🚨 Austerity update 🚨
"With hindsight we probably should have taken advantage [of low interest rates] and borrowed more when times were more stable...and invested more."
Former HMT permanent secretary (05-16) Nicholas Macpherson on Radio 4 Analysis ...
Thrilled to be starting a new job today as policy lead on "place" in the Industrial Strategy Unit at the Department for Business and Trade.
A hugely exciting time to be working on such a critical agenda.
A bit of personal news: after a fantastic time at UKRI, I'm moving to a job at the new Levelling-Up Unit in the Cabinet Office, where I'll be working on innovation policy.
The calibre of Whitehall's leadership will probably decline in coming decades as pay erodes. An SCS increasingly made up of people whose parents could afford to buy them houses in London.
A consequence of real terms pay cuts in the civil service - with SCS falling furthest behind... This is an SCS1 post which would have been more market competitive 15 years ago. Pay restraint & lack of flexibility means harder to get skills in as well as leading to grade inflation
"Fundamentally, the British dream is not owning your own home, it is owning someone else's."
Delicious line in a great
@duncanrobinson
piece on British landlords.
Lots of truth
@TorstenBell
's piece on Britain's distracted approach to the problems of the day.
A surprising number of policy people think Manchester's economy is essentially fixed and the city gets more than its "fair share" of investment.
I've said it before, but if Labour go ambitious on planning reform we can expect the Tories to become a militantly nimby party. Look at Sunak's response at PMQs!
Fascinating episode on the statecraft of a new Labour government, with lessons from the last one from Sally Morgan.
Ruthless prioritisation, proper cross-departmental working, and a functional centre of government all utterly necessary for success.
Tony Blair’s former Political Secretary Baroness Morgan tells
@ayeshahazarika
&
@Samfr
delivering in government is all about leadership and relationships & what it’s like to transition from opposition. Insights also from
@instituteforgov
's
@DrHannahWhite
.
Starting a new job outside the civil service tomorrow. I've loved my time there: from Local Industrial Strategies to the Levelling Up White Paper. I strongly suspect I'll be back one day, and like any organisation, it's got its good and bad quirks.
A bit of personal news: from mid-December, I'll be moving to a new job as Head of Government Relations at
@UKAeroInstitute
. Can't wait to get stuck in and do my bit for the UK's brilliant aerospace industry!🛫
Local Industrial Stategies are back, baby!
This version will have more chance of sticking given they'll be led by Mayors rather than LEPs. But they'll need meaningful funding levers and cross-Whitehall support to succeed this time around.
Some real treasures on display at the
@UkNatArchives
treason exhibition. Highlights include the posthumous treason verdict for Richard III, Guy Fawkes' confession signature, the court records of Charles I's trial, and Patrick Pearse's last letter to his mother.
Thoughtful and sober essay by
@TomMcTague
. Reminded me of Henry Tizard's 1949 remark:
"We are not a great power, and never will be again ... We are a great nation, but if we continue to behave like a great power we shall soon cease to be a great nation."
Very exciting announcement today as
@Boeing
and
@TheAMRC
launch a major R&D project backed by
@UKAeroInstitute
funding and a new Investment Zone.
Excellent news for South Yorkshire and the UK's world-class aerospace sector ✈️
Today we’re launching
@TheAMRC
’s largest ever R&D project. The COMPASS facility is part of the new South Yorkshire Investment Zone - the UK’s first investment zone focussed on advanced manufacturing - and it’ll help reduce the environmental impact of air travel. 🧵 1/4
It's my final week in the Cities and Local Growth Unit. Sad to be leaving such a fascinating policy area and brilliant set of colleagues, but also very excited to be joining UKRI's strategy team in the next couple of weeks!
I've written a piece for
@thefabians
on what Labour's science and technology policy should look like 🌹🔬
The Conservatives have made R&D a top governing priority. What should Labour’s response be? I argue for three things:
It's a really exciting time to work on this agenda: post-pandemic recovery, big ambitions for science and innovation policy, Net Zero, and a new focus on resilience are going to have huge impacts on places across the UK. I can't wait to get stuck in.
Thrilled to be published in
@thefabians
' 140th anniversary Fabian Review, exploring what Labour's science policy can learn from the Blair and Brown years 🌹🔬
A few highlights...
Some of the coolest jobs in British science and technology have gone live today.
Would be brilliant to see some younger talent apply for these roles. Perhaps one for
@UKRI_News
Future Leaders Fellows?
Very exciting news that Cambridge-based chipmaker Pragmatic has secured £182m to become the UK's biggest semiconductor manufacturer, expanding its operations in the North East 🏭
Industrial strategy is back on the agenda. I've written a piece for the
@BennettInst
reflecting on Labour and the Conservatives' economic strategies.
