Larry Chapp Profile
Larry Chapp

@LarryChappGS22

1,847
Followers
760
Following
1
Media
688
Statuses

Follow me at my blog:

Joined December 2023
Don't wanna be here? Send us removal request.
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
The saddest part about the new “clarification” from the DDF, mere days after FS was dropped on the church very non-synodally, is the sheer cartoonish incompetence of the whole affair. The DDF looks like a pure amateur hour outfit right now. Fernandez comes across as desperate and
33
33
235
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
This was not a misunderstanding. The actors saw it as a reenactment of the Last Supper. So the Lefty, virtue signaling Catholics can just shut up now. The French bishops condemned it and the Olympic officials did not respond by denying it was about the Last Supper.,
@AMJalsevac
Annette Jals
2 months
@rightscholar The actors seemed to think it was the Last Supper.
2
9
42
20
28
227
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
Behold what it is the current pontificate thinks counts as a genuine attempt at Church reform. Who in their right mind thinks that the average Catholic gives a damn about "synodal" anything? The Pope who began his pontificate with fulsome denunciations of a "self referential
30
23
209
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
21 days
What is most sad about the Pope's comments here is that it does not surprise us anymore. He avoids saying that all religions are "equal" paths to God but he does not really need to. It is implied in his comparison of religions with languages. Christ just gives us a different
@CatholicSat
Catholic Sat
21 days
Pope Francis to children in Singapore: "All religions are paths to reach God. They are—to make a comparison—like different languages, different dialects, to get there. But God is God for everyone. If you start to fight saying 'my religion is more important than yours, mine is
Tweet media one
4K
4K
27K
26
30
186
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
On the Ephesians controversy: how many men love their wives as Christ loves his church? I won’t wait for an answer since I know it. The answer is zero. The standard response to this fact is that nobody is expecting men to be perfect or sinless and so all Paul is saying is that
50
23
183
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
I was asked by Word on Fire to pen a response to a risible article by Heidi Schlumpf in US Catholic wherein she claims that conservative Catholics do not understand Aquinas and only like him because they hate ambiguity and seek simplistic black and white answers to complex
24
19
167
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
Why was today’s lectionary reading from Samuel so butchered in its edit? In fact, why are the readings shortened and edited at all? Why do some anonymous, bureaucratic, clerical twits with degrees in pastoral torture from Fordham or Marquette have the power to edit the lectionary
34
18
159
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
It is really amazing how someone this obtuse has gained such notoriety. This statement plays in the sandbox of a puerile false dichotomy, is condescending, and in its targeting of Catholics who love Eucharistic processions, mean spirited. I love Eucharistic adoration. And I run a
@austeni
Austen Ivereigh
3 months
“The revival focuses on individual rather than community …. on me and Jesus rather than the communion of Christians. It focuses on what happens to bread & wine rather than what happens to the community … on personal experience rather than mission.”
69
9
74
19
16
156
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
A lot of people are reading the Fernandez book and asking, "Oh my, how does a priest know such things??" But to me it reads like someone who has fantasized about having sex more than actually having it. It reads like a pulp romance novel, "I caressed his lips, oh my, how our
13
15
148
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
The number one problem for me with Michael Lofton's "Reason and Theology" channel is not that it is uncharitable to papal critics. My chief problem is that it is just boring. I can never get through an entire episode. I rarely get past five minutes.
21
5
139
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
8 months
In my 65 years of life there is one thing, and really only one thing, I have learned about the American government. And that is that it lies. It lies about everything. And then it lies about its lies. And so when a senior person in our government with access to sensitive
8
18
126
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
RIP Phil Donahue. I could not stand his show, his politics and his "version" of Catholicism. But he has passed and is now in need of our prayers. As will we all need prayers when we die.
11
10
128
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
This is why I do not trust Calvin Robinson. It represents the typical conflation of an alleged theological orthodoxy with populist right wing politics. No matter your view on immigration (and mine are pro legal immigration) this video at face value depicts an excessive use of
22
11
125
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
Last week I had a private chat with a traditionalist who was chiding me for my defense of John Paul II. He said, mockingly, "Oh yes, the Pope of overly long encyclicals nobody reads anymore." He then recommended instead the Summa. You can't make this stuff up.
20
4
111
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
What strikes me about both of the major party political conventions is that they are strange rituals where millionaire politicians, made rich through legal influence peddling from other rich people, spend a week trying to convince us that they are all about "the little guy".
9
19
109
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
