@EYakoby
Keep up the great work Eyal.
I don't understand how Penn, and the US, is allowing this to happen. It's pretty incredible to watch.
Any student showing any level of affinity towards a terrorist organization should be immediately expelled, investigated and potentially deported.
Whitelisting with editorial partners on FB changed the trajectory of our DTC business.
It took us from a miserable 0.9x ROAS to a profitable 2.1x ROAS with 4x the spend practically overnight.
Here’s what we learned.. 👇
Why can't Shopify just come out with an A/B testing native feature?
Put it right in the theme customizer - "start an A/B test" and then you build it. Connect it to Shopify purchase data + GA web data
Relatively low lift feature to build that'd make ecom world go bananas
I believe creative fatigue is 95% a lie.
Good ads that are wide-appealing & well thought-out don't fatigue in days or weeks.
If you think bad performance after a few weeks is creative fatigue - it's probably not. You just have bad ads.
Genuinely *good* ads are durable
Meta gave us $30K ad credit to A/B/C test the following this month:
Cell A:
• ASC with no restrictions, purchase objective ($10K)
Cell B:
• ASC with no restrictions, purchase objective ($7K)
• Manual "mid-funnel" campaign using 5 & 10% Pur LALs, purchase objective ($3K)
I like
@social_savannah
's testing structure.
Test creative on a 1-2x AOV budget. If you don't get any purchases within that budget, it's probably not a winner.
I've been using this for ~2 months and the winning creative it provides typically works just as well on higher spends.
Meta recommends that I increase my daily budget on this ad set from $500/day to $149,000/day to maximize my results with my current bid cap.
Should i take the advice?
When you step out of the DTC Twitter echo chamber, you realize two things:
1. There is so much opportunity out there to win
2. So many brands and people are crushing in DTC that you have never heard of on Twitter
We are now slowing rolling out a new agency directory on 1-800-D2C.
This will help us highlight both the tech stacks and the service stacks behind the best brands in D2C.
Our agency platform will be the same as brands and tools: a directory of the best, not a directory of all.
I've never understood how Apple's privacy policies impact FB, Snap, TikTok, etc. differently?
Why is FB the only one that seems to be dealing with the ramifications and Snap/Pinterest say it doesn't impact their platforms?
Or is FB the only one publicly owning the problem?
Athletic Greens could easily be one of the strongest DTC brands ever. For sure in health and wellness.
Every supplement brand either wants to be like them or rip them off somehow. All of them look to AG for inspiration for something, no doubt.
There has to be hundreds of
AG proving that you can build a massive $200M rev biz against just one killer offer.
Lots of nuances of course... and I'm sure insane testing to arrive to this exact one, but the use of offers like this is so underrated
We've directed over 80% of ad spend to whitelisting editorial partners. We've seen crazy efficiencies:
• 35% decrease in CPA
• 30%+ increase in ROAS
• Over 3% CTRs & CPCs < $0.30s
But the real benefit is being able to story tell & entertain customers, not hard-sell up front.
Recently transitioned our FB account to be 100% on cost caps & CBO.
No more "testing" or "scaling" campaigns - it's all one now.
Our account efficiency has increased ~15% but volume has dropped ~10%.
It still blows my mind how
@Shopify
is so against CBD. Can't make use of Shop Pay, Shop or anything.
I can sell my products in Whole Foods, CVS, Wegmans, etc. but can't use the full features of Shopify?
@harleyf
let's partner up and fix this.
We are about to launch hundreds (soon thousands) of app/tool comparisons on .
While they'll start out scrappy, we think they'll become a main feature for our users as our database, taxonomy and functionality improves.
We are an objective source of
It costs $100 to reach 10,000 people ($10 CPM). 3 purchases. Profitable.
CPMs go up to $15. Now it costs $150 to reach the same 10,000 people. Same 3 purchases. Same audience. Not profitable.
How do CPMs not matter?
