"Anti-intellectualism...is a counter-revolutionary agenda being cloaked underย the language of "accessibility". As a result of that rejection, there has been an ushering in of unprincipled and reactionary opinions all given validity because itโs how someoneย feels."
There has been a deeply anti-intellectualist response to my review of the movie 'Jawan'. The assumption is that films are not suited for detailed theorizing. The following passage by Todd McGowan easily dispels these ideas:
@LeninBol
Ajamu Baraka: โthe United States is a settler-colonial project, a settler-colonial state. Itโs had a continuity since 1791, once the new constitutional process was finalized, and that process just basically resulted in the consolidation of the power of the colonists that were on
I will be presenting a paper on the Karnataka hijab row, examining in particular the political efficacy of post-modernist theory in understanding identity and resistance.
Very excited to give this first look at the program for the Feminist Ethics and Social Theory *online* conference in October!
Some highlights in the thread below. Registration will open soon.
@LeninBol
the land since 1619. Even with the Civil War, thereโs been continuity, because the US national state won that conflict with the Confederacy. The very fact that the material basis of the US was the conquering of this land and then the confinement of Native peoples to concentration
Those who are saying that I am merely using jargon should read the entire article instead of just the slides. The slides don't convey the careful reconstruction of the different masculinities that are at play in Deewar and Jawan.
@LeninBol
camps that we refer to as โreservations,โ provides not only a moral critique but it provides a moral foundation for how a just resolution has to look.โ
@LeninBol
It was the evolution of the contradiction between Southern plantation capitalists and Northern industrial capitalists - rather an "abolitionist mindset" - that caused the Civil War.
@SevenDeviled
Most of the social media responses to my article were based on the reductive slides they had prepared. I think it is unfair to remove my article based on the supposedly representative feedback that FII received from a motley of digital users.
Saadat Hasan Manto and the Exploration of Madness via
@thewire_in
On Manto's death anniversary, I write about his short story "Toba Tek Singh," whose deconstructive logic opposes the logocentric metaphysics of right wing politics.
Noah Schnapp shares statement on Israel and Palestine:
โYou either stand with Israel or you stand with terrorism. It shouldnโt be a difficult choice. Shame on you.โ
@profhuq
I believe that both the issues are interlinked since theory needs a vocabulary through which it can articulate its analysis. My article was trolled because most people read the reductive slides and not the article. This conveys an unwillingness to learn theoretical vocabulary.
Hybrid conferences are so frustrating for digital presenters. In the absence of proper online infrastructure, ad hoc arrangements create a two-tiered system where those who can afford to attend in-person are given greater opportunities for networking and interaction, while those
My article on the need to rethink the debate on AMU's minority status from a subaltern-secular perspective so that anti-fascist opposition can be strengthened:
@MarxMidwest
According to Manu Karuka, there is no national territory in the United States. Nor is there a national political economy; only an imperial one, which continues to be maintained, not through the rule of law, contract, or competition, but through the renewal of colonial occupation.
@de_coloniszing
@TathagatEcon
It is not just about the prevalence of discrete "issues" wrt caste, minorities etc. It concerns the structural inequalities inherent in an economically exclusionary private institute like Ashoka. Dubbing it as a left wing space is the height of intellectual elitism.
@MarxMidwest
Many American workers of
the United States have advanced through the ongoing exclusion, marginalization
and oppression of an โunderclassโ inside the country, made up of dispossessed
Native Americans. Ignoring this as a "bourgeois ideological construct" is economistic.
Fanon: "The natives' challenge to the colonial world is not a rational confrontation of points of view. It is not a treatise on the universal, but the untidy affirmation of an original idea propounded as an absolute".
Some people on here today acted like they just read Fanon's chapter On Violence & got fixated by the "collective catharsis" bit, but ignored the warning that turning violence (mere killing) into an end in itself disconnected from a wider political goal/vision is a trap door.
@profhuq
I agree with the point about popularization, but it should not equate to a dilution of its theoretical uniqueness. For eg, Marx can't be understood without his meticulously constructed concept of surplus value. The demarcation between simplification and popularization is delicate
"That intellectuals who have made lucrative careers with tough-sounding buzzwords were so eager to condemn an actual instance of Indigenous resistance is a damning (and in my mind permanent) indictment of Western academe."
@jensensuther
The Marxist-Leninist PFLP has taken a side, unconditionally supporting the Al-Aqsa flood operation. PFLP even considers Hamas to be part of the Palestinian national movement. This hardly signifies the abandonment of vision; the PFLP was the only holdout in the Hamas led govn.
@nlasya
Patriarchal masculinity is driven by a search for an impossible phallic wholeness. Since we are relational, we can never be a solitary Master. But this is not recognized by male society, which sacrifices the dynamism of the present for the promise of future deliverance.
@GodEmpanada
@AndeanComintern
@ADavidTR
@RealDavidG89
@VirulentVir
Wages paid to Southern workers are one-fifth the level of Northern wages. For every unit of labor and resources that the South imports from the North, they have to export many more units to pay for it. Benefits of imperialism.
@donaldp1917
So are Lukacs and others completely wrong in saying that reification abstracts from the qualitative essence of things, resulting in the Weberian iron cage situation?
@sparklymachine
@hailewwwwshash
It does not carry any essentialist connotations since it only denotes the fact that women are not accorded full individuation or societal status under a patriarchal system.
A๐งตon my article about patriarchal socialization in India:
1/ The killing of 16-year-old Sakshi in Delhi reveals the rottenness of Indian democracy and the pervasive violence against women. The political response fails to address the systemic nature of gender-based violence
@jensensuther
It is useless to simply posit the universal standpoint of the proletariat and talk about the abolition of the value-form. That universality can be reached only through particular struggles, through the multiplicity of labor processes organized by global capitalism.
who cannot are left at a disadvantage. In the context of the imperialist world system wherein academic apparatuses are concentrated in the Global North, such organizational inequalities disproportionately impact Global South researchers. Academia needs to reflect on the material
@jensensuther
Gramsci used catharsis to refer to the transition from particular to universal demands. One can't derive a universal working class interest from the value-form. It is formed through particular experiences of class formation that modify the simplicity of value-form abolition
@sparklymachine
@hailewwwwshash
Take domestic life. It is essential for the construction of individual personality under capitalism. However, it is only the male who become individuated outside the family, and thus it is male activity that constitutes the public sphere of society.
@richard_maurhut
@donaldp1917
Well, Lukacs never said that you could separate appearance and essence, form and content. Konstantinos Kavoulakos is informative in this regard
My latest:
During the closing of the 7th Party Congress, Fidel Castro had declared: โTo our brothers in Latin America and the world we must convey that the Cuban people will overcome.โ
@avispartan
@LeninBol
Yes, there are other disparities too. But it was your denial of imperialism's benefits that I wanted to highlight. The ultimate conclusion of such facts: any internationalism must face the contradictions between the global North and South which will not go away automatically .
@sparklymachine
@hailewwwwshash
Pre-social refers to the private domain in which women's bodies are circumscribed (I clarified this in the first section that talks about the movie Deewar). Whereas the public sphere of society is fully constituted, the private realm of pre-social womanhood is open-ended.
@jensensuther
Asserting the abolition of value-form as the starting point functions to theoretically unify struggles whose only unity lies in political unification. It does not help recognize what Lenin called the "variegated and discordant, motley and outwardly fragmented" aspects of struggle
@Antiquelandsca1
@0AMARJEET
But the relation of overdetermination that Althusser establishes between these two terms is very different from Cohen's analytical individualism which separates forces of production from relations of production - the determining factor exists prior to the determined factor.