Chris Shaw Profile Banner
Chris Shaw Profile
Chris Shaw

@kalahar1

5,557
Followers
4,517
Following
239
Media
14,223
Statuses

Freelance climate risk communication specialist New book: Liberalism and the Challenge of Climate Change.

Seaford, England
Joined April 2010
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Pinned Tweet
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
What we talk about when we talk about climate change. A short(ish) thread. 1. What is presented as climate action is actually action intended to legitimise liberalism in the face of a catastrophe for which liberalism has no answers. Here's how it's done 1/10
Tweet media one
38
314
881
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
@OwenJones84 @katecmorrison @BorisJohnson Someone at @CCHQPress messed up and made the mistake of leaving @BorisJohnson alone and unsupervised with a journalist who was intent on doing his job.
5
51
515
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
Not me. I left my climate change job last Monday to focus on pursuing the kind of work I feel is necessary, given it is now obvious that 'net zero' is not an agenda that can save us
@postcarbonsteve
Prof. Steve Austin
1 year
we learned officially on Friday that “climate breakdown has begun” how many of us will go to work tomorrow like everything is fine?
156
264
1K
18
41
382
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
Thousands fleeing forest fires in Greece, devastation in Zagreb, rivers of ice flowing down the streets in Italy. Who would be brave enough to say net zero by 2050/1.5c warming limit isn't going to save us?
@ACMatt93
ACMatt
1 year
Never have I ever witnessed such a storm in Zagreb. It caused absolute chaos.. Some of the footage from it, it was insane.
80
763
2K
34
195
388
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
Never had such an engaged climate conversation at my local tennis club as I had today - real concern, anguish and acceptance that something is up. All for naught of course - the moral imperative, the political understanding and historical knowledge needed is totally absent.
43
38
280
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
I took time off from climate Twitter to protect my sanity, I can't deal with the disconnect between evidence of impending catastrophe and the complacency of mainstream climate policy/ climate policy discourse. Away from Twitter I hardly ever encounter mention of climate change.
35
46
274
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
Both my sons are utterly fatalistic about climate change and feel there is nothing left to do but watch how it all unfolds. I'm trying to excite them about the electrified neo-liberalism that is on its way and will save us all, but I'm not really feeling it, tbf.
65
18
262
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Thing about nuclear power is nuclear technology requires management over thousands of years. I look around at the devastation caused through the short term mindset of liberal capitalism and think, this is just not that kind of society, it is like giving a kid a machine gun.
12
70
254
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Compare the outrage at a one day interruption to the delivery of newspapers and the indifference towards the unimaginable destruction and suffering of climate change that is now underway.
0
88
249
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
It's time to let go of the old ways now. Time to say goodbye. Let's reorganise to ensure people are fed and housed, focus on the medical infrastructure. Then let's start rebuilding from there, smaller lives, end the industrialised war on nature and our pysches.
8
81
240
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
7 months
"Much of the discourse around net zero seeks to replicate all the comforts of middle-class life—for the middle class. That it needs the working class to come on board and do their bit to achieve it is one of many hypocrisies of the net zero story."
11
83
241
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
I don't enjoy working with children on #climatechange , it's too upsetting, eviscerating. I am working on climate change curriculum development (not in UK) and going through transcripts from classroom workshops, feel like crying to see how desperate kids are to change their future
14
84
223
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
How do u answer your 20 year old son, the light of your life, in his last year of university, trying to think of his future when he says "Its like the end of the world isn't it?" I can't bring myself to say, don't worry, we've got #NetZero and that is going to make everything OK
35
44
207
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
I'm not interested in "saving the planet", which is just code for bringing the whole of life under the control of technocratic elites. I am interested in building a kinder, slower, fairer way of living, which will hopefully allow the natural world to recover and thrive.
3
42
187
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
We need a new vocabulary of climate and a new kind of state, rooted in the best, not the worst of human nature. The work begins by abandoning the mainstream imperialistic, corporate and woefully naive existing visions of our 2050 1.5C net zero future.
20
44
208
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
Kind of struggling with wealthy white males from the global north promoting upbeat messages about 3C of warming. Seems very suspect to me.
