The 🇿🇦 ICJ genocide case re 🇮🇱 is unraveling the German political class. In the last 3 days, 3 frenzied articles attacking anticolonial thought have appeared to shore up 🇩🇪 and western colonial Weltanschauung, proving the point about the coloniality of the entire situation. 1/
The German state ideology is collapsing under the weight of its own contradictions, so its proponents are reduced to gutter comments, drivel, and abuse. Watch this space.
Would a German newspaper dare publish this searing essay by Raz Segal? “Here’s what the mass violence in Gaza looks like to a scholar of genocide” - Los Angels Times.
@PBahners
When 🇩🇪 politicians talk of “hartes Vorgehen” to describe the mass slaughter of civilians I wonder if they realise this is a German tradition & whether they’ve learned anything from their genocidal history going back to colonial massacres, starvations & scorched earth in 🌍
"One can criticize the Israeli military for using harsh measures in the Gaza Strip. However, that does not constitute genocide," said Germany's Economy Minister Robert Habeck.
"Berlin Museum Removes All Artwork Depicting Rivers or Seas. The German media praised the move, accusing several international bodies of water of antisemitism."
#GermanCatechism
I sensed the apocalyptic potential of genocidal Biblical tropes in Israel political culture in an article in 2011 called "Genocide and the Terror of History." Netanyahu was at it then too
#amalek
#GazaGenocide
I signed this statement to protest misuse of Holocaust invocations in the Israeli state's destruction of Gaza. I commend it to anyone who wishes the destruction to stop. Such misuses by anyone/side in this conflict do not aid the cause of peace and justice.
The Where’s Daddy? program that allowed missile operators to wait till targets arrived at home (where it easier to kill them) entailed killing their families at a 15-20 to 1 ratio, far above usually accepted proportionality principles. 1/
I spoke with Israeli intelligence officers about the AI-based target machine they used which marked 37,000 Gazans as suspects for assassination. These whistleblowers expose numerous machines & policies that killed thousands of civilians since October.
The
@BostonReview
has published my views on the Gaza-genocide debate. I resist the temptation of deciding "genocide or not" to highlight the just-as-troubling acceptance of permanent security's terrible violence in international law and politics.
Mehr Zerstörung als in Aleppo, Mariupol oder bei der Bombardierung Deutschlands im Zweiten Weltkrieg: Kein historischer Militäreinsatz war Analysen zufolge so verheerend wie Israels Gazaoffensive.
Prof Wolf Gruner
@USC
where he teaches Holocaust and Genocide Studies on its outlandish cancellation on Asna Tabassum. Based on growing up in East Germany, he writes “Punishing personal opinions is the first step toward authoritarianism” 👏👇
The Israeli scholars Alon Confino, Amos Goldberg & Raz Segal have published an important corrective to the dated views on the Holocaust, colonialism & Zionism by Yehuda Bauer and others. As it's in German, I offer an English translation in a long thread.
Unsere Sprecher*innen
@NDeitelhoff
und Rainer Forst haben mit Klaus Günther und Jürgen Habermas die Stellungnahme "Grundsätze der
#Solidarit
ät" zur aktuellen Situation in
#Israel
,
#Gaza
und hierzulande verfasst. Zu finden ist sie auf unserer Website ➡️
1/ If it's possible to imagine, a new low in German discourse on antisemitism and postcolonialism, as Thomas Thiel alleges in
@faz
that universities are systematically antisemitic for having produced a petition contesting the Habermasian liberal bromides.
Eine Chance, den Dialog über die palästinensische Perspektive auf die Geschichte des Nahostkonflikts zu beginnen: Rashid Khalidi: „Der Hundertjährige Krieg um Palästina“ ist im
@Unionsverlag
auf deutsch erschienenen.
@dlf
Rezension 👇🎧
Years in the making, _The Oxford Handbook of History and International Relations_ is published today. I was flattered to be asked to write the chapter on "The Diplomacy of Genocide." Thanks to the editors who herd the cats with aplomb.
