Congratulations
@MPaparinskis
! Today history was made as the first Baltic candidate π±π» πͺπͺ π±πΉ got elected to the
#ILC
. We thank all UN πΊπ³ Member States for their support. Best of luck to Dr. Paparinskis and all newly elected ILC βοΈ members!
#Latvia4ILC
β‘οΈ
Text of the draft conclusions on peremptory norms of general international law (jus cogens) and Annex, adopted by the
#ILC_2022
Drafting Committee on second reading, has been issued
Latvia is proud to nominate
@MPaparinskis
as the first Baltic candidate to the International Law Commission elections in 2021. We thank Estonia&Lithuania for their endorsement! π±π»πͺπͺπ±πΉ
#Latvia4ILC
Join an interactive dialogue on 24 February 10.00 AM (EST)
β‘οΈ
Is there an exception to the principle of full reparation under intβl law for cases where full compensation is crippling for the responsible State or its peoples? My answer now up on
@ModernLRev
early view (Open Access)
Delighted to see the formidable Professor Charlesworth elected to
@CIJ_ICJ
; chuffed that
@UN
fully endorsed Latvian
@PCA_CPA
Groupβs nomination of this eminently well-qualified candidate; enjoyed our talks of intβl law, courts, and institutions during this Intβl Law Week in NY
The great minds of international law
@philippesands
@PietEeckhout
@Lorand_Bartels
@usualcaveat
have already weighed in on the law of treaties on fundamental change of circumstances. I have nothing more to contribute on substance but do want to add a historical wrinkle. 1/n
BS Chimni on
@ejiltalk
Advance Access, a very interesting reflection on the 2001 ILC Articles on State responsibility for internationally wrongful acts
Eco Oro v Colombia Partial Dissent [9] is that rare piece of legal writing that needs no elaboration to be appreciated as an immediate classic h/t
@IAReporter
First (public) citation by a State of my work on crippling compensation: Uganda (Pellet) in
@CIJ_ICJ
Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (DRC v Uganda) (Reparations) CR 2021/12 (30 April 2021) 67
PRESS RELEASE: the public hearings on the preliminary objections raised by Venezuela in the case concerning the Arbitral Award of 3 October 1899 (
#Guyana
v.
#Venezuela
) concluded today before the
#ICJ
. The Court will now begin its deliberation
A propos nothing in particular, do tweets count as State conduct for the purpose of attribution under international law of State responsibility?
@wto
panel in Saudi ArabiaβIP says yes, for βthe tweets [that] are in fact governmental tweetsβ
Is there an exception to the principle of full reparation in int'l investment arbitration for cases in which full compensation is crippling for the responsible State or its peoples? My answer forthcoming in
@icsid
Review now available on Open Access
Delighted to open my
@UN
Intβl Law Week by moderating Panel Discussion 1 of the Informal Meeting of Legal Advisors on Pacific Settlement of Disputes beyond Contentious Settlement
@IndiaUNNewYork
(photo credits
@LexOceana
)
π’ Panel Alert!
At the 33rd Informal Meeting of Legal Advisers happening today:
π Panel 1 will focus on "Pacific Settlement of Disputes: Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in International Law: Conciliation and Mediation Efforts"
Moderator: Mr.
@MPaparinskis
, Member πΊπ³ ILC
I am struck by the fact that (almost) no States in the mega-claims argue that, as a matter of customary law of State responsibility, reparations cannot result in depriving the population of a State of its means of subsistence. 1/n
The Tribunal has rendered its Award in the case of ConocoPhillips Petrozuata B.V., ConocoPhillips Hamaca B.V. and ConocoPhillips Gulf of Paria B.V. v. Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela
READ HERE: a summary of the
#ICJ
Judgment on the question of reparations in the case concerning Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (
#DRC
v.
