3 unpleasant truths Beijing is learning about the West: 1 propaganda about a declining, divided West looks wrong given united, rapid support of Ukraine; 2 Russia is weaker than Beijing hoped; & 3 Western military technology is dominant on the battlefield.
1.4billion Chinese people with ‘hurt feelings’ from an NBA tweet, an Apple app or Tiffany ad is both a ridiculous &disturbing claim. Xi’s CCP has created a curated garden of outrage, and is weaponising their citizens’ emotions.
@noahbarkin
This is an extraordinary case of a democratic nation’s business community acting on behalf of the CCP. It’s behaviour the CCP wants to become normal.
Xi says Taiwan is a problem that shouldn't be passed to future generatons, tells the PLA & its Marine Corps to prepare for war, issues a PLA mobilisation order in January, kills the peaceful 1 country 2 systems option...Nothing to talk about here.
Germany relies on China for a key ammunition input, as does broader Europe. Globalised supply chains that hide dependence on authoritarian regimes like China's & Russia's are increasingly unacceptable.
After4.5 years, Friday is my last day at ASPI. I’m grateful for Peter Jennings’ insights, ideas & writing & for the company of a fantastic group of colleagues. It’s been a unique time to contribute to Australia’s security.
UN Resolution 2758 & the rest of the world (minus a few) recognise Taiwan as part of China.
It's the PRC's prerequisite for diplomatic relations.
So Taiwan Strait is Chinese waters as per UN Maritime Law.
Yet the U.S. led West regularly violates it under the pretext of FONOPs.
Training an F35 pilot costs about $10m and takes years. To have them take that knowledge & train the Chinese military can undercut the combat advantage of Aust’s $16.5bn F35 fighter fleet. So, enforcing security obligations & clarifying our laws is vital.
Why does anyone still call Geoff Raby ‘former Ambassador to China’ & not a China-based businessman whose income has depended on the favour of the Chinese Government for years now? I was once a 9 year old primary school student, but that isn’t the key fact about me now.
Former Australian Ambassador to China Geoff Raby awards Xi Jinping a “special distinction” for his statecraft and diplomacy before and after Putin’s invasion of Ukraine:
“The war has been entirely to China’s advantage…”
"It would be like the Chinese saying to us, look, we think Tasmania..."
No, it wouldn't be. Former Australian prime minister Paul Keating demonstrating his historical and strategic illiteracy on Taiwan. Kudos to
@FergusonNews
for challenging him.
‘The crowds were organised, transported, equipped & monitored by the Chinese Govt thru its embassy & state-linked groups. Far from spontaneous support for Li, it was a large Chinese state-organised propaganda & disruption exercise in Australia’s capital’
Senate candidate linked to Chinese government's foreign influence arm: ‘Dr Li said he was disappointed that his connections with the United Front groups were being raised’. No doubt that’s true.
Japan's new PM: Kishida's 'security & foreign policy reflects over 4.5 years as Shinzo Abe's foreign minister. Economic security is high on his agenda, as is Japan's military power. Good news for Quad, free & open Indo Pac
So, Vodafone found backdoors in Huawei software giving Huawei unauthorised access to a network serving millions of Italian homes and businesses. Despite Huawei’s assurances, testing show the backdoors remained. That’s a problem for governments, telcos and businesses.
A credible explanation for Australia's very poor Ukraine military package is Defence had to absorb the costs, so it cobbled together items it had that wouldn't affect its own priorities. The result: some trucks & M113 vehicles the Army Chief said weren't good enough for the ADF.
It makes no sense to allow China’s protected & advantaged EV companies to get unrestricted market access to other economies. The Chinese state would use this market dominance as a weapon. De-risking has to apply to EVs.
