Sociology is so strange. We elevate those who write so densely that we need a priestly class of mediators and interpreters to reveal the true wisdom and aesthetic meaning imparted by our saints. Is it the writer or the interpreter’s work we are learning?
First a great article came out. And now a letter from
@ubcprez
with the news that I am tenured and promoted. Or promoted and tenure. Either way...feels nice on my son’s third birthday.
Sociology has a pain "problem." We use concepts like (collective or cultural) trauma, draw allusions to pain, but do not ground them in the fundamental experience of rejection, exclusion, isolation, etc. This paper does this while theorizing SOCIAL trauma
Seeing sociologists struggle with Trump makes me want to reassign Weber's entire corpus on charisma. We are accustomed to what I call "bottled" charisma, or charisma that is restrained by the possessor's traditional or legal-rational authority. Clinton or Kennedy had charisma.
Please welcome one of our esteemed, new colleagues
@UBCSociology
!!!! We have a slate of newcomers (Andrew Jorgenson and Clayton Childress!) who are all excellent at their respective fields and who build on a department already doing a diverse array of important scholarship!!
It’s been a week. Book came out officially. Citizenship ceremony tomorrow. And today, promotion to full (7/1)! For someone who as not planning on grad school and had to take some circuitous oaths to get to here, I am so elated! I couldn’t have done this tho w/o a ton of ppl
Last night, we had a very moving tribute and vigil for our dear, late colleague, Sinikka Elliott
@UBCSociology
. We were hired at the same time, moving from NC and TN, respectively. She didn't know me, or I her, and yet we spoke a lot throughout the process; sharing bits of
This is happening! Can’t tell you how excited we are, and hope to see you all there! We worked real hard to make this book accessible for parents, teens, school staff, community stakeholders, and social scientists of all ilk!
Join Prof.
@seth_abrutyn
and co-author
@procAnna
as they discuss their new book, Life under Pressure: The Social Roots of Youth Suicide and What to Do About Them, with Malcolm Gladwell at
@92ndStreetY
on May 6.
@H_Wohl
- how do artists make aesthetic judgments? How do they change over time? How do others impact them?
@UBCSociology
distinguished speaker series live and in person!!
New paper alert (preprint, but still!!!). This is a long-time coming baby, finally birthed. It looks to bring the neuroscience of social pain into sociology. Physical pain operates along two dissociable neural circuits.
Twitter brings out the worst in academics, usually in the form, ironically, of the very things their discipline rails against. Sociologists, for instance, often use their own experiences as generalizable, fall back on essentialism, decontextualize historically contextual things,
Has anyone noticed that "critical" theories are mostly functionalist theories? They hone in on a thing (technology, patriarchy, etc.), then describe how it systematically functions to do X and Y, as well as its latent functions. The difference is the normative piece.
Finally teaching sociology of emotions this year! It is a blended grad/upper div undergrad seminar. Like the one I took in 1998 that converted me from psych. Can’t wait! Lots of ideas and lots of hope. And it’s not theory!
Worth a read. Another example of how the baby (a great concept) was tossed with the bathwater (Parsonsian functionalism), and how soc chose to spin and reinvent its wheels rather than just use typical scientific methods to hone, improve, and reclaim the baby
For sociologists, “socialization” is a controversial concept with baggage, usefulness, and potential. Excited to share
@JessicaCalarco
,
@milleridriss
and my (contingently accepted) Annual Review article “Whatever Happened to Socialization” via
@socarxiv
:
Welcome!!! We got a top-notch environmental scholar at a time when environmental sociology is so so important! Welcome to Vancouver and
@UBCSociology
!
#ASA2018
got me thinking a lot, about what on earth our discipline is up to re theory. In particular, I have been wrestling with teaching classical theory this fall (and last fall for grad students), and how asinine our pedagogy is; and, what that says about sociology
@seth_abrutyn
Best-selling author
@Gladwell
had this to say about the book: "Life under Pressure told me more about what has gone wrong with the upper-income corners of American society than any book I’ve read in years. It is a devastating work of scholarship."
Pre-order at the link above!
Was told by a reviewer that my attempt to set anomie free from its Durkheimian strictures caused them not merely emotional, but also physical pain. How is this even a professional review? Even if facetious, it is completely unhelpful, unprofessional, and profoundly stupid.
