stwill1 Profile Banner
stwill1 Profile
stwill1

@stwill1

2,916
Followers
1,461
Following
153
Media
1,003
Statuses

occasional visitor

Joined July 2012
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
Pinned Tweet
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
MULTI-MANAGER RISKS & A BUYSIDE NETWORK TOPOLOGY 1/
Tweet media one
6
28
310
@stwill1
stwill1
7 months
@ByrneHobart @turtlesnapz1 Also: could be that he drops in, fixes a bunch of stuff, things work, word spreads, marginal effect of fixing stuff elsewhere > maintenance ==> switch, w. higher comp
1
0
64
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
New post: “Addressing overseas USD funding conditions & the Fed as global collateralized LoLR”, discusses (1) optimizing CB swap line design for non-bank demands, (2) foreign CBs acting as localized primary dealers, softening international spillovers.
3
17
45
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
First step is indeed to understand that the a) initial Japanese purchase of USD bonds and b) the JPY-denom. reinvestment from swap counterparties due to a)’s FX hedges are mechanically linked.
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
2 years
The one that piqued my interest: the large foreign buying of zero yielding JGBs. It more or less matched Japanese buying of foreign bonds over the last ten years. I am talking my book, but I don't think you can really understand global finance unless you understand this trade
Tweet media one
3
11
50
1
7
33
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Enjoyed the recent BBG article on multi-manager risks, along with @FundamentEdge ’s expanded take on it . Raising these points and being responsive to their implications is good. 2/
1
3
18
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
do note that while this approach doesn't always capture every finest detail, I'm all butcertain it gets the overall picture right. And for the blue, orange and green stretches I know well, the local relations look eerily spot on. 27/27
3
0
18
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
Chapters 2 & 3 of the cooperation with @Brad_Setser . Focus is on the transition from Taiwan’s central bank to the life insurance sector recycling the country’s large trade surpluses & lifers’ management of overseas FI books.
1
0
18
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
Important move & first innovation by the Federal Reserve on the international front
@federalreserve
Federal Reserve
4 years
@federalreserve announces establishment of a temporary FIMA Repo Facility to help support the smooth functioning of financial markets:
50
130
171
1
10
18
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
franchise in half a decade? We're nearing the end of year 2 of the ‘grand multi-manager era’ and returns are clearly pointing to oversupply. Capital-weighted MM net alpha above RF through October is about 2%, which falls into negative territory when excluding the five 11/
1
2
17
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
Second post in a series on the “Effects, Balance Sheets and new Linkages” ~$3 tn of foreign private inflows into U.S. debt create.
1
2
15
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
The even more crucial next step is to realize that the mindset that led to these purchases (esp. post 2015) stemmed from an inherently flawed understanding of fixed income markets & FX hedging. From 4 yrs ago:
1
1
15
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
grasp how varying one or more variables changes risks in the system. Reasons are kinda obvious: The data situation is patchy. The desire for a fuller/higher frequency handle on most variables is perennial and always leaves uncertainty that is >> vs stress tests of single 7/
1
0
12
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
MMs equity," which Mr. KG deemed possible in Singapore. Put differently, it kind of matters to have an idea of whether the odds p.a. of a major incident are of order 1 in 5, 5^2, or 5^3, and my sense is that far too few G/LPs have given this enough thought, with a solid 6/
1
0
12
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Exposures: $1.3tn equity GMV, 2.4tn total cash GMV, 5tn total gross notional exposures (incl. linear derivatives) Volume footprint: In equities, largest firms each are party to 2-5% of ADV on most exchanges; sector as a whole is involved in around 90bn of trades globally 17/
1
1
11
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
It's something else to have modelling capabilities-- however imperfect--to play out industry-wide degrossing events from various starting points of: · industry AuM, · leverage, · interconnectedness/position overlaps, · market impact & price reversal, 4/
1
1
11
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
largest names. There is no disputing the long-term track of the handful of firms that have done it for decades, and it has taken unreasonably long for the in most respects superior platform model to gain widespread traction. 12/
@stwill1
stwill1
10 months
The other half is the depth of the alpha pool. Almost surely, E/DCM activity, retail particp., energy opps. etc. of ’20-‘22 won’t carry on at comparable levels. And the alpha trajectory from ‘15-’19 --before the capital influx-- flattened noticeably, even for Tier 1 firms.
