Lucas C. De Hart @Dehartspeaks1 Twitter profile

Pinned Tweet

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

10 months

Every Sunday weekly current even reading as it relates to US Empire by yours truly.

What Lucas Read Week of 12/17/23

Every Sunday the Best of Current Events by Lucas' Suggestion

democraticconstitutionblog.substack.com

0

Last Seen Profiles

@BinorRaja

@sami29389150448

@AtchinMarcel

@Seneves

@ThuyAnh205000

@bokeplokalmalam

@americatv_peru

@Alison_Senpai

@0xbifemboy

@muahid_hafiz

@BinorRaja

@smalld818

@aikezzn

@um_ali1986

@SexualArabiaxx

@WinningAngle

@saraymnn

@bokeplokalmalam

@bitchimonster

@stw_pdg

@onehae6

@shinkyu_emisuke

@stwmaniax

@yurari_mfm

@bokeplokalmalam

@stw_pdg

@GennyGamboa3

@MMftwh23811

@Fannx_21

@PigBear66

@bwpieksma

@ekfnd_nct

@ikiteruikura

@bokeplokalmalam

@kampung_jandha

@bokeplokalmalam

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

Mehdi you know that’s not how this conflict started. Stopping being in propagandist of US empire or be intellectually honest at least.

Mehdi Hasan

@mehdirhasan

1 year

I’m no fan of some liberals calling folks they don’t like ‘Russian stooges’ or ‘Russian assets’ but, come on, if country X illegally invades country Y & you keep viciously attacking country Y & not country X, fair to say you support, or at least have a soft spot for, country X.

634

385

4K

165

7

106

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@thehill this is such a lie

2

4

58

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@thehill bullshit

0

3

38

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

5 years

Dead heat now between Sanders and Pete. My guess is Sanders will overtake with rest of Satellite results. #IowaCaucusResults

1

4

41

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Eviljohna @thehill @MSNBC lol @MSNBC lies about everything

2

6

25

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

5 years

@_waleedshahid We live in an undemocratic system where 30% of the country is more represented than the other 70%.

1

3

24

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

Wow Richard Clarke, former CIA Dir under G W Bush says Russia hacking like troops landing on our shores. Wow

1

12

20

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

4 years

This interview with ⁦ @rickperlstein ⁩ on ⁦ @majorityfm ⁩ is a wonderful history of anti-democratic, authoritarian and violent rhetoric by those in government and its supporters on the right. This history is rarely talked about but I’d essential.

1

7

28

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@neeratanden @BenSpielberg one of the biggest examples, HRC.

0

13

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@KoryBobrow @ggreenwald You ever hear of "Palestinians" and the "2014 Siege of Gaga?"

2

1

12

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

Just so people know not all you learn in school are lies, just a lot of it.

Caitlin Johnstone

@caitoz

6 years

Babies "When the baby is old enough, they send it to school, where it spends twelve years being taught lies about how the world works so that one day it will be able to watch CNN and say 'Yes, this makes perfect sense' instead of 'This is ridiculous'"

57

398

822

0

6

12

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

Props to @michelleinbklyn for being the first in a long time to push back against Bill Maher on Israel/Palestine.

0

1

14

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@noreallyhowcome @RealTrevinShu @NomikiKonst @JoyAnnReid @RoseAnnDeMoro @WaywardWinifred I'm talking what joy tries to frame people for being. We're on the same page against the elite.

0

10

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@JohnJHarwood funny how most people click US Intelligence when they have record of lying and deceiving WL has perf authentic record.

0

6

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@PoonamKumpatla @mehdirhasan If Elizabeth Warren or Kamala Harris were as progressive as Sanders I would support them but they aren’t. They also don’t have the popularity and support Sanders has. He’s he only one to show the country the way a progressive should govern, that I’ve seen so far.

1

9

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

@donaldp1917 Check out some of Stephen F Cohen’s work in the nation before he died.

