Educational realist, Diehard edu myth-buster, Emeritus Prof. Educational Psychology Open Universiteit, Guest Prof. Thomas More Uni (Belgium), owner kirschner-ED
New working paper from
@DTWillingham
Gist: A knowledge-rich curriculum leads to better reading scores, but most importantly (for me) is that while the effect size was large for kids in high-income schools it was gigantic for kids in low-income schools!
The most successful teachers spend more time in guided practice, more time asking questions, more time checking for understanding, and more time correcting errors.
Day 18 of
#HowLearningHappensInFeb
a chapter of 'How Learning Happens' each day in February.
Today is chapter 18
'Direct instruction'
Join in with your own reflections using the hashtag above.
@P_A_Kirschner
&
@C_Hendrick
Yesterday more than 1500 teachers and researchers, hungry for good teaching and learning converged in London to present and listen to +/-120 sessions. Here are my two presentations on How Learning Happens and Generative Learning Strategies
Another one bites the dust! New research comprehensively examined the brain development of young boys and girls and shows no gender difference in brain function or math ability. Open access to original article.
"Science doesn't align with folk beliefs"
A year in the making and it’s (our new book
@C_Hendrick
@HealJim
& me, with illustrations by
@olicav
) now out of our hands and in the publisher’s.
Coming this spring: How Teaching Happens: Seminal Works in Teaching and Teacher Effectiveness and What They Mean in Practice
How guidance works! One step at a time so as not to overload…
Yes, learning in a sport and learning in an academic subject and learning to play a music instrument et cetera all follow the SAME general rules. Learning is learning.
Incredible resource on:
- knowledge-rich curriculum
- teaching driven by content
- forgetting as part of the learning process
- working memory limits
- practice makes permanent
Curriculum Links Part 1: Underlying Principles
I don't post such things often (or at all for that matter), but I'm making an exception today as I'm feeling very sentimental and so much in love today: for 47 official years we are one.
Explicit teaching drives student motivation, engagement, and achievement in NSW public schools
Yes, you read it correctly: Explicit instruction and success drive motivation and not the other way around!!
I find it strange that doctors, engineers, ... don't experience being required to use/adhere to proven methods (either evidence-based or -informed) as violating their professional autonomy or undermining their professionalism but that teachers do.
Zij staakten, gingen de barricades op, demonstreerden. Maar als de nood hoog is vangen ze de kinderen op, geven ze online les, stellen bange kinderen gerust... Docenten in NL, hoewel ondergewaardeerd, laten zien wat ze waard zijn.
@MinOCW
@arieslob
onthoud dit als het voorbij is!
Want kids to think critically? First, make sure that they have fundamental content knowledge!
Why Content Knowledge is Crucial to Effective Critical Thinking
The last day of
#HowLearningHappensInFeb
a chapter of 'How Learning Happens' each day in February.
Today is chapter 29
'The ten deadly sins in education'
Join in with your own reflections using the hashtag above. See you next leap year!
@P_A_Kirschner
&
@C_Hendrick
If you think Vygotsky was a constructivist, you probably never read him (I did). Here's how important he found good instruction to be.
Vygotsky's Doctrine of Scientific Concepts: Its Role for Contemporary Education in Vygotsky's Educational Theory in Cultural Context
Taking notes doesn't come naturally so don't take it for granted in your students (of all ages). We need to teach them how to do it properly, (just like how to summarise, outline, highlight, etc.). That's called good instruction!
For all researchers whose articles are rejected - oft for the strangest reasons and I can attest to this - keep going! Here's the rejection letter from Nature for the work that won this year's Nobel prize in Physiology/Medicine
As of today, I'm Professor Emeritus at the
@OU_Nederland
. I'm not stopping my work on how to we can best achieve and ensure effective, efficient, & enjoyable teaching/learning; it's just that the uni's no longer paying me :-) You're not rid of me yet; not by a long shot!
People generally have a poor understanding of how they learn and remember. John Dunlosky discusses some evidence-based learning strategies that boost learning and memory incl. the effects of small vs. large classes, (poor) teacher training...
Cognitive Load Theory: An Applied Reintroduction for Special and General Educators
A key reason why students with disabilities struggle in school is that professionals may not pay enough attention to students’ overwhelmed cognitive capacity.
What comes first:
#motivation
or
#learning
? Research suggests that learning leads to motivation and not the other way around, says
@EnserMark
. So why do teachers spend so much time trying to motivate pupils?
For anyone who is thinking of setting up a reading/discussion group for How Learning Happens, here's something that
@C_Hendrick
and I whipped up a little while ago
Oops! There goes the
#mindset
hype - Two large metastudies show 'growth mindset' educational interventions not effective: overall correlation between growth mindset and academic
#achievement
is weak at best
From Cognitive Load Theory to Collaborative Cognitive Load Theory - An expansion of CLT for designing and implementing collaborative learning is available open access -
Whoever thinks that direct instruction is monotonous, dull, and/or child-unfriendly either doesn't understand or doesn't know what direct instruction is! Thanks,
@teacherhead
for your Rainforest.