Tweet media one
1
0
7
1
0
11
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
If anything, however, the piece also underscores the handwaving character most discussion on crowding, concentration and interconnectedness takes, a condition ill-suited to the sectors' gravity. It's one thing to qualitatively point to some fuzzy, remote crowding risk. 3/
1
0
11
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
A project quite a while in the making...
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
5 years
I am joining forces with a market friend, the blogger Concentrated Ambiguity ( @stwill1 ), for a series of posts that will do a deep dive in the balance sheet of Taiwan's life insurance sector and the balance sheet of the Central Bank of the Republic of China (Taiwan). Stay tuned
3
8
44
1
0
11
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
golden as possible, can fund-level de-risking and return of capital be expected if it leads to poaching of top PMs while undermining longer-term firm viability by failing to sift through enough new PMs of this year's vintage, in search of the 3 to 5 stars who will carry the 10/
1
0
10
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
Too many who should have known better got wrong-footed on this, and much of the hundreds of $ bn flowing from Japan into USD fixed-rate debt with short-term rolling FX hedges from ’15-’21 should probably not have happened.
0
1
10
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
If meant as trick question, then just one : the three-letter palindrome. If literal, by rough size: Cathay UB, Fubon CB, CTBC, E.Sun, Taishin on the local side. HSBC, SC, Calyon, ANZ, JPM on the global end.
@TenreiroDaniel
Daniel Tenreiro
2 years
oh, you listen to odd lots? name three counterparties to the Taiwanese life insurance industry's FX hedges
14
31
752
0
3
10
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
· risk mgmt. cultures · counterparty flexibility Reaching a close-to-reality rendering of this is non-trivial, but fiddling around with crude sketches is a worthwhile exercise on its own and the only way to get a feel for what happens next after a "10, 15 or 20% joint hit to 5/
1
0
10
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Here is some, largely gpt-donated, pseudocode doing this, resulting in the following buyside network in which nodes represent individual firms. 22/
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
2
0
10
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
This is one of those things that is either obvious, or it requires half an hour of carefully walking through each transaction and cash flow. In short: HTM investors should think in “term premia” rather than “yield curve shapes”, and a steep yield curve ≠ arbitrage always.
Tweet media one
3
1
10
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
The BBG article, PB reports and a few extra figures give a decent tear sheet of multi-strat, multi-managers: AuM: ~$350bn Employees: 16.000, with ½ in investment roles 16/
1
0
9
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
institutions, lighter on interaction effects. "Now what?", which holds on many levels and is not very appealing when the answer is often just "less of it". E.g., is a long-term LP going to trim their MLP/Citadel allocation based on such thinking & risk not getting back in? 8/
1
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Are those pouring funds into (sub-)tier 2 platforms realistically expected to be dissuaded? Are bank counterparties expected to toughen terms or retrench, sending the biggest fee-payers to laxer rivals? And from a fund's standpoint, after making sure you're as operationally 9/
1
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Multi-managers in blue are unmistakably the by far densest region, with all of the graph's top 5 ‘influential’ firms by the node size measure located in it. This is getting pretty long, so let’s save the magnified looks for another day. As preface & caveat to it, 26/
3
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
Two tweaks: Using a very sophisticated technique--so called "manual inspection"--coloured landmarks are placed at the centres of the various clusters, with Gaussian kernels dropped on each, allowing node colours to be interpolated. Further, node size is scaled by the 23/
Tweet media one
1
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
· Blue: multi-managers · Orange: quant/market-making/prop · Green: traditional HFs, mostly equity · Pink: VC · Purple: PE & private debt · Red: public market AMs · Yellow: banks · Gray: commodity traders 25/
2
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
3 years
New post: "The CBC’s onshore FX deposits, a surprising mainland China connection & flighty hedging counterparties"
3
5
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
But now, with capital mobilization for new entrants still plenty and billions in committed but so far uncalled funds at established players likely tempering the upside, greater clarity around the downside is essential. 13/
1
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
10 months
The other half is the depth of the alpha pool. Almost surely, E/DCM activity, retail particp., energy opps. etc. of ’20-‘22 won’t carry on at comparable levels. And the alpha trajectory from ‘15-’19 --before the capital influx-- flattened noticeably, even for Tier 1 firms.
