Modern halakhists who permit abortion in cases where mother's life isn't threatened:
R. Yosef Haim (Rav Pealim EH 1:4)
R. Eliezer Waldenberg (Tzitz Eliezer 6:48 et al)
R. Shneur Zalman Fradkin (Torat Hesed EH 42)
R. Gedalia Felder (Sheilat Yeshurun 1:39)
1/
Virtually every major Jewish halakhist of the modern era has barred abortion except when the life of the mother is threatened. Don't try quoting the Talmud at me. You just don't know enough.
@benshapiro
If by "Judeo-Christian heritage" you mean the heritage of men like Nicholas Donin, a Jew-turned-Christian who engineered the burning of the Talmud in the 1240s right across the Seine from Notre Dame, then sure, it's a monument to that.
Gonna kvell a bit here. My wife and daughter made a siyum upon completing Shas Mishnayot - all 6 orders and 63 tractates - on the night my daughter became a bat mitzvah!
Wait, a country that banned ritual slaughter to prepare kosher and halal meat, ostensibly on animal cruelty grounds, has *15 million minks in fur farms*!?
Maybe the 2015 slaughter ban wasn't really about animal rights.
NEW: Rav Yitzchok Sorotzkin shlita, Rosh Yeshiva of Telz and Lakewood Mesivta, member of the Moetzes Gedolei HaTorah:
"The whole idea of going to the Washington Rally (this Tuesday) is treif like chazer (not Kosher like pig)."
He warms that this rally could backfire and
Bethlehem, בית לחם in Hebrew, is in Judea, the place that give us the word "Jew". In Hebrew, the word for "Jew" and "Judean" is the same, Yehudi (יהודי). Arabic was not spoken in Judea in the time of Jesus, and was not yet a written language. Jesus was a Jew of Judea.
Why so upset by the truth. Jesus was born in Bethlehem aka بيت لحم in Arabic. Bethlehem is in Palestine. It’s currently militarily occupied by Israel and home to a predominately beautiful Palestinian Christian community. Yes, the birthplace of Jesus is under military occupation.
i went to israel when i was very young on the big free vacation, basically agnostic about it all and thinking it was a "complicated" place. in no way was what i saw complicated. they're selling you a fiction when they say you're supposed to stand with whatever they do
@GilStudent
@benshapiro
Here's your Judeo-Christian heritage at Notre Dame de Paris.
On the left is the Judeo (synagoga). On the right is the Christian (ecclesia).
This is not our civilization, Gil. This is the civilization that claimed to replace us.
I have so little patience for this sort of garbage. Jews are indigenous to Eretz Yisrael by any reasonable definition of the term. But let's take UN criteria, to which he links later in the thread: 1/
Let me say this as plainly as possible: Jews are not an indigenous people. It is appropriative to make use of this word when referring to our relationship to the land of Israel, and it undermines the difficult work being done to fix the ongoing oppression of indigenous peoples 1/
@NoNameNoPr0blem
@GilStudent
@benshapiro
Then call it Christian civilization. Christians decided which parts of Judaism to co-opt and which parts to jettison or persecute. It is not our civilization.
A Seder hack we've been doing for years: Multicourse karpas. Keep the veggies (incl. bananas, strawberries, anything on which we make "haadamah") and dips (chocolate fondue, whipped cream) coming throughout Magid. It's a game-changer.
You're welcome.
The first kippah-wearing PM in Israeli history will lead the country's first government to include an Islamist, majority Arab party as a full member of the ruling coalition. Stick that in your pipe and smoke it.
29 years ago today, I began studying at
@KBY_Yeshiva
. We learned Bava Metzi'a that year. Today I dropped my son off for his first day there. They're learning Bava Metzi'a again. He's using my old Gemara.
For the past five years, I have been working to bring
@SefariaProject
and Peninei Halakha together. Through all the fits and starts and changes of personnel, the dream has become a reality, and I couldn't be prouder.
Another point to clarify, concerning the belief that Black Americans are Semitic:
I have no problem with the belief itself, regardless of whether or not it is true.
@Amareisreal
believes this, and it led him to become a righteous Jew with real ahavat Yisrael.
1/19
The
@ADL
hasn't changed how it measures antisemitism or Jew hatred for over 50 years. Entire theories, believed by millions, have developed since then. These beliefs, (about Ashkenazi origins, slave trade, "real" Semites) are no longer just held by some nuts at Times Square.
It's annoying go have to explain that "antisemitism" is only about Jews, not other Semitic peoples or speakers of other Semitic languages.