A typically German take on its political culture by
@RonenSteinke
who has written better takes in the past. Here he links far-right/ultra-nationalist critiques of German memory culture with what he and other establishment Germans quaintly call "postcolonials" (singling out me) 1/
Deutschland habe Komplexe, Israel zu kritisieren? Früher wurde das von der extremen Rechten behauptet, nun auch von Linken. Falsch war es immer. Essay von
@RonenSteinke
#SZPlus
"For white Germans to stand for the rights of Palestinians to life, health, safety, and freedom, they would need to study our world from outside Germany’s myopic narratives."
From Prof. Dr. Sabine Broeck's "Staatsraison: Dispatch From Germany":
I finally mounted my Australian spoon wall map to hang the many vintage spoons collected from/of from country towns. A high point of Stralyan civilization (sic.) IMHO.
@anthroprofhage
It’s an outrageous statement, typical of formulaic ones that German institutions feel compelled to issue if they think their funding will be cut.
„What is deeply disappointing to us at The New School is that your cancellation of her appointment disrupts our decades-long ties to Germany.“ Brief der Präsidentin der New School New York an den Rektor der Uni Köln
This is correct: many German journalists regard themselves as guardians of Germany’s Staastsraison instead of doing their job, thereby restricting freedom there.
"Viele Journalisten/innen hierzulande verstehen sich vor allem als Hüter der Staatsraison. Sie sind mehr damit beschäftigt, abweichende Meinungen zu verurteilen, als den dt Schulterschluss mit Israel zu hinterfragen. Als vierte Gewalt fallen sie aus."
I've written this text - "Why the International Community Made it so Difficult to Prosecute the Crime of Genocide" - for
@DAWNmenaorg
in relation to
#GazaMassacre
This AfD submission to the 🇩🇪 parliament attacking a state program on the “global south” as antisemitic repeats familiar points re: “postcolonial studies” long made in the mainstream press. It demonstrates a nasty Volksfront from the Greens to the AfD. 1/
“der postkolonialen Theorie zu ihrer Vormachtstellung in den Geisteswissenschaften”: the quaint belief of members of the German political class that “postcolonial theory” dominates universities there shows that the propensity to believe in conspiracy theories never disappeared.
What this article about racial "cleansing" and terror in US history reveals is that the US fascism debate has it backwards. It's not that Jim Crow was fascist (what historians call anachronism) but that interwar fascists were fascinated with settler colonial genocide & slavery.
Political Scientists Turned a Blind Eye to America’s Democratic Failures—I’m in
@ForeignPolicy
discussing the weirdness of Polity scores and the prevalence of political violence in US history
Chris, this is the hysteria I'm talking about. Think about your own piece a few days ago. It showed that you have no idea what goes on within Australian unis. Rather than debate, you censure and seek to censor. Who is being authoritarian? Is this what you really want?
If you want to understand the deeper reasons for the German memory mess, read this “The German State and the Creation of Un/Desired Communities” by Hannah Tzuberi and Nahed Samour
It also means the human shield argument is nonsense: operators waited till targets were among civilians. Each is likely a war crime, but what about at scale? A crime vs humanity? How will courts assess the quality of intention when the policy takes killing tens of thousands of 2/
Others have tweeted this book already but my copies arrived only today, 8 yrs (?) since
@MarcoLDuranti
's conference
@ArtSS_Sydney
. The cover is of officials arriving at the Aboriginal Tent Embassy, Canberra, July 30, 1972. Thanks to all.
@CUPAcademic
Apparently, writing books like this can get you arrested. I met Nadera in Haifa in 2013. She is an inspirational & courageous scholar & human being who belongs in the classroom & not in prison. Shame on institutions that imprison faculty & arrest students on paranoid pretexts.
In 2021, we ran a Book Forum on Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian's _Incarcerated Childhood and the Politics of Unchilding_ (CUP 2019) featuring commentaries by
@NiAolainF
, Sherene Razack, Smadar Ben-Natan, and
@NoamPeleg
with Nadera's response. .
