Appellate lawyer at Wright, Close & Barger in Houston, with a Fifth Circuit and TX appellate practice. So-called Dean,
#appellatetwitter
(banner from Art Lien)
Re-reading the Trump PA case just now, Iโm struck that perhaps never has a man lost so many cases so quickly. Itโs not just the volume of losses, but how fast and total they are. Iโm a little impressed.
You're telling me there was a US v. Canada football game where you played American rules in the first half and Canadian in the second and the trophy was a small teapot and we STOPPED PLAYING IT?
A football match between Canadians and Americans in London, England during WWII in 1944. The game, known as the โTea Bowlโ, drew over 30,000 spectators just months before D-Day. Canada would win 16-6.
There's a strange thread circulating about how food was more healthy in the 1980s. I just want to say, as someone who grew up then, it was *much* worse. Comically worse. In almost every way.
Non-lawyer followers: this litigation (in all the states) is truly blowing my mind. It's as if you're playing chess and your opponent lets off a whoopie cushion, throws a Zebra Cake on the board, and then runs off without pants and says they won. I don't know what else to say.
OK, I'm going to live-tweet the Twitter-Musk merger agreement, which just dropped. No judgment, just explaining.
For new followers, I was a corporate lawyer at a Fancy Firm a long time ago, and have forgotten a lot! So hopefully that helps me be clear
The country needs to come together to completely blow him away. No narrow wins, people. It has to be completely overwhelming. He has to become Mondale. It's the only way.
Every time thereโs another one of these appalling shooting, I think about what the public policy reaction would be if there were a low-grade terror campaign by a foreign enemy that, every week or so, had suicide attackers assault schools, religious institutions, and malls.
The perennial lawyering question is a chicken v egg scenario. Did they lose so badly because their lawyers are had or because theyโre bringing nonsense claims. Well, the claims. But otoh good lawyers wouldnโt lose those cases because they wouldnโt have brought them.
Guys, an actual filing in federal court is asking for the court to establish the Stewardship of Gondor in the absence of Aragorn. No, I'm not joking. h.t
@questauthority
This is a hobby horse of mine, so apologies. But - most NFL players aren't rich. They make less than a fancy lawyer for 3-4 years - maybe 10 if they're incredibly lucky - then they're left with injured bodies and a gap in their lives while they figure out what to do.
My mini-thread on the Pennsylvania decision is here. Bottom line: a completely expected but humiliating and harshly worded defeat for Trump. The judge pours calumny on Rudyโs head civilly but brutally.
The people challenging the drive-through voting procedure here in Houston (Republican operatives) haven't gotten what they wanted from the Texas courts (although one case is still outstanding), so they ran away to federal court. Pathetic. Let's destroy them on Tuesday.
Ok, here is my complete thread on todayโs hearing in PA. Takeaways: I think the Judge was very skeptical of Trumpโs claims. Iโd expect him to dismiss the case on Friday. Rudy Giuliani โฆ did not do a good job.
OK, I am theoretically in this MD Pa. motion to dismiss hearing conference call. Right now we've got some snappy hold music. But if I'm in, I will live-tweet.
UK Legal Scholars Track Down 17th Century Murder Case, Prove Justice Alito's Version of Framers' Original Intent on Double JeopardyโAdopted by SCOTUS in Gamble v. United Statesโis Wrong.
@lawdotcom
@TheNLJ
@JimmyHooverDC
Let me start with Judge Smith's dissent. It is hard to convey the ferocity of it on here. He disagrees in every possible respect. This passage is representative. /4
W....ow. The Fifth Circuit's just held that United
Airlines employees might suffer irreparable injury from the company's vaccine mandate. I will tweet the decision here.
*Bias alert: I have 0 sympathy for these employees and their claims. So keep that in mind. 1/
โWhat standard of review should I apply?โ
Rudy: โThe normal one.โ
I can hear the judgeโs befuddlement from here. The normal one is not the answer. He wanted โstrict scrutinyโ or intermediate scrutiny.
Thereโs a Sikh man who lives near me takes his very aged father for a long walk, hand in hand, every single morning โ whether itโs 100 degrees or 32, and every time I see him I feel better about things. Just the duty and love of it.
I've a strong view, formed over many years of litigation, that you should probably not broadcast pictures of the judge you're currently litigating in front of with lasers coming out of her eyes.
On cross-examination today, Alex Jones is confronted on cross that he has been calling the judge (sitting next to him) a โtyrantโ on his show during the trial, while showing lasers coming out of her eyes.
A devoted Rastafarian wanted to keep his locks while imprisoned, and TOOK a copy of the Fifth Circuit's opinion saying he could with him to intake.
