🇳🇱 Specialist on Normandy 1944, esp. the Cotentin. Author of 'Defending Normandy' book series.
Love history books but prefer to study the records myself
Thread
#dday80
When talking about the German preparations for the Allied Invasion (AKA D-Day), a lot of attention goes to the (in)famous Panzer Reserve. With 10 Panzer Divisions and 1 Pz.Gren.Div., this force sounds formidable. But it is often overlooked what it actually was...
Thread:
The 2 Dutch gunboats H.N.M.S Soemba and Flores participated in Operation Neptune. Armed with 3 15cm (5.9") guns they earned the nickname 'Terrible Twins' for their operation in the Mediterranean.
Getting the Soemba ready for D-Day required a peculiar series of messages...
Thread
Ever noticed that documentaries all seem to use the same German footage? That’s because many weekly newsreels (Die Deutsche Wochenschau) survived the war and are now the prime source of moving footage. Let’s explore the first newsreel for the landings in Normandy. /1
The level to which these divisions were operational varied wildly on D-Day Many had serious manpower problems (too few officers & NCOs), mobility issues, lack of (formation) training and shortage of weaponry/armor. So let's take a closer look at them...
Some divisions were good, like the Pz.Lehr. On 1 May it was assessed as Kampfwert I (Combat rating I), the highest possible. This meant it was deemed ready for all offensive operations. Mobility of its combat vehicles was at 90% and those of the support troops was 50%.
Where Pz.Lehr and 12SS where OKW reserve on D-Day. the 21.Pz.Div. was Army Group B reserve and in position around Caen. On 1 May it was considered Kampfwert I and 92% mobile.
I was quite surprised by the success of my Panzer Reserve thread. Thank you all for sharing, and welcome to my new followers! If you appreciate these deep dives into the Germans in Normandy, you might also enjoy my book series (in progress):
The situation was different for the 116.Pz., division which, like 2.Pz. was Army Group B reserve. On 1 May it was merely considered Kampfwert III. This meant it was suitable for defense only. Mobility was just 7.5%
The .Pz.Div. was also in the northern sector of .B, but was OKW reserve. On 1 May its condition was such, that only a battlegroup was taken into account as a fighting force. Although 100% mobile, this was only Kampfwert II.
This improved towards D-Day, but it was still only considered suitable for limited offensive operations. This would mean it was Kampfwert II at best. Training above platoon level was insufficient.
The 17.SS-Pz.Gren.Div. was in the southern half of France. It was OKW reserve as well. On 1 May its issues were such that only a battlegroup was taken into account. It was considered Kampfwert II, with only minor elements mobile.
Thread (well sort of)
I frequently get asked for recommendations on English language books about German troops in Normandy. I always struggle with that because there are very few I like. One of my all time favorites is Zetterling's 'Normandy 1944', but its not for everyone...
"A report has come in from the Soemba,
That their salvoes go off like a Rhumba,
Two guns, they sound fine,
But the third five point nine,
He am bust and refuse to go boomba."
A.D. Nicholl,
Director of Operations Division (Foreign)
There seem to be two options in talks about German MGs on the D-Day beaches:
1) All guns MG42s (especially at Omaha)
2) Just old and captured MGs
Neither are true. Let’s take a quick look at the available numbers for the 716ID and 352ID. [I’ll ignore the Osttruppen for now]
Although the division's six Pz.Gren. battalions were supposed to be fully motorised, two had to use bicycle and ad-hoc motorisation for their heavy weapons. The other four battalions had received ad-hoc motorisation.
There was a total lack of transport tonnage for the supply troops. The issue was so serious that no authorized or available tonnage was even mentioned.
Even further south were three more panzer divisions, all of the Army Group G reserve. One of these was the 2.SS-Pz.Div. On 1 May only a battle group was taken into consideration. It was Kampfwert II, with only ad-hoc mobility.
Information presented here is based on records held by the NIMH and a 1952 article, which has been reproduced here:
Will do a proper thread on the operations of the Terrible Twins in Normandy later. (I have a family connection through an uncle's father)
The division was particularly weak on armour. Available StuGs, Pz.IVs and Panthers were at 56%, 97% and 37%, respectively. These numbers also shows that the division was using a fair number of StuGs instead of Pz.IVs.
On 1 May the 9.Pz.Div. was still organizing. It was being reconstituted using remnants of the division and the 155.Res.Pz.Div. It only had a battle group available, but did have 100% mobility.
Thread: German orbats
German document can be very interesting, even if you don’t speak German.
Their visual OOBs are prob the best example of that, if you know what the symbols mean.
Yes, you can look those up online, but how about a crash course in several threads?
Thread (on going)
With
#DDay80
approaching fast, I'll try to address some myths. Let's begin with Omaha Beach, or more precisely the 352.I.D.
It's been called everything from elite to poor, but usually such extremes are not based on actual records. This list is.😎
It is well known that the German military had great difficult replacing losses. This did not only apply to manpower, but also to weaponry.