The Belt & Road Initiative isn't mainly about debt, but dependency: 'Beijing doesn’t aim to impoverish its potential clients, but to ensure...their national systems are fully oriented towards' consuming 'Chinese technology & services' says Vijay Gokale
I’m a little tired of reading Hugh White’s reformulation of “Resistance Is Useless”, as he tries to convince us that Australia and the rest of the democratic world is weak & hopeless while authoritarian China is apparently invulnerable & unstoppable.
"Why Australia's China strategy is dangerous"
What is dangerous is an analysis that only maintains its internal logic by eliminating the Taiwanese from its equation of regional security.
"Chinese authorities asked Sony Pictures to delete the Statue of Liberty from Spiderman: No Way Home". Two things: this symbol of liberty is powerful enough inside China to worry the CCP, & the CCP's anxiety is raw.
Spider-Man: No Way Home was banned in China. Chinese authorities had asked Sony Pictures to delete the Statue of Liberty from the movie; Sony immediately said no. Then they asked Sony to ‘minimize’ it; Sony thought about this but ultimately passed.
Britain's plans to offer millions of Hongkongers visas & paths to citizenship needs other 5 Eyes' nations buy in,
@AFP
reports. It's the morally right action, upholds our values & adds talented people to our nations.
Of 24 Chinese-language media outlets, 17 attended united front’s overseas media forum, 12 had executives in united front groups, at least 4 seem to have had CCP funding or support. Global Times' reaction: no rebuttal, much hysteria. Report with evidence:
Ex-Royal Air Force pilots teaching Chinese military pilots tactics & techniques for cash is shocking. I'd like to be sure Australian ex-military pilots aren't doing this too. It's against everything these pilots signed up to protect & needs to be outlawed.
The CCP didn’t use Kissinger to improve relations. They used him to broadcast their talking points to a receptive listener delighted to be the centre of attention. Numerous formerly powerful people have this need.
These armed drones are for use against China’s own citizens. The CCP is not as confident in the love of all 1.4bn Chinese citizens as Xi likes to project to the world.
The difference between Manila & Beijing in the South China Sea, as China knows, is that the Philippines is acting to protect its sovereign territory in accordance with international law, while China is breaking international law in attempts to seize others’ territory by force.
For one, Beijing also enacted domestic laws on its maritime zones in the early 1990s, so I don't see why Manila's move is any different. If PH authorities follow through, the new Act will "harmonize" with UNCLOS. In any case, isn't Beijing interfering with PH domestic affairs?
Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi’s visit: the sounds of silence. The visit happened on Beijing's terms, with stage management & silences familiar to journalists & citizens in mainland China, but quite alien to Australia's open democracy.
“In return for Australian capitulation in the name of stabilization, Beijing has given up little beyond removing trade restrictions it was wrong to impose in the first place”
@lavinalee3
Australian can do more now to support the Ukrainian military. Giving more Bushmasters - & the Hawkei vehicles - will do 2 things: 1. add momentum to NATO efforts - and 2. show that Prime Minister Albanese hasn't forgotten the war the Ukrainian people are fighting.
NEW from
@nataliabugayova
: The debate about the US facing a “long war” in
#Ukraine
is misframed.
Failing to resource all of the required Ukrainian counteroffensives — not just the next one — will protract
#Russia
’s war & increase the risks for the US.⬇️
Why on earth has UQ not dismissed the Chinese Consul General from his Honorary professorship at UQ? Or at least called him to account against the UQ code of conduct?
Update: “The court instructed the PRC Consul General, the University of Queensland, the Confucius Institute at UQ and the Chinese Students and Scholars Association, to provide any communications about the July attacks on Hong Kong protestors at UQ.”
Chinese government officials threaten an Australian artist’s powerful critique of the CCP & authoritarianism. Time for Australian diplomats in Europe to step up.
@vtchakarova
@simongerman600
China - ‘neutrally partnered with Russia’ and India - too dependent on Russian hardware to say much - are big parts of this two thirds stat. So, the surface figure tells us less than you suggest.
