A gentle reminder - “by the end of this year (2017) no child will wait longer for a scoliosis procedure than 4 months”. Aug 2018 and children continue to languish on lists. Do you still feel ashamed
@SimonHarrisTD
?
We need more politicians like
@catherinegalway
“You will not be having my support”
“Having no sense whatever what a republic means & what public services truly mean & what equality truly means”
@SimonHarrisTD
you made a promise to our children that you never kept
@SBH_PAG
We met an Taoiseach
@LeoVaradkar
in Sep '23 where we expressed no confidence in
@DonnellyStephen
.
9 months later, the situation is even more dire.
We reissue our lack of confidence in Minister Donnelly.
He has proved time and again incapable and incompetent in safeguarding
Liam is 5 weeks + 1day in hospital today.
What are the exact barriers to accessing care for this boy ?
@DonnellyStephen
Why has he yet to be seen by a spinal team ?
@SimonHarrisTD
Why is there no urgency on part of
@CHI_Ireland
?
Why no communication to
@pamdennehy
?
281 children are currently waiting for
#scoliosis
surgery.
Despite some parents signing outsourcing forms 5 months ago, there has been no movement.
A spinal taskforce spokesperson stated "I wouldn’t know that" when asked for a timeframe and mentioned plans for 8 children who
Like other parents and their children, Daisy and her family had spent years waiting for spinal surgery.
@SimonHarrisTD
#scoliosis
Lynn explained Daisy’s spinal curvature was at 62% when she passed away.
@CHI_Ireland
@OCO_ireland
“For the last year, Daisy had horrific bowel
Elections are approaching, and it's clear
@SimonHarrisTD
has found time for everyone across the country … except for the parents and children living with
#scoliosis
.
This neglect is unacceptable.
Taoiseach, you must address the needs of our families now. Make time for those
How long more will you allow this continue
@SimonHarrisTD
how many more hours should Liam suffer before accessing the 8 to 10 hours it would take to relieve him of enduring such suffering affecting each and every organ now
@DonnellyStephen
how much more deterioration do ye want
Written by Deirdre Taffe - fyi
@BernardGloster
I returned some equipment to the HSE building in Ardcavan today and I was shocked to see all of this equipment just left out in the elements. It looks like it’s left to rot but you can clearly see most of it is almost brand new. I
Remember the children living with
#scoliosis
when you cast your vote in the local elections today.
Over the past years, our government have failed our children greatly.
This neglect is unacceptable.
This is a children’s rights issue.
Why does
@SimonHarrisTD
consistently like to portray he is speaking with confidence and authority about the experiences of children who live with
#scoliosis
without ever actually engaging in direct conversation with them or their parents ?
Yesterday, he dismissed
@pamdennehy
&
@caulmick
@MaryLouMcDonald
Either the Taoiseach is being misled by Crumlin or Taoiseach is blatantly lying Liam had no orthopaedic assessment in April
He was last seen by his consultant on March 19th
The date given is administrative and is not based on the level of deterioration Liam has had since then !
Four years ago, an Irish doctor was quoted in the Dáil as saying that foreign specialists were coming here to study these kids because it is so rare elsewhere to see a child whose scoliosis has been allowed to get so bad.
@DonnellyStephen
@paulreiddublin
This week we saw a child with a 138° curve in the media.
No date for surgery.
Window of opportunity closing while they wait.
Everyone in CHI/HSE aware of this case.
Parents crying out for intervention.
@DonnellyStephen
you have done nothing since sep to improve access.
Taoiseach
@SimonHarrisTD
must correct the Dáil record.
This is misleading & dismissive of a parent/child lived experience.
Liam did not see Ortho Cons in April.
Liam was last seen in person by his consultant March 19th 2024.
He has deteriorated greatly.
5+ wks in hosp.
