Non collegium system gave us troublemakers like: Vivian Bose, Chinappa Reddy, Desai, Hidayatullah, Gajendragadkar, Krishna Iyer JJ
Collegium system gave us gems like: Gogoi, Arun Mishra, Bobde, Khanwilkar, Nasir, MR Shah JJ
So you decide ☺️
Happy Constitution Day!