FB/IG shops might help “fix” IOS14 but feel anti-DTC.
What’s the point of having an incredible site (& brand) experience if customers buy on FB/IG?
DTC is the lifeblood of FB, but FB trying to own the purchase experience seems wrong and unsupported by DTC.
What am I missing?
Our FB account is now 100% on cost caps.
Had previously been dishing ~15% of budgets into a lowest cost campaign. But underperforming CC by a wide margin.
What is the argument against doing this?
I think the best media buyers just operate at a different level of intensity.
Not smarter. No crazy insights. No hacks. Just work their accounts at a different intensity.
That’s why they and their brand are winners.
Intensity level = result level
October has been by far our worst month on Facebook of the past 12+ months..
CPAs up 30%... CVRs almost halved... NC-ROAS no where to be found..
It is no bueno out there!
Editorial whitelisting has taken us from an unprofitable 0.9x ROAS to a profitable 2.1x ROAS in <3 months with *4x* the spend.
We've seen CPAs decrease by 35%, ROAS increase over 100% and our LTVs increase across the board.
If you're not whitelisting yet, it's time to start.
I'm building a performance publisher with
@codyplof
to give DTC brands:
• Easy access to a whitelisting partner
• Better pricing & accessibility
• Top of the line content creation
We are launching in ~1 month and will take on 5-8 partners.
If you're interested, DM me.
Spending $$ on Meta has been difficult this month.
CACs up 15%, revenue off 20%... getting slapped in the face coming off a record month in September.
Hoping we're just filling the sponge through platform performance fluctuations and consumer hold out vs general weakness.
We are seeing a lot of success running 6-7 ASC campaigns at once segmented by creative type (video/static) and/or angle.
1-3 ads max per campaign usually. Our CAC is down ~25% compared to when we were running "consolidated" ASCs that had 8+ ads. Also have been able to get spend
Why don’t media buyers here share how they’re buying on FB, building their accounts, budgeting, etc. as frequently anymore?
Synthesizing all of the different ways to do it is a great way to learn.
Feels like now everyone’s just afraid to be called an “absolutist”
I don’t understand the idea that “30% of your revenue should come from Klaviyo”
All of those leads come from FB/IG/TT/organic..
It would make more sense if it was framed as “Klaviyo should try to claim 30% of your revenue”
In the past few months Meta's in-platform reporting has gotten quite accurate for us
We used to have a 35-40% reporting gap, but it's now shrunken down to ~15%
Still looking at everything at the campaign / ad set level, but in-platform reporting confidence is returning...
Seeing similar:
- 0% existing customer caps
- Multiple ASCs with lower budgets rather than 1 master
- ASCs split by asset type (video/static) and audience
What a time to be behind the steering wheel in DTC.
No better feeling than watching your Shopify dashboards light up after months of tenacious and challenging acquisition.
The consumer persists and eCom is ripping!
A model we are thinking about rolling out is joining all of the SaaS tool's affiliate programs and passing the revenue shares off to the brands as discounts.
On average we could likely help all of our brands get 10-30% off of tools.
No one in D2C does this now because they want
Creative fatigue is not real.
Bad ads that cannot scale are real.
Example: we’ve spent 80% of our YTD paid social budget on 3 pieces of creative with great success.
Someone could easily start an ecom ADA compliance agency and get it to $10-15K/month.
I'd happily pay to get our site audited each quarter for compliance.
Or
@Shopify
could just step in somehow.
Well, it's finally happened. We're getting sued in NY over ADA compliance on our website.
I want to fight it.
Anyone recommend some good lawyers who love a good fight?
Business idea:
Product/service that automatically blocks you from cold emails from the FB gurus promising 50x ROAS for your business.
