I hereby forbid anyone from doing any more translations of Weberβs Protestant Ethic. Iβm tired of buying them for every new class and I donβt care if the German was mistranslated, if he didnβt say βIron Cageβ he should have.
After being turned away from urgent care because he was "not cooperative", insurance is now contacting me to make sure that my son's employer won't cover his treatment (2 stitches in ER, $8000 bill) through workers' comp.
My son is three years old.
Thrilled to officially announce that I'll be joining
@NYUSociology
next fall! I feel so grateful for the support I've had these long 7 1/2 years at
@UCBerkeley
and honored to have such an exciting next step ahead of me.
This graph is intriguing, but unless you can show how the modal asylum resident (an elderly white woman) turned into the kind of person most targeted by mass incarceration (a young Black man) around 1975, you might have to accept the story is a bit more complicated than implied.
The inexorable march of time has transformed the pumpkin into a haunting representation of the fleeting character of fame and ephemeral nature of human beingsβ organic existence.
Or just how people feel after a day of zoom calls.
Once again, reviewed a paper that did a great revision, got positive reviews from myself and another reviewer, and was rejected thanks to a third reviewer, who wrote the least detailed commentary. 1/
RCT shows students learn more when they are made to participate actively, but think they learn less. This resonates so much with my experience with students who - to my great surprise! - preferred that I lecture in discussion section.
Just saw decision-letter for an article I reviewed. I recommended reject, so did someone else, and we both identified the same problems.
But the other reviewer included words like "disappointing" "meandering" and "unsophisticated."
People, we don't need to do this.
Some times when I actually follow a citation trail, the care with how we use literature scares me.
Currently reading a paper that says "Rates of involuntary hospitalisation vary greatly worldwide" and have "risen substantially" across countries.
Source: One study on England.
Following what's happening with
#cola4all
at UCSC and the terrible response of the university administration, and it's making me reflect with a few months of distance on being a graduate student, and realizing how completely insane it is.
So far having a front row seat to the NYU Palestine encampment has involved hearing a lot of serious conversations and music, although now my son is saying he wonβt go to bed until he hears them chant βfree Palestineβ so now Iβm mad.
After many years in the purgatory of my parents' basement and in-laws' attic, my books have finally been reunited.
I can only imagine what it will do for my academic productivity to have easy access to Parsons and Volume II of Capital.
One of my students critiqued that our course began with only white theorists like Marx and W.E.B. DuBois, and I guess sometimes I can't take criticism too personally.
The premise that all this is driven by push back to woke leftist professors teaching majors with no economic utility is kinda belied by the fact that they are cutting physics and nursing programs.
The right just doesnβt like public universities, full stop.
The University of North Carolina Greensboro has dissolved the Physics & Astronomy department. A major pillar of science education at that university is gone. I have no words. My heart goes out to my friends and colleagues.
Very excited to have officially broken ground on my book, Mental States, today!
I forgot how much more enjoyable I find book writing than articles - there's so much more space for telling a story about the social world.
There is so much methodologically strong qualitative research with substantively important findings that is getting rejected because of rote comments about theoretical framings and macro-/meso-/micro-linkages that could be written in a review of just about any paper. 2/
I'm glad it's such an easy moment to concentrate on work, since my university just e-mailed me to remind me "The standards for both promotion and tenure, and third-year reviews are continually rising."
Excited to be the lead on
@sfchronicle
's opinion page.
The
#conservatorship
vs. voluntary services debate is not going to be resolved anytime soon, but there is an opportunity for consensus on greater state authority, accountability, and a guarantee of a full continuum of care.
I was proud of how
#Conservatorship
turned out but I never would have expected such a kind review.
"It is rare that a book saturated in ambivalence and complexity is so eminently readable and insightful...he narrates with unfailing empathy."
On the advice of
@JoshSeim
I let my students submit diagrams in lieu of weekly reading response papers. So highly recommended! This week we're reading Eyal's Autism Matrix alongside Hansen's Pathologizing Poverty and they are just so much more clever than I.
