Teaches History King's College London. 20th Century Britain, Technology, Science, War. History and policy. New book “The Rise and Fall of the British Nation”.
Keir Starmer was insisting again that Labour's result in 2019 was the worst since 1935. Actually 1935 was a good year for Labour. And 2019 was better than 1983, 1987, 2010 or 2015. Labour lost badly in 1935 because of the electoral system, not lack of support.
Looks like Starmer’s changed Labour may well have fewer total votes than Labour got in that supposedly worse than 1935 election in 2019. Trouble ahead.
Forgive the shameless plug, but ... As we cut ourselves off from the continent over the New Year it might be a good time to think about British history, not because it led us to this mess, but precisely because it makes clear we are living in a new and very peculiar present.
Struck again, this time by interview of
@Ed_Miliband
on Today this morning, by the self-inflicted damage caused by Labour's own claim that its performance has got worse since 2010/15. Even 2019 saw a bigger vote share than 2010 or 2015, and 2017 was of course much higher.
My thoughts on how and why the myth of Britain alone was created on VE-Day and why 8 May was barely noted in the UK compared to D-Day, and above all Dunkirk, the Battle of Britain and the Blitz.
@kingscollegeLon
@kingshistory
@kingscbh
Chilling from
@adam_tooze
: 'we should certainly expect them to turn the crisis that they have created against the public sector in pursuit of their misbegotten vision of a small-state revolution'.
@davidallengreen
The national mythology of the Blitz Spirit didn't help - it was a post-war invention, and it is this imaginary Blitz which blights our politics.
It was a pleasure to meet with
@JustinTrudeau
, for a productive conversation about our mutual solidarity with the Ukrainian people and our unshakeable commitment to NATO.
Unity amongst democratic nations is vital in the face of Russian barbarism.
In 1956 the UK sought, with France, to assert its rights over Egypt. The US stopped them. Today a diminished UK is preparing to assert its sole sovereignty in Northern Ireland, ignoring the WA and the GFA. US and EU pressure will ensure it will be a case of Suez with knobs on.
Tony Blair claims 1935, 1983 and 2019 the worst defeats Labour has ever had, and all the fault of the far left. 1935 was easily the highest vote share of the interwar period, and better than 2005. Again in terms of vote share, 2019 was not the worst. He didn't mention 2017.
'Do you think you'll be the last ever Labour Prime Minister?' -
@campbellclaret
Alastair Campbell questions former Prime Minister Tony Blair on whether the Labour Party will ever be able to win another general election.
Just been to Northern Ireland. No queues at petrol stations. No shortages in the supermarkets.
Plus.
Marks and Spencer looking to open seven new shops.
In a typical colloqualism I heard today "What about ya?" What about ya NI.
Another case of peak investment in the 1960s and 1970s under public ownership followed by low investment and asset sweating under privatisation … rise and fall of the investing nation one might say.
'Social democracy has always been powerfully constrained by capitalism, as the historical record of the Labour Party clearly shows. But it is quite another thing to be limited by the politics of the Tory Party, especially the current one.' My latest ...
'It is this decaying British nationalism, a leftover from the 1970s, that is now disrupting the union, not the self-conscious Scottish, Irish and Welsh versions'. My thoughts on Brexit and breakup in today's New York TImes
'It’s essential Labour avoids this trap: reject the “black hole”. Refuse to accept cuts, now or later. Argue for well-funded public services in a high-investment, high-wage economy, taxing the rich if necessary.'
@meadwaj
Brexit Britain has faked it but has not made it - my thoughts on Britishvolt, industrial strategy, and the dangers of delusional thinking about being world-beating.
“Blaming empire is a deep-seated reflex that feels reassuringly progressive.” Re-upping this from last year as there is a fresh round of empire-invocation going on.
In the latest breach of Cabinet discipline, Alok Sharma say Charles should go to COP27: “Of course, he is head of state in the United Kingdom but he is also head of state in other countries, some of which are very much on the front line of climate change."
Perry Anderson's account of British history was a very necessary call to arms, but there is much that needs challenging. My thoughts in the
@newstatesman
My thoughts on Labour's recent electoral performance - 1997 and 2017 were good years for Labour, 2019 was not as bad as 2010 or 1987, and we are now back to 1983
@kingshistory
@kingscbh
Obviously I'm a heretic anti-growth sort, but while reading my daily quota of articles suggesting the UK can be a world leader in this or that sector I do wonder whether we actually need all this 'aspiring world leader' stuff and couldn't just focus on being just ok at stuff...
Forgive the shameless plug but this is a moment to remember that the majority of the British working class did not Labour until 1945, and even then the majority was not huge, nor long lasting. Discussed in my
As we go from Brexit to the Covid-19 crisis, we seem to be shifting historical analogy from Britain stood alone to the people's war versions of world war two. Both are postwar myths. Careless historiography costs lives!
A fascinating must-read article - in effect we had a radical liberal Brexiter approach ('delay') which crashed in flames last week - we are now going European via
@alexwickham
'Wilson was the great hope of British social democracy, and his failure was its failure ... it was under Wilson that Labour last wished to undertake a programme of national renewal while in office.' My weekend essay for the
@NewStatesman
'Thatcher did not roll back the state. Instead, she changed whom it serves and what it can do, in ways that still shape our world.'