I wish the Germans who coined the term to racialize their hostility toward European Jews in the late 1800s had been more considerate...
The gadlus of the rishes cold seltzer guy is that he gives us a path to a real geshmak, in both ruchniyus and gashmiyus, from some of the simplest things around: Cold seltzer, a kli from Costco, plastic cups, a perek taught in high school.
It's anti-gvir culture,
@DBashIdeas
BDE. Mrs. Fradel (Edith) Weiss has passed away at the age of 93. She is best known in my circles for being the mother of ילחט"א Rav Asher Weiss, שליט"א. I would like to share a bit about her remarkable story. 1/
BREAKING: American Jews just interrupted Biden's fundraiser, calling on him to support a
#CeasefireNOW
.
Rabbi Jessica Rosenberg from Jewish Voice for Peace Twin Cities: "Mr. President, as a Rabbi, I need you to call for a ceasefire right now."
The $1,000+ donors booed & hissed.
Some thoughts on the present situation, after a night of little sleep, interrupted by booms and sirens. A thread:
I'm not getting into the discussion of who is the bigger victim. There's no point. It's Twitter. Nobody changes their mind here.
1/n
IT FINALLY HAPPENED.
I can't believe they have finally said it out loud.
This was never about judicial reform or democracy AT ALL.
This is actually about creating a "God-fearing DAVIDIC MONARCHY".
IT FINALLY HAPPENED.
I can't believe they have finally said it out loud.
This was never about judicial reform AT ALL.
This is actually a "secular, liberal uprising".
For two months the students of the Mizpeh Ramon yeshiva haven't left their "capsules". The yeshiva dean just told them that because of the high infection rate throughout the country, they are not letting anyone in or out for another two weeks. This is the students' reaction.
@ZaidAmali
@SaeenDiddyCombs
Here. I'll try:
75 years ago, the UN concluded that one state in Palestine would be disastrous, and so proposed two states, one Jewish, one Arab. The Jews accepted. The Arabs rejected and began a violent uprising. After the Jews of Palestine declared independence 1/2
"We do not redeem captives for more than their worth for the benefit of the world at large ('tikun olam'), i.e., so that enemies will not pursue people to hold them captive." (Mishneh Torah Gifts to the Poor 8:12)
This caveat comes 2 paragraphs after the one
@TheRaDR
cites 1/
There was a time that a robust Religious Zionist party would have the Education and Religious Services ministry atop their lists of coalition demands. Now the key demand is Internal Security (i.e., police). Sad, maddening, frightening.
A thread on Rav Shmuel Brazil, for a change.
He's a talmid chacham, a rosh yeshiva, a true mentsch, and a warm, friendly human being. He is not, and never was, at the center of a cult of personality, and there were never rumors or allegations of predation 1/
I should clarify: I have no problem with theocracy. Only with representative theocracy. Let God rule directly. I don't trust any person who seeks who govern in His name.
IT FINALLY HAPPENED.
I can't believe they have finally said it out loud.
This was never about judicial reform or democracy AT ALL.
This is actually about creating a "God-fearing DAVIDIC MONARCHY".
"Semichas Chaver" of R. Asher Weiss, from the Klausenberger Rebbe, after passing an oral (closed book) examination on *over 600* pages of Gemara, with Rashi, Tosafot, and other Rishonim and Acharonim.
Oh, and this was around the time of his 17th birthday.
I read this over Shabbos. It's a book I never heard of before Shabbos. It's not even this book, but a book of responsa with the same name and by the same author. Responsa Devar Yehoshua by R. Yehoshua Menahem Mendel Ehrenberg. There's a story here, and it's worth telling. 1/
Today is the 100th yahrzeit of Jacob Israel De Haan. He was murdered by the Haganah on 29 Sivan, 5624 (June 30, 1924).
@DailyYahrzeits
@Yahrtzeits
A short🧵 on this endlessly fascinating character.
From the "can't make this up" department:
There's a doctor named Manish Tanna.
Some of his patients are in on the joke:
"has been very patient with my many questions"
"He takes ample time to fully address any questions"
"encourages questions."
Not to take anything away from
@sam_salz
, but
@DavidSamuelMay
was walk-on backup kicker for
@TerpsFootball
right after my time as OU-JLIC campus rabbi there. (We overlapped his first year on campus.) And he's shomer effing Shabbos.