#Uganda
)
I look forward to speaking later today on 'Obligations Erga Omnes as a Distinct Category of International Obligations' in the
@unimib
@esil_sedi
conference 'The Concept of Obligation in International Law'
Only 3 days left for the conference on The Concept of Obligation in International Law organized by
@unimib
with support from
@esil_sedi
!
For online participation, please contact g.losi3
@campus
.unimib.it.
READ HERE: summary of
#ICJ
Judgment in case concerning the Appeal Relating to the Jurisdiction of the ICAO Council under Article II, Section 2, of the 1944 International Air Services Transit Agreement (
#Bahrain
,
#Egypt
and
#UnitedArabEmirates
v.
#Qatar
)
Congratulations to the newly elected
@CIJ_ICJ
members, who happen to include all the nominees of the Latvian
@PCA_CPA
group β as bittersweet as it is to lose the
#ILC_2023
colleague
@BogdanAurescu
I congratulate the newly elected members of the International Court of Justice
@CIJ_ICJ
for a 9 year term beginning 6 February 2024:
π·π΄ Bogdan-Lucian Aurescu
π¦πΊ Hilary Charlesworth
πΊπΈ Sarah Hull Cleveland
π²π½ Juan Manuel GΓ³mez Robledo Verduzco
πΏπ¦ Dire Tladi
By far not the most important point about
@CIJ_ICJ
Qatar v UAE provisional measures but worth noting the very subtle discussion of general principles β a point on which adjudicators are often sub-optimal β by two great minds who have thought about this for a very long time. 1/n
MULTIMEDIA: photos and videos of the public hearings on the Request for the indication of provisional measures submitted by the United Arab Emirates in the case of
#Qatar
v.
#UAE
before the
#ICJ
are available here
It may be that everybody already knows this but Iran-US Claims Tribunal has a new webpage, , with a supremely user-friendly search engine, a clear improvement upon the slightly idiosyncratic previous system. Dare one hope for a IUSCT
@Twitter
handle next?
There is here a clash of Grundnormen (in the wild): Mathias Kruck and Ors v Spain, ICSID Case no ARB/15/23, Decision on Reconsideration, 6 Dec 2021; h/t for uncovering the decision to the, as ever, indispensable
@IAReporter
The bittersweet end of the last meeting of
#ILC_2023
, many thanks to all my indispensable assistants throughout, particularly the brilliant Baltic(-based) team of the last week
@MRaminta
@AlexBDeslandes
@JuliaVassileva
π±πΉπ±π»πͺπͺ
A supremely niche law of treaties point touched upon obliquely in the last weekβs
@CIJ_ICJ
Qatar v UAE judgment: what is the place of unrelated treaties on the same topic (pari materiae) within the principles of treaty interpretation reflected in VCLT arts 31-32? 1/n
READ HERE: summary of the
#ICJ
Judgment on the preliminary objections raised by the United Arab Emirates in the case concerning Application of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (
#Qatar
v.
#UAE
)
Still at the
@UN
Delegates Lounge, delighted to finally meet in person the Chairperson of the
#ILC2021
Drafting Committee and the Co-chair of the Study Group on the Sea-level Rise
@PatrciaGalvoTe1
Statement of the Chairperson of
#ILC_2022
Drafting Committee on the draft principles on protection of the environment in relation to armed conflicts, made earlier today
I am thrilled to announce that the 2nd edition of our textbook by
@CUP_Law
will hit shelves in April! The cover image, βOxygenβ, reflects our joint hope that the follow-up to our 1st will be a breath of fresh air to all followers of intβl investment law.
@ProfCLLim
@MPaparinskis
Join us for this in-person lecture on Friday 14 October 2022 in the Centre's Finley Library/Berkowitz seminar room with Professor Martins Paparinskis
@MPaparinskis
@ucl
All welcome to attend. More info:
Breakfast discussion co-organized by π±π»π²π½π·π΄ on
#ILC
and Compensation in the Law of
#StateResponsibility
was moderated by
@MPaparinskis
with panelists from π²π½πΊπ¬π·π΄π΅ππ¨π¦.