Mainstream Nakba denial in 🇩🇪: "Zwei Drittel der 900 000 in Palästina lebenden Araber flüchteten vor allem aufgrund der Propaganda ihrer Führer. Von den Israelis hatten sie in der Regel wenig zu befürchten und erhielten auch die Staatsbürgerschaft"
The hitjobs on Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian continue. Here an 🇮🇱 tv "report" trundles through her work, including the
@JournalGenocide
forum on her book on the unchilding of children to allege that she relies only on interviews with children who lie and are actually terrorists 1/
Look what arrived in the mail today. The book of
@EUI_History
dissertation I was privileged to advise. Huge congratulations to
@boyd_vandijk
on this and other achievements on an alas all-too-relevant subject: the laws of war.👏🍾✨
The German position is entirety predictable. “Please bomb and blockade those Arab-Nazis just as the allies rightly bombed and blockaded our Nazi ancestors, as we need to stop a Holocaust.” This is the Israeli frame, and the Germans have adopted it for their intl’l rehabilitation
I wrote this over two months ago in response to the demented reaction to
@juergenzimmerer
and M. Rotbherg's article in Die Zeit. A German journal agreed to publish it but then got cold feet, fearing possible controversy and bearing out the article's thesis. 1/
Die Erinnerung an den
#Holocaust
als Zivilisationsbruch ist für viele das moralische Fundament der Bundesrepublik. Der Vergleich mit anderen Genoziden gilt daher als Häresie. Es ist Zeit, diesen Katechismus zu verabschieden, sagt
@dirkmoses
.
For arguing that the Holocaust is also (not rather) accountable by traditions of violent expansionism ("redemptive imperialism") in some recent publications, German reviewers went crazy. Now that their "arguments" are appearing in English, people are noticing, and that's good.
"The fact that the Holocaust can’t be explained by theories of imperialism" is an absolutely insane thing for anyone, especially a German, to suggest. Lebensraum was the justification for basically everything the Nazis did, including the Holocaust
2/ with Michael Rothberg & I as "matadors of Holocaust relativization." That a supposedly serious newspaper allows such defamatory nonsense--which incl. attacks on
@Deborah_Feldman
--is a sign of new intensity with which
#Germancatechism
is being enforced by the political class.
Germans upset that author Lana Bastašić questions their geopolitical morality. How dare a Bosnian do so after all that her German press has done for her.
We have published the first instalment in a new Forum on Gaza: International Humanitarian Law and Genocide by
@MsJamshidi
- “Genocide and Resistance in Palestine under Law's Shadow”
@karinloevy
@NimerSultany
@AeyalGross
Delighted to be giving the Gerald D. and Norma Feldman Annual Lecture tomorrow on “German Memory Culture at a Crossroad?” I will be arguing that it’s actually the end of the road.
women and children as a given in attacking a military target? The article also reveals the cavalier manner in which these targets were identified. Are we seeing the blurring of military and genocidal logics? This case will test courts’ customary distinction between them. End
I give the background/context to the
@mashagessen
cancellation by
@BoellStiftung
in this article about
#documenta15
. In light of recent events, including the Oyoun defunding, its conclusion that "cultural freedom is in mortal danger in Germany" seems right
My boss said "If you were a historian, you would say, 'over the past 20 years, the greatest crown risk to research intensive universities has not been foreign governments. It has been the Australian government slashing research funding'." I am a historian. He is right.
Exclusive interview with
@mashagessen
by
@hahauenstein
that details her careful and ethical arguments and how German elites can't understand or abide them. I hope it appears in English.
.
@mashagessen
ist in den letzten Tagen nicht gerade mit Samthandschuhen angefasst worden. Hier mein Versuch eines empatischen Gesprächs mit Masha Gessen—über Deutschland, Hannah Arendt und einen umstrittenen Essay.
Glad to see this article on Palestinian trauma, the Nakba, and its denial in Germany, published in German: "Obwohl zutiefst verflochten mit der Geschichte des Nationalsozialismus, wird die Nakba aus dem deutschen kollektiven Gedächtnis und öffentlichen Diskurs ausgegrenzt,... 1/3
Israel is beginning to launch a large-scale operation alongside its ongoing military campaign: the biggest crime cover-up in the country’s history.
By Dan Owen of
@Yesh_Din
.