Every reviewer should finish with a checklist:
- Did the author commit gross research malfeasance?
- Is the author wantonly misrepresenting or appropriating other work?
- Did the author harm someone in your family?
No? Cool. Then tone it down. It's okay they didn't cite you.
If I were a psychiatrist, and I wanted society to take my discipline more seriously, I would drop the endless search for a new neuro-biological wonder cures, and re-focus on not-doing this:
Can California come up with a new model of care that serves those left behind by the existing mental health and homeless services systems?
Neil Gong (
@NeilMGong
) and I have a piece in the
@washingtonpost
on Governor
@GavinNewsom
's
#CARECourts
proposal.
Waiting for this election feels like waiting for Santa Claus when I was 8, except if Santa Claus had a 10-25% chance of deliberately setting fire to our house.
Excited that this article with Nick Rekenthaler is in print in
@socprobsjournal
! In it, we examine three different proposals to expand involuntary psych treatment for "the homeless mentally ill" in CA.
Excited to have an OpEd in
@latimesopinion
based on my research for
#Conservatorship
.
California is about to expand involuntary care. The risks are huge. The state is going to need to take a much more engaged role for this to have a chance of going right.
Prop 1 passed. CA is going to get 11,500 more "beds."
Reupping this thread about why "bed" doesn't mean anything - whether Prop 1 will help or harm will depend enormously on what kind of "beds" actually get built, who runs them, and how we demand accountability from them.
The second component of
#Prop1
is a $6.4 billion bond to build "beds", 4000-or-so would be in independent supported housing (partly earmarked for veterans) and 6000 "treatment beds."
Excited to see my article on media coverage of involuntary psychiatric treatment in print at
@society_mental
journal.
The topic - California's LPT Act - is a bit obscure, but there's broader implications for research on stigma and MH policy.
Although I'm grateful for the publicity in general, I'm particularly glad that this story made it seem like I'm actually a guitar player who does a bit of sociology on the side.
These days, rarely get to talk about the year-and-a-half I spent studying mental health in France, and am grateful for UCLA giving me a chance to in two weeks!
As I show, when state hospitals closed, almost no one talked about people with mental illness going to jail or onto the streets - because they didn't go there, they largely went to boarding homes, nursing facilities, and back to their families.
Hey hey! This article made it into print, thanks in part to (among others!)
@santiagojmolina
,
@JoshSeim
, and
@beingwhatever
, and the journals who rejected it at just the right times to give me a chance to improve it (really).
Todayβs
#Conservatorship
Thread: Crisis
(As a reminder, you can order my book from the press with the code CUP20 and get a 20% discount. Cats everywhere are finding it an excellent pillow.)
I feel incredibly lucky to get to spend my days learning about a topic I care deeply about, but there are times when the abuse and neglect of people with mental illness is just too much, and I wish I still studied dumpster divers the food we abandon, not the people we abandon.
As a result, I get the sense that much of the revision time a quant person would spend running other models or robustness checks, we spend far away from our data, coming up with new italicized concepts that we do not need. 3/
In the last year, I have enjoyed figuring out:
- Why my health insurance kicked off a dependent abruptly.
- Why 90% of OBGyns in NYC won't take women who are 'too pregnant.'
- Why a doctor charged $35,000 for one hour in a delivery room and then changed it to 1/10th that.
I am grateful for social scientists helping us make sense of yesterday's mess (and also those who saw it coming).
I still find Kathleen Blee's "Inside Organized Racism" (2002) to be incredibly revealing, and also highly recommend
@schradie
's book on right-wing organizing.
In light of yesterday's events at the U.S. Capitol, sociology & other other social science research provides critical insight.
Below, several recent ASR articles that people may find helpful in contextualizing yesterday:
Weβre holding a teach-in! Come join sociologists Ruha Benjamin
@ruha9
, Michael Burawoy, Roi Livne
@RoiLivne
, Areej Sabbagh-Khoury & Sharmila Rudrappa reflect on their support for the ASA Resolution for Justice in Palestine!