Tweet media one
@bucketshopcap
Bucket Shop Capital
10 months
Btw the whole pod/SM discussion can pretty much be reduced to "Capital Returns". What do you think will happen as Tier 2/3/4 MMs keep accumulating capital & talent to scale up? From crowding alone, returns will deteriorate; it isn't rocket science. Nothing good lasts forever.
9
5
126
1
0
7
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
totality of incoming flows, thus representing a mix of firm size and interconnectedness. This produces the graph from the opening, displaying the 850 or so core firms that make markets move day by day. The colour assignment is the following: 24/
Tweet media one
2
0
7
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
A couple of words on U.S. repo markets last week and the supply response of the Fed’s foreign repo pool.
1
1
7
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
· infusing fresh information into prices and · greasing its wheels through mid-frequency inventory management, is still underappreciated today. Certainly in the broader discourse, and with a couple exceptions likely on here. 15/
1
0
7
@stwill1
stwill1
5 months
The TBAC presentation on Treasury futures has deservedly received a lot of attention and contains great background & aggregate figures on the basis issue. 1/
1
0
8
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
each day, or around 20-25% of lit ADV in mid-cap upwards. Corresponding figures for cash fixed income is around 120bn, and for notionals of linear derivatives, 700bn. 18/
1
0
7
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Dissecting the Fed's Foreign Repo Pool: Part III - The Foreign Repo Pool Rate (FRPR) 6/6
0
1
2
0
2
6
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
To simulate extra transitions, consider the following thought experiment: Let each firm (in turn) hypothetically close down and each front-office individual probabilistically jumps to other firms, proportional to the presence of the latter in the direct network of the former. 21/
1
0
6
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
A dated chart giving a sense of the numbers involved. FX hedges provided by reserve managers are labelled “FX swapped debt” and were around USD 1trn in the 2010s.
Tweet media one
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
2 years
One last thing I learned from Concentrated Ambiguity (the blog of @stwill1 ) -- a lot of the world's hedges are supplied out of the world's central bank reserves. FX hedged yen reserves, for example, generate dollar funding for Japan's institutional investors ...
4
5
24
1
1
5
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
Ahead of the concluding sixth chapter in the Taiwan project, a quick look back at the story so far, especially chapter V. ( @Brad_Setser 's summary here last week).
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
5 years
Taiwan’s central bank almost certainly has an undisclosed forward book over well over $100b – and has been intervening far more heavily after 2009 than would be inferred from its disclosed reserves. This is joint work with @stwill1
2
15
67
1
0
6
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Dissecting the Fed's Foreign Repo Pool: Part II - Funding Mechanisms
0
2
9
1
0
6
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
professionals. Core idea: firms that hire from another are similar in some respects, and this similarity has downstream effects on strategies, positions and ultimately P&L. The issue is that, even though fast paced, actual job switches are insufficient to map this. 20/
1
1
6
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
*** With the tirade out of the way, on to the more constructive, fun? part of justifying the above. Despite the buzz the last 1.5 yrs, it’s, imo, still a good bet that relative to when the history books will be written, the centrality of platforms to liquid markets due to 14/
1
0
6
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
(While the details are in the paper, @TheStalwart & @tracyalloway were kind enough to host my co-author @Brad_Setser last fall. The resulting podcast remains the perhaps gentlest intro to the overall topic.)
1
2
6
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
1)This plus 2)Extend QE to allow for direct reserve manager sales of USTs/MBS already in Fed’s custodial accounts to the Desk – no need to clog dealers even momentarily. 3)Encourage foreign CBs to intermediate global repo funding for USTs/MBS by transferring private sector..
