@MamaLama43
@TheDUIGuyPlus
Jen McCabe helped John O’Keefe with his niece and nephew. She welcomed Karen into her home. She was the one trying to protect Karen from saying too much when she was blurting things out to the police. What has been done to her is beyond the pale of decency.
@SleuthieGoosie
They did not “unequivocally” say that. Experts may testify to an opinion only. It is up to the jury to decide what did or did not cause the injuries. I will say that is is not exact. There are pedestrian strikes that cause significant injury and some that cause very little
@itstrickortreat
I don’t care what side you’re on. Is this what we’ve become. Some of you think it’s ok for a sick fuck like this to threaten violence against a young woman. Caitlin Albert had nothing to do with the tragic death of John O’keefe. This guy needs to go
As I’ve thought about it, and done a bit of research, my opinion has changed. Unless they can show some structural defect in the deliberations, the ambiguity of it suggests the jury had not reached a final verdict fitting the legal definition where jeopardy would attach.
@stacymqc77
@EESprite
@Anastasiakk23
@TheDUIGuyPlus
Who is more culpable the woman that was the last with him that said I hit him that called him 53 times that called Kerry Robert’s at 5 am and said he was dead the women with the cracked tail light that went to his house got her belongings and took off or the 18 year old kid
@EstatePlan
I would stick to estate planning. This post is reckless and inaccurate A judge cannot ask a still deliberating jury if they’ve reached a verdict. It is strictly prohibited. The foreperson sent three communications informing the judge they were deadlocked.
@EliNBCBoston
@NBC10Boston
From a legal perspective, there were no verdicts Agreements, even unanimous ones, are not verdicts A verdict must be filed with the clerk and recorded. This is not on the judge, it was the jury that sent the letters indicating they could not reach a consensus on the charges
@factsdontlie10
Really why does Karen have a cracked tail
light, why did her event data recorder show a collision, why did she call her father at 1 am and 4 am. why did she tell Kerry Robert’s that he was dead at 5 am. Why did she go to Johns house ignore his family and leave get a grip
@TheDUIGuyPlus
You can’t be serious. You’re a lawyer act like one. Malicious prosecution after after a hung jury is not even remotely plausible. Also if she sues she then has to be available for deposition. You should just stop.
@stacymqc77
@EESprite
@Anastasiakk23
@TheDUIGuyPlus
I represented Colin more than a year ago. I disclose that on every television appearance. I am biased when it comes to him. He was maliciously slandered His life was turned upside down. To this day not a single person puts him within a mile of John O’keefe that night
@Courtne91162652
Can we just calm down. Why is someone going to his business to harass him. Chris Albert had nothing to do with the death of John O’Keefe (something everyeone agrees on) and yet people just won’t leave him alone. He was at work trying to run a business and earn a living.
@jarheadmom
@audlox
@gtconway3d
Yes but Trump talks tough when he really is not. Mayor Pete and Beau Biden left great jobs to go overseas and serve yet conservatives think they own patriotism.
@TheDUIGuyPlus
Honestly lawyers should be held to a higher standard when posting regarding legal issues. The U.S. attorneys office lacks jurisdiction over 90% of your list. They are not being charged with anything. Also if reports are accurate (big if) it was 10 to 2 against the defendant
@KerriTrueCrime
Do you know the Albert’s or McCabes? Real courage piling on to a family you’ve never met. What if you’re wrong and Karen simply was drunk and hit John. Do better
@JohnLorenz87787
@MAL5144
I know and the defense knows he had zero to do with the death of John O’keefe. Karen would blame her own father (as is her right) if it was viable. Having said that there’s more evidence that her father was part of a coverup than there is against Colin
@mauiswifter
@SleuthieGoosie
There have been people that have actually gotten up and walked away and some with multiple fractures and catastrophic injury.
@TheDUIGuyPlus
That’s not how it works. A judge cannot poll a jury unless it’s on a verdict that has been reported in open court on before it’s recorded Mass R Crim P 27 If the jury reported a verdict on one count(s) but an impasse on others she could have taken a partial verdict
@SzelagNicole
A person is factually innocent when they actually did not commit the alleged crime A person is legally innocent before a verdict because everyone is presumed innocent and when the Government does not prove the charge beyond a reasonable doubt and they are found Not Guilty.
@MichaelAvenatti
I'm a 20 year criminal defense, civil rights, and civil litigation Attorney. Also former boxing and mma commissioner. Bring me on board. You need a team of lawyers.
@JulieCar94
They are going to need a hearing. It may of course not be as straight forward as laid out by juror A. If it was merely part of some sort of discussion and informal self polling is different from reaching a unanimous verdict.
@wdunlap
@realDonaldTrump
@LibbyNon
Riots and violence by either side is wrong However, protesting over racial inequality and the murder of unarmed black men at the hands of police, highlighted by the murder of George Floyd, is different then a sitting president soliciting violence against our own government.
@YourClarkness
@DoctorTurtleboy
We are dealing with a young kid that was falsely accused of something terrible. That’s where the outrage should lie. Sure he made some immature videos but the hypocritical attacks by nameless people is gross.
