment to request nude photos from your coworkers.
If they have a problem with it then clearly they are watching too much porn.
@sander_jennings
@iamsheadiamond
What do you mean by "trans women are women" specifically?
It appears obviously wrong - I.e. adult human males are adult human females - self contradictory- if 'woman' were a 'social role' then the slogan itself would be unnecessary or otherwise incoherent.
Can you clarify?
@PiscoLitty
@SwipeWright
Internet leftist does not understand counterfactual reasoning, a cornerstone of biology, quelle suprise.
How would you define "human" such that it encompasses people with Downs, people born without limbs and infertile people?
@GaryPayinda
Dr Gary discovers that karyotype, a sex determination mechanism, is not sex, a reproductive strategy, but remains confused about "spectrum".
What is the continuous variable, Gary?
@cephalopie
@jessesingal
What are you talking about? There are no anti-trans murders, all the violent rhetoric is aimed at TERFs by gender cultists.
As for legal assaults, weird that you imagine child safeguarding to be an assault.
@feral__mama
@kenzietuff
But it is literally saying he is NOT the complete package.
The complete package would be "I would have hooked up with you in a heartbeat, but I would always have wanted more".
@TBYSTweet
You can't be racist against goblins and orcs.
If they were not malevolent garbage savages then leftists and progs wouldn't champion them.
Being evil is basically requirement
#1
for the woke to love them.
@blablafishcakes
@Wild_Womyn
Tell them your pronouns are I/me.
And then make it impossible for them to figure out if you mean "I say 'I' and 'me' when I refer to myself" and "I want you to say 'I' and 'me' when you refer to me"
@Slatzism
Tips for attracting "high quality men"
1. Shower preeeettty much every day, sometimes more
2. Cut waaaay down on the orgies. Probably none tbh
@lukaszg141
@HeatherEHeying
That is sophistry. To ascribe a property to an individual is not an exhaustive linguistic act.
I.e. 'Mike is a plumber' is in no way incompatible with 'Mike is poet'.
@pkmntrainert
@PunchingCat
Can you imagine?
A friend told yours truly their cat got hit by a car and dragged himself back home with broken legs and pelvis.
Couldn't sleep for weeks imagining the horror.
@n4ski37
@Pinko69420
It is unclear whether your rhetorical ineptness in attempting to dodge the question or your overconfidence ignorance is more amusing.
@LORDBONGLORD
@Terfs_R
The logic is unquestionably that of autogynephilia - the erotic motivations clearly require being affirmed as a "woman" by women to be fulfilled.
Everything else is a smokescreen