I've been signing more clients for !
It's been fun to help people improve their manuscripts, feel more confident in their writing routines, and get close to the finish line.
If you want help getting your book into the world, let me know!
If we're playing Magic at a kitchen table or at a sanctioned tournament of any scale and you play a proxy of any quality or condition, I will simply accept that it's the card you say it is and continue to play the game.
Because—and this is very simple: I am not a cop.
I dream of a world in which you can buy a simple, mechanically-identical version of every Magic card for $5 or less.
This would mean the maximum price to own any Commander deck conceivable would be $500. Reserved List? Nah.
Please tank my collection's value! I'm asking nicely!
And yes, I'm aware that by not reporting another player using a proxy in a sanctioned tournament I might risk getting disqualified for Unsporting Conduct — Cheating.
I'll say it again.
I'm not afraid of this because—and this is very simple: I am not a cop.
🧵
Over 23,000 cards are legal in Commander.
About 2000 of them are played in cEDH.
And cEDH games end in just 4 ways.
Here are cEDH's essential patterns.
Sam's new video thoroughly details the history of foil Magic cards.
Near the end, he dispassionately lists all the "special" treatments in the Lord of the Rings set. It's brutal. A sad litany of capital hedging its bets.
That moment crystallized some thoughts on the game…
A rarely-spoken truth about Commander is how often players check out when it isn't their turn.
This is caused in part by neurodevelopmental disorders like ADHD, phone addiction, the beer & pretzel nature of the format, and low tolerances for boredom.
That invites a question…
Having looked a bit into the economics of Magic: The Gathering and those who benefit most from its profitability, my official stance on reprints is:
YES PLZ PRINT IT INTO THE FUCKING GROUND BUT ALSO YOU YES YOU RIGHT THERE PROXY WHATEVER YOU WANT
A cEDH player resolved Chromatic Orrery and Expropriate in a non-Narset deck and those plays won him a Black Lotus.
Time is a flat circle.
I love cEDH so much.
Magic nerds:
You time travel back to 1994 to compete in the first big Magic tournament.
You've got your 2023 knowledge of the game, but can only use the 1994 card pool. You want to win.
What deck do you build?
I played against a staxy cEDH version of this deck at
#Magic30
, and good LORD does that deck have legs.
Legs with which it kicks you. Hard. Over and over again.
An exhaustive list of Magic cards I name with Demonic Consultation in order to exile my whole library:
• Sloppity Bilepiper
• Go Hog Wild
• Steamflogger of the Month
• Hot Soup
• Flumph
• Rocket-Powered Turbo Slug
• Goblin Bookie
• Walking Sponge
I'm slowly converging to the opinion that Commander games are best for me when they're either out-of-the-box precon level or cEDH.
Getting four players to find balanced games in between is tough—even in known playgroups with good pregame conversations.
"What is the most ANNOYING Commander deck you HATE to play against?"
I'm so tired of these questions.
My brother in Christ: if I was consistently annoyed by any aspect of this card game, I'd stop playing it.
It's painful to hear a word used strategically by contemporary fascists (those who violently maintain beliefs in hierarchy) in the LGS to describe fantasy card game pieces.
Folks: please reconsider using "degenerate" as Magic lingo.
Look at this. The gold makes so much sense!
Excited to play this stylish, WotC-produced, and perfectly-legible Magic card in my Commander deck tonight. 😘
Today I'm wondering about selling all the Magic cards I'm not playing in decks, then replacing all my super fancy cards with their simplest, most accessible equivalents.
I love the game very much.
But I'd also love to not feel FOMO re: ≥20 expensive cards every month.
Collectively the Bullies did not do well today!
1-13-2 with Dio having the only win! And still didn't top 16. We had a BLAST!
36 total people and KOLL WAS the ONLY UNDEFEATED going into top 16.
Top 16 is a GO.
Your friendly reminder:
Foil Secret Lair cards will likely be VERY curled.
Might be best to buy the non-foils, which are both cheaper and better quality!
Just found a new beautiful piece of Magic art.
So I search the artist's name, find his Twitter—and am quickly met with COVID, climate change, and antisemitic conspiracy theories.
I'm so tired…
me: "I'm not the biggest fan of Magic lore, to be honest…"
them: "So this little guy Skrelv is a bug deemed defective and worthless by his huge pitiless empire, but he's also really clever and lucky and has outwitted them to live a good tiny bug's life."
me:
The year is 2025.
cEDH players worldwide beg the Rules Committee to "BAN THE CAT." The Displacer Kitten Meta has broken hundreds of tournament organizers' spirits.
A package of ham costs $48, I'm made entirely of microplastics, and I'm still playing Commander.
Imagine you're playing pickup basketball.
Your opponents win the game.
You immediately and loudly exclaim, "WELL IF I HAD JUST MADE THAT THREE WE WOULD'VE WON."
Weird and off-putting, right?
This is what Magic players do. All The. Time.
Let's imagine the best possible commander in cEDH.
It would cost 0 mana, have the keyword Split Second, and say "When you cast this spell, win the game."
Okay. Now let's use this concept to examine some popular cEDH commanders.
