If you retweet this - and you should - you should know that the director of Yesh Din, Ziv Stahl, was in Kfar Aza on 7th October, hiding with her family an entire day as her neighbours were murdered. She continues to stand for humanity.
[1] Under the cover of war: These are the Palestinian communities that were attacked by Israeli settlers between Oct. 7-22. Settlers have attacked Palestinians in more than 100 incidents in at least 62 towns and villages in the West Bank, at times accompanied by soldiers.
Similar statements were made by several ministers, but none of them had direct involvement in war policy. Now it comes from Netanyahu and should be seen a statement of intent.
Netanyahu said today he is actively working to ethnic transfer of Palestinians out of Gaza in a Likud meeting today. The problem, he said, is which countries will take them.
"If there would be a Gaza." To avoid any doubt: Rotman (architect of the Judicial Coup) does not talk about a Jewish kid visiting Gaza under Palestinian rule. He is talking about Israeli rule over Gaza, Israelis settling in Gaza, and replacing Palestinians there.
Extremely important: senior Israeli lawmaker Simcha Rothman admits the main goal of the assault on Gaza is that "a Jewish kid can walk freely in Gaza. If there would be Gaza."
They're openly admitting this all about ethnic cleansing, forcible transfers & re-colonizing Gaza.
The Rachel Riley T-shirt is the best visual illustration of the staggering myopia which characterises some of the response to antisemitism. A thread with some thoughts.
Smotrich agrees with
@mashagessen
that Gaza is a ghetto: "If we act strategically they will emigrate and we will live there. We won't let 2 million stay. With 100-200K in Gaza, the 'day after' debate will be diff. They want to leave, they've been living in a ghetto for 75 years."
Locking up 2 million people in an open air prison for 15 years is a horrendous thing, and it engenders horrendous things. It is not surprising that people with nothing to lose will sometimes do terrible things.
Israel has been committing unspeakable war crimes, crimes against humanity, and illegal collective punishment against Palestinians in Gaza for 15 years. 15 years. Any comment or analysis that doesnโt take this fact into consideration today is hollow, immoral, and dehumanizing.
According to the veteran Israeli journalist Nahum Barnea, the deal was ready for approval on Tuesday night. 50 Israeli hostages (children, women, elderly), 5 day truce, Palestinian women and child prisoners. Netanyahu decided to stall
Public statements (so many of them) which do not mention the the 7th October massacre are cowardly. I'm all for context and root causes, but pretending this thing never happened is just not serious.
This is for the Jewish/Israeli anti-Apartheid left.
If it's not you - scroll on. I also (for the first time ever) locked for replies.
On our priorities now, a thread.
---------------------------------
Saying Israel does shitty things - not antisemitic
Saying Israel is the origin of all evil shit - antisemitic
Thank you for coming to my talk, various caveats apply
Last night, settlers invaded the village of Susya (South Hebron hills) and ordered its residents to leave within 24 hours - otherwise they would all be killed.
The activist who was grabbed from behind, thrown to the ground and punched in the face is now under house arrest on suspicion of assaulting the soldier. Yes, that's right
On Friday, Israeli activists (mostly religious Jews) paid a visit to Hebron to express support & solidarity with Palestinian families who were attacked by settlers the previous week.
Clearly, the IDF soldiers posted there to protect the settlements didn't appreciate their visit:
I, for one, take inspiration from my Palestinian friends who - despite having lost homes, family members, friends - continue to see the humanity in Israelis, in everyone. They are the people with which we can build.
/End
1930s hot take: Jews in Europe are actually not Europeans, they should all go to Palestine
2023 hot take: Jews in Israel are actually Europeans, they should all leave Palestine
1/The Tanzanian government has confirmedย the death of Clemenceย Felixย Mtenga, one of two citizens who was takenย hostage by the Palestinian group Hamasย during the 7 October raid on Israel.ย A thread.
If your argument is "most Jews consider anti-Zionism a form of antisemitism, therefore it is" you have to consider that virtually all Palestinians consider Zionism a form of racism against them.
The attacks on Emma Watson's tame solidarity message reveal that there are those for whom it would always be wrong to support Palestinians or criticise Israel. This effectively means that *whatever* Israel does - it should be beyond criticism. 1/
The persistent denialism of 7th October suggests a QAnonisation of some subsections of the left. Not entirely new yet now with ever more effective means of dissemination. This should worry anyone who believes the current global polycrisis requires radical left answers.
The question who hit the hospital matters. But there have been so many civilian buildings attacked by Israel in Gaza, dozens of families obliterated, so many children killed. The enormous harm to civilians is clear and is undeniable.