The wide attendance reflects the importance of this topic for
@UN
members.
I look forward to hosting
@SundhyaPahuja
next Thursday for
@UCLLaws
Current Legal Problems Lecture 'Empire Comes Home: Three Phases in the Struggle to Decolonise International Law'
Sign-up details π
π’ Upcoming Current Legal Problems Lecture (online)
Empire Comes Home: Three Phases in the Struggle to Decolonise International Law
Speaker: Professor
@SundhyaPahuja
, University of Melbourne
Date: Thursday 3 March
Book your free place now:
Tonight, look forward to hosting
@DCHovell
@LSELaw
Current Legal Problems
@UCLLaws
lecture 'The Limits of Positivism in International Law', chaired by Lord Sales
Sign-up details π
On Thursday 18 November, Dr Devika Hovell (Associate Professor in Public International Law
@LSELaw
) will deliver an online lecture on 'The Limits of Positivism in International Law', chaired by Lord Sales.
Book your free place now
Far from the key issue in the case but worth flagging the possibility that the
@CIJ_ICJ
or a Judge writing individually may say something of interest to investment law(yers) on fair and equitable treatment (FET), one of the primary rules invoked in the case. 1/n
REMINDER: the
#ICJ
will deliver its Judgment on the preliminary objections raised in the case concerning Alleged Violations of the 1955 Treaty of Amity, Economic Relations, and Consular Rights (
#Iran
v.
#USA
) tomorrow, 3 February 2021, at 3 p.m. (The Hague)
Friday afternoon in the
@UN
Delegates Lounge, delighted to crystallise in a selfie the meeting this week of the
#ILC
Co-chair of the Study Group on the Sea-level Rise
@niluferoral
What is the customary law on law of treaties and armed conflicts? This is an important question not often directly addressed in intβl dispute settlement, which makes YamantΓΌrk and Ors v Syria all the more important (h/t to the great
@IAReporter
team for uncovering the award) 1/n
Look forward to discussing 'Crippling Compensation after the Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo Case' with
@pierre_dargent
at the
@AthensPIL
Discussion Group next Wednesday
π’ Third AthensPIL Discussion Group: A discussion with Dr.
@MPaparinskis
and Prof.
@pierre_dargent
π 23 February 2022, 18.30 EET
ππΌRegistration and more information on the link below
Can the COVID-19 global pandemic affect foundational elements of the international legal order, in particular the generalist vocabulary of State responsibility? My answer now up on
@AJIL_Unbound
(free to read)
Look forward to speaking at the Latvian Parliament about three dimensions of int'l law and relations thinking of our first President: a professor of public int'l law, the head of Latvia's delegation to the Paris Peace Conference, and a great supporter of the League of Nations
Required reading for generalist intβl lawyers thinking through the consequences of Covid-19: one of the first contributions on the role of State responsibility,
In his essay,
@MPaparinskis
poses "three sets of questions helpful for calibrating the Monetary Gold principle for the modern world..." read the full essay here:
Look forward to chairing next Thursday night (23 November) at
@UCLLaws
an important talk by
@yanwen_zhang
'Appointing Adjudicators in Investor-State Arbitration and International Dispute Settlement'
Join our event next Thurs 23 November on 'Appointing Adjudicators in Investor-State Arbitration and International Dispute Settlement'
Speaker:
@yanwen_zhang
(PhD candidate, UCL Laws)
Chair:
@MPaparinskis
(Professor of Public International Law, UCL Laws)
4 hours to go until my
#ASIANSIL2021
talk on the future of State responsibility and the Asian perspective. The right time for brewing an excessively late coffee and flicking through the classic text and the most recent addition to the State responsibility library
Look forward to speaking on Wednesday (2 am BST/11 am AEST) at the
#ASIANSIL2021
@AsianSil
Panel 20 on the future of the law of State responsibility, with an eye to tensions between universal and regional and particularly the Asian perspective
If what is missing from your life is a snappy authority for the basic proposition about different roles of adjudicators in domestic and international legal orders, I give you Ayat Nizar Raja Sumrain and others v Kuwait
A question for public international law/international dispute settlement aficionados: in how many previous int'l disputes have States been represented by their heads of government? PM Mosaddegh in the Anglo-Iranian Oil Co. case, obviously, but apart from that?