0

10

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

Under Obama, the rebel program in Syria ended up aiding the al-Qaida-laced opposition and stoking the war."

2

12

9

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Well you have to understand difference between the orthodox Marxist revolutions in the 19th early 20th centuries with the goal of the democratic republic and the post-1917 national liberation movements after the Russian tragedy, former colonial countries.

Carlos

@agent_of_change

3 years

Some Marxists in the West see that nationalism has played an important role in the Chinese/Vietnamese/Korean/Cuban revolutions and conclude that we must build a revolutionary nationalism in the imperialist heartlands. Understandable but incorrect. There is no class basis for it.

26

165

2K

1

9

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@jasonjmoreland @RealTrevinShu Lol you're funny. I've watched her plenty and she hardly focuses on anything substantial. On twitter all she does is attack the left.

1

0

7

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@RealTrevinShu @NomikiKonst @JoyAnnReid @RoseAnnDeMoro @WaywardWinifred You're not the alt left, by alt left Joy means like insane racists who also want income equality.

1

0

8

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Eviljohna @thehill @MSNBC lol they do not sell @BernieSanders . You have been lied to.

3

0

7

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@neeratanden neither of us said anything about Jill. And I don't say Bush and Obama are=, I said he's expanded Bush's policies.

1

0

5

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Happy Holidays to everyone who celebrates them and remember to agitate for a democratic constitution!

0

9

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@neeratanden @BenSpielberg I mean to be fair, I can think of plenty so called "great candidates" who have dinner with dictators all the time

1

0

7

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@eclecticbrotha @MaxBlumenthal @likingonline @PaulBlu No one said it does.

1

0

7

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@aSkepticalHuman @JohnWilson @ggreenwald @ACLU It's literally attempting to criminalize free speech.

0

6

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@davidsirota @BernieSanders @nytimes didn't @SenBookerOffice get tons of money from big Pharma also?

0

1

6

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

Just because not for supporting certain policies does not mean it's to help countries become democratic or stable. It's in the oligarchy's interest. Foreign aid doesn't always but often creates client states and spheres of influence. There's a diff btw Capitalism n neoliberalism.

Josh Rogin

@joshrogin

7 years

We give foreign aid because its in our interest to help countries develop into stable, free market, democratic and peaceful societies. It's not a payment for supporting the President's politics or policies. And it's counterproductive to withdraw it as punishment.

160

615

2K

0

1

6

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@RoKhanna @BlueGreenSpork Ok but to be honest there's lots of reason to distrust the Democratic Party.

0

7

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@JulianAssange @JoyAnnReid you have anything to say for yourself?

0

1

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@RealTrevinShu @NomikiKonst @JoyAnnReid @RoseAnnDeMoro @WaywardWinifred But she tries to frame them as racist which is really just bizarre.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@neeratanden @BenSpielberg British intel lied completely about WMDS also.

1

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Salon @AmandaMarcotte complete bullshit watch the video to see how an official acts rather than how she should

1

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

This audience is really not liking May. #BattleForNumber10

0

5

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@thehill haha so are you sell out Debbie

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@PoonamKumpatla @mehdirhasan What do you have against sanders?

2

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@albamonica @MarkHalperin that's complete bullshit

0

1

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@RaniaKhalek It's not "the intercept" it's Mehdi Hasan, the Intercept gives editorial independence.

0

5

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

Most nation writers and journalists are actually really great. She's just one that doesn't belong.

1

0

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

2 years

Hell yea it does!

Marxist Unity Group

@MarxistUnityDSA

2 years

This means demanding a democratic constitution that will take power out of the hands of the capitalist class, allow our class to defend itself, and provide the framework for the achievement of socialism and the emancipation of all humanity!

