99.9% of my tweets are about the Cincinnati Reds and baseball. Rest are about University of Michigan sports or people trying to take away my health insurance.
Nick Castellanos was told by MLB his suspension was because he incited a 2-minute shoving match that posed the risk of a "super spreader" COVID event. Health and safety. Yet MLB allowed the Texas Rangers to fill its Opening Day stadium with 38000+ people.
MLB is an utter mess.
Hey
@Reds
, how's the "please do something, anything" list going?
□ Winker extension
□ Mahle extension
□ Castillo extension
□ Bell/Johnson/Boddy extensions
□ Buy Castellanos opt-out
□ Hire external President of Baseball Ops
□ Fix the bullpen
□ Fix the bullpen more
The Winker-Suarez trade was a rash, colossal and unforgivable mistake by the Reds front office and owners. It devastated the 2022 roster and doomed the season.
Thinking of all the crap Joey Votto took from the Brennaman family over many years and how they poisoned many Reds fans against one of the greatest players in the team's history because they couldn't stand any change in thinking in baseball.
Nick Castellanos: "The history of baseball in Cincinnati is second to none. The fans there are dying for something to really believe in again, to get behind, to feel proud of, to call their own. Right now, it’s not happening. And that’s sad."
The Reds didn't even call him.
Eugenio Suarez is 0-4 with six runners left on base tonight. How much longer are the Reds gonna run a guy out there every night who offers negative value?
Nick Castellanos got suspended because of "health and safety" protocols.The umps tonight showed no regard for the health and safety of the players. None.
Reds ownership and front office need to wake up and get contract extensions from Tyler Mahle and Jesse Winker and sweeten Nick Castellanos's contract so he'll stay with the club.
What's a baseball stat that sounds impossible at first but actually happened? Please contribute. I'll start.
Barry Bonds during the 2004 regular season reached base 376 times and had 373 official at-bats. 🤯
The Reds had a winning record last year and were close to contending with the team they had returning. Then the Castellini family pulled the plug because they might only have $950 million in wealth instead of $980 million. I wish we could (metaphorically) fire them into the sun.
The Reds aren’t tanking for a draft pick. They’re lowering payroll just for the sake of making more money. There’s no baseball plan. They don’t care about fans or putting the best team on the field.
And to add insult to insult, the Reds have only a 16.5% chance at the No. 1 overall pick in 2023 because of the new draft lottery.
Even worse: Teams cannot receive lottery picks in three straight seasons, so if Cincinnati doesn't try to win by 2025, the earliest it picks is 7th.
My 93-yo mom, who never misses a Reds game: Why did they trade Sonny Gray?
Me: I don’t know. I guess to save money.
Mom: What good does it do to save money if they don’t win and nobody watches?
Raisel Iglesias has the lowest xFIP (2.13) among all major league relievers. The Reds letting him go to save $8 million AND get nothing back for him might be the biggest ownership and front office blunder of the season for all MLB. Ranks with blowing the Chapman trade.
Chris Welsh is at the top of his game and profession. Super-prepared. Insightful. Most former players are cliche-ridden as broadcasters and fall back on their knowledge of the game when they played. Chris works hard to stay up to date and works new thinking into his analysis.
Today would be a good day for Reds fans to take a moment to thank several iterations of Miami Marlins management. The Marlins traded Anthony DeSclafani to the Reds for crumbling Matt Latos. Traded Luis Castillo to the Reds for meh Dan Straily. And DFA'd Derek Dietrich.
Instead of shopping Nick Castellenos at the deadline because of his opt-out, why don't the Reds buy it out so he'll be with the team two more seasons.
I know, it would require them to wake up and do something but dare to dream.
Ex. of Thom misinforming audience b/c of agenda. Notes Votto and Perez tied for HR w/ Reds. Thom's agenda is to belittle Votto, says: "Perez didn't play entire career with Reds and Votto will" implying Votto has more at bats. Truth: Votto 7404 PA, Perez 7630 with Reds. Terrible.
Sonny Gray was worth a lot more than a flier on an 18-year-old pitcher that most services project as a reliever.
This is why I don't trust the front office or ownership. This was a salary dump. Not part of some new, smart plan.
Hey Reds, look at what Jesse Winker said: "I’ve always wanted to be part of an organization that is really going after winning, is really going after chasing a division titles and making a run for a ring."