'Xi has achieved the trifecta of change in just 5 years-getting Aust to shift from diesel to nuclear subs & getting the UK & US to share nuclear technology with Australia'. China's environment has worsened as a result.
So refreshing what everyone has known for years can now be said by the Aust, Japanese, Canadian, US, UK and other governments: The Chinese state steals commercial secrets from the rest of the world at scale. If you can't name the problem, you won't solve it. A great first step.
Australia publicly accuses China of economic espionage operations against Oz as the US leads coordinated western condemnation of Chinese global hacking ops.
Aust Govt ‘Ukraine support’ fails to meet the lowest expectations.’70 military vehicles’ includes 28 trucks & 28 obsolete Vietnam-era M113s that were destined for the boneyard. If this is it, Albanese should stay away from the July NATO meeting.
'A war may arrive in this decade, & the US must be prepared.' 'the simple reality is..the US would face serious difficulty in an extended trans-Pacific conflict'
@ElbridgeColby
So, Australia must produce, repair & sustain more of what it needs in war
Denise Ho: ‘I would prefer to be arrested in Hong Kong than extradited to China’. Why does a Hong Kong pro-democracy voice get questioned for 30mins & asked if she has weapons as she enters Australia? Are pro-Chinese State voices treated this way? Actions must follow values.
Australia's govt - & other PIF members - can't keep pretending Sogavare wants a democracy in the Solomon Islands. He's used Chinese money & will use Chinese security forces to stay in power. Now, like dictators through history, he's changing the Constitution to avoid elections.
So it's happening. PM Soga has submitted the Constitution Amendment Bill to postpone dissolution of the 11th Parl. I encourage citizens to use the Bills Committee process to air their views.
AUKUS: draft US laws ‘greenlight the sale of two Virginia-class submarines to Australia, permit the training of Australian nationals for submarine work and allow Canberra to invest in the US submarine industrial base.’
“Professionals with inside knowledge” say the Taipans are in a “variety of configurations. Some have been almost completely pulled apart, but many others are in far better condition” “12 to 20 Taipans could be reassembled without any great difficulty”
Something unthinkable a few years ago just happened: Japanese destroyer escorts Australian vessel for 1st time. Practical cooperation to strengthen regional deterrence.
The Chinese govt wants us to believe its authoritarian model is best for fighting Covid, but a democracy with Chinese characteristics - Taiwan - is the beacon of global best practice, closely followed by other democracies: South Korea, NZ & Australia.
Beijing is making it easier for the Philippines to cooperate even more closely with the US, Japan and every other partner like Australia interested in sovereignty, maritime security and international law.
Australia can’t expect support for AUKUS in Washington if we don’t do our part. Deciding where the East Coast base now will leave just enough time to get it built by 2043. Big infrastructure projects in Australia are slow.
Victoria's BRI program's a zombie project, proceeding despite the world changing around it. It's undermining national cohesion on China. It must be halted & reassessed by Federal agencies who understand national security, technology & foreign policy.
“Voting against this bill is a vote for the Chinese Communist Party. The opponents of this bill aren’t defending free speech, they’re defending Chinese access to American data and American minds.”
We just passed legislation out of the House that will separate TikTok from the Chinese Communist Party. You‘ve probably heard lies that this bill is a Trojan horse, or that it doesn’t solve every problem on planet earth. The truth is, this bill just says that TikTok can’t be
South Korea providing military supplies direct to Ukraine would be very good news in 2 ways: 1. ROK defence technology & production is first rate - & 2. It shows President Yoon understands the connection to security in the Indo Pacific.
Awkward truths about US & UK AUKUS challenges. "Put together, the three reports show an alarming and growing set of challenges in front of Australia’s AUKUS partners when it comes to meeting their own submarine needs."
Tomorrow's AUSMIN is all about China, but our approach needs to escape the gravitational pull of US-China rivalry- because China is a challenge to many nations, not just a bilateral tussle with Washington, & what Australia does matters beyond Beijing & DC
This narrative that conflates criticism of the Chinese Communist Party with discrimination against Australians of Chinese ethnicity is intellectually flawed and does the damage it says it fears.
