While I applaud greater acceptance in society of trans identities and have worked for this globally, the huge upswing in # of adolescents asserting trans identity defies explanation. Something is going on that we don’t yet understand. See this week’s Pew and CDC surveys.
Just finished reading ‘Time to Think,’ and now I need to go for a long walk and consider what I have learned. For those concerned about gender questioning youth? Please read this before we talk again.
Invoking the recent words of another courageous woman: I say this to my colleagues who are defending the indefensible: there will come a time when clarity and truth will win out. And your unyielding ideology will be revealed as bias not principled advocacy.
An international pushback to woke gender ideology has commenced.
1. Parliament in Sweden is balking at reliance upon self attestation for gender identity
2 parents in Toronto are today protesting gender ideology in schools
3 students in a high school in Pennsylvania walked out
Swedish Christian Democrats block trans bill. Sweden is known to be progressive on trans issues. But they are taking a pause regarding self attestation for legal gender changes. Because they are thinking seriously about it now.
@katbalmy
Yes as you must know I have taken a lot of heat for urging caution and adherence to best practices. One would think such a message would not be controversial??????
Have we reached the “tipping point,” on trans youth care? Malcolm Gladwell in his marvelous book years ago said 3% was enough to accelerate the tipping point. It seems we are there now. I’ve been watching for at least 5 years. Next come the ones who stayed silent with their
As children line up at gender clinics, families confront many unknowns. Some have said that they don’t believe that any gender clinics provide hormones on the first visit. Reuters found otherwise.
Caution in Denmark. So cautious that the rest of the world finds out about it retrospectively. Perspective in line with Sweden and Finland and soon Norway. All progressive and trans affirming societies.
@benryanwriter
@SashaLPC
For what it is worth Kennedy has blocked me. They apparently not only don’t want to hear what I say, but they don’t want to allow me to say it. Cancel culture much?
I have always advocated open dialogue and transparency. Apparently many ideologs can’t handle the truth.
I'm transgender and I found few fascists at parental rights protest | National Post. Well said Julia. The interests of sincere trans persons and caring parents are not incompatible.
@stclairashley
The restrictions came after a full Systematic Evidence Review caused the Swedish Authorities to pivot to new more cautious Guidelines. They now emphasize psychological support for gender questioning minors.
Alberta’s new trans legislation is evidence based and progressive, despite critics’ temper tantrums and gaslighting via
@NewWestTimes
. The fight is on in Canada. I think I know who will win… all children and parents.
No one kept data on Tavistock children — it’s a monumental scandal David Freedman who did the first audit of GIDS Tavistock. “Gobsmacked” that in the 20 years since no further audits have been done.
Reporters are calling me for comments about the AAP meeting this week anticipating a potential show down concerning positions of AAP on gender affirming care for gender questioning youth.
My favorite quote from ny mag on the GLAAD critique of the NYT:
It is true that Republicans are passing a wave of harmful, restrictive laws on trans medical access. The blame for laws like this does not rest with the medical providers who demanded evidence for the rapidly
TikTok, YouTube, Instagram. The media most consumed by adolescents. Algorithms which can best be characterized as addictive and influencers with financial incentives to be outrageous. Are we surprised we have a problem here?
Over 1000 school districts in the USA have parent secrecy policies about gender. Youth can in these districts change their names and pronouns and if they say “don’t tell my parents,”the school districts will oblige. This has to stop, for many reasons.
@deeveemee27
Thank you. I’m in the middle trying to broker reasonable dialog. Trans people deserve compassion and care AND society has to work for everyone.
A Trans Pioneer Explains Her Resignation from the US Professional Association for Transgender Health Thank you Lisa Selin Davis for helping me express my observations and concerns!
More than 5 years ago I started questioning the then conventional logic about trans youth care. I watched with concern the rising numbers of youth asserting sexual and gender minority labels and presenting to gender clinics. And watched the changing demographics within a
A slippery slope. The California legislature decided that teachers know better than parents what is good for the children. And that youth should be able to decide what parents know.
“We Thought She Was a Great Teacher” | City Journal. Very very disturbing. Teachers deciding unilaterally to socially transition kids.And hide it from parents
Districts in California are taking back control and recognizing that parents not schools raise children. Many parents are furious snd want teachers to stay in their lane.
BREAKING:
@OrangeUnifiedCA
becomes the sixth school district in California to pass a parental notification policy on a vote of 4-0-3.
