Reporter | Author 'The New India'
@littlebrownuk
(UK),
@public_affairs
(US) - Aug 2024 | True Story Award winner 2024 | Harvard Radcliffe Institute fellow 22-23
In 1946, the RSS went door to door with a picture of Nehru smoking as evidence of his immorality. (From D.R. Goyal's 'Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh'.)
Nehru really felt it when he said about them, "If these people had their way, neither you nor I would have a tolerable existence."
In recent times, Congress leader Sonia Gandhi has been targeted several times with manipulated images. The latest in that series is a morphed photo of a woman holding a cigarette, which was edited with Sonia's face.
#AltNewsFactCheck
The Guardian asked me to recommend five of the best books on Indian politics. I stretched it and recommended five political books I admire and/or absolutely love*:
A Free Man, Curfewed Night, Malevolent Republic, The Incarcerations, Gujarat Under Modi
A country surprised that the State wants to register relationships—after allowing itself to be coerced into getting ID cards, having its citizens’ face scanned, and normalising truck checks by cow vigilantes—is a country that’s really not thinking ahead.
Wake up India, an intrusive state is your future.
Uttarakhand UCC makes registration of live-in relationships compulsory. Couples must submit statement to registrar who will carry out inquiry which might include couple providing additional info.
Sickos.
Doing everything I possibly can to not finish this extraordinary book. I’ve read This House of Grief over four months, and with only a dozen pages to go, I find myself retracing each sentence slowly, as if it’ll show me how Helen Garner shifts the mood so subtly; foolishness.
Just back from 🇨🇳 to discover waiting for me a preview copy of what I'm convinced will the most important book on 🇮🇳 for many years: "The New India", by the formidably talented
@rahulabhatia
.
Everything Rahul does is top class. Looking forward to reading very much 📚👊
Removing tiles to fill them with grout. Turn around one minute to write about Hindu nationalism, and next thing you know they’re wrecking the one good thing Bandra had.
In The New India, I go deep into the use of “Bangladeshi” as a slur, and show how profoundly it would change the relationship between the state and all citizens.
The slur, it turned out, led to the creation of Aadhaar, the ultimate tool of exclusion.
Book out on Aug 8.
We all know who are Bangladeshis for them.
No one is listening to this hate-monger in Bangladesh, he is just seeking legitimacy to orchestrate violence on Indian citizens.
Why is this man not arrested yet ?
A total of 36 feature reports are nominated for the True Story Award 2024. The nominees were chosen from 974 submissions from 101 countries:
#tsa2024
#truestoryaward
Still grinning at how cool yesterday’s audience in Bangalore was. (That’s me on the left at the back, doing book signings – a thing I’m never getting used to. In the foreground, in blue,
@prempanicker
, who was a superb moderator.)
They’ve modernised it. Replaced rocks with a staircase. The amphitheatre I’m conflicted about because it needed restoration. It’s certainly a more public space now, but it isn’t the fort.
I don’t know, man. I don’t know.
See it for yourself while the park is closed because they've got three exhausted men dismantling it tile by tile. This is the alternate route: head to Land's End, go up the side to the top, turn right, and head down to the temple by the water. The path to the park is there.
So while the government can now delete its own data interception records within six months, telecom companies are required to keep all user data for at least two years.
Information flows only one way in this country.
Every tech reporter out there should be looking at Digital Public Infrastructure and its effects on civil rights across the global South. This tech is justified as a public good, takes root in places where rights are fragile, and ends up being about surveillance.
No one. It's a private company not accountable to government or citizens. Yet it's being forced upon us.
Digital public infrastructure = Digital Surveillance Infrastructure
This is quite a claim: “Following our report, we were told that SEBI pressured brokers … to close short positions in Adani under the threat of expensive, perpetual investigations, effectively creating buying pressure and setting a ‘floor’ for Adani’s stocks at a critical time.”
“The intensity of intellectual labour that has made a work of this kind possible is simply amazing.”
Avijit Pathak reviews The Identity Project/The New India.
There’s a great burn-all-bridges story to be done about the ethics of a famously credit-hungry Mumbai auteur whose lavish production budgets run dry when it’s time to pay his writers.
A thrill to see
@nilanjanaroy
’s Black River on its list of 20 indie books for the fall. Such a brilliant exploration of power and its absence through the prism of a crime. You know when you want everybody to read a book you just read? This is that.