Gareth Evans says,
@Asialink_au
speech: in current climate of hyper-anxiety about baleful Chinese, & particularly CPC, influence in AU business, politics & unis, Chinese-Australians are going to find it even more difficult than they do at present to aspire to leadership positions
The ‘5 Nots’ of AUKUS: it’s not an alliance, not a replacement for the Quad, not a departure from engaging ASEAN, not a substitute for the 5 Eyes, or just about subs. It IS a technology accelerator to shift the military balance in the Indo Pacific.
There are five reasons Australia needs to do more now to support the Ukrainian military. Only one is because helping 44 million people resist a murderously brutal invasion is the right thing to do.
‘Japan’s capital is quickly closing the gap with Beijing as global information technology companies and other businesses turn way from the Chinese city due to growing security concerns and U.S.-China tensions.’
A former Japanese envoy to the US said US presidential elections are like Christmas presents for Japan:
‘No matter what turns out to be inside the box when it is unwrapped, he said, Japan has to immediately respond, “This is exactly what I wanted.”’
Australian Navy divers were injured by PLA aggression, but this seems not to have made the agenda btw Mr Albanese & Xi Jinping at APEC. What is leaders' dialogue for if not to say simple difficult things directly?
Malcolm Turnbull tells us: ‘When we were at odds with China the Australian business community tended to side with China’ & ‘the Vice Chancellors in particular sided with China’. Doesn’t seem to be causing a ripple, despite being shocking & true.
It’s worth paying attention to what Lavrov & Putin think is at stake in Ukraine. Based on their 4 February meeting & their joint China-Russia statement, I think Xi agrees with his two Russian friends.
“This is not about Ukraine at all, but the world order. The current crisis is a fateful, epoch-making moment in modern history. It reflects the battle over what the world order will look like" - Sergei Lavrov, Russian Foreign Minister.
Straight from the horse’s mouth.
This is good news! Those mechanical and warranty issues that were preventing Mr Albanese and Russell Hill from providing Hawkeis to Ukrainian soldiers fighting Russian forces now look to be resolved. We can get Aussie Hawkeis battle tested & help Ukraine.
A regime that operates like this is one other nations must give less leverage to. Diversification and digital decoupling is the minimum essential response. Business leaders have to stop trying to find new reasons to discount the risks of Xi’s China.
There’s no equivalence between Canberra & Beijing’s espionage activities. Canberra doesn’t pollute other nations’ domestic politics or do broad-based industrial espionage. But Beijing’s threats increase risk of arbitrary arrest for Australians in China
China will vote at the UN General Assembly calling for 'peace & mutual respect' while hiding it's support of inhuman, war hungry material circulating in China. The Party State censors words like 'Peng Shuai' & 'Winnie the Pooh', so this is deliberate choice by Beijing.
23. A viral video from China is advocating people to not share compassion with war victims in Ukraine but support Russia.
The influencer has more than 12millions followers from 抖音Douyin(tiktok‘s Chinese mother company)and 快手 Kuaishou
Japan's 2nd new gen 3000 ton attack submarine began construction in 2018. It's estimated to cost US$640 million, be launched in 2021, enter service early 2023 & have lithium ion batteries. Fast delivery, attractive cost, modern technologies...
Imagine needing to get a promise to not be punished if you join an international inquiry into the causes of a global pandemic. Seeking such a promise shows an understanding of who you’re dealing with. Believing it is charming.
Remember how close Australia came to signing an extradition treaty with China under the previous Labor & Coalition governments- as part of what now seems a ridiculous Comprehensive Strategic Partnership?
“It may look purely symbolic but it means someone like Kevin Yam, an Australian, will have to fly over many Asian countries which have extradition treaties with China before he can land somewhere safely,”
@mcgregorrichard
, a senior fellow at
@LowyInstitute
, told me.