The largest bakery in the Mid-Gaza governorate was attacked last night. As a result, over 100,000 people who relied on this bakery are now without bread. Is a bakery a target? How can this be real?
A policy paper from Misgav thinktank - headed by Netanyahu's former national security advisor: Israel now has an "rare and exceptional opportunity to remove all Palestinians from Gaza to Egypt"
The reports from today are harrowing. We know that at some point the US will force a cease fire. How many deaths will it take? Will 30,000 be enough? 40,000? 50,000?
The average member of Hitler's SS killing squads had a real sense of conscience and regret when they shot Jews in the head or participated in the worst genocide in human history. Very few were committed antisemitic murderers, Douglas Murray tells the Jewish Chronicle readership!
A key Netanyahu surrogate calls for expulsion of Palestinian citizens.
"It's all very simple actually.
If Arabs rioting are expelled to Gaza
It will end very quickly
Hello 1948,
We're back"
Those who have said almost nothing for three weeks - despite repeated warnings that Israeli policies in Jerusalem are leading to a major blowup - and now wake up to condemn the rockets and call for peace, are proving Hamas right: apparently only this kind of violence registers.
BREAKING: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called on Palestinian civilians in Gaza to โleave nowโ because the Israeli military is going to โturn all Hamas hiding places into rubbleโ
Putting aside the question why hate a 12 year old hostage so much: the hostages' families are currently the main moderating voice in Israel, and a hostage deal is the only route to truce/ceasefire.
But the people defacing these don't really care about ceasefire, or Gaza.
It's striking how some commentators, who are very attentive to anti-Jewish racism, particularly around its Israel/Palestine manifestations, somehow manage not to hear the "Death to the Arabs" chants in Jerusalem.
I remain aghast by the failure in some progressive spaces to recognise the 7th October atrocity for what it was and call it by name. I remain opposed to the bombing of Gaza. One crime does not justify another.
Cease fire. Free the hostages.
There are structural reasons why Palestine solidarity can sometime overlap with antisemitism, and these reasons have nothing to do with Palestinians, and everything to do with the pervasiveness of antisemitism in Western culture.
Denying that risk is harmful and unwise.
Mere two days after the Hague ruling, a third of the Israeli government participated in this event, in which gencoidal visions for the Gaza strip were openly advocated.
12 Israeli ministers (including from Netanyahu's Likud party) participated at a conference today about rebuilding Isrseli settlements in Gaza & encouraging displacement of Palestinians from Gaza. Ministers Ben Gvir, Smotrich and several others from Likud gave supportive speeches
So let me get this right: Tzipi Hotovely, proud supporter of Unequal One State between the river and the sea, walks briskly to her car (past some protesters with flags) after uninterrupted talk at LSE - and this is just like kristallnacht.
Reports of more than 40 Palestinian citizens of Israel - Bedouin - killed by Hamas. Read one account of a woman, wearing the Hijab, shot and killed at close range in her car. Her injured husband managed to escape
I said in class about two weeks ago that we would soon see a settlement nucleus in Gaza. Anyone who is familiar with the history of the settlement movement knows: this is how it starts.
No Israeli government in the last 15 years has offered any mid or long-term prospect for Gaza beyond the continued siege, imprisonment and occasional bombing of 2.2 million people.
So the Zionist movement built what they called colonies, for colonists (their terms), funded by the Jewish Colonial Trust, and their efforts of *colonization* were proudly celebrated e.g at the Paris Colonial Exhibition 1931, but how dare anyone use the c word to describe zionism
300 Palestinian prisoners are slated for release.
17 were convicted of attempted murder
283 for less serious, often far less serious charges
123 are under 18y old, most of them in prison for stone throwing.
Remember this:
The Palestinians who will be released in the impending deal are convicted terrorists who are in prison because they tried to murder Israelis.
The Israelis who will be freed are innocent civilians being held hostage by terrorists.
There is no equivalence. None.
Not only - as many pointed out - this reductive view does not reflect the fact that there are light skinned Palestinians and dark skinned Israeli Jews - it does enormous injustice to early 20th century Palestinian society, which welcomed people from diverse backgrounds.
/1
More than twice the number of Palestinian refugees in 1948. More than twice, probably, number of homes destroyed in 1948. Three or four times the number of casualties. An unmitigated catastrophe that will cast a shadow for generations. What will it take to stop it?
The reports from today are harrowing. We know that at some point the US will force a cease fire. How many deaths will it take? Will 30,000 be enough? 40,000? 50,000?
In 2010, Itamar Ben Gvir was the attorney of Haim Perlman (centre), arrested on suspicion of murdering Khairi al-Qam. Perlman was never charged.