0

5

45

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

It’s not actually funny to those who can read Cyrillic because Яussiaи in Cyrillic does not = Russian in English written language. It just comes off as ignorant and not caring to represent a language appropriately.

jeremy scahill

@jeremyscahill

7 years

When you write Russian Roulette like this: “яussiaи Roulette,” it looks really funny to people who can read Cyrillic/Russian. In Serbian, USA is “сад.” Feel free to use in your book titles and cable news graphics about how scary the US is.

16

22

128

1

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

I really enjoyed the panel. As someone who agrees with Gil Schaeffer’s analysis on the US political system and the need to demand democracy immediately, I hope this panel will lead to new conversations.

mass vanguard

@gracchusstrupp

3 years

I am grateful to all three panelists for agreeing to participate in such a stimulating discussion and to everyone who attended. I just thought I'd throw in my two cents (hampered by character limit) to keep the conversation going.

0

1

9

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@politico shows Politico is indeed part of corporate establishment media

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Eviljohna @thehill @MSNBC you are absolutely living in fantasy land. They practically are the Clinton camp. Except Joe and mica, they are

1

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

A great essay on state and non-state terrorism by professor @vijayprashad

0

6

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Eviljohna @thehill @MSNBC right wing. You are either blind or really really biased towards Hillary

0

2

5

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

Can't even tell us what her policy differences are. Literally j use hate talk on Corbyn

0

2

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@kade6767 with that response sounds like you don't know how to defend your response. I know lots about politics.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@Bershidsky I still don't think one degree in Russian Studies or whatever makes anyone an expert.

1

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

Literally supporting an ongoing apartheid regime with an illegal blockade and military occupation against indigenous Palestinians. Stop pretending to be dumb and covering for US Empire interests. It’s disgusting.

Aaron Rupar

@atrupar

1 year

@ZeeshanAleem Show me where the Biden administration encouraged war crimes

333

41

1K

1

2

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Lol we need far more nuclear energy not less.

The Spectator Index

@spectatorindex

3 years

BREAKING: Belgium is set to postpone its plan to shut down nuclear energy by 10 years amid energy crisis and Russian invasion of Ukraine

91

779

5K

0

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

11 months

Only NYC’s elite could be this mean to Halal Cart vendors

Chase Madar

@ChaseMadar

11 months

Sounds harsh but I don’t know what other conclusion can be drawn here. Just an extremely telling moment at an Upper East Side Halal food cart.

7

11

63

1

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@thehill saying this because Bernie is on the up and up and Sanders annihilates @realDonaldTrump in polls across the nation

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

Russia Beyond Supervillainy. Looking forward to reading Tony Woods’ new book Russia without Putin

1

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@dpakman @mtracey @davidpakmanshow Look at Trump’s policies toward Russia, he’s more aggressive than Obama.

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@politico2016 @politico @HillaryClinton not yet. You're performing bad journalism oh yes establishment doesn't care.

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@kade6767 @cnnbrk @BernieSanders @HillaryClinton lol any American is qualified to be in the senate! You don't even have to go to college!

1

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@RaniaKhalek @BenjaminNorton I agree with you on most issues in Syria but why can't you just condemn Assad for his actions that hit civilians as well?

0

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@Sophie_V_R @BenjaminNorton @Sophie_V_R just so you know Ben is being sarcastic. He’s playing off of what the US is doing in Venezuela.

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Been told by veteran reporters, peace activists, propaganda had not been this bad since 1950s. Maybe after 9/11 but far worse than Iraq War refusal to allow for dissent.

Nomiki --- "No-me-KEY"

@NomikiKonst

3 years

At what point is Congress going to look into these paid propagandists here to disrupt the left and push fascist conspiracies? Some of the funding has shown up on tax returns being funneled through "journalism awards" by assadists. These guys are toxic and spreading disinfo.

226

50

231

2

1

4

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@nytimes lol not really liars

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

. Yemen is a real complete mess. @vijayprashad

1

6

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

Now single payer advocates gotta do this to make their representatives and senators endorse single payer as position if not for voting yet.