APEC shifts strategic momentum to US. Xi’s core problem is he isn't being believed. The gap between ‘open, inclusive, balanced, global economy’ words and Chinese actions are just too great to bridge. And the US, with its partners are devising alternatives.
This uncritical reporting by the SMH of Chinese military talking points is disturbing: it buys the idea the problem is the US, not China’s seizure and fortification of islands it now ‘must protect’ by force.
Anyone but a politician who sold out their country to a foreign spy agency would have a bag on their head, & police forensic teams tagging & bagging all the electronic devices in their house. ASIO doesn't decide on prosecutions. Time for the Attorney General to do his job.
Sean Aylmer talks to Michael Shoebridge about
#ASIO
's startling claim that a foreign spy network allegedly 'cultivated and recruited' a former politician.
Listen here 🔊
Xi’s policies on Taiwan, the Chinese economy & the US have all ‘hit a wall’ but no one around him can say so. The new Great Helmsman isn’t likely to change direction, because, like Mao before his end, Xi can’t have made mistakes: only those around him do.
PM Albanese not raising the PLA’s dangerous sonar use against the Australian Navy last year told Xi he needn’t stop. Now more lives have been threatened. It’s time for Mr Albanese to use his leader to leader relationship, pick up a phone & tell Xi to stop
US-China talks: Not much optimism here. Beijing using old plot: others have to give China concessions to show they want to ‘reset’ relations. Beijing just ‘clarifies’ it’s positions.
COVID-19 has no nationality. COVID-19 originated in Wuhan. Without the Chinese Govt’s suppression of doctors reporting it, the world would have had a chance of containing it in Wuhan. Xi Jinping’s govt lost us all that chance.
Opinion: The virus does not have a nationality. Using racist and xenophobic names to cast blame for the outbreak on other countries can only reveal politicians' irresponsibility and incompetence
Anyone wondering whether the Chinese government’s efforts at political interference in democracies are real has their answer with this CCP-instigated protest against Taiwan’s President Tsai Ing-wen visiting the US.
Racism against Chinese students in Aust is not a factor in Beijing's calculus. The Global Times inadvertently told the truth-Beijing's pressure's about the Aust govt acting in our national interests on the pandemic inquiry, freedom in Hong Kong, investment
Global Times' recycling Aust media reporting from 1995 & claiming a map, compass & money prove spying might be laughable, but it shows the risk of arbitrary arrest of Australians under the CCP's Party-controlled legal system is growing.
In times of weakness, the CCP traditionally sees confrontation as sensible. That's bad news, as now Beijing is in a weakened position internationally & struggling domestically - so aggression against India makes insane sense.
Aust's new defence strategy requires an urgent increase in military power. The key is fast delivery on sovereign missile production, fuel security, & in-service autonomous systems. Plans & cash are there, but need to be accelerated to match the strategy
Taiwan's COVID-19 response is incredibly good. A similar sized population to Aust right beside China has 322 confirmed cases and 5 deaths. Aust: 4,800 cases, 20 deaths. Our PM and President Tsai need to talk. And we need to cooperate and learn.
The voices of rusted-on self-interest are already advocating we maintain or even increase our dependence on China. With Covid-19, the Chinese state has created unacceptable risks for the rest of us. That'll go on until we reduce the leverage we give them
Shinzo Abe is the father of the Quad, the vision for a Free & Open Indo Pacific, the deep Aust-Japan strategic partnership & of Japan as a force for good in regional security. His life is defined by achievements.
It was during Shinzo Abe’s term that Japan founded its Free and Open Indo Pacific vision. It’s also Abe who presided over formulation of the Vientiane Vision that reinvigorated defense and security ties with SE Asia. We will always remember your stewardship and contribution. 🙏🏼
Pres Biden has appointed Jim Miller, former top Pentagon official, to spearhead its plan to help Australia develop nuclear-powered submarines & the rest of AUKUS. A new position not in DoD & with direct access to the leader-not a bad idea.