6
46
185
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
How is this bad news? Looks to me like the start of a promising and long overdue trend in decreasing levels of consumption. Surely our climate woke media should be celebrating this. BBC News - Worst year for retail in 25 years, says trade body
13
39
180
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
Remove the words 'solve' and 'solution' from the climate change discourse. The climate science is clear, climate impacts are here for centuries to come. One might manage the pain and suffering of someone with an incurable condition. But you won't be curing them.
13
37
165
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
I can't properly express the rage that overcomes me when my children tell me about the despair they feel about their future, their fatalism about mainstream politics and the impotence of a 2050 climate target.
10
46
161
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
The disorientating schizophrenia of the mass media
Tweet media one
15
47
162
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
"The results clearly show that thousands of tons of methane are leaking from old drill holes on the North Sea floor every year."
2
128
159
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
I would have thought a sophisticated, humane and advanced civilization would have a back-up plan ready in case the net zero strategy started to look like an ineffective and overly optimistic approach. But as far as I can make out, it's net zero or oblivion.
16
45
159
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
7 months
"Environmental science, guided by a false ideal of neutrality, aiming at a depoliticized notion of relevance that is blind to power inequities, and in pursuit of a technocratic understanding of sustainability... enables the continued exploitation and destruction of nature."
Tweet media one
4
53
160
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
20-25C warmer than it should be in the Arctic circle. Not for just one day, but relentless. I am sat opposite my 18 year old son, home from university, and fear for him, and for us all.
@ScottDuncanWX
Scott Duncan
4 years
We are in a relentless Arctic #heatwave - Siberia is literally on fire right now and it's set to continue. Temperatures will comfortably exceed + 30 °C within the Arctic Circle over the next 10 days at least. It is a staggering + 20-25 °C warmer than it should be... [THREAD]
243
6K
6K
11
124
154
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
7 years
This 'Dump The Guardian' list of anti-Corbyn headlines is fun
9
134
138
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
What to do? We can’t work with existing liberal capitalist states. We need to build new ‘climate’ states. That requires we work at some distance from the state to build an alternative model. A new language of climate, us and the world is an essential part of that work.
8
36
156
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
8/10 I interviewed 14 climate opinion formers. All recognised the urgent need for fundamental changes to our economy, ideology and politics (IPCC 2022). None (myself included) know how to bring that change about or what the destination looks like. No one is in control
12
46
155
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 years
The latest IPCC special report underplays an alarming fact: global warming is accelerating.
4
118
140
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
The crap the media were pumping out at a time when there was still a chance to take meaningful climate action. 50 ways to save the planet No.1 Wrap gifts in fabric and tie with ribbon; both are reusable and prettier than paper and sticky-tape.
24
33
140
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
I wonder what the people of the future will think of the decision made circa 2020- in full knowledge of the science- to a. continue increasing atmospheric concentrations of CO2 for another 30 years and then b. sell that policy as a hopeful vision that will solve climate change.
5
36
129
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
@IceGoingSouth @xr_cambridge @ingredient_x Probs time to dump the happy clappy 'by 2050' climate solutions timelines. It will be too late by then.
2
8
127
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
4/10 Guardrail 2: The Western construction of climate change is universally true. Western descriptions of acceptable levels of harm sit above ideology, national interests, culture and geography. The one dangerous limit to climate change is the same whoever and wherever you are.
2
24
120
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
@CraigMurrayOrg @BrikKirby Do I today in my small reactionary town take my Palestinian flag and stand on the street in the rain and just take the abuse and inevitable police aggro? I feel I have no choice.
15
8
108
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
Guardrail 1: Climate change is not a challenge to individualism. It is through our individual free choices that climate change is solved. The state and corporations will respond to the signals they receive from individual choices, and enable the change that individuals demand.
2
21
117
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
It's so hot. I can't believe the weather patterns have been so transformed by just 1C of warming. How can it be safe to aim for a 66% of limiting warming to 1.5C? What is wrong with me that I can't just accept that it is indeed a safe and sensible objective?
10
29
106
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
I've got less than no time for all these people jumping on the climate bandwagon 30 years too late and who spent that 30 years getting rich creating the horror show we are now living through.
26
7
105
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
11 months
@GdnPolitics @chunkymark Condems Corbyn and praises Thatcher. Yeah, not for me thanks.