How long more will you allow this continue
@SimonHarrisTD
how many more hours should Liam suffer before accessing the 8 to 10 hours it would take to relieve him of enduring such suffering affecting each and every organ now
@DonnellyStephen
how much more deterioration do ye want
No spinal review
No information from Crumlin
No call back
No communication bar a letter acknowledging receipt and the usual. I'll pass it on
No contact from spinal nurses/Dr's despite asking
Date issued for surgery is elective and not urgent (they knew he was urgent in Dec 23
A gentle reminder - “by the end of this year (2017) no child will wait longer for a scoliosis procedure than 4 months”. Aug 2018 and children continue to languish on lists. Do you still feel ashamed
@SimonHarrisTD
?
Parents do not share the hard stories.
The failures.
The infections.
The reduced outcomes.
They sit with it … afraid to upset other parents.
Over the past 2 weeks we have had an avalanche of contact from parents.
Parents will not stay silent anymore.
@DonnellyStephen
“his son’s pain is now so bad that “he bursts out into tears”.
“Harvey’s mobility went from being a very good wheelchair user, to that he does not want to push himself around any more. He is deteriorating at a rapid pace.”
@DonnellyStephen
Not one mention of the thousands of people who can’t access care due to a lack of capacity in our health service.
@DonnellyStephen
speaks of the entertainment industry being able to breath once again. Perhaps he should start focusing on his health Portfolio.
#rtept
@RTE_PrimeTime
@SimonHarrisTD
Hello From the over 4,000 children waiting on a 1st assessment with an orthopaedic consultant in
@CHI_Ireland
.
These are the children you made a promise to - that no child would wait >4mths for
#scoliosis
care.
Some children cannot have surgery now as they are too sick.
.
@CHI_Ireland
, fully aware of the consequences of allowing children to deteriorate on
#scoliosis
wait lists.
‼️
@SimonHarrisTD
, we are still waiting for our meeting date.‼️
Your lack of urgency and willingness to listen is unacceptable.
The President and the Ombudsman should
A mother from Kerry has been highlighting the ordeal her 13 year-old son has been through while waiting on urgent scoliosis surgery. Pamela and Liam Dennehy have been forced to stay in Crumlin hospital for the last nine weeks due to his severe curvature.
Listening to
@SimonHarrisTD
it’s very clear that he is not the one to bring change. Absolutely nothing to add only rehashing his excuses on his failed promises
#scoliosis
All the while children are in hospital because they can’t breath properly.
@SBH_PAG
@TodaywithClaire
@DonnellyStephen
@TomClonan
You are presiding over a ministry where children loose function due to delays in access to care.
You have no care for the children you are failing.
More worried about how you are perceived publicly.
313 children waiting on a spinal surgery.
@CeoHardiman
@BernardGloster
Health Department will not reach surgery targets for children with spinal problems
266 children currently waiting on a
#scoliosis
surgery
23 children on suspended wait lists. Some waiting 36-48 months.
Independent clinical review of services needed.
Sep “23 we met with
@LeoVaradkar
Since then nothing is in place for children
#scoliosis
#spinabifida
No Taskforce
No 2nd opinions
No support coordinators
No outsourcing
No insourcing
No surgery for 1 cohort.
There is no urgency.
Children are left to deteriorate.
Consultants and nurses should not be on extended Christmas holidays - Taoiseach.
@campaignforleo
How about taking some time to praise the very people who will hold the HSE together over the Christmas period ? Some working for 50% less pay ...
"I feel like I'm at the bottom of the barrel. I'm crying myself to sleep." 💔
Adam Terry is 10 years old and has been waiting for over 4 years for urgent scoliosis surgery.
@oconnellbrian
spoke to him & his Mum about the pain he's in with no date set for surgery
@TodaywithClaire
“It is CHI policy to treat children firstly on the basis of clinical priority and secondly on the basis of length of wait.” - David Moore
How can CHI implement such a policy when children are not reviewed when they clinically deteriorate ?
Today is
The High Court has directed the Chief Executive of Children's Health Ireland to appear before it tomorrow to explain why it has delayed releasing the medical records of a child caught up in the spinal surgery controversy.