Shawn Hubler

@ShawnHubler

8 years

This is absolutely true.

0

1

0

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Isn’t it interesting, as Russians get further into Mauripol, the more civilians seem to be able to evacuate.

Pepe Escobar

@RealPepeEscobar

3 years

Civilians, previously kept as human shields by Azov, finally able to leave Mariupol.

53

549

1K

0

1

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

Great old piece that should be revisited on al Qaeda and US relationship in Harper's by @andrewmcockburn

2

1

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

It won’t if we center the movement on a democratic constitution and don’t lose that as our ideological center. When Nixon went to China, and the Vietnam War ended, SDS lost their purpose, when WWIII was avoided the New Left lost its center.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

10 months

@donaldp1917 I find this so interesting. Kinda like David Horowitz, great historian of US Empire in the 60s only to become a reactionary decades later. Benny Morris writes an undeniable history of the creation of the modern state of Israel only to again become a reactionary.

0

8

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@CorrectRecord yea lol this is bullshit he had every right to talk like that.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@thenation great article explaining the genocide committed against Palestinians by the Israeli govt. Bernie knows Foreign Policy.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@Dem4Hillary @thehill @MSNBC @MSNBC never tells the truth

2

0

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@ChandraMJordan @cnnbrk @BernieSanders @HillaryClinton in what way is she just as qualified?

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@davidsirota was awesome on MSNBC! We gotta get more people like him on the mainstream media.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@aaronjmate @mtaibbi @aaronjmate honesty killing it on @TheRealNews putting out some of the best and most important broadcast journalism.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

Really goes to show you guys when you look closely, the Democratic Party meaning Dem Leadership don’t pursue policy based on principles or popular opinion, it’s all about maintaining the system wether than is the antidemocratic US Constitution or global US EMPIRE.

Lex McMenamin (they/them)

@leximcmenamin

1 year

my latest @TeenVogue ⬇️ as noted by @alexbkane , only 10% of Dems (incl @RashidaTlaib @Ilhan @AOC @MaxwellFrostFL ) have backed the #CeasefireNow resolution. @muslimdems issued Biden an ultimatum: “As Gaza turns red, so could crucial battleground states.”

1

133

329

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

This is exactly why no one should ever listen HCR. Lying about the reality of the rules-based international order which is supposed to be international law but we know who wrote them, violates them and benefits from them. This is just US Empire propaganda at this point.

Heather Cox Richardson (TDPR)

@HC_Richardson

1 year

Important to remember that U.S. alliances and partnerships underpin the rules-based international order. Weaken the U.S. and you destabilize that order, opening the door for dictators with imperial ambitions. Everywhere.

317

1K

4K

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@mtracey @RawStory Also who thinks of joe Rogen as right wing?

1

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

11 months

Just to be clear Democracy, the Democratic Republic is a state form. What that state form consists of is universal and equal suffrage in a unicameral legislative body. It’s the foundation for socialism or whatever societal project the people want. #demandademocraticconstitution

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

You don't blame the voters that demonizes them. You blame the system and the politicians who hold the power and must be kept accountable.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@davidsirota the senate is one of the most undemocratic institutions in our country.

0

3

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Reading a ton of Hal Draper’s archive on . Started with Marx on Democratic Forms of Government. Really excellently illustrates his strong principled belief in the democratic republic as the political tool for class struggle.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@neeratanden @BenSpielberg no, Bush was insane and a liar from the start. Obama got convinced by deep state to do what all presidents do.

1

0

1

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

What in the actual fuck is this reaction centrist talking about? Who in the fuck is even headed too far left?

Chris Matthews

@HardballChris

3 years

I want Hardball fans to know how I appreciate your faith in me. 2022 could be a great time to show what we’ve learned. I tried to warn we were headed too far left.

5K

357

4K

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

Ok this is just ridiculous at this point. I mean really guys really? Gonna keep playing fairytale.

