Indian right to opponents: "Go to Pakistan."
Indian right to Kashmiris: "You are Pakistani."
Indian liberals to Indian right: "Don't make us a Hindu Pakistan."
Indian elections: "Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan."
Indians at the UN: "It's offensive to mention us with Pakistan."🤔
Keep us out of the IPL. Cancel tours at the last minute. When we tour, give us 2 tests max. Ignore us and when you don't, mock us. Go on, keep doing it.
Debut years for Pakistani batsmen who average above 45 in tests:
1976 (Miandad, 53)
1990 (Saeed, 45)
1992 (Inzi, 50)
1998 (Yousuf, 52)
2000 (Younis, 52)
2001 (Misbah, 47)
Basically, it's been two decades since Pakistan produced a good batsman.
Last Friday, I became a US citizen. To celebrate finally being able to travel like a normal human being, I wrote a blog post about my worst travel experiences on a Pakistani passport. There were so many I had to break it down into two posts. Here's part 1
My piece for AJ
Main points
1 This was an intra-elite thing, not mass mobilization
2 Army should learn nurturing proteges doesn't work
3 Hybrid regime set PK back 30 yrs politically
4 Only potential upside: PTI base turns against army role in politics
The closing of ranks by Indian media, the foreign policy/natsec establishment, and even academics has been something to behold. It's actually been pretty scary to watch in real time.
A thread on the Iraq war. I came to the US as a college student in Jan 03 and couldn’t believe the BS people were selling and buying about Saddam + 9/11 and/or nukes. What was obviously nonsense to people outside the US was treated with laughable credulity by Very Serious People.
Pakistan's "official" policy on the Taliban would be a lot more credible if every two bit retired brigadier on Twitter wasn't positively salivating at bodies being hung from bridges.
My basic argument was that the US invaded Iraq to assert hegemony and demonstrate strength to a global audience. Akin to prison yard bullies or drug cartels, the idea is to attack targets to send a message to those watching to submit to your authority.
First of all, his name is not Mian Atif but Atif Mian. Secondly, he is a named professor at Princeton with 12,000 citations whose previous positions were at Chicago and Berkeley. Your EAC was a step down for him, don't get it twisted
One curious thing about the Atif Mian episode is how little "pressure" there actually was from mullahs and the religious right. There were no street protests or rallies. Only news story I can find about a protest is by...PTI supporters .
Nice piece that neglects to mention the most shameful detail: that dead Pakistani soldiers remained unclaimed by their military. The firing may have ended twenty years ago but diplomatically, PK continues to pay the costs of the Kargil disaster to this day
Woohoo, it's official! Good time to remind people that my book is free If you're in poli sci and just want to read the theory chapter, or you are a normal, and just want to read the case studies, you can download specific chapters
Congratulations to Ahsan Butt, winner of the 2019 ISSS Best Book Award, for his book, Secession and Security: Explaining State Strategy Against Separatists (Cornell University Press, 2017).
@ahsanib
@GeorgeMasonU
@CornellPress
@isanet
"Pakistan's Military Elite," a new paper in
@jststs
by
@pstanpolitics
, Adnan Naseemullah, and me We gathered data on ~200 corps commanders and DGs ISI since 1971 to analyze the organizational politics of the Pakistani army
A thread on the cipher. The framing (and headline) of the Intercept article is pretty misleading. It makes it seem like the process was: Imran Khan firmly in power, his stance on Ukraine pisses US off, they institute regime change. That’s not really what happened though.
So tomorrow I start teaching "The Coercive State," a grad course I've been thinking about and wanting to teach for 2-3 years. Really excited about it. Here's the syllabus Thanks to everyone on Twitter who answered my requests for reading suggestions.
I voted, it felt good!
In
#NA247
, I voted for
@MJibranNasir
, an inspirational and easy choice.