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
4 years
My new idea is a facility that lets large countries with substantial holdings of Treasuries and Agencies repo them for cash. Would reduce demand for swap lines from countries with lots of reserves, and would reduce their need to sell Treasuries into a difficult market
1
3
20
1
2
6
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
The pivotal chapter of this project…
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
5 years
Taiwan’s central bank almost certainly has an undisclosed forward book over well over $100b – and has been intervening far more heavily after 2009 than would be inferred from its disclosed reserves. This is joint work with @stwill1
2
15
67
0
0
5
@stwill1
stwill1
11 years
1992 "NY Magazine" article with notes from Ray Dalio. Pretty bleak mood they all had with FI better than equities. http://t.co/s3yjrO3a37
0
1
5
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Ahh, that's interesting. This would mean outflows are due to corporate invoicing behavior and not CapFlight?
Tweet media one
2
2
5
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
@quantian1 @groditi Try this: 'Synthetic repurchase programs through put derivatives: theory and evidence '
0
1
4
@stwill1
stwill1
5 years
@nosunkcosts @Brad_Setser Difficulty with JPB is assessing their hedge ratio for foreign bonds held indirectly via trusts. On balance sheet foreign currency bonds are hedged ~50%, while trusts likely fully hedged.
Tweet media one
2
0
5
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
4. All combined, the following picture emerges. It will provide the basis to slice the nationality based numbers into more functional categories in the next post.
Tweet media one
1
2
5
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
core claim: the existence of its >$100bn FX swap book, reflecting FX intervention far beyond the known headline FX reserve number.
1
0
5
@stwill1
stwill1
10 months
@Value_Ideas @YellowLabLife @FundamentEdge Smoothed over a cycle, and assuming that most hires are first-time pod PMs and not laterals, this is a reasonable approximation historically.
Tweet media one
Tweet media two
1
1
5
@stwill1
stwill1
8 months
While all true, actually *seeing* where they fit into the bigger picture, recognizing connections and relative proportions, is oftentimes superior to isolated facts. The most macroscopic means I'm aware of looking at this is through the flow of front office buyside 19/
1
0
5
@stwill1
stwill1
5 months
Interesting survey & results. Putting aside all contractual minutiae, it indirectly asks for takes on 1. the street’s/MMs’ risk aversion/utility and its 2. short-term risk-bearing capacity in relation to the trade’s size, i.e. the extent of capital constraints.
@KrisAbdelmessih
Kris
5 months
Totally fair coin. Heads you win $50mm, tails nothing happens. Coin gets flipped in an hour. No credit risk. You can shop the proposition to Jane, SIG, Citadel or anyone else for that matter. What price does it trade for?
75
12
237
2
0
5
@stwill1
stwill1
7 months
@jeuasommenulle @MarcRuby @vitoshet1 @Brad_Setser It's been a while, yeah. And it's kind of incredible how obvious it was that this wouldn't work out long-term.
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
but are (on the bond side) ultimately far eclipsed by two depository institutions: Norinchukin and Japan Post Bank, which together hold foreign bonds of close to $1 tn. As the single biggest buyers, the effect of their purchases (and FX hedges!) on markets is hard to overstate.
1
1
2
0
0
4
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
freeing banks to focus on domestic issues while limiting spillovers foreign liquidations would cause. From the Fed’s perspective, the transaction is just another repo, this time not with a domestic bank but a foreign CB, equally collateralized (& margined) by Treasuries.
1
0
4
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
This is a follow up to what began as joint project with @Brad_Setser last October. Some housekeeping and looking back is in order. This includes publication of the project as a proper paper and how the central bank of Taiwan, after initial deflections, eventually did confirm our
1
0
4
@stwill1
stwill1
9 years
@modestproposal1 @M_C_Klein @RajaKorman Also interesting: CROCI by geog.§or
Tweet media one
1
1
4
@stwill1
stwill1
2 years
Characteristically good China post by @Brad_Setser . If you have answers to issues raised, can only recommend getting in touch with Brad directly.