2
5
102
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
5/10 Guardrail 3: Climate change is not an historical phenomenon. Climate change can be solved within the existing capitalist relations of production. Climate change should be de-politicised, and responded to purely on the basis of the science and agreed targets.
4
18
107
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
I mean, just stop and think. The capitalist/bourgeoise/liberal/free market/industrial civilised world - the apogee of human intellect and endeavour, to which there is no alternative - creates the scenario where I am sat with my son talking about the imminent end of the world.
6
22
98
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
6/10 Guardrail 4: Climate change will be solved, and it will be solved through technological innovation. Human progress is real, is expressed through technological change and is an unassailable imperative of human existence.
3
23
103
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
Spent some time over the weekend with very senior people from law, military and finance. This is what they told me Yes, climate change is real and serious No, I will not countenance any response which costs me a penny or imposes any limits on me.
14
19
97
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
@RyanTheMato Politicising the issue, rather than pretending humanity, capitalist states and corporations are all one happy family united and holding hands as we skip happily to the net zero castle on the hill.
4
5
93
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
Anecdotally, the Royal Marines are being told by their officers that food shortages are coming and they will be preparing to deal with securing access to food.
5
27
94
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
I was listening to a webinar with the gardening presenter Adam Frost and he said, throw away your gardening books. The seasonal patterns are now changing so rapidly and profoundly that such books are no longer any guide to what is actually happening, past knowledge is redundant.
@WeatherProf
Jeff Berardelli
3 years
1
9
21
5
27
94
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Buddhist teachings suggest change is only possible at one moment - now. Climate change policy frameworks, which have continually sought to postpone the radical, revolutionary and profound change to some moment other than now, are the problem, not the solution.
2
23
88
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
2/10. Dominant representations of this unprecedented and overwhelming crisis are anchored in what is already familiar and known. That anchoring has to date been done by liberal Western institutions, within discursive guardrails that serve the interests of those institutions.
1
21
94
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
7/10 Guardrail 5: New stories will save us. We need new stories that show how the whole of humanity can align with the norms of Western liberal democracies, and live clean, smart, prosperous and fulfilling lifestyles without dangerous emissions of greenhouse gases.
4
19
93
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 years
How are we now not locked into an imminent catastrophe? I mean, it's not just that this hasn't peaked - its accelerating at record breaking speed. It's like, you see your dinner is burning and you decide the best thing to do is turn up the oven.
Tweet media one
4
66
86
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
The Earth does not engage in gradual change. Rapid and violent changes are the norm, not the exception. Pearce, 2007.
2
22
84
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
3/10. Climate scientists talk of boundaries or guardrails to describe limits we must observe to avoid dangerous climate change. Likewise, liberal discourses of climate change employ symbolic guardrails to avoid dangerous political ideas. I identify five discursive guardrails.
1
20
88
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
"A single litre of petrol used today needed about twenty five tons of ancient marine life as precursor material." Mitchell, Carbon Democracy, 2011:15
5
54
81
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
The problem with saying 'listen to the science' is that the science says lots of different things about the level of risks we face, and - properly - says nothing about the politics of responding to those risks. So that's a 'no' from me on calls to just 'listen to the science.'
20
14
82
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 months
"Coloniality is a political blind spot and a systematic amnesia in climate policies and actions, despite being a key driver of climate change manifested through various forms of extractivism, economic growth, and hegemonic Eurocentric knowledge production."
Tweet media one
6
31
82
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
In an advanced sophisticated reasonable democracy the national economic conversation would be about how to exploit this drop in emissions as a catalyst to close the gap on climate targets. It's not. It's about how we get back to climate destroying economics asap.
3
35
79
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Does anyone actually believe in a painless and smooth path to a world free from the impacts of climate change? Why can't an optimistic or hopeful vision also hold in that space acceptance of inevitable suffering? At the moment it seems a choice between doom and naive fantasy.
14
15
77
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
A new paper in 'Climate and Development' argues climate finance institutions are unlikely to be capable of 'catalyzing transformation', given 'these institutions embody the same liberal logics that created the challenges they are designed to address'.
1
31
73
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
This image of a French playground = 1000 books of social critique of liberalism
Tweet media one
2
22
70
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
@SophiaKianni @SCROTUSinChief An additional 328000 bird deaths. I'm not arguing against wind turbines, just pointing out this is a weak argument in favour of wind turbines.