Interesting blog on how classroom displays can distract.
Children were more distracted by the visual environment, spent more time off task, and demonstrated smaller learning gains when the walls were highly decorated than when the decorations were removed.
We should stop using the term 'social distancing'. The 1 thing we don't need to do is to socially distance ourselves from each other. What we need is physical distancing. We can and need to be very close to others even though we must physically distance ourselves from them.
"
#Learning
requires attention, focus and effort, not a good giggle. Only those who think that ‘Happy sheets’ are a true indicator of learning adhere to the nonsense that learning should be all fun" Read
@DonaldClark
's 'Learning is not a circus and teachers are not clowns'
Neen
@marielle_paul
, u begrijpt er echt niets van! Lezen, schrijven en rekenen zijn voorwaardelijk voor o.a. digitale geletterdheid, burgerschap enz. Zonder geletterd te zijn kan je niet digitaal geletterd zijn! Stop met deze onzinnige initiatieven en zorg voor goed onderwijs!
Leren om digitaal vaardig te zijn is minstens zo belangrijk als goed lezen, rekenen en schrijven. Het expertisepunt digitale geletterdheid is er voor leraren die hier in de klas mee aan de slag willen. Verbinden, inspireren en informeren op één plek. 👇
Why doesn't it surprise me that growth mindset lessons don't work? Maybe because it's BS? Professor Dweck admitted to Tes last week that she had not initially recognised the "complexity of the implementation" of growth mindset in classrooms. WTF?
Again backing for what I've been saying for years: Success/achievement leads to motivation to continue and not the other way around. Motivation can get you started, but success will keep you going!
Attention ALL
#students
/
#authors
: Want to make my life (and all editor's, reviewer's, supervisor's) more pleasant, and improve your chances of success? Study and apply this
OK - I give up; I've met my match. If you want to understand dual coding / cognitive theory of multimedia and what it means for teaching watch
@adamboxer1
's incredible
@researchEdhome
presentation
When will schools wake up? A pre-published, groundbreaking study has found that for “deeper reading” there is a clear advantage to reading a text on paper, rather than on a screen, where “shallow reading was observed”.
"The thing that surprised me most about my teacher prep program was that we never talked about how kids learn...I assumed that I would eventually learn how the brain worked because I thought that studying education meant studying how learning happens.
Seven myths that undermine math learning:
(1) conceptual then procedural understanding
(2) teaching algorithms is harmful
(3) inquiry learning is the best approach
(4) productive struggle is important
(5) growth mindset increases achievement
Reading from paper leads to better integrative processing and comprehension (this time of text and illustration) than reading the same thing from a screen - open access -
Vanaf heden ben ik officieel emeritus hoogleraar op de
@OU_Nederland
. Ik stop niet met mijn strijd voor effectief, efficiënt en bevredigend lesgeven/leren. Het enige verschil is dat de uni mij niet meer betaalt :-) Jullie zijn dus nog lang niet van mij af :P
We've know since at least 1984 (Gabi Salomon) that letting learners do what they think is most efficacious just leads to them doing the thing that feels good and ultimately learning less.
Make your slides available to students? “Researchers have done some global comparisons and the bulk of the news does not favor making slides available. Students with slides do worse on exams or show no improved learning over students without slides.”
Schriftelijk gedeelte van het toelatingsexamen voor de 1e klasse van het Bilthovense lyceum (havo/vwo) in 1959
Hoofdrekenen: 18 minuten voor 20 vragen, kladpapier mag niet gebruikt worden.
Soms zegt één foto meer dan duizend woorden!
As if we needed to prove this again!
Explicit instruction (with
#phonics
) provides dramatic benefits in learning to
#read
above self-
#discovery
.
Please retweet/spread the word to the so-called progressive non-believers!
An interview with me in TES about direct instruction: An evidence-based and versatile instructional method that many teachers use without realizing it!
Vocabulary knowledge matters for the effectiveness of instructing reading strategies, especially for weaker readers. The connection between learning to read and reading to learn is clear.
When you hear things in education, remember:
-Hitchens’s razor: What can be asserted without evidence can also be dismissed without evidence.
-Sagan's standard: Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
“Students universally need predictable environments that support their attempts to experience and develop competence at all school levels (e.g., Aelterman et al., 2019; Ryan & Deci, 2017; Skinner et al., 2008).”
This has been getting some play recently. For you 'youngsters' out there: Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching
Our article advancing cognitive load theory to collaborative learning "From Cognitive Load Theory to Collaborative CognitiveLoad Theory" is available and is open access!
Finland: "The more that digital tools...the worse learning outcomes...in all areas of the Pisa measurements" Phenom-based learning "works for students who perform well in school...but less naturally-gifted students face the risk of being left behind"