Amir Garrett, Sean Doolittle, Kyle Hendrix and Josh Osich combined for 47 pitches without even one swing-and-miss. Doolittle had 11 pitches with no called strikes or whiffs.
As Reds pitching coach Derek Johnson said, swing-and-miss don't lie.
If the Reds win today, they will finish with 75 wins in 2019. The last time the Reds were 75-87was 1989. That was the year before they won the World Series.
Why is no one talking about this?
The story here isn't the billboard. It's that a bunch of average Reds fans felt strongly enough about this to pool together thousands of dollars that *otherwise could have been spent on Reds tickets or gear* to express their opinion. Hope local media sees that as fit to cover.
Since 2008, Rays have spent $307 million less on payroll than the Reds. Rays have won 74 more games over that period.
Thom Brennaman said today Rays are an "awful organization."
He's going to be *really* upset when he learns about the Cincinnati Reds.
The Reds could pay Aaron Judge $35 million, sign Trea Turner to the contract he signed today with the Phillies and Nick Krall would still have $10 million to sign Mike Minor and stay below the Reds’ 2020 payroll.
At some point we need to acknowledge that David Bell knows what he's doing. He kept Barnhart and Miley together tonight and it seemed to be important and paid off. Bell knows Stephenson can hit. Had him
#2
and
#3
in lineup recently.
If Reds kept Winker, Suarez, Gray & Garrett and not acquired Minor, Strickland & Moran. It would add $19m to payroll for $130m total. $130m is what they spent last year. If Reds signed Nick Castellanos to add another $20 million, they hit $150 million, their 2020 payroll.
The national baseball press is all over Phil Castellini’s obnoxious and revealing comments today. Gonna be a long night for the opinion writers at the local paper.
Luis Castillo extension covers his age 31-34 seasons. 4 years of free agency plus the arbitration year of 2023. It’s a disgrace the Reds wouldn’t make an offer like this. Especially when they have Greene, Lodolo and Ashcraft for league minimum for years. A damn disgrace.
Reds 9 worst win% since WWII:
.377 (1982)
.394 (2022) **
.395 (2015)
.403 (1949)
.407 (.2001)
.414 (2018)
.418 (1948)
.420 (2016)
.420 (2017)
Five worst in last 8 seasons, so yeah, the Castellini family is doing a great job. Driving the franchise into the ground.
For the first half of the 2010s, the Reds had better than or similar attendance to the San Diego Padres. One team slashed payroll (several times) the other invested in player contracts. Now:
CIN: 18K/game
SDP: 37K/game
Small vision, not small market.
If today feels a little brighter, if you have extra giddy in your giddy-up, it’s because the Cincinnati Reds are 7 games over .500 for the first time in 2585 days (July 9, 2014).
Hey, Phil Castellini. Can't you admit what's been obvious to others for years, that your family doesn't know how to run a baseball team? Please, if you won't sell the team, hire a smart, aggressive outsider, put that person in charge, and stay out of baseball decisions.
Jeff Brantley blasted -- and I mean blasted -- the Reds organization last night for its failure to develop pitchers.
"Can you name one pitcher who has improved from last year to this year?"
He pointed a finger at both minor league and major league instruction.
The Reds play hard and never give up. It’s a tribute to the players and the manager and coaches. It’s a shame the team’s bosses don’t have the same dedication.
Phillies 87 wins. Padres won 89.
The 2021 Reds won 83.
Instead of doing the work and finding the money last offseason, they folded. Broke faith with fans, now doomed to suffer 100-loss seasons.
Hope now rides on the judgment of Phil and Nick and long odds on prospects.
The sad thing is, the Reds have the pieces to be an excellent team if ownership didn't starve it for resources. Another $20-25 million would make them a sure-fire contender. But more focus on the bottom line for billionaires.
The Reds drafted Nick Senzel
#2
overall and didn't make a place for him to play in either of his positions. The Reds drafted Jonathan India
#5
and didn't make a place for him to play either of his positions. Senzel was forced to move to CF. What will they do with India?
Sigh.
The Reds could be putting this exact team on the field, plus Sonny Gray and Luis Castillo, with Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Cam Collier and Connor Phillips still coming. The total wipeout wasn't necessary, just cheap.
Again, the main issue with the Castellini ownership isn't that they're cheap. It's not easy, but you can build a winning team with $110 mil. The problem: they don't know what they're doing, they are impatient and they insist on meddling in the decisions of the baseball experts.