22
1
64
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
This election isn't just about the UK. If @jeremycorbyn and @UKLabour win, the world's political centre shifts leftwards, and the universe begins the long awaited arc towards climate justice.
3
18
67
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
If we can't get our climate change act together in these last days of relative climate stability then heaven help us when it all starts to unravel.
4
22
68
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Absolute monster of an ongoing heat bomb here in SE UK. I wonder how many people know the plans for solving climate change mean turning up the furnace, and keeping it at that higher setting in perpetuity.
12
33
64
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
One long standing characteristic of climate discourse and research is to offer a radical proposition (eg we have no time left) and respond to that proposition with a reactionary and conservative response, such as 'so everyone should turn their radiator down by 1C'.
7
10
61
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
11 months
The system that is giving us the genocide of the Palestinians is obviously not a system capable of providing a just response to climate change.
2
11
59
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
If anything had shifted in the environmental mindset of our worldview there would be no such thing as disposable facemasks. All the green/sustainable talk is just rhetoric, a deceit intended to placate public anxiety.
5
12
58
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
I'm numb more than scared, it's like 20 years of rage and fear have been sublimated into a kind of low level spiritual death.
@ClimatePsych
Margaret Klein Salamon, PhD
1 year
I’m so scared
179
191
1K
3
12
60
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
Debates about the seriousness of climate change continue to circulate on twitter. Just to clarify, this graph is the answer you were looking for👇
Tweet media one
8
43
60
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
Someone please give me the lowdown on why the way to avoid dangerous climate change is to continue increasing atmospheric concentrations of CO2 for the next 30 years? Asking for the young, the poor and dispossessed of the world.
7
18
57
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
Have spent some time recently with diverse groups of young climate activists. It is now clear to me that the demands that are motivating many young people are far more radical than is apparent from the reporting, which is primarily focused on whose placard is the most witty.
8
12
57
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
@ClareSaxon I feel you. My PhD and subsequent book from 10 years ago was all about how come it was possible to make people believe climate change not dangerous until 2C. My message was not always welcomed. And now, brave would be the person who claimed 2 degrees of warming is safe. ☹️☹️
3
1
57
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
@JamesGDyke It feels like a profound and growing divide, between those who think the climate crisis is the result of our way of being in the world vs those who believe there is nothing wrong with the way we relate to each other and the world, we just need to decarbonise those relationships.
4
17
53
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
What surprises me is not that cider was mentioned 10 times and climate not at all in the UK government's budget, but that people are surprised by such a thing, that they actually ever believed the government was up for doing what it takes on climate.
@henrymance
Henry Mance
3 years
mentions in Rishi Sunak’s speech: “cider” - 10 “climate” - 0
8
64
229
1
21
55
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
When I first became aware of climate change circa 1989 it was immediately obvious that we had to choose between capitalism and averting a global catastrophe. And no one would choose the end of the world, just so they could keep working hard to buy a nice car. Would they?
7
20
53
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
"The environmentalism of the highly industrialised countries is at bottom a sham, because it fights against something it does not really want to destroy. We all live by robbing nature, but our standard of living demands that the robbery shall continue". Wendell Berry, 1989.
5
28
55
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
So we are definitely going with 'recovery' as the word to describe a return to the state of permanent crisis that defined the pre-lockdown era?
3
22
50
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
I don't buy any of the late in the day conversions to the reality of anthropogenic climate change. The denial was ideological, the new found 'concern' is ideological. Four Years Ago, Boris Johnson Said Climate Concern Was ‘Without Foundation’
4
24
53
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
@CharlieJGardner The media are structurally incapable of responding to the depth of this crisis. The primary goal of all activity in liberal capitalist democracies is directed at reproducing liberal capitalist democracy.
1
5
50
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
The proportion of people who are “very concerned” about climate change has jumped to a record 52 per cent, up from just 18 per cent five years ago.
4
30
51
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
In any sane world the record breaking heat would not be one news story amongst a sea of inanity and infantile trivia. The only stories would be about climate change, upcoming meetings, events and activities for all citizens to be involved with, updates on adaptation plans etc.