Register here:
A freshman came to my office hours and said it was her *first ever* office hours and left saying that the class had blown her mind and that meeting with me wasn't as scary as she thought and I think I'll just retire now on a high note.
It's somehow fitting that after spending my twenties eating garbage off the sidewalks of New York I am spending my (hopefully, just early) thirties preventing my child from eating garbage off the playgrounds of New York.
Apparently I am giving a talk in French ("From dumpsters to institutional activism" - it rhymes) next Tuesday!
Judging by the fact that I don't feel comfortable writing this tweet in French, this will be an adventure.
Sign-up below!
Looking through these interview transcripts, I have concluded that about ~40% of what Americans think they know about mental health still comes from what they remember from watching One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.
That terrible moment when you change your single spaced paper in Garamond to double spaced Times New Roman for a journal, and realize that it is now not only ugly but more than twice as long.
βThe reality of the state of California right now is there are a lot of people who have been so repeatedly failed by the social service system and the mental health system that they do need a higher level of care that isnβt available to them.β β
@avb_soc
of
@nyuniversity
"We're still dealing in America with black people being killed in some of the most arbitrary ways, driving while black, walking while black and now we have to add living while black," co-counsel Benjamin Crump said.
#justiceforbo
#BothamJean
Rewriting the methods section of a qualitative paper and have to admit that we really are pushed to say a lot of bullshit.
I mean, how many people out there are *actually* doing grounded theory, versus reading their notes and finding interesting stuff?
Very excited for this virtual joint presentation on Friday at 3:00 p.m. with
@NeilMGong
on "Fixing Public Psychiatric Care" through the Problem-Solving Sociology Workshop.
All our welcome, zoom link available here:
Was feeling FOMO for not being able to support my striking comrades in
#UAW2865
at UC Berkeley, but then realized that there was a picket at the New School.
It seems adjunct and graduate academic labor is under-valued just about everywhere.
#toddlersforafaircontract
Extended family congratulating me on how I'm "going to get paid now" and "have my own health insurance" and I realize they think my parents have been paying tuition and room & board for the last 10 years of graduate school.
While we're all happy to have autonomy in grading, I think it'd be helpful if universities communicated that a B+ is not a Rupture in the Sacred Ethic of Care Between Professors and Students, and just a way of communicating you did good but not great work.
I realize that the chance of getting any given academic job is vanishingly small, but there is a small moment of pleasure in looking at the scholars at the universities I am applying to, whose work I have read and cited, and imagining that maybe, someday, I could be a colleague.
It's more impetus for me to start a Journal of Substantively Important Findings and a SocArXiv but just for rejected framings that authors can slap on the front of papers in response to vague reviewer comments.
If all these grad applications are to be believed, the people coming into our discipline are excited about studying climate change, applying intersectionality and queer theory, and putting research into practice.
I'm not sure we're ready for them.
Ep 3 live today. An interview w/ Prof Alex Barnard of NYU highlighting the findings of 4 years of research into CA's FRAGMENTED mental health system. This is a book for our time. Buy two copies; one for you and one for your favorite elected official.
I mean, if youβre comfortable with the U.S. have 30x the rate of gun deaths as other developed countries, why not also offer up an order of magnitude more COVID deaths than those countries to the altar of American exceptionalism?
Alex: What works well in the French mental health system?
Interviewee: Nothing.
Alex: There's nothing the U.S. could learn?
Interviewee: Well... of course, having universal free healthcare is good.
Some things are just assumed, until you remind people you're from the U.S.
Excited that this paper is in print in
@CSSHJournal
.
I ask why French psychiatry has kept its distance from "mainstream" biomedicine, in stark contrast to American psychiatry's endless (if flailing) insistence it is a specialty 'like any other.'
There's no question the failures of our mental health system are leading to people being incarcerated or left on the streets, but the reason everyone is sharing this graph this week (that if we still had state hospitals, Jordan Neely would not have been murdered) doesn't track.
To be clear: thank you for the well wishes, but my son is definitely fine! It was probably the least serious thing for which you can be stuck in a pediatric ER.
The American healthcare system, on the other hand, is not fine.