@MTGrepp
The day after an assasination attempt on Trump,
people think it’s ok to say this about a former first lady. Trump was shot at because a young kid was probably the target of constant bullying and insults Similar to the behavior you’re engaging in More decency is what we need
@jessmachadoshow
@MazzaMedia
@letstalkliveytc
Is the reason not to appear merely because someone has an opposing view? Healthy debate based on opposing views is what the media should strive for. As a journalist you need to be objective.
@LuanneCarey
@amyklobuchar
Her service does not shield her from criticism. However, for Carlson and by acquiescence Trump, to question the patriotism of a woman that lost her legs in battle, crosses a line that invites condemnation. At some point decency has to prevail.
@richardvetstein
Rich, when attorneys submit requests for jury instructions, they typically submit instructions that are additional to the standard required instructions. There is nothing unusual about this.
@PhilipCDube
@TheDUIGuyPlus
If it was 12-0 Not Guilty on counts 1, 3 they should have checked Not Guilty Maybe there was confusion generated by verdict slip Ultimately, they need to bring the jurors back for a post verdict hearing. If confirmed, Double Jeopardy precludes retrial on those two counts.
@MAL5144
@JohnLorenz87787
John enjoy your Sunday I really mean that The trial is over. There are people dressing as ducks because harassing and bullying this young man gives them purpose As a local lawyer that was at one point involved in the case, I consider my opinion pretty solid
@toomuchintel
Ms. Hyde was definitely not rambling. She is highly regarded. Also, she had her work peer reviewed. Maybe it was rambling to people that only want the salacious stuff.
@SpecialKay423
@TheWiseCrow1
I also want to be clear, I don’t think my opinion matters more because I am a lawyer. On some of the legal issues sure, but I’ve learned a lot from listening to those of you that have been watching the trial and coming on here.
@EstatePlan
When a jury reports deadlocked a second time and the first time after a Tuey Rodriguez instruction it’s a mistrial. Your post stated that the judge “ignorantly” failed to determine if the jury reached a verdict is just legally wrong.
@TheDUIGuyPlus
Yes, someone followed a juror to their house and handed them an envelopw, right. Why aren’t you reporting on the reported breakdown that had a majority voting guilty?
@SpecialKay423
@TheWiseCrow1
I honestly would do a youtube channel if I had the time I’m a trial lawyer and spend most of my time in court. I love the enthusiasm this case has generated. I appreciate different points of view. I try to give an informed opinion but I know I can be can be a bit obnoxious
@TheDUIGuyPlus
A judge absolutely cannot inquire as to the split. As a matter of fact, part of the imstructions to the jury inform them not to report a split under any circumstances.
@RiekaMcCoy
@ProsecutorsPod
There are strict procedures an attorney must follow before contacting jurors post verdict They are not permitted to inquire into the content of deliberations which would seem to include their split I assume a juror willing to talk to an attorney will offer that on their own.
@AmyPNJ
This was spot on. There is a lack of imprecision in this field of expert testimony. No expert can definitively say the injuries did or did not come from
a pedestrian strike. It was an indirect strike with a stagger and fall. The Commwnealth expert should have kept it simple
@MAL5144
@OnTheRecordSC
I should refrain from personal shots but, I expect
more from an attorney. He is literally insulting the integrity of a judge based on his own lack of understanding of the law.
@Autopsy_MD
@CourtTV
@JoeGiacalone
@149Zone7
The judge allowed almost unlimited cross examination of Proctor at trial. The way to handle it is to own it. He texted deplorable things because he in good faith believed she ran O’Keefe over and left him to die on the front lawn. unprofessional and deplorable but not fatal
@ourx_vault
Kevin, first and foremost I truly hope you get well soon Hard to imagine someone would go so low as to question your veracity when it comes to something so serious. I don’t care what position someone takes on this or any other case, it shouldn’t be taken personally
@factsdontlie10
Do you remember exact times you leave a gathering. That’s your evidence. I don’t know I don’t represent him but I imagine he had a text from his cousin at 12:10 and used that as a reference point to estimate when he left. Not a single witness not one puts them together
@Bederowlaw
@HowieCarrShow
@G_CURLEY
Typically retrials are more difficult on defendants. The shock and awe of certain aspects of the trial are mitigated. For example the inverted photo was very impactful for defense I presume the mistake won’t be repeated and there will be an explanation for the inversion.
Olympics used to be amateur athletes competing for country. Big corporations have bought the olympics. It’s just not the same. From the opening ceremonies to Nike keeping Jaylen Brown off the team.
@Anastasiakk23
@TheDUIGuyPlus
I’ve appeared before that judge hundreds of times. Ask any defense attorney worth anything in this state, she is smart and fair. She gave the lawyers all the leeway they wanted to try their case. Yanetti is terrific. He gets it.
@GrantSmithEllis
There’s all ready too baseless rumors going on in this case Attorney Jackson is too smart for that. We should stick to debating the merits of the case.