Here are some of the numbers for Normandy.
(losses on the left, replacements on the right)
#HistoryWritersDay22
I'd hoped
#defendingnormandy
would have been released by now, but, like for all of you, it is a waiting game right now. Instead I can offer some teasers.
Volume 1 (well 1a and 1b) will by organised pretty much like this:
@ourpussports
Here you go:
Four Panzer Divs. kinda fully ready for action on D-Day. Rest not so much. 😉
The four considered ready for all offensive operations were the 2nd, 21st, Pz.Lehr and 12.SS-Pz.Divs.
Three of those on correct side of Seine and in or close to Normandy.
I hope this overview of some characteristics of the 'Panzer Reserve' helps to better understand what they were really capable of on D-Day. I may expand this thread to address manpower and/or training issues as well.
If you like to support me, you can at
"To find any Yard for the Soemba
We've searched from the Clyde to the Hoomba
But we haven't got room
For Van Tromp's ruddy Broom
Much less for this useless old Loomba"
G.A. Bassett
For Director of Dockyards
It was answered in a series of poems from other commands
"This is very grave news from the Soemba,
Whose guns are all needed to go boomba,
On a fast nearing day -
Though we cannot say
When exactly will rise the balloonba."
R.K. Dickson
Director of Plans
"These ersats-made guns of the Soemba's
D.G.D. has said times without numbers,
If OPS want nice pops,
At the Huns, then these guns,
Must be changed for some British made Boombas."
V.C. Begg
Gunnery and Anti-Aircraft Warfare
...
Though some of the minutes are just on the verge
I note with regret no proposals emerge.
I can only assume that the Staff and Soemba
Have returned with with relief to their usual Sloemba."
A.B. Cunningham
First Sea Lord
To continue in Dutch:
"Waarom wordt nog niet begonnen
Met verwisselen der kanonnen?
Rijmpjes maken helpt geen zier
Want met pen, inkt en papier
Werd geen oorlog ooit gewonnen"
Van Holthe
Dutch Naval Liaison Off. in Defence of H.N.M.S. "Soemba"
Then the Dutch joined in as well
"After so much backchat it is but right
That Soemba should join in this fight
Because she loves very much
To be rude too, and in Dutch.
So no one can read it, serve you right!"
"It is agreed (in every quarter)
That to get results you oughter,
Make the boomba under water.
As Gun-Boombas aren't my line
I suggest she tries a Mine."
John Cowie
Director of Operations Division (Mining)
"I hasten to say
In no uncertain way
That my personal cares
Are as few as my hairs.
With some satisfaction
I note proposed action
And pass for notation
With gratification."
E.M. Evans-Lombe
Director of Gunnery and Anti-Aircraft Warfare
"Best Plans! Where childlike learning sits
Remote from worldly cares
And leaves to skilled Division its Administry affairs
(With apologies to Oriel College)"
C.C. Hughes Hallett,
Director of Plans (Q)
"This dreadful affair of the Soemba
Is really too hard for a "Plumber"
Referred with a laugh
Straight back to the Staff
for the personal care of E-Loemba*."
Olivir Bevir
Director of Naval Ordnance
*E.M. Evans-Lombe
Which has been freely translated as
"Oh why have you not yet begun
The exchange of (above-mentioned) gun?
How can rhymes help you when,
No ink, paper or pen
Have ever a (bally) war won."
"Soemba has awakened the Staff from repose,
I am amazed, all the same, that they do not propose
To allocate Soemba with modification
(Soft velvet chairs the one stipulation)
To the "Overlord" plan for accommodation
...
Thread: German static divisions in Normandy supposedly had very poor personnel. While true to some extend but as always it's a bit more complicated. Cross-Channel Attack (1951) made a serious attempt for a balanced view. Arguably better than much what has been written since!
Great example of why it is important to check your sources, and your sources' sources, and your sources' sources' sources. The core material is not always what it has been turned into by others.
(and yes, if you come across certain authors there's reason to be extra vigilant)
Damn. Drilling into an account I was going to use and now discover I can't. Still, a lesson in always checking historiography.
The account is from Spitfire pilot Wing Cdr Glover who was spotting for Warspite on D-Day. He describes turbulence from Warspite's shells! Except...
By 1 June the division had a mobility of 20-30%. The battlegroup was still Kampfwert II, and the division as a whole was Kampfwert III: suitable for defensive operations.
A disadvantage of waiting for your book to come out is not really being able to talk about its content. On the other hand... you at least have time to prepare a number of presentations for when it finally does come out. ;-)
Update: my book about German troops in Normandy is making good progress and will be announced soon, once we have figured out the photo to go on the cover...
Yes, I have a clear favorite, but it may be too expensive to use.🙄Perhaps one of you has a brilliant suggestion?
The final Panzer Division in the West was the 11.Pz.Div.
Much like the 9th, it was being reconstituted using its own remnants and the 273.Res.Pz.Div. On 1 May its battlegroup was considered Kampwert II.