@MalcomsonLaw
@SBH_PAG
Ava Cahill speaking on
@rtenews
is just heartbreaking.
Access to essential and life changing ortho surgery is a children’s rights issue
Drs state very clearly that children suffer harm due to no access to care
@CappaghKids
Yet no urgency in bringing change.
@DonnellyStephen
There is no Taskforce
There is no spinal unit
There are no outsourcing/insourcing agreements in place
There has been no surgery for 1 cohort of children in over a year
@CHI_Ireland
are gravely derelict in their duty of care
@DonnellyStephen
has no control of his brief
Leaders' Questions - February 28th, 2024
Simon & Stephen's commitment on
#scoliosis
waiting times -
@PearseDoherty
Missed Climate Targets -
@HollyCairnsTD
State of the Art Campus in South East
@VeronaMurphyInd
Medical Negligence Claims - broken health system - Carol Nolan
📢 281 children on spinal surgery wait list as per
@CHI_Ireland
.
❌Yet, only 221 children are listed as waiting for surgery as per official NTPF report.
🚩A difference of 60 children ‼️
CHI can't accurately count/report those waiting. Unbelievable in terms of wait list
281 children are currently waiting for
#scoliosis
surgery.
Despite some parents signing outsourcing forms 5 months ago, there has been no movement.
A spinal taskforce spokesperson stated "I wouldn’t know that" when asked for a timeframe and mentioned plans for 8 children who
“It’s a form of torture”
13 year old Liam is one patient at the mercy of increasing waiting times for life-altering spinal surgery. The curve in his spine is now over 85 degrees, causing severe pain and making him sicker as time goes on.
His mum Pamela spoke to
@oconnellbrian
And
@DonnellyStephen
has left the building …
How disrespectful to the children and parents who have travelled from all over Ireland.
Surely, any meeting could have been rescheduled.
Needless suffering of our children caused by abject failure of ministerial responsibility.
As a mother there is no worse feeling than your child’s pain is being ignored.
Communication is such an important basic & one that
@OCO_ireland
ref as a rec in their Ivy Report.
So what has changed ?
@DonnellyStephen
How has the escalation process changed ?
@SimonHarrisTD
Liam is 5 weeks + 1day in hospital today.
What are the exact barriers to accessing care for this boy ?
@DonnellyStephen
Why has he yet to be seen by a spinal team ?
@SimonHarrisTD
Why is there no urgency on part of
@CHI_Ireland
?
Why no communication to
@pamdennehy
?
This is heartbreaking.
Harvey cannot thrive. He is living with pain. He needs a
#scoliosis
surgery.
19m allocated last year for scoliosis surgery, yet children still wait.
Dysfunction & poor governance result in long waits & poorer outcomes.
@CHI_Ireland
@HSELive
"I have to watch my son go through horrific pain."
Stephen describes how his son Harvey is waiting on surgery which has been cancelled due to reviews into aspects of orthopaedic surgery at Temple Street Children's Hospital.
#RTEUpfront
You need to make contact with
@pamdennehy
and explain why her son is now many week’s in hospital still waiting for a surgery despite Pam escalating her concerns for her boy.
#scoliosis
@fiannafailparty
There is zero accountability.
Parents are sleeping on floors in
@CHI_Ireland
tonight.
Nurses are trying to work in tiny rooms with no space.
@CeoHardiman
moved to Strategic Programme Director NCH despite her glaring failings as CEO CHI.
@SimonHarrisTD
now Taoiseach
Today we listened to
@pamdennehy
speak of her son Liam who is currently 2 wks in hospital in Tralee as it is now too unsafe for him to be at home.
@oconnellbrian
Liam is only 13.
He needs access to his surgery.
@DonnellyStephen
@SimonHarrisTD
the Buck stops with you.
“It’s a form of torture”
13 year old Liam is one patient at the mercy of increasing waiting times for life-altering spinal surgery. The curve in his spine is now over 85 degrees, causing severe pain and making him sicker as time goes on.