BREAKING NEWS:
@wizards_magic
heard about the Krark problem at
@MonarchMediaTW
's Marchesa tournament.
They now must legally print this warning on new copies of the card:
I read Reid Duke's article about Commander.
It's full of reasonable advice written in plain, humble, and focused language.
I hope he continues to think and write about my favorite format of my favorite game. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Today I went 6-0 on Krark Sakashima.
The deck feels incredible right now. I'm still gathering data and impressions on the Powerbalance package, but otherwise it hums.
This is the deck's best new card, and it's not even close:
Tapping a land for mana resets priority. That's a rule of the game that can be leveraged in tournament cEDH.
That said, I have also said in a cEDH tournament: "If you pass priority to me expecting me to tap out, I will pass priority and we will lose."
Tactics cut both ways.
Casual Commander enjoyers:
I want to build a new $50 deck that:
a) does Group Hug;
b) has one absurd restriction;
c) can win the game if needed.
Pitch me!
I don't know how long in advance Wizards folks work on sets, so keep that in mind as you read what's below.
It seems plausible to me that Dominaria Remastered is WotC's most serious attempt to address the widespread acceptance of playtest cards/proxies among the cEDH community.
I'm watching Neon Genesis Evangelion for the first time—properly, all the way through—and the fourth episode is not only one of the best episodes of TV I've seen… it's one of the best pieces of media I've seen. Period.
tired: pretending that the Reserved List is a legal obligation rather than an implicit justification for the logic of artificial scarcity
wired: making Underground Sea cost $5
Commander is touted as a format meant to encourage self-expression in the world of Magic.
Yet it doesn't feel great to express yourself in a social setting to people who aren't paying attention.
And this, funnily enough, is why cEDH feels so nice for some folks!
Here's what I think about Commander:
1. cEDH is EDH is fun.
2. Do what you want and be kind.
3. Rule 0 is the heart of the format.
4. Casual and competitive are mindsets.
5. Proxies are good. (Cat's out of the bag.)
6. Precise pregame conversations make good games.
Deciding at this very moment that the only 60-card Magic format I'm interested in playing in competitive settings is Pauper.
≤$100 decks? A diverse metagame? Utterly based.
What's the best deck right now? (I now the format's just now getting shaken up.)
Group A claims Group B did wrong. Group A provides good evidence.
Group B claims Group A is lying. Behind the scenes, B threatens to sue A. Group B claims they have evidence, but provide none.
Maybe I'm dumb, but I wouldn't yet call Group B a trustworthy organization.
I'm so sad that Sheldon is gone. What a generous spirit.
He helped Magic come into its own. He shepherded a global community into fun, enriching experiences.
We were lucky to have him. Rest in peace, my friend.
Brewing $50 decks Commander decks that are consistent and efficient has never been easier—and that's cool as hell!
This is a big upside of Wizards' decision to flood the market with reprints and new art/frame treatments. (The biggest benefit imo: more artists get paid!)
A brief review of Izzet decks in cEDH:
1. Stella Lee
The most efficient combo commander in the color pair. Likely to suffer from its efficiency (cf. Winota), but will be a tournament staple for a long time.
"Maybe play more lands in your Commander decks!" said math, wisdom, and rationality.
"I'M NOT A COP AND I'D RATHER EAT DIRT!" said goopy goblin gamer brain, Major Depressive Disorder, and aesthetics.
Oathbreaker fans:
Tyvar / Vampiric Tutor for Hermit Druid into Necrotic Ooze combo seems like a VERY consistent T3 win.
Is there a more efficient and linear combo deck out there?
Still dazed at
@con_tier1
. So many kind, supportive, & skillful players. So many cool Krark players. So many good games. Such great judges & tournament staff.
Very grateful and VERY very lucky. Krark did me right (and snagged me a Timetwister, my first piece of the Power Nine)!
@wachelreeks
Commander is first and foremost a spectator sport.
Just realizing how much time players spend not playing—and how that's an invitation to pay *more* attention, not less.
cEDH encourages attention to game actions and pieces. This makes cEDH players *more* receptive to others' self-expression (in many instances).
Yet the cEDH metagame pressures folks into narrowing their decks' card pools. This narrows the range of game-mechanical self-expression.
As a writer and publisher, I had to figure out—and very early one—some principles for navigating the strange relationship between art and artist.
As a sick person, I learned the hard way how to identify ableism and cruelty.
Fucking bummer about Seb. Ideology is a helluva drug.
Woah. We're closing on a house!
My parents will live in the main house (we'll take care of 'em as needed). My wife and I will live in the studio—which we're calling The Goblin Church. It's 800 sq. ft. with a super high pitched roof.
I'm so excited to have a blank living space!
I want you to beat me in Commander with Vampires.
I want you to beat me in Commander with Myr tribal.
I want you to beat me in Commander after making 30 Treasures with Smothering Tithe.
I want you to beat me in Commander with Ad Nauseam.
*
Do what you want. Have fun.
Magic: The Gathering cards I am too dumb to play well:
• Sanctum Prelate
• Chalice of the Void
• Archon of Emeria / Rule of Law / Eidolon of Rhetoric
• Intuition
Thank you for coming to my TED Talk.