The Spectator Index

@spectatorindex

3 years

BREAKING: NATO formally invites Ukraine's President Zelensky to address the coalition's summit on Thursday via video

194

2K

12K

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

@mtracey @mtracey this just came out too:

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

7 years

Cameroonian troops tortured and killed prisoners at base used for U.S. drone surveillance by @bobtrafford @nickturse

0

8

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

11 months

My god you’re lying to yourself and your followers if you believe Biden can’t pressure the Israeli government right now. It’s all political and you’ve been in politics long enough to learn that Harry.

Harry Sisson

@harryjsisson

11 months

@KyleKulinski @POTUS @JoeBiden Wait, why are you attacking him? It’s obvious that Israel will not agree to a ceasefire no matter what. They’ve made that clear and that’s what he’s referencing. He can’t force Netanyahu to do it

231

22

476

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

If you don’t understand all of this is about US imperialism, you’re missing a lot of history, which goes back to 1945. Key, read Franz Schurmann’s Logic of world power.

Pastor Ben

@BenjaminPDixon

3 years

Wait. I thought anti-imperialist meant all imperialism.

72

158

2K

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

That being said, there’s a set of facts that led us here. Hamas is not the force with overall military power and advantage, backed up by the worlds only global empire. They don’t have a systemic process of continued ethnic cleansing and pogroms. That’s Israel.

Dr. Mia Brett

@QueenMab87

1 year

Neither Hamas nor the Israeli government have the best interest of their people in mind. This conflict produces so much harm to civilians and there’s no good outcome that won’t cause a tragic death toll

15

285

1K

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@alexnpress @jacobin does publish some really awful commentary on Syria though sometimes.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

The literal existence of the Israeli illegal occupation system is an ongoing war crime

Aaron Rupar

@atrupar

1 year

@ZeeshanAleem Show me where the Biden administration encouraged war crimes

333

41

1K

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@matthewstoller @joshtpm Matt, Josh is one of those who’s job is to confuse those trying to understand the system.

1

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

1 year

Yes Democrats and Republicans aren’t the same my ass. They have different masks but their goals are the same. They are”indispensable enemies” who need each other for survival, to maintain the antidemocratic constitutional system that terrorizes the American majority.

Laiken Jordahl

@LaikenJordahl

1 year

BREAKING: Biden admin will waive 26 laws to build border walls through South Texas wildlife refuge & nearby communities. Biden's DHS will take “immediate action" to speed wall construction, casting aside protections for endangered species, clean water, Indigenous graves & more.

279

3K

6K

0

2

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

8 years

@LukewSavage is a total savage and makes my day so bright after reading his tweets.

Luke Savage

@LukewSavage

8 years

It's very much news to me that Keith Olbermann is a "devoted left winger"

3

2

17

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

9 years

@bpolitics Hillary is still for fracking

0

3

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

6 years

@OmarBaddar @aaronjmate To what extent has Hamas hurt or killed Israelis during the march? Because i have found no evidence of this thus far.

1

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

5 years

@NathanJRobinson Nathan why don’t you write about the institutional hurdles the Left must overcome to pass the agenda we want. An undemocratic Senate, an Electoral College, the use of judicial review in the Supreme Court for any legislation they don’t like.

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

5 years

Mayor Pete is all talk but really just all bullshit #DemDebate #CNNDebate

0

2

Lucas C. De Hart

@Dehartspeaks1

3 years

This is a more accurate view of SDS it was most active after 1968 grew as the intensification against the imperialist War in Indo-China grew. But factions like weatherman had little to do with SDS’ downfall.

wild_rover

@IsaacBarleycorn

3 years

Ppl have awful historigraphy with SDS. If it's national crisis was so bad, then how come the largest student mobilization happened a year later in 1970? how come thousands were fed post-69 into a decade + of revolutionary organizing from their chapters?