This
@andreasbabst
profile of Arnab Goswami is so revealing – "We want to bring the power of nationalism to every home in this country" – and so bonkers: "Subtlety is just a lack of confidence in taking a stand."
I’ve been thinking a lot about the techniques used to force tech adoption in India. Hurdles are placed in everyday activities to force a change. A simple thing is made more complicated in order to make the invasive thing look easier.
Few people know the RSS (including many sympathetic to it) as well as Dhirendra Jha. His book on Golwalkar promises to be revelatory, and from everything I’ve heard, people will be studying it to learn how extreme organisations take root.
It should find publishers abroad.
do attend, after the lok sabha results & now haryana the rss has more control. in haryana, modi was non-playing captain, his vote-gettng ability & aura in decline. This alters the equation with the rss, which remains undiminshed, its ugly history manifested in our bigoted present
People, come on over to Alliance Francaise in Delhi on the 17th evening! I’ll be chatting with the astounding legal scholar Usha Ramanathan and the incredible Nisar Ahmad over at the launch event for The Identity Project!
We’ll talk about identity, riots, and much else.
Come!
Mark your calendars
#Delhi
!
Join us for the first event of the
#IdentityProject
Tour on 17 Sept at M.L. Bhartia Auditorium.
@rahulabhatia
in conversation with Usha Ramanathan and Nisar Ahmad.
Aadhaar, FastTag, and now Digiyatra. When these dudes go on global roadshows talking about the exponential growth of digital public infrastructure, you don't hear them talk about the strategic coercion employed with the help of the State.
Delighted that
@prempanicker
will be chatting with me about The Identity Project at BIC in Bangalore on Sunday! Bring your friends along. Tell them attendance is voluntary mandatory.
An extract from The New India / The Identity Project. In the book, the passage the Guardian published is twice as long, and intertwined with a parallel story: of Nehru grappling with rumors and violence as refugees crossed the border between W Bengal and East Pakistan in 1950.
“Their entire functioning has been so boring and dull and drab that it has helped them to build a very powerful national network of people who cannot think"
1/3 Take it from India. When rumour networks and alternative histories become entrenched, it limits the effectiveness of legitimate news sources, weakens public resolve to find out what's real, and allows entire worlds to be constructed in the knowledge gap that opens up.
Happy US publication day to
@nilanjanaroy
, whose fantastic Black River has already received rave reviews in the UK and India!
America, you’re going to love this one.
About a decade ago, while I was researching the nature and causes of stampedes in India, someone shared an unreleased official report on the Wai stampede, which killed about three hundred people in 2005. It was caused by a single misaligned step, if I remember correctly.
This is really at the heart of many institutional failings. The RSS, which cannot abide by questions and criticism, is a conveyer belt of mediocrity, and it fills open positions with its members. Even Nehru was hobbled by inert rss-Mahasabha faithful during 1947 Delhi riots.
To what extent is the mess a result of the systematic attempt to create back-door entry for preferred candidates into premier institutions and government jobs - both at the top, at the recruitment level and at the bottom, at the admissions level?
"Many years later, as I faced the deadline for writing this review, I was to remember that distant afternoon when Márquez showed me the Spanish manuscript of Chronicle of a Death Foretold and then refused to let me read the novel until its publication."
"...part of what makes billionaire philanthropy so dangerous is that it is difficult to recognise it for what it really is: political power."
A fine interview about Bill Gates and his philanthro-lobbying.
Love this headline from
@the_hindu
:
"The art of Gatescrashing democracy"
Around the world, a major reappraisal of the Gates Foundation is underway-----amazing to see the news media opening up a public debate about this undemocratic institution
This
@andreasbabst
profile of Arnab Goswami is so revealing – "We want to bring the power of nationalism to every home in this country" – and so bonkers: "Subtlety is just a lack of confidence in taking a stand."
“What’s messed up is that most of the claims about human cognition, the psychology of Homo sapiens, are based on a very homogenous sample of human beings.” A fine piece on the work of the marvellous Roberto Zariquiey.
@RadInstitute
.
The first review is here.
The Guardian reviews The New India, calling it “a vivid portrait of how a nation turns callous and changes into something unrecognisable.”
Mark your calendars
#Delhi
!
Join us for the first event of the
#IdentityProject
Tour on 17 Sept at M.L. Bhartia Auditorium.
@rahulabhatia
in conversation with Usha Ramanathan and Nisar Ahmad.
“The cycling track is hardly being used by cyclists.”
Yeah. That’s because cyclists (me among them) figured out an absolute sadist designed that cycling track. Make it better, don’t do away with it.