When the Klausenberger Rebbe decided to build Laniado Hospital, people told him, "Rebbes don't build hospitals." He said, "I know. Here, secularists build hospitals and invite us to put up a mezuza. But I'm going to build a hospital and invite secularists to put up a mezuza."
Back in 2016, I wrote an article for
@Jewish_Action
profiling the settlement of Har Bracha, the hometown of the two brothers who were murdered yesterday and buried today.
It's important to say some things about Har Bracha today. 1/n
Briefly visited
@YeshivatOrayta
this AM. One of the Rebbeim, a good friend who lurks on
#FrumTwitter
, says to his students, "Guys, this is
@Adderabbi
from Twitter," and they stood out of respect. That was just awesome.
Multiple fetuses where the mother's life is not in danger: ALMOST ALL poskim PERMIT aborting one or more fetus to save the rest.
R. Elyashiv (see Tzitz Eliezer 20:2)
RHD HaLevi (Mayim Hayim 1:61)
RSZ Auerbach (see Nishmat Avraham 425:1:30)
R. Nahum Rabinovitch (Siah Nahum 116)
Two headlines on the passing of Rav Steinsaltz ob"m, from two leading Israeli English-language news sites.
@TimesofIsrael
nails it. R. Steinsaltz's greatest contribution was his project of elucidating and making Talmud newly accessible to millions. Our generation's Rashi.
People of Poland- please know that the current government in Israel is illegitimate and does not represent the people of israel! It is made up of petty politicians who broke all their promises to their voters, and of the party of the Muslim brotherhood.
Discussions of Nittel Nacht often begin with a dichotomy: Hasidim observe the custom of not learning, whereas Litvaks disregard this and learn. But neither of these groups was the first to observe Nittel. The custom originated in an unexpected place: 1/n
And for that very reason,
@rabbiandykahn
's misguided view that Jews are not indigenous to Eretz Yisrael, in addition to being wrong, only furthers us from the type of mutual understanding that can be a foundation for peace. /end
In the ancient Egyptian numbering system, 10,000 is represented by a finger, 100,000 by a frog, and a million by a god with outstretched arms. These elements appear in the Exodus story. That's not coincidence, right? And the weird Haggadah math?
It is important to add that saying that Jews are indigenous does not imply that Palestinians are not indigenous to the very same territories, and vice versa. If fact, I don't think there will ever be peace until each side accepts the other's indigenous status. 11/
The problem is the belief that ONLY Black people are the true Jews or Israelites or Hebrews or Semites. That non-Black/White/European/Caucasian/Ashkenazi Jews are at best medieval converts and at worst usurpers conspiring to oppress the "real" children of Israel
2/
@Adderabbi
@zpyarom
@TMan1040
@avitalrachel
@Feldheim
"My issue with Feldheim is not halakhic, but pedagogical."
Yes! The difference between knowing this halacha and deciding that it's a good idea to print it in a children's book is the difference between knowledge and wisdom.
Jonathan Pollard was the beneficiary of a widespread and sustained multi-year advocacy campaign when he was in prison for espionage but calls for jailing the families of the hostages to keep them silent
In 4 weeks, cases worldwide have fallen by 40%; this is worldwide phenomenon - with one notable exception. One nation remains with stubbornly high cases counts - in fact, the very highest cases per capital in the world....
It is wrong to equate anti-Zionism with antisemitism, just as it is wrong to deny that anti-Zionism is never antisemitic. Sometimes - but not always - anti-Zionism is motivated by antisemitism. Sometimes - but not always - it is expressed using antisemitic tropes, stereotypes and
Rav Eliezer Melamed: "Here are guidelines for making a minyan during the corona crisis, but those who are 'mehadrin' should daven alone, like I do." I love how he inverts halakhic rhetoric here. Really brilliant.
And there's also the obvious etymological fallacy concerning the term 'antisemitism.' It was never about Semites. It was never about speakers of Arabic, Aramaic, Amharic, Tigrinya, etc. It was a racial term applied by Germans to Jews in the 19th century. 3/
The notion that "ain't nobody gonna tell us how or when to plant trees in Israel, cuz this is *our* land" is *exactly* the type of attitude that Shemitah is supposed to combat. This is God's land, and we forget that at our own peril.
חברות וחברי כנסת של הליכוד נטעו היום עצים בנגב בתגובה לאיומי רע״מ, השותפה הבכירה של בנט, נגד נטיעות בארץ ישראל.
אף אחד לא יגיד לנו איפה ומתי לנטוע עצים בארץ ישראל. זו ארצנו 🇮🇱