The guards threw it away and forcibly shaved him. However, he loses his case for damages under circuit precedent.
Link coming.
Right. Again, this is hilarious. Gohmert asked for the appeal to be sped up, with briefing today and tomorrow and reply briefs and amici. The Fifth Circuit said, yeah, never mind, you lose.
Thereโs a lot of confusion on my timeline about whether Elon has a right to walk from the Twitter deal for $1bn. No. He would write that check right this second if he could walk away.
The agreement allows Twitter to try to make him buy the company at the price he agreed. 1/
700,000 ballots were not allowed to be viewed in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh which means, based on our great Constitution, we win the State of Pennsylvania!
Even non-lawyers should read Gorsuch in Patel v. Garland for a sense of how impossible our immigration laws are.
Patel tried to apply for a Green Card. He checked the wrong box on the form. Immigration authorities said he was lying. 1/
Just a reminder, Trump walked through recently deployed tear gas to give a speech with a bible he's never opened. But people are occupying the Capitol, he loves them.
Yeah, I'm a little hot right now.
I went into a store this PM, and for the first time ran into someone who had printed out a "mask waiver" from facebook. They told her they wouldn't serve her. She put her stuff on the conveyor belt and said "ring me up."
Cashier: "Oh I can wait all day for you to leave honey"
Every lawyer who signed any of those briefs should be treated with total disdain. Iโm sorry. I am not a harsh person. But this litigation was so far beyond the pale, so outrageous, so disloyal to the Constitution. Incredible.
21) NOT ADVICE, OF ANY KIND, IN ANY WAY
I WAS NOT VERY CAREFUL WITH MY WORDS HERE, AND DO NOT MEAN ANY OF THEM IN A TECHNICAL OR LEGAL SENSE; I MAY WELL HAVE NOT DESCRIBED THINGS RIGHT though I'm trying to be transparent. I'M NOT A GOOD DEV AND PROBABLY MISDESCRIBED SOMETHING.
Getting a late start today because I was looking for the constitutional text that says you can't use evidence of immune official acts to prosecute non-immune non-official acts.
The Fifth Circuit reverses and grants judgment *for* a judge who does a prayer ceremony in his courtroom before hearing cases.
Judge Jolly dissents in relevant part. His description of what the scene in Court is like is below. 1/
Rudy was unable to express a single clear answer to anything the judge asked; he hardly understood the questions; and then desperately sought to amend his complaint again but didnโt know you needed to file a motion for leave.
There were fewer options in every single category, the meat was bad, the veggies were bad, the fruit was bad, the cereals were bad, the restaurants were much worse.
I'm talking about person in regular urban or suburban middle class. If you raised your own beef, ok.
You.... can't make something true by ... just saying it in a Rule 41 Notice of Dismissal.
Otherwise all y'all lawyers whose Rule 41s say something other than "We are dismissing this case because we have won and opponents owe us Eleventy Billion Dollars" are doing it wrong.
๐จBREAKING: The Trump campaign just told a federal judge in MICHIGAN that because the Wayne Co board of canvassers have "declined to certify the results of the presidential election" it will no longer press a lawsuit seeking a judicial order blocking certification
The day before Florida lawmakers voted to create a new board overseeing Disney, the Disney-aligned old board passed an agreement basically neutering the new one, to be in effect until 21 years after the death of the last survivor of King Charles (?!?)
The life cycle of a frivolous appeal. Filed, 11:31 am. Motion to expedite filed 1:54 PM. Affirmed, 7:21 PM. Mandate issued 7:33 PM. Itโs the mayfly of appeals, except it didnโt even last a day.
Ok, Iโll stop making fun of them now. Enough.
Oh man this is amazing. No random public announcements (that's normal) except Elon Musk is allowed to tweet about the deal (lol) but not if he insults Twitter. I'll get back to the previous topic in a second, but this was too delightful to ignore. /9
New: Another GOP election challenge loss โ 11th Circuit rejected L. Lin Wood's effort to stop Georgia from certifying. The 3-0 opinion, written by Judge Bill Pryor, agreed with the district judge that Wood lacked standing, and concluded it was moot
Iโm seeing comments like this from the Trumpy right. Just to make this clear for everyone: you always lay out the goods before you show up in court. Thatโsโฆ how it works. This idea that you go to court and then you drive in a clown car of surprise witnesses is Lionel Hutz stuff.
Also, since I can't leave well enough alone, especially when it comes to history, the notion that there was some golden age before the 80s is, alas, not true.