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
2 years
I have spent almost twenty years of my life looking at China's balance of payments data in one way or another. Right now neither the current account numbers nor the financial account numbers quite fit together. 1/x
13
142
527
1
0
4
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
In light of China’s continuing reserve decline, some thoughts on management of reserve drawdowns & possibly changing effects on mkts. 1/
1
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
Since there are many moving parts in setting up such a term premia framework, an extra post is published alongside, to slowly walk through the (not always intuitive) overlap of FX and FI markets.
1
4
18
1
0
4
@stwill1
stwill1
9 years
@quantian1 Simplest solution imo: Use subsector OAS from here and apply SP500 weightings.
1
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
@ericbeebo @tomashirstecon @KenVeksler Thanks guys, much appreciated
0
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
9 years
Some thoughts on Chinese outflows: consensus seems outfl. due to Cap. Account reversal ($ deleveraging…). PBOC, SAFE, BIS all confirm 1/n
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
@ericbeebo Yes. Forgot to use sarcasm font. Some resemblance here...
Tweet media one
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
7 months
@KrisAbdelmessih @W98AB Quoting a fmr. colleague: “What Blackrock does [in equities] in a quarter, the larger platforms do individually in a busy two weeks.”
0
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
9 years
Peak Profitability is behind us. US ROE just slightly above LT average. (ht @Jesse_Livermore )
Tweet media one
0
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
9 years
FC credit in China, Pure offshore transactions and attempts to reconcile BIS and PBOC data [new post]; fdbk welcome
0
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
Re CB currency swap lines, it’s broadly agreed that transmission is much tougher today, as large shares of the ultimate demand is from the buyside and not banks themselves. See for instance here
@HyunSongShin
Hyun Song Shin
4 years
Good piece by Wenxin Du on the determinants of the deviation from covered interest parity
1
11
33
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
11 years
@Jesse_Livermore for dependency ratios use this http://t.co/Z7IwgeFAmK
0
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Peak Probit & Logit recession models? Extra points for those not capping the scale at 100%.
0
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
How will it be used, what will its effects be? Fed’s statement contains little color on *how* it would like overseas CBs to utilize the facility + the current design misses some features I’d thought would be included – so tough to make precise predictions. Statement
2
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
Fed’s Desk and not rely on bank intermediation, even at a later time. This would further reduce pressure on dealers in that knowing that FX managers will (for some time) sell directly to Fed would allow focus to be placed elsewhere. Pricing of direct sales could be somewhat of an
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
@GMarchbanks @Brad_Setser Thx, missed that one. FTAV one of few appreciating importance of Eurodollar market @izakaminska
0
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Pettis 2003: “Reengineering the Volatility Machine”. Core concepts from the book in 7 pages.
0
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
6 years
(2) FX-unhedged foreign demand. This is largely a story about foreign fixed income investors taking on a rather uncharacteristic risk: FX exposure. USD appreciation has helped these institutions immensely and invited further inflows. Closing of such positions (or hedging
1
1
3
@stwill1
stwill1
5 months
One interesting follow-up, probing those two factors more directly, would be to swap variables: How large would $ X mm have to be for it to trade at a discount of, say, 10% compared to 0.5X?
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
4 years
A second puzzle is the reappearance of regular late-day depreciations of the TWD. It has long been clear (see prior reporting by @hwang61 , @ariespoon , @samsonellis & Argin Chang) that market forces alone would not give rise to such a pattern, hinting at active CBC involvement
2
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
8 years
Agree, CNY very path dependent as Vol of KA > CA. CA not always buffer against outflow though - amplifies sometimes. If expectation for
@Brad_Setser
Brad Setser
8 years
Does China's current macroeconomic situation (and exchange rate) lend itself to multiple equilibria? I fear so
1
6
10
1
0
3
@stwill1
stwill1
11 years
Some more years... http://t.co/6nfVeb5Wl8
Tweet media one
1
2
3