Yesterday al-Qam's grandson, who was named after him murdered seven Israelis.
Ben Gvir is the Israeli minister of National Security.
Netanyahu's decision to escalate the bombing of Gaza despite the presence of Israeli hostages and prisoners there sends a devastating message to Israelis. Far more dangerous to Israeli cohesion and sense of security than Hamas's atrocious attack.
1/
Shouting "free Palestine" randomly at Jews in the UK is antisemitic, in the same way that shouting randomly anti-China slogans at East Asian people would be racist.
Sat outside a kosher restaurant in Golders Green with a friend.
Someone driving past leans out the window and screams โfree palestineโ. Weโre a bit shaken.
British Jews are not responsible for a foreign conflict.
I want to explain something that perhaps isn't clear to some people.
Jews deported to Auschwitz were told they were sent to a work camp. The "Arbeit Macht Frei" was part of that deception. The sign pretended to say "work hard and you'll survive". But this was a lie.
1/
This is a genuinely despicable tweet, belittling the seriousness of the industrialised mass murder of six million Jews. Anyone who speaks like this has no place in the left whatsoever.
The former opinion editor of the Forward recommending to "always read" a Nazi whose twitter handle has reference to Heil Hitler (88).
That's where we're at.
Seven weeks after the 7th October, PM Benjamin Netanyahu has still not found time to meet with survivors and refugees from the Kibbutzim that were attacked - but he does have time to meet with Elon Musk tomorrow.
Deeply moved to see a dear colleague - one of the brightest and most original historians of the Middle East I know - detained in a military jeep, his eyes covered, for the crime of delivering water to Palestinians in the south Hebron hills.
Danny Danon, former Ambassador to the UN (Likud, coalition), and Ram Ben Barak, former deputy head of Mossad (Yesh Atid, opposition) demand that the world help Israel expel Palestinians from Gaza by accepting them as refugees. Monstrous, brazen, stupid.
There are obvious parallels between the current attack and the 1973 war. In both cases, Arab leaders had reached out to Israeli leadership, and were rebuffed. Sadat to Golda's government, and Sinwar to Netanyahu (he even sent him a note in Hebrew)
1/
But for now, we should focus on the ongoing catastrophe. We know this fascist government for what it is, we know the underlying forces. We understand that, especially with the Kahanists in power, genocide is entirely possible. Stopping that should be our priority.
/4
1/ Yesterday we saw forceful and vocal response from Palestinians worldwide to incidents in which people waving the Palestine flags targeted Jewish neighbourhoods in London with vile antisemitic harassment and threats.
The response below is one of many.
My view on the settler-colonial framework in Palestine/Israel: it is an absolutely vital lens for understanding history and present; it is essential yet insufficient to explain Zionism; and, as we've seen, much of its current political use is disastrous and hyperbolic.
People think that acknowledging Zionism's settler colonial dimension leads inevitably to a one state solution or even Hamas-style "decolonisation".
In fact, the settler-colonial impulse is what, more than anything, killed the two state solution.
1/
If you, a white English person, are talking about the systemic racism as a global issue, and the only example you come up with is "Israeli secret services taught US police how to kill black people", then it doesn't sound like you want to understand global systemic racism 1/
We have little power or influence and we should use it for preventing the killing of tens of thousands. The Israeli government has been given carte blanche to act, the cries for revenge are deafening, and unthinkable horrors could unfold.
5/
"Stop the occupation, stop the bombing, and the casual antisemitism will soon disappear".
NO. Diaspora Jews are not accountable for the occupation and the bombing.
Stop the occupation. Stop the bombing. Fight antisemitism.
These things do not, must not, depend on each other.
This sounds to me like a justification for antisemitism, potentially even incitement. I mean I can't even begin... these are supposed leftists and anti-racists whose usual mantra is that racism is never justified...Apart from now obv.
2 million people have been living in the penal colony of Gaza for 16 years now, noticed by the world once every few years, only when the bombs start falling. What kind of a world is this.
Most of us are devastated by the failure of so many people - progressives, people we know and appreciate - to say anything about the Hamas's 7 Oct atrocity, to acknowledge it for what it was - even with a word. Worse are those who endorse the attack, or even celebrate it.
2/
If you are looking for people shouting "from the river to the sea", you can start with the Israeli government, which not only says such things but is also implementing them daily.
6 months ago, Smotrich called to wipe out Huwarra - and was met with universal outrage and condemnation.
In the last 3 days, five neighbourhoods in Gaza were very literally wiped out, without condemnation.
Outrage over Hamas's atrocity does not justify staying silent now.