His mum Pamela spoke to
@oconnellbrian
Michelle Long and Claire Cahill at the Scoliosis Advocacy Network share his concerns.
“The minister's failure to hold CHI accountable has caused significant harm to our children, preventing many from reaching their full potential,” they said.
Children
Not one public statement from
@CHI_Ireland
to reassure parents.
To outline how they plan to manage wait lists at this time.
More cancellations this week of scoliosis surgeries and OPDs CHI Crumlin.
More worry for parents.
#scoliosis
#spinabifida
@SBH_PAG
“Noah’s organs are being distorted, his weight is decreasing, his lung function is being affected, and he is in pain”.
A SEVEN-year-old boy from Limerick has had his
#scoliosis
surgery cancelled for the third time this year
@LeoVaradkar
@DonnellyStephen
It’s day 17 in hospital for 13 year old Liam.
The progression of his spinal curve has made it too unsafe to be at home.
No date for surgery
@SimonHarrisTD
@DonnellyStephen
no actions taken
Waiting on talk shop to be convened while children become inoperable.
@SBH_PAG
“It’s a form of torture”
13 year old Liam is one patient at the mercy of increasing waiting times for life-altering spinal surgery. The curve in his spine is now over 85 degrees, causing severe pain and making him sicker as time goes on.
His mum Pamela spoke to
@oconnellbrian
We have absolutely no faith in
@DonnellyStephen
to lead on this.
Nothing achieved weeks later.
Children are deteriorating on wait lists while MOH is “considering options”
@OCO_ireland
will be busy writing up another report it seems.
@LeoVaradkar
Hi
@DonnellyStephen
-I Received Written Instruction at 10.16 am Wed. ‘The Cathaoirleach has asked that you proceed with the Commencement Matter today as another Minister or Minister of State can take the matter’ NO Minister, NO Minister of State Showed Up.
🩻 Scoliosis Awareness Month is here.
We’re weary of displaying our suffering children to spur government action.
Our children need & are entitled to care.
Nearly 10 years of advocacy & not one MoH tweet in support of
#scoliosis
awareness day/month ever
@LeoVaradkar
We would beg to differ ... There are children across Ireland waiting on basic healthcare & scans, to see a consultant. Families who feel no option only to pay for private care.
@FineGael
have failed to deliver equitable & timely access to public healthcare 4 our most vulnerable
What more can parents/children do to show how necessary these surgeries are ?
Children have shared their lives. Cried on TV, allowed pics of their backs be shared. Spoke of their trauma.
Who is willing to do something for our children ?
Year ending with no hope
@LeoVaradkar
Mr Justice Cregan said it was extraordinary that there had been no replies to letters from his parents requesting the records and they had been forced to retain a solicitor who sent two letters to the CEO.
@DonnellyStephen
@LeoVaradkar
“Working on”… so what happens to children who needed their op 2022/23.
What about the children who have Magec rods implanted 5+years.
Are they to be written off as collateral damage.
@LeoVaradkar
@DonnellyStephen
@HIQA
@MichealMartinTD
"I don't know the details of that particular case" - Taoiseach Leo Varadkar' when asked about a child being permanently paralysed due to lack of spinal surgery, as raised in the Seanad by Senator
@TomClonan
this week.
Question by
@Ben_Scallan
.
Harvey was reviewed today and unfortunately is not currently suitable for surgery for his
#scoliosis
due to other issues-issues that were supposed to be addressed years ago but instead he has sat on waitlists
@CeoHardiman
@DonnellyStephen
@CHI_Ireland
Email sent to
@DonnellyStephen
seeking out why this spine register is not in use ?
Who’s decision was it to remove it from website & most importantly what happens to all data shared ?
Parents had no notification that this was not in use.
Let’s see if he has any answers …
We wish to clarify
#JustFourMothers
are NOT meeting Mr Nayagam.