Someone should wake up Nick Krall and let him know the Reds are starting the worst SS in baseball tonight (also one of the worst hitters in MLB) against a 1st place team in the middle of a division race. And that he has Jose Barrero in AAA. But, you know, NINE relievers.
The Reds will never trade fan favorite Eugenio Suarez … er, fan favorite Jesse Winker … er, fan favorite Luis Castillo … um, fan favorite Jay Bruce … eh, fan favorite Todd Frazier … I mean fan favorite Jonathan India. Never.
The people complaining about Votto in the 9th (including Thom) must not be old enough to remember the time he drove in two runs with a two-run single, oh, ONE inning before.
Cincinnati Enquirer Reds beat writer
@johnfayman
says “social media” drove Dick Williams out. The one example Williams mentioned was a reference to the Reds being an “embarrassment” which came from a column by ... checks notes ... a Cincinnati Enquirer columnist.
Joey Votto has never had a 5-hit game. He was 4-for-4 last night. In his 5th PA, he took a walk instead of swinging for a career game best. Because he's Joey Votto, that's why.
I hope reports are right that a bunch of tickets have been sold for GABP this weekend. Need a huge, loud crowd for the Brewers series. If you're undecided, go and yell your brains out. This Reds team is crazy deserving of the support.
Phil Castellini just said there are still tickets left for Opening Day in Cincinnati. Amazing. Are fans voting with their feet and wallets about the direction ownership has taken the team?
I'm not categorically opposed to the Reds trading Mahle (although I love his trajectory) or Sonny Gray or Luis Castillo.
Problem is ZERO confidence in the dysfunctional front office in getting a smart return. Less than zero, really.
The Reds GM actually said this yesterday:
"Over the next couple weeks we have a tough schedule. We've got teams we have to go out against especially in our division. Those games will tell us a lot. We'll make decisions after that."
Do you see how incredibly dumb that is?
Reds down to two position players on the bench. Stephenson and Suarez in the third inning. Can't imagine how Nick Senzel could help the team, though. Not as much as the 9th reliever.
The team put together by Nick Krall and the Castellini family has now lost nine games in a row and sports an MLB-worst record of 2-11. They were outscored 42-10 on the seven-game road trip. The abject failure leads to the question ...
Where are you gonna go?
Reds fans are gonna have to get used to other teams making moves to compete while the Reds sit around and do nothing except figuring out how to save money for their billionaire owners.
Off-day Reds “to-do” list:
✔️ Winker extension
✔️ Mahle extension
✔️ Castillo extension
✔️ Bell/Johnson/Boddy extensions
✔️ Buy out Castellanos opt-out
✔️ Hire external President of Baseball Operations
✔️ Fix the damned bullpen
✔️ Do that last one even more
Everyone (rightly) is talking about Luis Castillo's 13 K's. But he also walked just 1 batter - Mike Trout on a full count in 1st.
In his last 7 starts, Castillo has 55 Ks and 11 BB, for a 6.1 BB%. League average is (8.5%). His K/BB of 5 is 11th best in MLB.
Huge development.
Reds payroll spending:
2019 $132 million
2020 $149 million
2021 $131 million
2022 $107 million
2023 $73 million (est.)
Keep these numbers in mind when Reds say they only have a "little" payroll room. They're rebuilding now because that's all they're willing to pay for.
Nick Krall chose Minor to be the third highest paid player on the roster. Turns out the Reds would have been better off setting the $10 million on fire at home plate. Galaxy brain stuff.
Reminder: The Reds biggest need is replacing Nick Castellanos bat vs LHP. They need a right-handed OF who can also play a passable CF. Needs to be a legit guy. Note: Aristides Aquino not the guy.
There’s a reason pitchers like Brad Brach have been cut by five teams. It’s great if he can put together a few good appearances. But it doesn’t change who he is or that the Reds have to use waiver cut guys in big innings like this. Quit applauding the front office for those blips
The Castellini family plan of installing Barry Larkin as Reds manager when the team is ready to break through from its rebuild is gonna look strange when David Bell wins manager of the year.
Hope this isn't Sonny Gray's last game in a Reds uniform. Have enjoyed watching him pitch. The trade for him and immediate extension was an A+ move by the Reds front office.
The Reds ability to convince pitching and hitting coaches to leave teams that were just deep in the postseason and to make a parallel move to a last place team is both surprising and impressive.