@davepalex
@MAL5144
He dropped out of school purely as an act of selflessness BSU being D3 is irrelevant He played because he loved it. He did not want the harassment to ruin it for his teammates. What has been done to him is so beyond disgusting. The defense knows he had nothing to do with it
@nickdiaz209
At the time of your suspension I was the Massachusetts state MMA commissioner I was the only commissioner in the entire country that went to bat for you and said your suspension was an outrage welcome back
@MAL5144
@TheDUIGuyPlus
As a trial attorney of 25 years, the lack of decorum in this case is breathtaking. He might be a great guy. Sometimes though enough is enough. Dancing tailgating accusing the judge of corruption. There is so much at stake in this case.
@RiekaMcCoy
@ProsecutorsPod
A judge is not permitted to poll a hung jury. A judge polls a jury upon request by, usually the defendant, after the reading of the verdict into the record.
@AmericanCatMom
@DonaldJTrumpJr
@catturd2
Embarrassment? The man has literally spent the last year on the front line’s of a war zone. He’s demonstrated more courage than any other modern leader of the past century
@BarstoolZ
@TheDUIGuyPlus
Jen McCabe is a victim in all of this. Hos Long eviserated into thin air. Those that bought the tshirts and paid for the billboards didn’t even acknowledge it.
@lemisterjo
@DonaldJTrumpJr
I hope not. We need to change to tone of the discourse if we ever want to move forward. Respect our differences seek common ground and compromise. Govern from the middle but listen to the far left and the far right and understand they have a right to be in the conversation
@OAChirpinTigahs
Let’s make some fooking noise today. IL Ambicion, Willy please let me play Williams, Diesel my trucks bigger than yours Bourne, James the Beast Beatty, Cunning Cullen Gallagher, Max I belong in the insanity Ward
@ColonelPop21364
@SleuthieGoosie
The ultimate cause of death was a combination blunt force trauma and hypothermia. There was significant head injury. The torso doesn’t always have injury. The notion that you can’t definitely say it was or was not a pedestrian strike is false factually and legally.
@EstatePlan
Brian out of your lane. The jury did not report reaching a verdict either full or partial. That provision applies only when the jury FIRST reports a partial verdict Otjerwise a judge cannot inquire whether or not a jury has reached a verdict
@DanBilzerian
George Floyd, like many of us wasn’t prefect
However,
let’s be clear, for 9 minutes Chauvin kneeled on his neck. He killed him. He is played judge jury executioner.
@Courtne91162652
Really. You don’t know her. You come on here with a fake name and disparage her. She is a victim in all of this. A terrific person falsely accused of something
@RuthKaye7
@Trumpsters45
@JulieCar94
@TympanickLaw
Ruth very well stated. There is going to be substantial almost insurmountable deference paid to the lack of a verdict slip endorsed verdict . As a trial lawyer, I see why they are doing what they are doing. Interesting to see how Juror A explains the discrepancy
@johnhawkinsrwn
@stillgray
If it was a conspiracy, to assasinate Trump, or conversely to garner support for him, this is not the person they would have enlisted I bet we learn he was bullied then isolated to the point where something like this became an attractive alternative to the life he was living
@Douglas111857
@IngrahamAngle
I live in Mass a progressive state. We have a better health care, better schools, less crime and a much healthier economy than Florida.
@TheDUIGuyPlus
An open investigation is not evidence of anything. All of a sudden you all love the feds. Real trial lawyers don’t consider extraneous information. The case was decided on the evidence. It’s the best jury system in the world. Respect the jurors decision.
@DARollins
DA Rollins please keep going. Being Anti police brutality and anti racial profiling is not being anti police. Change is hard but this is a fight worth having. I represent young men of color from Brockton to Boston. I hear their stories every day. We support you!!!!!!!!!!!
@mezmerelda007
@EstatePlan
I didn’t advise anyone to do anything regarding Proctor. I have consistently been critical of him. As a defense lawyer I found his texts to be unprofessional and abhorrent. I was giving legal analysis. It’s called being objective.
@JulieCar94
The filing raises an issue warranting a hearing If they were in fact 12-0, I am not sure why they did not check Not Guilty on those counts However, if all 12 deliberating jurors individually confirm under oath they voted Not Guilty then double jeopardy would apply This case 🤦♂️
@balmycook
@AOC
Yes two women that put themselves through college and got themselves elected to Congress. Any racism here? Two women of color scare you? Get used to it. Trump is a dinosaur. The wrangler jean wearing pickup truck driving bible thumping racist MAGA crowd is shrinking
@Bederowlaw
In Massachusetts judges usually give the Tuey Rodriguez charge after a second communication from the jury indicating an impasse. I myself agree there had been due and adequate deliberations and the charge was warranted at that point. However, common to wait for second note
@BillyCorben
@UF
Such a dream for people of color to graduate from college. Many times first in their family. There is zero harm in joyous celebration. What occurred was ridiculous and racist
#FLORIDARACISTSTATE
@catwoman_1111
@Courtne91162652
Allen Jackson didn’t mention Colin’s name in his closing. There were pictures and video of Colin in the days and weeks following the incident with injury free knuckles. Not a single witness not a single one places Colin and John within a mile of one another that night.
@DavidWohl
@realDonaldTrump
That deep state hack won the Purple Heart. Trump dodged service because of a medical diagnosis of bone spurs bought and paid for from a doctor friend of his family.