@chakrabortty
nails the inconvenient verities.
It is telling that the Labour party’s fundamental criticism of the Tories is their lack of competence, rather than their policies. Some thoughts on the implications of Starnakism.
Looking for a cheap Xmas present for someone you want to enlighten or perhaps annoy? I shamelessly suggest this, though please buy it from a proper bookshop.
Nailed: 'Dominic Cummings may seem like a novelty in the political realm, but he’s a version of just about every big-league MBA School graduate who has mistaken reading airport lounge books about Silicon Valley and quantum physics for wisdom'.
Brexit is going feral. New post on my Brexit Blog on how and why we're seeing an intensifying attack on the Civil Service (and judiciary, BBC and some media, business). It's dangerous - but the Government should be wary of hubris. Long read, just up:
Some thoughts on History and Brexit in the Observer
@kingshistory
@kingscbh
@kingsartshums
The idea of deep continuity in British history is absurd. We’ve always been in flux | David Edgerton
An extraordinarily revealing and damning interview given by Philip Hammond on Brexit. Confirms lots of worse fears, including
@davies_will
view of May as a narrow securocrat.
The UK R&D 'roadmap' just published uses 'world-leading' 18 times and phrases like 'moon-shots' and 'big bets'. It is a shamefully poor, evidence-free document. Even a third rate knowledge economy could produce a better document than this.
@guydej1
'Increasingly, the situation for the EU seems like that of a law-abiding citizen stuck with the neighbour from hell. At first, you try polite, rational argument ... But they just swear at you and turn the music up louder.'
@chrisgreybrexit
does it again!
Saw 1917 this week. Astonished that none of the five reviews I read pointed to its consistent portrayal of the Germans, collectively and individually, as sneaky, and better supplied, than the (diverse) tommies. The nationalist narcissism of the film is surely worthy of comment.
'The most remarkable and the most tragic thing about Brexit is how rare it now is to hear anyone – and certainly the Brexit Ultras - speak of it as something that gives them any pleasure'. Another remarkable blog from
@chrisgreybrexit
I am afraid the Guardian has fallen for the myth that the NHS is paid for through national insurance. The whole point of the NHS was that it was (overwhelmingly) tax-funded and for all, not just those who paid NI.
Half a century on from the collapse of Bretton Woods and the emergence of a fiat money world, 20 years since the beginning of the euro, it is time to give our financial and monetary system a new constitutional purpose. Essential reading from
@adam_tooze
'We need a policy of doing better, not falsely claiming to be the best. We desperately need a more modest politics, a politics of improvement and imitation, rather than one of rhetorical excess and deepening social misery.'
"The idea that Brexit is an anti-elite project is a nonsense."
Professor David Edgerton says, "a certain section of the British political class are suffering from terrible delusions of grandeur."
On this day remember that Operation Bagration, on the Eastern Front, starting 23 June 1944 was very much larger than D-Day and Normandy, and so were casualties. In UK and US we forget that victory came in May 1945, not June 1944, in Berlin, not Normandy.
Can Britain really become an 'innovation superpower' after Brexit? And why does its political class still appeal to ideas of national exceptionalism?
@aaronbastani
interviews
@DEHEdgerton
premiering on our YouTube now 👇
Great piece by Vaclav Smil - Moore's law an exception - most technical change is much, much slower. Exponential growth is a pipe dream via
@financialtimes
'Rather than austerity as such, it is selective austerity that has defined the Conservatives’ approach over the past decade: key voter groups such as pensioners and asset-owners have been shielded ...' Exactly right by
@georgeeaton
Fascinating 1948 interview with Aneurin Bevan where he makes clear his dislike of the Beveridgean contribution system, preferring tax-funded social services like the NHS.
On the 72nd anniversary of the NHS, we republish an interview with its founder, Aneurin Bevan, in which he describes the socialist ambitions that influenced its creation.
A great piece from
@gsoh31
- fantasy science policy and no political economy. In this Cummings shows himself to be as old fashioned, as British, and as daft as, say, C. P. Snow.
@chrisgreybrexit
mourns 'A diminished and dolorous land whose only route to salvation lies in the honesty stolen by its guilty men and which, even now, or at least for now, eludes us.. '
Delighted to kick off a new series of podcasts on the Second World War on this 8th May with a discussion on how to understand the British Second World War. World War Two Revised
@johnmcternan
John, Labour did worse than 1935 in 1974, 1979, 1983, 1987, 1992, 2005, 2010, 2015, and 2019. It did worse than in 2019 in 1983, 1987, 2010, and 2015.
"It does not have to be like this". But it is. New post on my Brexit Blog analysing the Frost letter, latest debates about extension, trust, and the glimpses we're getting of post-Brexit Britain. Just up:
'as Brexit limps on, the unloved orphan of a failing populism ... we shouldn’t forget the lies shamelessly told, the promises blithely made, and the fears viciously propagated which have brought us to this shambolic point'.
@chrisgreybrexit
sums it up.