@WSJ
Peng Shuai wrote: ‘Even if I’m an egg throwing myself at a rock, even if I’m a moth flying at a flame, courting my own destruction, I will still speak the truth of us.’ Only Orwellian doublespeak can seek to airbrush this away.
Chinese tennis star Peng Shuai said that she had never accused anyone of sexually assaulting her, and that a social media post she had made early last month had been misunderstood
China's defence minister Wei telling us the PLA 'should be considered 'part of the world's peace forces'' reminds me of Carrie Lam saying the brutal HK National Security law was all about bringing 'peace' to Hong Kong:
Australia cancels it’s only near term armed drone program & buys more crewed helicopters. Ukraine uses armed drones to destroy Russian helicopters. Who here is making good choices?
Australia’s diesel, lead acid battery sub program with the French was taking too long & costing too much to get too little. Ending it was in our national interest, & entering the AUKUS arrangement is too.
Sigh. ‘Mr Morrison has…deliberately deceived the French.” So tired of ex-PMs awarding themselves a free kick on Australian strategic policy. Australia is exercising its contractural entitlements to withdraw from the program.
Bigger news than Xi-Albanese if you're interested in substance: Japan's Fumio Kishida & South Korea's President Yoon 'held the first official summit between the two countries in nearly three years'.
Beijing tries to tell us 2 things: the South China Sea is Beijing’s, and anyone not agreeing is a US puppet. Both are wrong. The SCS is an international waterway with overlapping claims. And many nations have interests in ending Beijing’s intimidation there.
State-run
#China
Daily editorial: The UK should “refrain from being Washington’s sharksucker" after British warship sailed through contested waters in the
#SouthChinaSea
Daniel Andrews: “I’m not quite sure what people are suggesting, rather we have a good relationship with China or..a bad one, or we send less product to China, rather than more,”-This one dimensional view shows he needs national security agencies' insights
Countries watched but did little while the Chinese State militarised the South China Sea. We’re now watching while 1 million Uighur people are interned. Watching isn’t setting any limits. What’s next?
BRI wedge tactics by Beijing have failed. Good decision by Minister Payne - although the Victorian govt could have understood the importance of cohesive national policy on China & not created the problem for the Feds to fix.
As EU puts sanctions in place for Chinese govt’s mass atrocities in Xinjiang, Beijing warns it will try to punish those who speak first (see Australia for notes). This is Xi’s ‘China Dream’ for anyone not in the CCP. Silence & acquiescence is the goal.
Ahead of EU’s human rights sanctions on Monday, China warned EU institutions “spearheading accusations” against Xinjiang policies will bear the brunt of planned countermeasures, while “individuals in EU countries” who have “behaved badly” will be punished.
Not all European leaders are fawning on Xi. Poland, Lithuania and other central European stares who’ve experienced Russian authoritarianism first hand before are pretty clear eyed about Xi & the CCP. Xi’s Moscow trip validates these concerns.
Especially after Xi's visit to Moscow, it must indeed be a bit strange to sit in Washington and watch European leaders fall over themselves to accommodate the most important ally of Russia in a war in Europa that the US is making bigger contributions to than the EU itself.
Elite unis say academics feel undervalued & it's the government's fault for not using their work more. Apparently it's also think tanks' fault for getting listened to here & internationally. Could it be about policy relevance instead?
On Mr Keating’s ‘advice’: ‘Turning away from powerful partners like Japan, India, the US & the UK & seeking stability through China’s role in the world is a fanciful path to hear from the mouth of a former prime minister.’
Huawei are hiring Obama’s former director of Cybersecurity policy, Samir Jain, as a lobbyist. He’ll be full of insights from his time in US Govt service and probably also have ideas on countering DoJ proceedings against Huawei. And somehow this sits comfortably with Mr Jain.