For those interested, here's a small overview of when different German years-of-birth started being called up. When you call up more than one year per year you're in a race to the bottom... 🧐
[Ages are simplified and the list only includes years that were called-up in full]
These are the PWs captured up to 30 June (when the Cotentin had been cleared by US forces). The most obvious is the massive presence of men born in 1925-26, making them 17-19 yo. This group amounts to about 19% of all PWs.
"To the foregoing notes on the Soemba
Which imply she is now a back Noemba
You must pay no regard, For she's got to bombard
(As is very well known to E-Loemba)."
E.N. Syfret
Vice-Chief of Naval Staff
One of her guns was out of order. Knowing that replacing it in those busy times would get little priority, A.D. Nicoll decided to make the request as a poem to help move things along.
Yes, a poem.
(image above is of the Flores, used because it shows the guns very well (NIHM))
If you'd like to know more about German armour in Normandy, the talk I did on
@WW2TV
might be of interest. It also covers armour outside of the Panzer Divisions.
80 years ago
#OTD
in
#Normandy44
began a nasty little scrap in and around Bretteville-l'Orgueilleuse.
You can read about it in this little book and follow the battle either here on the ground or using Google Earth. Handy, eh?
Up the Johns!
#WW2
#DDay80
#ShamelessPlug
Although I typically post about German forces, I'm actually just as interested in the allies.
When studying the fighting on the Cotentin peninsula it quickly becomes clear how costly the campaign was for both sides. Here is a casualty list of the infantry regiments of the US 4ID
To celebrate my 1 year Twitter anniversary: a thread of threads, posts, and videos.
And a big thank you to all my followers, friends and Ko-fi supporters. You’ve made 2021 far better than it otherwise would have been.
#OTD
in 1942 Hitler issued his infamous 'commando order'. All allied personnel involved in 'commando operations' was to be killed
This is an Ob.West copy from Russian archives.
#WW2
#SWW
Pick up any book on DDay and you'll find a thorough breakdown of the Allied units.
Harder to find is accurate information about the German defenders. Tonight
@Niels_1944
will run through just exactly what German Armoured units were in Normandy
7.00pm UK
Noticed some typos 😬 Sorry about that.
#editbutton
First message should obviously be "10 mobile divisions, 9 of which were Panzer Divs (1SS, 2SS, 12SS, 2Pz, 9Pz, 11Pz, 21Pz, 116Pz & Pz.Lehr) and 1 was a Pz.Gren.Div. (17SS)"
I know many people are still catching up on all the
#dday80
content from yesterday. But don't forget that much of the heavy fighting only began on the 7th...
Here are some videos I did about that
@Maynardgcrabbs
Despite their best intentions, a lot of scholars are influenced by outdated analysis they trust to be correct. Unless you start digging into the Germans, it's a difficult trap to avoid. Much of our knowledge of the Germans needs to be rebuild. I'm trying to do that with my books
Book update:
The editor *finished* his work on
#defendingnormandy
. My turn to check & answer his questions.
Also means I finally can start to finish maps, graphics and other illustrations. That includes these maps, showing six divisions on 5 June 1944
#WW2
#SWW
#DDay
#Normandy
A standard Wochenschau is a mix of homefront news (political, cultural, sports, war effort) and news from the fighting fronts. The propaganda use of these newsreels is obvious, often expressed through bombastic music and narration. Setbacks are downplayed or go unmentioned. /2
Very special to have been a small part of the process and even more special to be able to attend the ceremony today.
Often it looked like this would never work out, but ultimately everything aligned.
Welcome home . Nathan B. Baskind. May you rest in peace
#Normandy
WE DID IT. 80 years after Nathan B Baskind died and was buried in a German mass grave, he is now resting amongst his American comrads in arms, and under a Star of David grave.
It was an honor to have been a small part of this incredibly emotional journey.
(Thread)
Since people are asking
@ww2tv
when my book about German troops on the Cotentin Peninsula will be out, it's only fair I explain what's going on myself...
#defendingnormandy
#Normandy
#WW2
Famous photo but almost always miscaptioned. There is an account from a soldier who was there when this photo was taken. It wasn't really *near* St.Lô, but close to Carentan. The US public was very familiar with St.Lô so many captions simplified things so people could relate.. 🧐
D-day had been long expected by both the Allies and Germans. But, when it finally began, what was the German population told by the weekly newsreel?
#dday80
Thread
Ever noticed that documentaries all seem to use the same German footage? That’s because many weekly newsreels (Die Deutsche Wochenschau) survived the war and are now the prime source of moving footage. Let’s explore the first newsreel for the landings in Normandy. /1
Ever wondered what a German Table of Organization and Equipment (TO/E) looks like?
Let's take a look.
A Kriegsstärkenachweisung (KStN) has a unique number and date. This is KStN 131n of 1 May 1944 which covers a standard infantry company in mid-1944.