People say you shouldn't take peer review personally, but on days where I submit a manuscript, I like to frame it as sending a piece of my soul for final judgment as to my worth as a person.
How come Berkeley sends out a campus-wide e-mail for every high level administrator they hire, and never for faculty? I'd be far more excited to learn about the new professor of medieval literature than the "Chief Innovation & Entrepreneurship Officer."
So honored at the prospect of sharing a (virtual) stage with Keris Myrick
@KerisWithaK
.
Looking forward to a conversation about changes to California's
#Conservatorship
system and improving support for people who are being failed by the state's current approach.
Register below!
California laws related to mental health and conservatorship have changed dramatically in the last several years. Please join us for a conversation with Alex Barnard and DRC Board member Keris Myrick about the implications of new laws expanding involuntary treatment and voluntary
I've been thinking about the claim that defunding police or abolishing prisons is unprecedented or unrealistic, and realizing how much we have a precedent for it in terms of de-institutionalization of psychiatric hospitals. 1/
[BTW, to end the story, the union went to the mat for me and I didn't have to pay the tuition, which is one of many reasons I think all grad students (I mean, workers) should be unionized.
How we fail the most vulnerable: "our system was built around the idea of discrete populations that fit neatly into specific boxesβhomeless, older adult, drug user, mentally illβand thus frequently has no place for those that check βall of the above.β
Alex Barnard details the depressingly holey safety net for older unhoused adults with dementia, mental illness or substance abuse issuesβand nowhere to go. In MayβJuneβs
#GenerationsToday
:
@NYUSociology
@avb_soc
@NYUSociology
is hiring! 2 assistant professor lines, with possibility 1 could be associate. Topic, method open. Apply here . For recs, click on as if you will upload recs, & use option to have Interfolio send message to your recommenders asking for recs.
My 110,000 word outline for Chapter 3 does not bode well for how much of my research is actually going to make it into this book.
But if anyone wants excruciating detail about some random debates in French social policy, DM me.
And, judging by the above average number of delivery bikes out tonight, wealthy New Yorkers continue to think staying safe and inside requires having poorer New Yorkers be unsafe outside.
New York City now has the worst air quality of any city on Earth.
If exposed to the current air quality in NYC for 24 hours, it would be equivalent to smoking about 6 cigarettes.
That moment when you open a new word document and think, "A new paper! Soon I will share my knowledge with the world" and then you realize, no, you'll still be trying out new theoretical framings four years from now.
Today in gender inequality:
Marie: I felt bad I had to leave my work call early.
Alex: Did you say it was to do child care? People think you're cool when you do that.
Marie: No, people think you're unprofessional.
Alex: Okay, people think men are cool when they do that.
I think it's understated just how incredibly demoralizing AI is for instructors.
I've spent hours preparing a lecture on some of my favorite readings, and response papers are just a mass of ChatGPT.
How are we supposed to stay motivated as teachers?
I think it was the moment where I realized this idea that we are "trainees" and therefore should be paid a joke wage is incredibly stupid. That semester, I was teaching and I was producing research, with very little oversight in doing either.
With
@GavinNewsom
's proposal for "CARE Courts" to compel treatment for unhoused people with mental illness, we're going to hear more and more claims about whether involuntary treatment 'works' or 'doesn't work.'
Blanket statements will be almost always be over-simplifications.
@EveGarrow
@Jeharrislaw
and others pointed out that empirical research has repeatedly cast doubts on the effectiveness of coercing treatment ... and that housing and accessible *voluntary* services + community-based resources are more effective.
Every time I am frustrated that my students don't seem able to do easy things - do the readings, get papers in on time - something reminds that they are doing seemingly impossible things every day - working full time, raising kids, supporting parents, getting degrees
#WillMissUCB
After one week with
@kjhealy
's very helpful "Data Visualization" book, I have already managed to turn data on involuntary psychiatric care in California into abstract art.
I'm pretty sure the 15th revision of this literature review is bound to reveal some novel theoretical insights and not just a new haphazard mix of references some reviewers told me to add.