Our position & that of the families we represent remain unchanged
We are boycotting any review that reports into
@HSELive
@BernardGloster
railroading ahead despite
@IHCA_IE
& our concerns
PLEASE RT - Spinal Surgery - Spinal Review & Urology Interventions Denied to Most Complex, Sickest & Vulnerable
#Disabled
Children. Limb Reconstruction Also Curtailed -I’m Informed a 2 Year Old Child has had an Amputation. Let. That. Sink. In. IRELAND’s SHAME
@CHI_Ireland
@wereontheditch
Liam is now 21 days in hospital as it is too unsafe for him to be at home. His whole life on hold while he waits for access to surgery. He is becoming more unwell as his spinal curve progresses.
There are at least 270 children needing a spinal surgery.
#scoliosis
@SBH_PAG
“It’s a form of torture”
13 year old Liam is one patient at the mercy of increasing waiting times for life-altering spinal surgery. The curve in his spine is now over 85 degrees, causing severe pain and making him sicker as time goes on.
His mum Pamela spoke to
@oconnellbrian
@CHI_Ireland
cannot say how many children are waiting >4months for
#scoliosis
surgery.
❗️This is either incompetence or hiding figures
#NTPF
Audit 2017 - recommendations were never implemented.
#NTPF
figures & CHI wait list figures do not align. A
19m allocated to improve services were misspent.
@DonnellyStephen
failure to hold
@CHI_Ireland
accountable has resulted in significant harm to our children, preventing many from reaching their full potential.
Despite our &
@SBH_PAG
continual efforts to raise serious patient
A HIQA inquiry directed by
@DonnellyStephen
is not enough for what has happened to our children.
Nor can its remit be sufficient to address all issues.
We ask for an external, absolutely independent review outside the Irish Health System.
@LeoVaradkar
@BernardGloster
Children suspended on surgery wait lists for years …
Usually spiel is the child is a complex medical case.
Yet our children become more complex in such a dysfunctional system.
Wait time for 1st appointments can be years.
Remove barriers to care
@LeoVaradkar
@BernardGloster
Stephen Donnelly misled the public – in a written response to a Dáil question – when he claimed that a controversial surgery for children with serious spinal conditions had been suspended.
This wasn’t the case – the surgery was still being carried out.
“Not being treated within the therapeutic window”
313 children are currently waiting on a
#scoliosis
surgery in Ireland.
The harm, trauma and reduced outcomes to our children can never be fixed.
Children who will never reach their potential
@DonnellyStephen
@CeoHardiman
I Raised
@orthokids_irl
Scandal in Seanad - 150 Children in Pain & Crisis - One Child Permanently Paralysed Due to Delayed Surgery. Last Night I Learned At Least One Beautiful, Precious Child is at Imminent Risk of Dying on This List
@roinnslainte
ACT NOW - TASK FORCE NOW
Wishing
@ThalidomideIre
all the best for their press conference tomorrow.
We stand with you, urging the state to listen, respond with respect, and ensure justice is served for all who have suffered and lost due to state neglect.
Statement
The Scoliosis Advocacy Network represents children and their families who have been diagnosed with scoliosis. We are shocked, upset and appalled by recent revelations of failings from Children's Health Ireland (CHI).
@KatieGHannon
@RTEUpfront
#rteupfront
When will Liam be reviewed by spinal team ?
@SimonHarrisTD
@DonnellyStephen
Weeks & weeks in hospital deteriorating.
Safe care = ongoing review of situation & planning for surgery.
EOS scan - anaesthetic rv - respiratory rv etc.
@CHI_Ireland
must step up.
@BernardGloster
Surgeries for children with Spina Bifida & Scoliosis have now been paused since Nov 22. In what other country would this be acceptable ?
The window of opportunity is closing for surgical interventions
Add to that no access to PICU beds
@LeoVaradkar
Yet
@SimonHarrisTD
said - “I left that meeting with a real confidence that the health service is beginning to make progress and getting on top of this issue once and for all.