For all the talk of a new Butskellite-style consensus, the parties' plans are actually quite different.
The Conservatives and Labour are each developing a distinct strategy to grow the British economy.
In a new piece,
@WJBLord
discusses their strengths and weaknesses and recommends where they should focus their attentions.
As far as I know, the Inflation Reduction Act and CHIPS & Science don't have big "complex and nuanced" strategy documents. They pick their goals and act through huge new investments.
Contrast that with Britain's love of churning out glossy bits of paper without much in them 🤷🏼♂️
To try and finally put an end to the question 'just how many plans for growth have this government had?' I am pleased to announce....
📢🏭THE DEFINITIVE LIST OF UK INDUSTRIAL STRATEGIES (POST-2010)🧑🏭📢
(I'll expand this thread as and when we get new ones)
Tweets like this from members of the city and university's leadership are instructive. If Cambridge doesn't want to grow, fine. But maybe the state should invest more of its R&D funding in places that do.
I'm starting a new job at UKRI next week and am very much in the market for good papers and articles about science & innovation policy, emerging technologies, missions and more. Any suggestions Twitter?
Lots of green industrial policy reading today! Latest is this great analysis from
@GeorgeDibb
and
@LukeSMurphy
on the UK's dire record on investment.
This is what a broken economic model looks like.
The new Advanced Manufacturing Plan has just dropped 👇🏭
I've got a professional interest, but it's a genuinely chunky set of interventions. Perhaps Ms Heeves lives after all...
On that note, I hear an email went round several departments from no10 asking for ideas about how to fix inflation by midday today. Time's running out lads!
Terrific piece on industrial strategy and government's tendency towards bitty funding pots and over-governance.
Two additional critiques of UK policy I'd add to the mix...
What is the Biden administration’s international economic agenda?
National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan (
@JakeSullivan46
) kicks off a
@BrookingsInst
talk on the New Washington Consensus.
In this morning's Politico London Playbook. I feel this needs further investigation, because if it is true the university in question deserves to be stripped of its public funding.
David Willetts reflects on the Eight Great Technologies and his time as Science Minister.
A story of the UK building promising niches in the face of policy churn, Whitehall restrictions, and challenges with scaling and adoption (particularly in the NHS).
Fascinating article on why the university-led science model delivers fewer productivity gains than the old corporate R&D labs.
Especially challenging for the UK given how unusually reliant on Higher Education our R&D system is.
Finally got round to this excellent
@CentreforCities
report on Britain's housebuilding malaise.
The 300,000 new homes a year target is badly out of date. If we really want to tackle the problem, 442,000-654,000 per year is needed. 👷♂️🏘
Finally got round to the
@edballs
@annastansbury
and
@DanTurnerSY
paper all the cool kids in regional policy are reading. It's very very good!
Long story short: UK regional inequality is far from all about skills. Transport and R&D matter too.
Tremendously helpful and interesting presentation by
@ndrlee
and
@siri_arntzen
on testing innovation in the real world.
Everyone wants a testbed/living lab/sandbox. But what actually are they, and what are they best used for?
#IGL2019
Important
@UKRI_News
analysis on the sustainability of the research base.
Inflation and low cost-recovery rates led to a ~£5bn deficit in the cost of university research in 21/22, requiring more cross-subsidy from international fees and other activities.
Was bowled over by the
@britishlibrary
Anglo-Saxons exhibition! Seeing the Domesday Book and the world's only manuscript of Beowulf were real highlights
#BLAngloSaxons
Quick thoughts about today's departmental changes:
1. UKRI is potentially going to represent the vast majority of DSIT's budget. Will make for an interesting department/NDPB relationship.
2. What happens to OSTS?
An extraordinary success story from
@ForgemastersHQ
.
An £80m loan to Forgemasters was cancelled by the Coalition in 2010. Then it was was nationalised in 2021. Now it's developing critical technology for manufacturing SMRs. Quite the journey.
Really interesting piece on what R&D policy for a place looking to level-up should be. A proactive local university combined with support for innovation and diffusion all make the difference.
Chunky update to the Science and Technology Framework announced today. DSIT must be busiest department in Whitehall right now!
In her recent
@sciencecampaign
lecture,
@uksciencechief
said she hoped the framework would survive any political changes.
If there's a lesson here, it's that an incoming Labour government will need to decide and execute its regional policy sharpish.
Spend 2 years coming up with a new policy framework, and the opportunity to show progress by 2028/9 is lost.
Delighted to have written a review for
@CSWnews
of
@ndrlee
's new book "Innovation for the Masses".
An excellent guide for policymakers on how to combine a dynamic innovation economy with broad-based prosperity. Grounded in four fascinating case studies.