The author is an expert of the Armenian Genocide. They assess the status of civilians in modern warfare and in the fields of Holocaust and Genocide Studies—in relation to Gaza. Must read 👇
"This volume will undoubtedly prove too theory-heavy for most lay readers. However, for scholars of the postcolonial world it will prove immensely valuable. The breadth of time & place covered ensure that a range of scholars will find use within its pages. It adds nuance & depth"
@RiggioPhd
from Trinity University, Texas, reviews
📖Decolonization, self-determination, and the rise of global human rights politics
edited by
@dirkmoses
@MarcoLDuranti
and Roland Burke
👉
"For 🇩🇪, its commitment to Israel is offered as a test of whether the country has overcome its Nazi past. This is politics as psychology or, better, put, psychoanalysis. There are no limits of prudence or public reason. Reality is of no consequence, what matters is redemption" 1
For 3 months I have been trying to make sense of Gaza, not just what is happening in the Strip but everything around it. I wanted to wait a bit but finally here it is, a long essay
@TIME
was generous enough to publish. Please read and spread if you can
One does not expect anything more from academic careerists but that Habermas signed this discredits his legacy. If this is what all his work comes to over 70 years, what can it be worth.
@Birmo
@SenKimCarr
Hey Minister, your friends
@theramsaycentre
may disagree. Aren't the Straits of Gibraltar on the faultline of Western Civ? If you want us to use chestnuts from the lexical repertoire of Western Civ, it seems the barbarians are not only inside the gates, they are the gatekeepers.
Congrats to
@FrankGerits
for this tremendous book, drafts of which I marked up years ago
@EUI_History
. Wonderful to see it in book form and so handsomely produced.
"Zum ersten Mal wird nun auch eine jüdische Künstlerin Opfer der aktuellen Serie von Absagen und Ausladungen wegen Aussagen, die als antisemitisch gelesen werden. Zur Absurdität dieser Situation gehört, dass Breitz‘ Werk, das nun nicht gezeigt werden wird... 1/
We are honouring our UC Berkeley doctoral adviser Martin Jay on the occasion of his 80th birthday. Some of us started with him (over) 30 years ago. His landmark first book, The Dialectical Imagination, appeared in 1973.
"The effects of the use of starvation as a method of warfare, together with other attacks and collective punishment against the civilian population of Gaza are acute, visible and widely known" says
@KarimKhanQC
. Given the 🇮🇱 defendants' statements widely regarded as genocidal 1
The
@ABCaustralia
goes after its employees with Arab heritage. Also 'hesitancy to use particular terminology such as “invasion”, “occupation”, “genocide”, “apartheid” and “ethnic cleansing” in its reporting.' Hello, this is the vocab of international law.
@torte81
@BoellStiftung
@faznet
Good job Torsten. I would not say that the German discussion is unserious. The German clerics busy excommunicating people like Gessen are deeply serious in their self-righteousness. The German discussion is obsessional, as I argue in
@JuergenZimmerer
new book, Erinnerungskämpfe.
Finally a German newspaper starts to listen rather than moralise and scandalise.
@anthroprofhage
is interviewed about the student protests and his work 👇
In honor of Hayden White's scholarly life, History and Theory has collected online all of the works by and about him that it has published since 1960–37 items, including Hayden's articles and review essays, articles about him, and reviews of his books.
My response to German critics who want to divert the debate to the question of the Holocaust's singularity whereas I think the central question is the state instrumentalization of memory. (I didn't choose the accompanying image btw.)
Der 2. Teil unserer Reihe zur
#Catechism
Debatte:
@dirkmoses
mit einer scharfsinnigen Antwort auf seine Kritiker:innen, die (so Moses) Meinungsfreiheit und Menschenrechte missachten. Eine Streitschrift für ein anderes Erinnern in D.
@berlinerzeitung
am WE
In the
@tazgezwitscher
today,
@JanFeddersen
claims I use the term "Schuldkult," which I never have. Upon informing him of this when he first alleged it 2021, he wrote to apologize on 15 July: "ich bitte um entschuldigung, das war misslich und fälschlich." So why repeat it now?
Neujahrsansprache die Terror auf Israels Süden vom 07. Oktober zurecht verurteilt, das Leid das Israels Regierung seit Wochen über die Zivilbevölkerung Gazas bringt, jedoch mit keinem Wort erwähnt—das ist nicht Staatsraison, das ist selektiver Humanismus.
The people who cancelled Nancy Fraser would not even know who and what she’s talking about in her explanation of the non-Jewish Jewish tradition she discusses with
@hahauenstein
As Nancy Fraser spoke to me about her recent cancellation at the University of Cologne, she explained why she considers Germany's unconditional allegiance to Israel to be a betrayal. And why she’s far from repentant about signing open letters in solidarity with Palestine.