In
#PS111
, there was a dearth of quality candidates. I went for party over individual, and spurred by
@BBhuttoZardari
's campaign for a progressive Pakistan, voted for
@murtazawahab1
I wrote a piece for
@AJEnglish
on the EU DisinfoLab report Summary:
1. "5th gen war" is a vapid term
2. Unlike IND support for terrorism, IND propaganda can only be weaponized if PK helps
3. Consequences of report will be mostly harmful for rights in PK
God I wish I was rich. If there are any 17-23 year-olds following me, please don't try to follow your dreams or whatever. Just cash out. The difference between business and economy class is too vast to justify any "self-fulfillment" BS.
I have an article in
@SecStudies_Jrnl
on why the US invaded Iraq. I argue it was about demonstrating hegemony + sending a "don't mess with us" message, and nothing to do w/ WMD, oil, Israel, or democracy Free to read for 6 months (thanks
@Rout_PoliticsIR
!)
I wrote a piece for
@USIP
how desperately South Asia needs climate cooperation
1 Vulnerability of SA + threat being transnational = lots to be gained from Ind/Pak/Bang talking
2 Diplomatically, reparations claims much stronger coming from 2 bn people
To help you understand the India-Pakistan ceasefire, our panel will feature an Indian diplomat, an Indian security official, an Indian journalist, and two Indian academics. We hope to challenge precisely zero of our audience's assumptions. Please join us.
One year late with this, but cannot recommend Owen Bennett Jones' podcast series on the BB assassination highly enough Even if you read the article version (which I did last year), still really worth it.
Owen Bennett Jones' new book (highly recommended) says that Zardari would speak for 40 mins at a stretch in meetings w/ Obama. Told him that while he [BO] was surrounded by many highly educated people, he [AZ] had a PhD in life. Obama tried to avoid 1-on-1 meetings after that😂😂
"In Imran Khan, the generals have found a rare entity: a populist who is eager to collaborate because even he isn’t sure whether he was elected or selected." Great piece by
@mohammedhanif
I have a lot of random memories of
@Nadir_Hassan
. We were very close in high school. We drifted apart during and after college. But I really cherish the times we had. He was extremely bright and had a great sense of humor.
England are good but they are not "easy wins against India + New Zealand" good. Pretty disappointing from those two. Anyway, that's that. The Sri Lanka washout really burns right now. Also showing up to day 1 of the WC like a hungover 21 year-old on spring break didn't help.
RIP to an absolute giant. Did things differently, like "I'm going to write a chapter on soil" or "tell PhD students to read fiction". The realest of real ones whose work will live for a long, long time.
𝗝𝗮𝗺𝗲𝘀 𝗖. 𝗦𝗰𝗼𝘁𝘁 passed away on July 19. He was a political scientist and specialist in Southeast Asia. He was a dissident within Political Science. Yet his books opened up lines of research on central issues, such as the exercise of power and resistance to power.👇
Re: IK's rape comments, he's been a mullah for 25 yrs. This is a pretty anodyne observation for most people but when I made the argument [] after his 2018 (s)election, I was subject to A LOT of abuse by PTI supporters. Hope some have changed their mind.
I'm starting a (hopefully regular) cricket column for Dawn. It will be called Outside Edge. First piece is on the lack of an Andre Russell-style power hitter in our white ball teams (or domestic circuit more generally)
Oh ho Barkha, yeh kya baat? What about house arrests in Balochistan, FATA, Xinjiang, Guantanamo, World War 2, Mahmud of Ghazni's invasion, Sparta etc? Shameful tweet.
Slapping PSA against eighty plus Farooq Abdullah is totally senseless. He has been under house arrest for over a month without any explanation for what law he has broken.The more you punish those who have stood with India, the more you embolden extremists and militants.