I would pay whatever it takes
@lexfridman
ask him about how he thinks his AI plans will impact the entire Meta ecosystem - agencies, designers, creators, advertisers and who wins/loses
Looking to chat with a few DTC founders/marketers who use either Triple Whale or Northbeam for a
@1800D2C
piece
Use case doesn't matter. Ideally doing $10M+ in revenue and spending $1M+ on media
Reach out via DMs if interested or tag them here
Why don’t more consumable brands try to optimize for a low first order AOV?
I want to get our first order AOV as low as it possibly can get with our economics still functioning and profitable.
The lower my first order AOV, the easier it is to get customers to try our products.
We're now paying $499/month for a slide cart from Rebuy
$6,000/year for a slide out cart is pretty wild
Is Slide Cart from AppHQ the best alternative? Or should we take the one-time custom dev hit?
We were charged $2,000 for
@RebuyEngine
in June...
Thankfully I found some alternatives...
$250 for
@aftersell
(Better functionality than Rebuy)
$99 for Slide Cart by AppHQ
$5 for EasyGift (could do for free with scripts)
Good luck with that pricing model Rebuy..
At what point does CRO become inconsequential and the only things that matter are your product, brand & story?
My take is that if your site has basic functionality and a decent UX, CRO does not matter
In 1-2 years:
TikTok will have either been outright banned from the US
or become entirely irrelevant after Zuck destroyed them with Reels
(identical to Snapchat & stories)
Recently added 2 new tools to our tech stack that I found via 1-800-D2C.
#1
- Recart. The guy
@AaronOrendorff
can sell! We initially had no intentions of launching SMS until we got beyond $5M/year or so. Always thought we were too small for it to make a real impact and that
Sometimes it’s very hard to tell whether your Facebook ads just stopped converting OR if external factors (pre-holiday, household budget cuts, etc) are driving things..
I'll never understand why "Order Revenue" is not a selection on the Shopify dashboard.
Instead of gross sales, which is pretty useless, why not replace with total order revenue? It'd take 10-15 mins for Shopify to do.
Anyone have experience running ads through a founders FB/IG page?
Seems interesting and underutilized. Makes it personal, easy to build brand upfront, sell with your story.
What are the downsides?
On some of our best performing ads/campaigns, there's little correlation between quantitative soft metrics (i.e. CTR) & CPA.
But there's always strong correlation between CPA & qualitative metrics like quality of content (advertorials), messaging alignment throughout, etc.
Our paid performance has been abysmal this past week.
CPAs showing serious fluctuations we haven't seen for months: up 50% one day, down 50% the next day.
Rough waters out there..
Zooming out, sailing is smooth. But daily volatility makes decision making very hard.
The three things we try to consistently do in our ad accounts:
• Consolidate and simplify our structures
• Maximize audience sizes
• Rotate or reset creative/audiences weekly
All of these “UGC” video ads I get served daily are starting to get so cringy.
Everything looks so fake, scripted and unauthentic.
(..but not commenting on their efficacy)
Cost caps have outperformed lowest cost for us over the past 2 months by about 30%
Lots of variables in there, but a change that’s driven some real efficiency
Manually typing out your business metrics into a spreadsheet everyday instead of glancing at a pretty dashboard is a major accountability hack.
Having to manually punch in your CAC, revenue, media spend and profitability each day drills it into your mind.
One of the greatest gift a founder gets:
Knowing that 1,000s of people are giving and receiving their brand as a gift this morning and smiling because of it
Merry Christmas 🎄
In the past 2 months on Facebook, our attitude has gone from:
"This is working great because our ads are doing X really well!"
To:
"I have no idea WTF is going on here, but it's converting!"
There are way too many plain UGC creators
We need more AD creators who know how to make UGC ads that can eat $250k in spend over a 6+ month lifespan
If you are this, please DM me
We are working on fully automating our profile creation and maintenance on 1-800-D2C.
Right now it's all manual and quite challenging to be on-call managing/updating 450+ tool, 1500+ brand and 50+ agency profiles.
Now, the new profile creation process is 90% automated other