The three other school board members left in protest when the president refused to shut down the meeting after opponents to the policy
@Nettie_Stevens1
@genspect
They have interviewed me several times this year. Watch for a feature article next weekend in the NewYork Times Sunday magazine.
California House Passes Bill Barring Schools From Informing Parents of Students’ Gender Identity | The New York Sun. Meanwhile in California. Parents are told that teachers know better what is good for children than their own parents. They don’t.
@billmaher
Time to interview me on the show. I know you and your team are curious. As your producer Vanessa knows I’ve got a unique perspective to share.
Why did three journals reject my puberty-blocker study? - UnHerd I was in a small group of scientists and clinicians that listened to Dr Baxendale address several important questions about the brain and puberty last year. The science is unsettled.
@BriannaWu
No not in absolute terms. I have opposed outright bans. But the over medicalization of gender questioning youth is something I have decried for years. Publicly for 6 years and counting.
My Amazing colleague and friend Dr Laura Edwards-Leeper and I started on a journey several years ago. Unknowingly then we were monitoring developments which we have come to see more clearly as indications of the shift away from the careful evaluation of individual youth identity.
People are in denial following the Cass report – it's like deprogramming cult members. Sadly some kids have been collateral damage. Horrible under any circumstances but especially so because any children harmed are innocents.
@jessesingal
Another student characterized James hateful rhetoric as catnip. To the contrary. It’s poison. Vile antisemitic poison. Pure hate speech. Apparently such animus has infected many of the so called protestors.
New law in California which essentially permits all minors 12 and older to operate as emancipated minors. Another mistake in overreach by the State of California driving wedges between children and their parents.
This is why in my lifetime post traumatic stress has been recognized by the modern military. Why soldiers are taken off the front line after a period of time. I’ve been on the front line all this time. Including people who disagree with me taking their best shots. Now there are
@LeorSapir
Thanks Leor for breaking it all down. X format requires bite sized chunks. In this case it forced you to take up each of the issues. Well done once more!
Returning from a meeting with School Board Directors across Wisconsin. I felt sincerely and warmly appreciated for my work in safeguarding children and adolescents. Guess I need to get out more?
What will trans activists do now in light of Cass? Put on their back foot, previous claims and threats are no longer tenable. In the UK Stonewall and Mermaids are in retreat. In the USA Gender Spectrum and PFLAG have merged. How about ACLU and GLAAD? A Reckoning is coming.
@CattyArt1
@katbalmy
Thank you. I seek to be a trusted source. I’m listening to everyone. Willing to talk to anyone. Applying all I know as a clinical psychologist for 44 years. In leadership with WPATH and personally helped hundreds of gender questioning/trans persons of all ages. This is hard.
@BuckAngel
@SwipeWright
Buck I had the same reaction. I’m concerned that advertising such surgeries under a Children’s hospital banner suggest that it is no big deal to have such surgeries. As those who know until the recent past such surgery was never done on minors. It creates the wrong message.
Reframing the Gender Debate | City Journal. Language as always matters. Gender affirmative care has come to rely upon self attestation( eschewing evaluation) and fast tracking of medicines. The term has been high jacked from its origins.
The Observer view on the Cass review: children were catastrophically failed by the medical profession | Observer editorial | The Guardian Scathing its it criticism of ideologically captured clinicians and activists.
Parent secrecy policies and practices being dismantled. Even liberal parents don’t want schools to hide things about their children from them. No surprise to those of us who are parents.
Todays open letter to the NYT and the back and forth since have revealed how polarized these issues have become. I want more light than heat. Dialog not dismissal.
@cmind_g
They are not suppressing. They are reminding journalists of their code of ethics and NYT reporters of the code of conduct to which they voluntarily agreed. Quite the opposite of fascism, free speech with accountability.
California plants new flag on transgender student protections This new law is purported to be a way to protect kids. It does not. Most teachers and most parents see through the pretext. Parents need to know what’s going on with their kids.
Important study on suicide( completed suicide) not suicidal ideation(suicidality) The results question whether providing hormone care for adolescents is protective for suicide. I heard an informal report of this study last Oct. now published.
Discord concedes in effect that it has operated in such a way at least until now as to place children in unsafe circumstances.. first sign of a platform recognizing the harms being caused by social media.
@BonitasMomToo
There is a quietly growing coalition of the sane. Professionals( many of whom concede they’ve been intimidated by activists both among snd outside of their ranks), educators, and foremost parents.
Impact of social transition in relation to gender for children and adolescents: a systematic review | Archives of Disease in Childhood few studies, low quality, little to support recommending social transition for children and adolescents.