#Kashmir
I have a piece in
@TheNatlInterest
on India, Pakistan, and Kashmir Basic argument is that
1. S. Asia is, by far, world's most dysfunctional region
2. Solutions to Kashmir exist if IND+PK want to see them
3. IND+PK owe their citizens a deal
Bajwa was going to get rid of IK regardless of that meeting. If Army wants something but US doesn’t (e.g. Benazir or her dad being killed), it happens. If Army doesn’t want something but the US does (e.g. fighting the Taliban), it doesn’t happen. So army, not US, is key.
I have an article forthcoming in
@SecStudies_Jrnl
on why the US invaded Iraq in 2003 (draft version here ). The basic argument is about hegemonic status and reputation.
On Monday, PM Imran Khan gave a rare background briefing to news show hosts in which he reportedly emphasized that the time had come to do more to crack down on militant groups.
Call me a pedant but I think it's more like “I stood with them when they came after you but now they’re coming after me so please stand with me against them.”
Beginning to wonder why whenever Nawaz Sharif is in trouble, there is increasing tension along Pakistan's borders and a rise in terrorist acts? Is it a mere coincidence?
Been a surreal day. Indians + India-focused people on my TL are trying to figure out Modi's escalation strategy. Pakistanis are discussing PSL. No tweet or statement from Imran Khan. No response from Gov of Pakistan beyond this frankly awful press release
The reaction has basically been " (1) We didn't do it, but (2) even if we did, we were justified. Oh and btw, (3) Trudeau publicizing it helps Modi's reelection."
With Putin's speeches and all these demographic maps of Eastern Europe floating around, thought it would be a good time to remind ourselves of the 7 rules of nationalism
The Boult trod on the boundary, the Bairstow lbw not given first ball, the last over deflection which I will go to my grave knowing was intentional, the stupid rule of a tied super over being decided on who scored more boundaries (?), and that's just today.
Lol. "35-A a red herring, it's really about Pakistan" is peak BD. Taliban ascendancy --> Mehbooba Mufti, Sajid Lone, and Omar Abdullah being put under house arrest and the internet being cut off. Genius.
Pakistan response appears to confirm my theory-35A is a red herring, not the story at all. Threat assessment is external, deployment seems in response to a possible Afghanistan/Taliban ascendancy & spillover, possibly enabled by China, with US looking other way as it exits..
I’m chuffed to see this argument get some mainstream acknowledgement and attention (e.g. NYT or Foreign Affairs ). But there are still many holdouts (at least in US intelligentsia circles) that WMD was a fair/reasonable explanation.
Part of me is really not surprised b/c I've seen a lot of this before but part of me is surprised b/c this situation is so unprecedented that you'd think someone would step back and ask "Are we the baddies?" But nope.
Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 vanished into the Indian Ocean five years ago, and we still don’t know why. The explanation lies not in the sea but on land—in Malaysia, where officials know more than they dare to say. William Langewiesche reports:
A cool opportunity that I'm looking forward to. First order of business is to advertise this call for papers and special issues/forums on race and security If you work in these areas, pls submit. If you know someone who does, pls encourage them to do so.
Security Studies is thrilled to announce that Ahsan Butt of George Mason University will be joining the editorial team as of August 1 and that Sheena Chestnut Greitens of the University of Texas at Austin will join a month later. Welcome,
@ahsanib
and
@SheenaGreitens
!
What are the best novels and films on war/violence you have come across? Next semester I am (super excited to be) teaching "War in Fiction and Film" for the first time. Am looking for any suggestions, especially for categories with a ?
Too good,
@mohammedhanif
got the word "chutiya" into the frigging New York Times Also, "garmi mein kharab" is translated as "wasting away in the heat"
#memories
The cipher, which is not even an American document but a Pakistani one, does not suggest US was pushing for regime change, only that it would be happy/happier when it happened. There is a significant difference between those positions.
These claims are, IMO, bogus. Myth 1: Saddam was hiding that he didn’t have weapons. WRONG. In late 02+early 03, Saddam opened up his country to inspectors and they went thru more than 500 sites more than 700 times and turned up nothing.