@CHI_Ireland
@HSELive
⚠️ An Taoiseach left that meeting knowing that children are not been reviewed at
100’s of children attending the
@CHI_Ireland
Spina Bifida MDT clinic
@TempleStreetHos
no longer are receiving a review by a Spinal Ortho Consultant
Children not being seen so they cannot be wait listed for surgery
@SBH_PAG
@scolionetwork
#backus
Thank you Tom for speaking out
🚨BREAKING🚨
CEO of Children’s Health Ireland, which manages Temple Street Hospital, has been removed from her position and is being reassigned to another role.
Eilísh Hardiman’s reassignment comes after The Ditch’s exposure of serious allegations on practice at the hospital.
In 18m Noah’s
#scoliosis
has grown by 80° going from 26 to 100° & is crushing his lungs & making it hard for him to breathe
@DonnellyStephen
“When the shunt went in, some infection went in at the same time, so he got meningitis,
#infectioncontrol
Sep ‘23 we asked for basic supports & services for families and children.
@SBH_PAG
#scoliosis
#spinabifida
Not one has been implemented to date.
No funding for independent opinions.
No outsourcing.
No insourcing.
@SimonHarrisTD
having faith in people when absolutely
Scoliosis Scandal - sad state of affairs.
When will the scheme that allows children to travel abroad be reinstated ?
And when will the government fund second opinions, independent of Children’s Health Ireland
#CHI
@MaryLouMcDonald
#D
áil
#BackUs
#scoliosis
#HealthCrisis
Over many years of engagement with CHI, HSE and DOH we have come to learn that their is no separation of organisations. Each and every meeting with HSE or DOH we asked for had CHI management present unasked for.
Zero separation. Zero transparency. Zero trust.
Email sent to
@DonnellyStephen
seeking out why this spine register is not in use ?
Who’s decision was it to remove it from website & most importantly what happens to all data shared ?
Parents had no notification that this was not in use.
Let’s see if he has any answers …
🚩 Despite funding
@CHI_Ireland
failed to utilise spine register.
Link to same not available - …
Reply from
@npsoIRL
@CHI_Ireland
say not in use.
Shocking disregard for patient safety - register if utilised properly can act as an Early Warning System.
The source said Green had shared the innovative surgery he was planning at a meeting with consultants, hospital management and the CEO of Children’s Health Ireland (CHI),Eilísh Hardiman.
@BernardGloster
@DonnellyStephen
@OCO_ireland
It’s disappointing & disrespectful to families that some of the key people who are in paid roles to protect & ensure safe care to our children are missing in action.
No comment.
No presence.
No leadership.
It’s no wonder we are where we are.
#scoliosis
#TonightVMTV
Irelands Shame-The Continued Injury & Suffering of Disabled Children on Surgical Wait Lists-Spinal & Urological Surgeries -Constitutes Abuse.The Real Story of Incompetence
@CHI_Ireland
&
@HSELive
is NOT Billions of Euro Cost Overruns -It is the Damage to Disabled Children & Teens
@ismiseadam
Huge need for patient liaison person on each ward. A need for development of better communication to families needed. Should not be task of clinical staff. Designated persons needed in hospitals.
@AdvocacyIre
Feb ‘24
@DonnellyStephen
added: “Another thing I’m looking to do is to put in place end-to-end funding for any family that wants to avail of care abroad”
❌ July ‘24 - not done ❌
🚨 every non action has a consequence for our children.
⚠️ 5 months of spinal deterioration
@caulmick
@irishdailymail
Donnelly must step down at this point.
We are sick and tired of being told - “x or y” will happen when they NCH opens.
What’s the plan for now
@DonnellyStephen
?
Mother slams HSE over storage of 'nearly new' walking aids outside supply depot
@dee111284
“There were at least 20, and maybe as many as 30, wheelchairs, various walking frames and I noticed a few hoists for lifting people out of beds.
@nmichael_ie