4
22
50
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
"Only 18% of people working in music and the performing and visual arts grew up in a working-class household. In publishing ,it’s a pitiful 13%; in film, TV and radio, it’s only 12%." I reckon it is similar numbers for the environmental sector.
@JulieDoylej
Prof Julie Doyle
5 years
Yes! Structural (class) critique of the concept of imposter syndrome. 'Impostor syndrome’ is a pseudo-medical name for a class problem | Nathalie Olah
0
8
24
3
15
47
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 years
Get your head round the fact that we and our children are living at the time when these headlines appeared in establishment publications and state broadcasts. Asides from all life actually having ended, how much more real can this crisis be?
@medialens
Media Lens
6 years
This is the reality we're facing. Nothing matters now beyond digesting this awesome fact and doing something about it. Everything else - everything! - is trivial by comparison. #ExtinctionRebellion
Tweet media one
7
107
145
1
25
45
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
As a climate person I see the UK state is sending warships to aid in this slaughter and I think, how can I or anyone else believe the UK state, as currently constructed, has anything to offer the project of building a humane and equitable response to climate change ?
3
8
45
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
This is where pretending climate change isn't a political issue ends up. Could dimming the sun save the Earth? Bill Gates wants to spray millions of tonnes of dust into the stratosphere to stop global warming via @MailOnline
19
24
48
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
@DaveThroup There has been a serious misjudgement about how sensitive human societies are to changes in the climate. Our human world was built for an entirely different set of conditions from those face today.
0
5
49
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
Because technocratic liberal capitalism is the best system there has ever been or ever could be I am confident that we have well advanced plans for how to care for isolated and vulnerable people during a possible record breaking heatwave this summer, under pandemic conditions.
3
13
43
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
I hoped never to see the day but things have got so bad not even the Telegraph can continue denying climate change. Climate change is already making California feel unlivable
1
20
46
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
@lewis_goodall @BBCPM Covid: UK was over reliant on the idea that science could finesse the numbers so that we didn't do any more than was (economically) optimal. Other countries less driven by the science instead adopted the precautionary principle. Climate policy: ditto
4
4
46
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
@yalawiya @ProgressiveCDN What a dark, horrible nightmare
2
4
46
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
2 years
@hunt_cheese @saaaauuull "Voters should reject this irresponsible left wing wish list and replace it with the rich peoples wishlist, same as everywhere else."
2
2
41
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
4 years
"For thirty years we’ve swallowed the delusion offered by the blue pill, nonsense models of utopian tech and cheery tales of green growth. But in 2020, even the blue pill dealers are having their doubts."
4
17
45
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
1 year
Sh*t falling apart at 1.2C of warming and yet for 30 years elites (with the help of environmental NGOs) have got away with framing 2C as a dangerous limit for climate change. That was no accident on the behalf of elites but a deliberate ploy to delay action.
3
7
42
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
Liberal market democracies are defined by acquisition for acquisitions sake, acquisition for no goal other than more acquisition (R.H. Tawney, 1920). The net zero discourse has as its primary aim the preservation of conditions needed to enable continued and endless acquisition.
9
11
44
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 months
Optimistic that we can save liberalism and maintain Western dominance of the world.
Tweet media one
9
10
41
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
3 years
We are still living in 17th century. Locke's claim that the property rights of the individual should be the paramount guiding principle of liberal civilization remains unchallenged. It is more important to uphold that principle than take meaningful action on climate change.
3
12
43
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 years
@medialens The anti-Corbyn circus is in complete disarray - panicked into promoting a rapidly unravelling Daily Mail story. Game on.
3
17
39
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
5 years
Researching public attitudes to climate policy shows people are supportive of ambitious policy as long as they know everyone is playing by the same rules. That's why people are cooperating with the lockdown. And it's why liberal politics - do what you want -won't work for climate
2
19
40
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 months
Not just an unhelpful slogan, but a failed policy framework which sought to remake climate change in the image of the technocratic co-ordinating caste, offering nothing for the working class, thus making it an easy target for the right.
Tweet media one
3
13
40
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
7 years
@GeorgeMonbiot The Guardian has not been kind to Corbyn either.
3
3
38
@kalahar1
Chris Shaw
6 years
@GretaThunberg @WeDontHaveTime0 I would say this is the first piece of genuinely good news on climate change I have encountered since I first became aware of the issue.
1
3
38