The early 20th century especially was a nightmarescape of adulterated foods and weird chemicals that killed.
โIf I conclude that rational basis applies, why donโt they satisfy that standard?โ
Rudy: โhow is this rational?โ
That isnโt the answer Rudy.
We used Covid-19 shutdown to do projects that wouldโve been inconvenient for residents regularly (street paving, park renovations etc). One project was ripping up the 1960s vinyl floor at city hall. We thought weโd find garbage but instead we found the original from 100 yrs ago
New from SCOTUS: Justice Ginsburg is in the hospital with a gallbladder condition. She has undergone a successful procedure and will participate in oral arguments tomorrow morning from her hospital room
It is genuinely heartwarming to me that my TL is split between being outraged at how stupid this is, and outraged at the complete misunderstanding of LOTR. Abandoned Gondor! The Kings did not abandon Gondor!
And fast casual? Basically not a thing.
Literally the best place to go with friends around me was pizza hut. You can make fun of assembly line burrito places, but they're *much* better than what we had.
I wanted to note something about Texas SB8 that's been my hobbyhorse since this law was proposed, and should give pause *even* to people who want abortion banned. Look at the text of the bill. 1/
By โfree speechโ, I simply mean that which matches the law.
I am against censorship that goes far beyond the law.
If people want less free speech, they will ask government to pass laws to that effect.
Therefore, going beyond the law is contrary to the will of the people.
I've tragic news. My wife's first cousin, Hilda, died from COVID-19 this week. She was a lovely person, the maid of honor at our wedding. Our family is utterly crushed.
There's a gofundme. Not asking you to donate - I'm linking so you can see her.
Sorry about being hyperbolic in tweets above but I am honestly flabbergasted that DOJ has to get in front of a federal judge and admit they don't really know what the President means but everything they told the judge the other day was not true.
You could have quite a good podcast that was nothing but explaining, with no thumb on the scale, crazy making aspects of criminal law and a no lawyer would be the guest and theyโd say โwait are you sureโ and the lawyer would say โyesโ and thatโs the show.
In case you donโt read to the end of the abstract,
@WilliamBaude
and Professor Paulsen say that Donald Trump is, right now, disqualified from being President.
OK, I am theoretically in this MD Pa. motion to dismiss hearing conference call. Right now we've got some snappy hold music. But if I'm in, I will live-tweet.
I see there's some discussion about whether Aronchik is being too harsh on Rudy. It's harsh, but I don't think it crosses a line. Someone has to say on that side this is crazy.
Oh, bread. My supermarket now has a bakery where it bakes decent bread with a real crust twice a day at least. It's not *amazing* but it's very good. That bread would have been at the fancy French bakery when I was a kid you'd go to 2x a year.
OK, here we are!
Very first thing, confirming that indeed, Twitter is asking that the Court force Musk to buy Twitter at the contract price.
Again, this case is *NOT* about a $1 billion termination fee.
1/
Thank you all for the encouragement. I am pooped. And have actual work (I'm like a lawyer or some such).
One last note: mighty lawyering from everyone involving on the side of voters, especially
@ChristinaA_Ford
. Y'all make me proud.
He showed up in Court with a bunch of pictures but they're not in the complaint and he hasn't shared them with anyone and he's trying to hand them to the judge (no).
Judge Smith calls for en banc reconsideration, even though the case is unpublished, because, in his view, the opinion overturns well-established Fifth Circuit precedent.
"The Good Ship Fifth Circuit is on fire" he says. /5
Lawyers: Listen, Elon, you were defrauded by this bot situation, you understand, and you relied on those frauds to buy twitter. We wrote that all down.
Elon: Absolutely, like you said I'll go online and say I wasn't tricked.
Lawyers: No, the opposite of that.
Elon: Got it.
History side-note moment: I read this 1776 report. I'll leave to others the various errors and whatnot. But it is a singularly bad piece of writing. Like how I wrote as a first year college student, but before my teacher told me to try again.
@BroyleTim
I don't really know what's going on in the case more generally. But basically, the defense lawyer found out the judge had been pressuring a witness to testify with the DA but without defense counsel. The Judge told him to say how he found out. Counsel refused, and the judge 1/
The quoted email here is just shocking. Not that we didnโt know Trump was pressing DOJ to bring these claims. Of course he was. But in black and white.
@JohnJHarwood
@gtconway3d
@JoyceWhiteVance
@AWeissmann_
He has 30 days after judgment, which is not yet, to bond the judgment or put the money somewhere safe, pending appeal. Otherwise enforcement can begin. But often plaintiffs will reach some sort of agreement with the defendant about bonding pending appeal.