I’m in hell. I have a virtual graduate seminar in 40 minutes that I barely finished reading for and am on lone daddy duty right now for two insane kids. I think I understand the software, but have no clue how effervescence will be generated under these circumstances.
I think it might be time for academics to just drop off of social media. It isn’t really doing anything for ppl. It brings more anxiety than career, policy, or personal benefits. That sugar water dopamine hit just isn’t enough.
Found myself prepping for grad theory seminar, wk on emotions. Forgot just how good, and simple, Susan Shott's 79 AJS piece on symb interact and emotions was. Will share the basic principles (once again, soc has principles!)
Yesterday we had a phenomenal showing for
@allison_pugh
's talk on connective labor
@UBCSociology
! More grad students than I'd seen in ages, colleagues I haven't seen in 1-2 years, and energy. I for one can't wait for the year to unfold.
Fewer words are sweeter than "your manuscript has been accepted." My theory of social trauma - integrating collective and cultural trauma processes and grounding them in the neurophysiology of social pain - will soon see the light of day in Society and Mental Health.
@omar_lizardo
and I edited a new handbook on classical theory. It is not designed like others, as it is not a review. It asks of its incredible slate of authors to reimagine what classical theory is and what it should be doing.
Hurray! The Handbook of Classical Sociological Theory is here! I'm honored to be among
@seth_abrutyn
and
@omar_lizardo
's amazing list of authors. If you're interested, check out my counterfactual history of the sociology of education, "Why Study Schools?"
@omar_lizardo
& I wrote a thing, check it out
#soctwitter
! The paper resurrects the concept of roles, which we argue is 1 of the most imp concepts in the discipline, but 1 that is mostly superficial since the 80s (we evoke the word, but don't study them)
New open access article, "The Social Roots of Suicide: Theorizing how the External Social World matters to Suicide and Suicide Prevention" by
@procAnna
@seth_abrutyn
@pescosol
and me is available now ||
While Goffman often made it appear as though the self was nothing w/o the situation, we show that in places Goffman wasnt interested in the positive attributes of self, but rather where things he took for granted as "normal" attributes of the self were 1/
I saw someone say we need a sociological theory that challenges such and such. That’s fundamentally not what theories do. They make sense of data, orient research, and communicate science. Get it right folks
I’m beat.
@procAnna
and I are finished presenting the findings of our community-based 4 year student of youth suicide and help seeking. The district and schools came out in force as did key stakeholders. Felt meaningful. Might be the rare moment in my career I make a difference.
Here is a paper I am particularly proud of, and though it is debatable (sure
@procAnna
would choose our 2018 Soc Theory piece), it is one of my fave theoretical pieces on suicide. The logic of the paper is simple. 1/n
For real. I spent so much of my first two years reading widely. I had the time and freedom to really build up a base of knowledge. But that’s not the game plan anymore.
Academia really really needs to sit with the fact that first year PhD students are stressed if they haven't published yet. I mean this is truly absurd. When do they get to learn? To train? To develop their craft? Slow it down. Slow it way the f down.
Scholar activism is not what I think sociology is about. But
@procAnna
doing evidence-based public sociology - talking to teachers and counselors and first responders about the social roots of suicide in adolescence. That’s how we do it
Opening my classical theory class with a discourse on why we don’t need classical theory classes any more. Why they are an utter waste of time, and having literally zero to offer ours students. There isn’t a single science - social or natural - that devotes a whole class...
Theory Rant
#64
: I was combing contemp theory syllabi, online, for some assignment ideas, and I cannot tell you how often Goffman is placed in the symbolic interaction camp. He is not, was not, will never be a symbolic interactionist. He was a structural dramaturgical Durkheimian
You know what I miss from grad school? Being assigned readings that I had to do from smart people - meaning I had to read and had no choice, while also having the time to read deeply, broadly, and wildly. I miss reading irresponsibly, like a month of Mesopotamian archaeology.
My incredibly talented student did something difficult: published his MA thesis in an
@ASAnews
journal. A great paper on the identity processes of becoming a drinker. Counterintuitive findings. Great work!
#UBCSoci
PhD student Colter Uscola has recently published a single authored paper about drinker identity development in Society and Mental Health (
@society_mental
).
We talked to him about his work on this piece, read the full Q&A below!