#Mumbai
guardian minister
@MPLodha
has asked MMRDA to remove the existing cycle track lane in Bandra Kurla Complex (BKC) & merge it into the road. He told TOI that congestion BKC was witnessing needed to be eased on priority.
“If the far right ever loses its grip on India, The New India will be remembered as a truthful account of all the people who preyed on a nation’s collective fear.”
@JohnReedwrites
recommends four books to understand India. *ing:
-
@alpashah001
, who "has a gift for nonfiction narrative";
- S Jaishankar;
-
@kunalpurohit
's "vivid and richly reported" H-Pop;
-
@jaffrelotc
's Gujarat Under Modi, a "rewarding read".
2/3 Organisations that produce storytelling ecosystems at scale, with legends and rationales for every conceivable situation, which can position themselves as 'grievance aggregators', will end up thriving – and will operate like a parallel government.
It's hard not to see the current political aesthetic in the devastation of this Portuguese fort. It has been 'beautified' and ordered, and locals have had little say in its appearance. In one way, the new aesthetic is a fitting record of our times.
The promenade and the sea were this city's greatest asset. That's where they gathered and celebrated and got respite.
Because it was an asset of intangible value, access to it was restricted, it was made smaller, its views broken, and new parking charges imposed a needless cost.
Last week,
@DigiYatraOffice
reached out to IFF to offer information and clarifications on the DigiYatra data ecosystem, and invite us to a private closed-door meeting with the CEO & team.
This is what we had to say in response. ⬇️ 1/2
OMG.
“
@nilanjanaroy
has spent her entire life and career preparing to write “Black River,” and it shows. With its depth of feeling, narrative sweep and deceptively plain writing style, this is a crime novel I’ll be thinking about for a long, long time.”
“[One Nation, One Election] would release the government from constraints of democratic accountability. With a rapid decline in all autonomous institutions, elections are now the only effective mechanism of holding the government accountable.”
Let us call the govt’s proposal for simultaneous elections by its real name: One nation, one election, one party, one leader.
I wrote this in 2019 when this baloon was floated. The argument still holds. What do you think?
(Pl read before answering)
3/3 The book, Unequal, is up for pre-order. It's right up there with
@mrajshekhar
's Despite the State, and
@Rukmini
's Whole Numbers and Half Truths—two of the very best books on Modern India.
1/3 Massive day for
@SNavatar
, who decided to travel along the border between Bangladesh and India to study economic and social differences between India and its neighbors.
Delighted to be back here to announce the publication of the first volume of my debut. Available at bookstores 10th May onwards. Please consider pre-ordering VAJPAYEE: THE ASCENT OF THE HINDU RIGHT, 1924-77 on the link below:
You can see this in aviation regulation, food safety, and air and water management, this callousness about safety. Whatever they're thinking about, it's not safety.
This is all to say that India's mass tragedies are not unconnected events. They are failures waiting to happen. From the contractor laying steps to the signals guy at the train station to the cops overseeing crowds, to the falling bridges - there's a failure to meet standards.
Just beautiful on Radio 104.8 in mumbai. “The city’s air quality has deteriorated significantly, and there’s nothing that can be done about it. The pollution control board has an app you can check, and we can help by not burning candles indoors.”
Today, we announce our 2023–2024 fellows, a cohort whose projects contend with the urgent, the beautiful, and the vast: from reckoning with the challenges of climate change to creating digital models of iconic Italian violins to detecting distant galaxies.
What is the impact of Aadhaar, India's biometric identification system, on its democracy?
#GrandTamasha
's 🆕 episode features
@rahulabhatia
, whose new book, "The Identity Project: The Unmaking of a Democracy, provides an in-depth look at the state of India's democracy.
Listen
This is quite something. Protesting farmers who were barred from entering Delhi are now stopping BJP leaders from campaigning in their villages.
Via
@ramanmann1974
Other reasons for stampedes: poor crowd management, bad communication, not enough room to ease the squeeze. The reports put out in the aftermath of stampedes tend to share similar findings. But what happens after all this depends on where you live.
This is such a great point,
@andymukherjee70
: “[Corruption did not] go away under the strongman’s rule. Only the threat of discovery disappeared, as independent institutions were emasculated.”
My latest
@opinion
column on why markets mustn’t worry too much about the return of coalition politics to India. ‘Reforms will slow’ is such a trope: What land or labor reforms happened under Modi? Free to read link: