Comparing China’s 1995/1996 live fire exercises during the Third Taiwan Strait Crisis (left) and with those just announced for August 2022 (right).
Sources: and
I can think of no armed conflict involving China where it has released casualty figures publicly at the time of the conflict. Usually, they are published years or decades later. Casualties from 1962 war only published in 1994 internal history.
Indian intel agencies looking carefully at audio intercepts, visuals, survivor reports to assess casualties on Chinese side. Preliminary reports indicate heavy fatalities acc to Indian Govt briefing. India doesn’t except China to own up to because of track record of hiding deaths
Speaker Pelosi's visit to Taiwan is confirmed via
@CNN
,
@FT
and
@WSJ
(though not yet publicly by the Speaker or her staff).
How will China respond?
A short thread 1/
China today has active territorial disputes with seven countries over six areas:
—Tawain
—India border
—Bhutan border
—Paracel Islands (Vietnam, Taiwan)
—Spratly Islands (Vietnam, Malaysia, Philippines, Taiwan)
—Senkaku Islands (Japan)
China has conducted ballistic missile tests with 16 missiles.
They landed in three closure areas to Taiwan's northeast, east, and southeast.
A short thread. 1/
As Communist China moves to at least double the size of its nuclear stockpile, modernizing our nuclear force and maintaining readiness is essential to a free and open Indo-Pacific.
Xi Jinping has not left China since the start of the pandemic.
Yet, due to the Olympics, Xi has met with ~19 foreigner leaders so far.
China has also signed joint statements with 7 countries—Russia, Ecuador, Papua New Guinea, Argentina, Pakistan, Mongolia and Kyrgyzstan.
“Indonesia on Friday rejected a Chinese offer for negotiations on the South China Sea, as Jakarta reiterated that it had no overlapping claims with Beijing in its exclusive economic zone."
Translation: we do not accept your historic rights claim.
Of course, even if Biden believes Pelosi's visit to be unwise, he has no authority over her actions. The executive and legislative branches of government are separate but co-equal. But, b/c Pelosi and Biden are both Democrats, Xi will likely believe Biden has such authority. 4/
The upcoming Biden-Xi phone call later this week, reported by
@Dimi
, is likely to force both sides into a box from which it will be hard to escape. 2/
Now, assume Pelosi goes ahead with the visit. This seems likely, as other members of Congress cast her visit as a question of what China can or cannot "dictate" to Congress (not what is sound vs unsound policy). 6/
Who are they to say that
@SpeakerPelosi
shouldn’t go to Taiwan? The Chinese Communist Party doesn’t get to dictate the travel schedule of the Speaker of the House.
When you hear that China did a better job containing COVID-19 because it’s authoritarian, remember South Korea. The issue is competence, not democracy.
Xi will likely state in no uncertain terms and in tough language that Biden should stop Pelosi from visiting. He will also likely include vague threats of unspecified consequences should the visit go ahead. 3/
If China quadruples its stockpile of nuclear warheads, it grows from low 200s (per DIA) to, say, 900 to 1000. The US stockpile is around 3,800. In what world is having 4x the stockpile of your competitor being "overmatched"?
Sen. Tom Cotton: China "could possibly have nuclear overmatch against the United States before the end of this decade, is that correct?"
Adm. Philip Davidson: "If they were to quadruple their stockpile Yes."
A short thread on China’s maps and claims in its territorial dispute with Bhutan, focusing on the area around the Sakteng wildlife sanctuary in eastern Bhutan (adjacent to India’s Arunachal Pradesh). 1/
CIA director Burns remarks on China yesterday:
1) Burns said that the United States knew "as a matter of intelligence" that Xi had ordered his military to be ready to conduct an invasion of self-governed Taiwan by 2027.
Thus, the stakes for Xi in how to respond will be even higher, and create even stronger incentives for a forceful response, than if no phone call occurred. Policy, reputation, and credibiltiy will be seen to be at stake. 8/
Xi may now conclude that 1) the United States is continuing to "hollow out" its One China policy, perhaps to a point of no return, and 2) that he has been snubbed / scorned / slighted by Biden. 7/
Important note: PLA Daily story that revealed the deaths was about decorations for gallantry awarded by the CMC and the actions by these five soldiers. It was not a complete account of clash or designed to provide a full accounting of all casualties.
The PLA's Western Command has issued a statement on the Galwan River clash. A rough translation is attached (sharing, not endorsing). A few things to note:
Is Taiwan a US treaty ally?
Is the PRC's "One China" principle the same as the "One China" policy of the United States?
No.
A brief thread on some useful reference sources. 1/
Remarkable news about China’s rocket forces:
Its new commander comes from the Chinese navy, not the PLARF.
For the first time since at least 1982, the PLARF commander is an outsider without any previous experience in the service.
Big shake-up.
Bhutan: “Bhutan totally rejects the claim made by…China. Sakteng Wildlife Sanctuary is an integral and sovereign territory of Bhutan and at no point during the boundary discussions between Bhutan and China has it featured as a disputed area.”
“Huawei Technologies Co Ltd will immediately lose access to updates to the Android operating system, and the next version of its smartphones outside of China will also lose access to popular applications and services including the Google Play Store and Gmail app.”
So,
1) The response will almost certainly include a military component, most likely with a show of force in the first instance—live fire exercises, a much greater military presence within the Taiwan Strait and esp across "the median line," even missile tests. 7/
China's readout of SecState Blinken's phone call with FM Wang Yi contains new language on China's position in the Ukraine crisis—it contains China's most detailed public statement to date. 1/
THREAD
How much does China spend on defense?
A hardy perennial question!
US officials and analysts suggest it now exceeds $700B—rapidly approaching the level of the US defense budget.
1/
4) The goal will be to underscore resolve without sparking escalation, but the likely prominence to the military component will include the potential for miscalculation. There are also significant US naval assets in the region at the moment. 10/
Xi Jinping’s phone call with Ecuador’s president dominates Xinhua’s homepage this morning, Beijing time. The only mention of Galwan clash is “below the fold,” and just a link to the Western Command’s statement from yesterday. No signs China is trying to mobilize public opinion.
The missiles landing in the eastern closure area almost certainly overfly the island of Taiwan, which is unprecedented in PLA exercises targeting the island and highly provocative. 5/
3) The response will likely unfold over days if not weeks, but likely start after Pelosi departs Taiwan. Unlike previous CODELs even earlier this year, China will do more than surge aircraft into Taiwan's ADIZ for a day or two. 9/
Big news — the good folks from
@CASI_Research
have posted a complete and downloadable translation of an important Chinese military text, the 2013 edition of the Science of Military Strategy (战略学). h/t
@CollinSLKoh
1/
Authoritative statement from the PLA's Eastern Theater Command.
Rough translation: it will conduct joint air and sea exercises north, southwest and southeast of Taiwan and "ordinary" (常导) fire power test launches *east* of Taiwan (ie, over Taiwan)
Pompeo’s apparent intent: move as far toward de facto recognition of Taiwan as his authorities as Sec of State allow...placing Taiwan in the cross-hairs of US-China relations, leaving a flaming diplomatic turd for the new administration, and avoiding all the consequences.
“Executive branch agencies should consider all “contact guidelines” regarding relations with Taiwan previously issued by the Department of State under authorities delegated to the Secretary of State to be null and void.”
A few things to bear in mind:
First, since last fall, after Biden's two gaffes in October, senior Chinese leaders have expressed elevated concern about changes in the US "One China" policy and US policy toward Taiwan. 2/
Thus, China will likely believe it needs to restore its credibility and bolster its red lines over Taiwan and to deter further erosion of US policy. 4/
Indian intercepts reveal that Chinese side suffered 43 casualties including dead and seriously injured in face-off in the Galwan valley: Sources confirm to ANI
Second, the PLA is nearing the peak of its annual training cycle. Many units are active and in the field—they can be easily tasked to undertake additional operations. 5/
“Indian troops began taking an alternate track to reach Finger 8 on foot, going behind the heights at Finger 4. This was strongly objected to by the Chinese and tensions mounted in the area, leading to the violent scuffle...May 5/6 this year.”
A few thoughts on this image from
@detresfa_
1) China has built a dirt road up to the "triangle" of patrol point 14 on or just over the LAC as shown in the image
2) the "triangle" appears to be under Chinese control
Images via
@Maxar
of the
#GalwanValley
face-off point on 22 June 2020 show possible defensive positions being set up by
#China
, small walls, trench type areas have now appeared on site
#IndiaChinaFaceOff
Wang Yi in late October began describing the US as pursuing a "fake" One China policy.
Xi Jinping at least twice warned Biden in separate virtual meetings "not to play with fire" over Taiwan. 3/
We could start by talking about how misleading this. US Pacific Fleet, under INDOPACOM, has more destroyers and cruisers than the entire PLA Navy, 55 to 33. And, as
@nukestrat
notes, it omits all US nuclear forces.
Of course, there are many unknowns at this point: Pelosi's schedule, whether the visit will be described / portrayed as an unofficial one, what Pelosi says in Taiwan, etc. 11/
Just saw a US-based China analyst propose on TV that India should play the Tibet card against China, to make it pay a cost for occupying Indian territory.
That would surely induce China to play the Kashmir card, joining hands with Pakistan.
Anyone wants to war-game the outcome?
Interesting piece by an analyst from the PRC’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs research institute, on why China will not pursue forceful unification of Taiwan...for now.
Video from the PRC MOD
-- shows the DF-15 short-range ballistic missile being fired from several locations
-- unclear if other missiles were used
-- includes a map showing 16 pins landing in closure areas 2/
A picture is circulating on Weibo, showing the tombstone of a 19 year old Chinese soldier who died in the “China-India Border Defense Struggle” in June 2020. He was from Fujian Province.
Since late Nov 2020,
@US7thFleet
has issued press releases for freedom of navigation operations it conducts. Targeted maritime claims include those of Russia, Japan, China, Vietnam, the Philippines, South Korea, Sri Lanka, India, and the Maldives.
A somewhat analogous episode occurred in early Sept 2012, when Hu Jintao appealed to Japanese Prime Minister Noda to halt the purchase ("nationalization") of three the Senkaku islets at the APEC meeting in Vladivostok. 9/
China’s official media continues to downplay Galwan Valley clash. Xinhua’s homepage leads with Xi’s speech to China-Africa Forum. The readout of Wang Yi’s call with Jaishankar is the 13th story down.
#Editorial
: If Pelosi's plane is found flying toward our airspace, the PLA fighter jets could warn, follow, intercept, electronically interfere, force a landing, or drive it back.