NEW! Hallett, Stapleton & Sauder: Social science ideas become public when mediators make them objects of interest using them to make sense of news and draw connections between matters of public interest across national and local contexts
Worth a read. Sociology is filled with non-theory theories. Little explanation, like there is an allergy to it. An ironic fashion, those that accuse folks like me of science envy often have philosophy envy, as though Durkheim's commitment to Kant or whomever makes a difference
Reading books on theory construction. And I keep coming back to Art Stinchcombe’s summation: the reason for having theories of social phenomena is to EXPLAIN the pattern in observations of the world. Homans agreed.
@omar_lizardo
and I did a thing on affective neuroscience, cognitive science, and social psychology. Super fun paper to write, and a frontier worth traversing!
#soctwitter
All, the newest issue of Contexts is live and living in color!!! It is free to download for 30 days, so get your rad, rigorous, readable, relevant sociology now, now now!!!!
Happy new issue day! Contexts' Fall 2023 issue is now live and *free* to read, download, and share through 12/15. Spread the word!
Clickable Table of Contents here:
Interesting article on
#suicide
(
@elizculotta
). Mentions our early
@asr_journal
paper on suicide diffusion! And a quote from my brilliant co-author,
@procAnna
Have humans developed natural defenses against suicide? | Science | AAAS
What might a new sociology of emotions look like? Maybe one that finally collapses the strict separation of cognition and affect? One that expands its measurement beyond self-report and adopts the multi-component view of emotions.
We knew this decades ago. But worth repeating:
“A new study, published in Psychiatry Research, has concluded that psychiatric diagnoses are scientifically worthless as tools to identify discrete mental health disorders.”
Study on the DSM's validity finds no scientific meaning
#socialwork
Colin Ross, Stuart Kirk, Herb Kutchins will be saying, "yeah, we said this a while ago'
An amazing review of the robust evidence supporting the Durkheimian theory of collective assemblies and effervescence: "In conclusion, this century-old model is remarkably supported by recent results, mostly collected in experimental settings."
#sociology
Great group of folks! Another example of colleagues killing it! (if you didn’t know, Clayton and
@nedasoc
are headed west to their new home
@UBCSociology
)
Princeton University Press @princetonupress.bsky.s
Welcome to three new editors for the Princeton Studies in Cultural Sociology! Clayton Childress, Angèle Christin, and Iddo Tavory join current editors Paul DiMaggio, Michèle Lamont, and Viviana A. Zelizer. Meet the new editors
@AngeleChristin
#ASA2023
Woke up to read
@Jamie_Ducharme
's excellent
@TIME
mag article on our work (
@procAnna
/
@MOsborne_Soc
) on how & why cultural beliefs contribute to the persistence of youth
#suicide
clusters/diffusion. The paper is open access @ Society and Mental Health
Made my late mom’s noodle kugel for the first time (prepped for tomorrow night). Been hard to imagine making it till now. But I’m excited to make my son’s first truly cognizant Hanukkah a smash hit
Ordered a screwdriver. Server brought me a rea screwdriver. I laughed, politely, and said I meant the drink. “The drink?” I said it is an alcoholic drink. She said: “I just turned 19. And I don’t really drink”
Marshall Sahlins, a giant in the field of anthropology and a treasured
@UChicagoPress
author, died yesterday at his home in Hyde Park. This is Marshall in 2013, enjoying a pastrami sandwich at Manny’s Cafeteria, his favorite Chicago lunch spot. RIP.
Prepping for grad contemp theory tmrw. Realizing the balance between “how do ppl publish theory-oriented pieces,” “how do ppl use theory in emp driven papers,” & “what is (scientific) theory and what should we be striving for in writing/using it in soc” are the roots of the prob
Hey y’all - check out
@procAnna
and I talking about our suicide research and the need for more sociological attention to this serious health/social problem!
Sizzling quote of the day: “[the more atheoretical sociology becomes, the more] it condemns itself to the sterile state of knowing more and more about less and less." P. Sorokin
Hi! I’m an associate prof
@UBCSociology
. I work with
@procAnna
, studying adolescent suicide diffusion and clustering. I try to synthesize emotions, social psych and cultural soc into otherwise structural or psychological frameworks.
#ElevatetheConvo
Theory shouldn’t be a puzzle or unapproachable. It should be eminently usable or it’s shite. Theory should guide questions not raise more because it makes no sense
@MarioLuisSmall
Very nice. I was told to keep a happy email folder. Praise from mentors; acceptances that mattered; invitations; etc. it has really helped me a lot.