This is interesting. We hear a lot about DARPA, but one of the most successful examples of US industrial policy is the Manufacturing Extension Partnerships: an adoption and diffusion programme.
Fantastic day visiting
@TheAMRC
today with
@UKRI_News
and
@beisgovuk
colleagues. A great opportunity to see its ambitions for achieving
#NetZero
and driving growth in Sheffield City-Region.
Readout from the Council of Science and Technology: the PM reiterates the importance of R&D to the levelling-up agenda and challenges science to come up with "moonshots" where the UK should aim high.
An important data release from
@ONS
today on the regional distribution of public R&D funding.
Previous GovERD stats only showed R&D *performed* in-house by government. This shows where all public R&D funding is invested.
Following on from that Northern Gritstone announcement last week, a piece from me looking at what these innovation accelerators in the levelling up white paper are all about:
164 new homes planned near Tunbridge Wells, 40% affordable, + landscape and biodiversity enhancements. Planning inspectorate said yes, government intervenes and says no.
Regional policy is just as much about prosperity as it is equity.
If you want the UK to be a wealthier and more dynamic country, you cannot afford to ignore the dire economic performance of regions outside London.
This is very good on the rise and rise of self-service admin work. Raising a purchase order is one of the most baffling experiences of my professional life.
An excellent day's discussion on how we drive up R&D and innovation across the North through ambitious Local Industrial Strategies. Massive thanks to
@IfMCambridge
for organising!
Secondly, still too centralised. If you want long-termism, local institutions tend to be more consistent than national ones.
Greater Manchester and the West Midlands stuck to their Local Industrial Strategies long after Whitehall moved on. Give them more tools to deliver!
British cities badly underperform. It's one of the biggest things holding us back.
Meanwhile the PM comes out with stuff like this. Not a serious policy agenda.
A great initiative to grow R&D clusters. Between this,
@innovateuk
's Launchpads in Tees Valley and Liverpool City-Region, STEP2 in Nottinghamshire, and the three Innovation Accelerators, lots of exciting place-based R&D investment coming out of
@UKRI_News
and BEIS at the moment.
We're exciting to launch the
@EPSRC
Placed-Based Impact Acceleration account competition. We're giving you plenty of time to build your ideas & consortia and have townhall events in November. Get in touch if you'd like to discuss the scope further
Would thoroughly reccomend this
@BritishAcademy_
report on UK science policy since 1916. Striking to see how the legacies of big decisions made decades ago (e.g. Rothschild in 1971, Guise in the 1980s) can still be felt today.
@TomMcTague
@David_Goodhart
Whisper it, but there's a lot of cross-party consensus on the roots of the problem and how you address it (devolution to city-regions, long term "missions", supporting innovation clusters). Turning that into sufficient action is another matter...
Very bad news indeed if this funding isn't channelled back into R&D. Would be a very poor start for the new Department for Science, Innovation and Technology.
The Gov have released details today that BEIS has surrendered to the Treasury £1.6b of funds which had been allocated for Horizon Europe association.
This is a reversal of its previous position and a false start on ambitions to be a science superpower
Wonder what happens to London's public sector, charities, universities, the Civil Service etc. when the generation that should be moving into leadership positions is simply priced out of the city.
Had a fantastic two days zipping around Cambridge talking to academics, think tankers and commercialisation experts about innovation and how it really works. All thanks to the
@CSciPol
policy fellowship scheme!
I've written a piece for the
@BennettInst
on Levelling Up one year on from the White Paper. What's gone well? Where has it fallen short? What does government need to do next?
BLOG One year on since the
#levellingup
white paper was published to tackle inequalities between the UK’s most & least prosperous places,
@WJBLord
- a former advisor at
@luhc
- gives it an honest appraisal.
Enjoyed this latest report from the Tony Blair Institute on AI.
Makes the case for increased investment, big reforms to the Whitehall machine, and a new national laboratory focused on safe AI.
Some wonderful works on display at the National Gallery's Lucien Freud exhibition. The fleshy, intimate later works are always compelling. But I also liked a lot of his earlier paintings. Very dreamlike.
@stephenkb
There's a caged football pitch right next to the path I take to get home. Every day I live in fear of the moment a ball will find its way over the edge while I'm walking by.
A very different kind of external engagement today. Great to speak to the students about all things science policy and see their brilliant ideas, from new apps for the elderly to VR classrooms!
#STAHSYear9
are leading the way in STEAM innovation 🌫 We were delighted to welcome
@wjblord
from
@UKRI_News
to deliver a brilliant talk and judge the Youth Industrial Strategy Competition. There were some excellent ideas with the Edible Water Bottles crowned the overall winners.