Is abuse of rights a general principle, a rule of international law, a notion, or an annoying distraction? My answer in a deep-dive review of Jan Paulsson's new book in Arbitration International now up on Advance Access
The
@CIJ_ICJ
President Donoghue currently speaking to the
@UN
Sixth Committee on the subject matter βThe Roles of International Judge And Foreign Ministry Lawyerβ
Prof
@MPaparinskis
(Professor of Public International Law at UCL Laws) will be speaking at 'The UN International Law Commission in 2023: A Conversation', discussing the role & relevance of the ILC
π Wednesday 29 November
β° 6:15pm
π« Online & in person
Statement of the Chairperson of
#ILC_2022
Drafting Committee on the draft articles on Immunity of
State officials from foreign criminal jurisdiction, made earlier today
@Concha_EscobarH
Still time to bookβ³
27 Sept: What next for the International Law Commission?
Spks Prof Dapo Akande, Prof Phoebe Okowa & Martins Paparinskis
Give their views on the future work of the Commission.
Hybrid event
Supported by
@EssexCourtLaw
First (public) citation by a State as a non-disputing Party in international dispute settlement '21:
@StateDept
in Angel Samuel Seda and others v. Republic of Colombia
Watch Dr Devika Hovell's (
@LSELaw
) Current Legal Problems Lecture from December 2021, which acknowledges the limitations of positivism as a means through which to understand the development of international law and the international legal system
If you expected
@ICC_arbitration
ISDS cases by Turkish construction companies to raise the most fascinating intβl law questions of our times, well done. With h/t to
@IAReporter
, Cengiz v Libya muses on interplay of jurisdiction, title, UNSC Ch VII Res, no-fly zones, and Bankovic
I donβt have a particular punchline here, just to say that opposition to any/broad form of fundamental change of circumstances has been UKβs policy since Gladstone. Good realpolitik reasons for Great Powers to insist upon formal rule of law in treaty matters. Right AND smart. FIN
Look forward to hosting on 24 November
@UCLLaws
@UCLCLP
lecture 'The Advisory Function of International Courts and Tribunals' by Professor
@PatrciaGalvoTe1
, chaired by Professor Vaughan Lowe
Details π
One month to go: Join us online or in person for 'The Advisory Function of International Courts and Tribunals' by Prof PatrΓcia GalvΓ£o Teles
@PatrciaGalvoTe1
, as part of the Current Legal Problems Lecture Series 2022-23. Thursday 24 November, 6pm-7pm GMT
Delighted to field the hard questions this morning from the stellar international lawyers of
@agcsingapore
, grateful for the very fine moderation to
@UCLLaws
alumnus
@ashley_j_ong
A formalist take on the intervention that launched a 1000 memes: why 'specific and limited'? A (quick and superficial) search through the usual suspects -- ICJ/ILC/RIAA/UN Ybks/conferences -- shows no context where that phrase has established technical meaning. My 2 1/2 answers:
π¨ Brandon Lewis confirms the Government will break international law on EU Withdrawal Deal:
"Yes, this does break international law in a very specific and limited way".
Very pleased to experience the vibrant atmosphere of public international law academia as a Visiting Researcher at the Department of Legal Studies of the University of Bologna.
What is abuse of rights in international law? Some preliminary thoughts in an extended review of Jan Paulsson's new book now published in (2021) 37 Arbitration International 387
Apparently my 2013 monograph is still good (customary) law on denial of justice, Gramercy Funds Management LLC and Gramercy Peru Holdings LLC v. Republic of Peru (
@icsid
Case no UNCT/18/2), Award, 6 December 2022,