Israel's Minister of Finance, Bezalel Smotrich, calls for the erasure of the Palestinian village of Hawara. "The village of Hawara needs to be wiped out. I think the state of Israel is the one that needs to erase it."
#HuwarahPogrom
@POTUS
@StateDept
@SecBlinken
Everyone is overwhelmed by enormous pain and grief and cannot see, hear and believe the stories from the other side. And it's not surprising. What I can't take is people mocking accounts of atrocities as "obviously false". Nothing is obvious now and the mocking is disgusting
The 1940 anti-Nazi manifesto of Palestinian leftist intellectual Najati Sidqi, in which he argued that Nazi ideology goes against the principles of Islam.
"Saying that Israel kills children in Gaza plays into a modern blood libel"
"Saying Hamas murdered kids and raped women plays into the racist depiction of Arabs as barbarians"
Both arguments are made and both are terrible. You don't fight dehumanisation by denying reality
Sociologist Yagil Levy, Haaretz:
"Israel embarked on a campaign of vengeance devoid of either military or diplomatic logic.
This campaign of vengeance is fueled as much by anger at ourselves over our failure as it is by anger at the Palestinian residents of the Gaza Strip."
1/
Israel's government is moving fast to eliminate the judiciary, public broadcasting, and academic freedom, and remove the civic rights of Palestinian citizens. It is completely acceptable to describe these measures as fascist.
Keir Starmer's spokesman says that Labour MP Kim Johnson's description of Israel's government as "fascist" at
#pmqs
was "completely unacceptable" and the Labour chief whip will be demanding she withdraw her comments.
I regret to inform you that Bezalel Smotrich's roots in Palestine go back to the 18th century.
Regardless, the problem with Smotrich is not that he has a name that ends with the slavic "ich", but that he is Jewish supremacist committed to ethnic cleansing.
If you have Palestinian or Israeli friends, colleagues, employees, if you know anyone with loved ones there - check on them.
We're terrified, shocked, worried sick, in pain. We need to know you see us.
The term Apartheid, as a shorthand for a system in which some people have full political rights and most people have no political rights - is pretty much a common-sense way to describe the West Bank.
To call it "antisemitism" is gaslighting.
A devastatingly detailed reporting from
@yuval_abraham
demonstrating the manner in which civilian houses and residential blocs in Gaza became military targets, resulting in the horrendous death toll of the last 8 weeks.
Please read.
I am sharing this, reluctantly, to point to the song they're singing. It's a Kahanist revenge song, words from the biblical story of Samson:
"O God, that I may be at once avenged of the Philistines for my two eyes"
(Yimach Shemam, may their name be effaced, the youths chant)
I'll say this again, if you use your public voice to cast doubt on unverified accounts of atrocities, but have absolutely nothing to say on abundant verified accounts of atrocities, not even a tiny word, you are an apologist and I don't want you anywhere near my feed
There is ample documentation of looting in Gaza, in videos posted by Israeli soldiers. It's an indication of the weakness of IDF's high command; looting is a symptom of a military force with poor discipline, and it's indicative of much more serious issues.
Itamar Ben Gvir (here kicking a Trans woman, 2008), the new Israeli minister for national security, would be in charge of:
Police
Border Police in the West Bank
"Green patrol" (against Beduins)
And his party in charge of:
heritage and archaeology
"Negev and Galilee development"
Azmi Bishara, 2005:
"The conflict between Israelis and Palestinians isn't between the good guys and the bad guys, it's between justice and injustice. There are good and bad people on both sides. Occupation is evil, not people."
1/
I'll say this again: the debate on Jewish "indigeneity" is entirely a North American obsession and a conversation conducted in English. In Israel, the only people who refer to themselves *in Hebrew* as indigenous are Palestinians.
Remarkable consistency from the Israeli right, insisting that "there was no expulsion in 1948, it's all a lie" and then threatening "watch out or we'll do it again".
Anti-Zionism does not "slip over into antisemitism". It's not a sliding scale.
Rather, views on Zionism (hostile or supportive) can overlap with (and articulated through) antisemitism.
2/ Antisemitism in the Palestine activism scene in the West almost never comes from Palestinians, almost always comes from non-Palestinian activists. We should acknowledge the heavy burden this places on Palestinians, especially in this moment.
It's striking that many people seem to think that harassing, threatening and excluding Jews who live outside Israel is a way to fight Israel, when in fact this is doing (accumulatively) the exact opposite
PM Bennet today:
I'm against Oslo.
I will not allow a Palestinian state.
I will not allow negotiations with the Palestinians.
Strangely some people are completely sanguine about this version of "From the River to the Sea"