With no denial from its creators, it does seem that the opening ceremony did indeed engage in a drag queen mockery of the Lord’s Supper, even if it then morphed into a bit on Dionysius. Pathetic and a sign of the degradation of French culture
18
14
109
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
I went to confession last week. I got a really good blessing from the priest even though I am a sinner. Apparently, this kind of accompaniment has been standard practice in the Church for millennia. Who knew?
10
10
106
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
5 months
My latest in Catholic World Report. It is a rebuttal to the truly awful essay by Massimo Faggioli in Commonweal a week or so ago.
16
18
101
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
Great article in The Pillar by Ed Condon on the intrigue surrounding O’Malley’s replacement. The whole article is fascinating, but what caught my eye is the fact that the proven liar and disgraced protege of McCarrick, the prissy Donald Wuerl, crawled out of hiding to lobby Pope
11
10
98
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
Steve Millies is such a despicable hack. And it is a sign of the utter intellectual bankruptcy of the Catholic Left that this guy is considered credible. He shares the typical blindspot of those on the Left for their own incendiary rhetoric and their condoning of actual
@carleolson
Carl E. Olson
3 months
Well, there you go. True colors. As expected. I'm not surprised in the least. There's been plenty of nasty political rhetoric for decades. But Trump, whatever you think of him, has been demonized unrelentingly in ways that are hysterical, incendiary, and inciting. #Pathetic
10
9
78
7
9
96
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
It never ceases to amaze me that those who think it heretical to hope for an empty hell almost always leap to the conclusion that this hope means that there are "no consequences" for our actions. As if a punishment has to be eternal in order for it to make our actions mean
32
9
92
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
7 months
Christopher Altieri on the total failure of the Francis papacy on the issue of sexual abuse. Scathing in its truth-telling.
11
35
85
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
I read the Instrumentum laboris for the Synod this morning. I thought it was very good. All of the nonsense about LGBTQ outreach and women's ordination is gone. The whole focus is on a true synodalism from within an ecclesiology of communion. It is in many ways a very solid
17
7
85
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
The one thing that really strikes me the most about FS is how its production and promulgation were completely contrary to synodality. The CO2 was still in the atmosphere from all of the jets bringing synod participants home when this document comes out of the Vatican without
7
18
74
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
And make no mistake. The mainstream French Catholic Church has enabled this cultural septic tank by turning a blind eye to it and “making nice” with the seculars. And when the minority of French Catholics who still attend Mass started attending the TLM in response to the
8
9
77
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
5 months
So Facebook has removed my CWR article on Faggioli since they say it violates their community standards. It most certainly does not. I have requested a review but doubt it will produce much. They never give details or reasons for these things. First time this has ever happened to
13
7
72
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
4 months
Hello, 1975 called. It wants its false dichotomy back.
3
6
67
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
It is possible to hold the following three positions at the same time without the slightest contradiction: 1. God loves everyone and wills their well-being on every level of their existence. 2. Fiducia Supplicans is a pastoral mistake 3. Position #2 flows naturally from #1 .
6
11
61
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
A friend emailed me and said, "Man, this Church of ours is wearing me out. So much nonsense going on." To which I replied, "Yes, that is true, but that is the glory of it, no? Show me another Christian communion that is so consequential that what it does in even minor things of
4
5
58
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
5 months
Well, well, it seems the German bishops have a headache on their hands. A new survey shows around 75-80% of young German priests disagree with all of the proposals in the German synodal way.
5
2
54
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@GeraldMurray8 @dianemontagna The whole sad affair is unraveling before their eyes. Pope Francis overreached and this experiment in incrementalism was seen for what it was.
1
5
53
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
Cardinal Fernandez has stated in an interview in The Pillar that FC is indeed a repudiation of what the Germans are proposing. Excuse me, but did not the DDF already do that in 2021? Why then a "new" document?
7
10
47
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
My latest in The National Catholic Register. I compare the two ministries to homosexuals in the American Catholic Church: Outreach and Courage. As I make clear, I think Courage is the far better of the two.
6
13
48
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
If there is nothing new in Fiducia Supplicans then why was it issued? If all it is saying is that priests can and should bless those who are sinners then why was there a need for a new "Declaration" to repeat that which is already obvious?
9
7
42
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
And shame on all of the Lefty American Catholics who were quick to defend it just so they could virtue signal about how open minded they are and how dumb conservatives are.
3
3
46
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
8 months
One good thing about very progressive universities cancelling conservative voices in the name of DEI sensitivities is that Catholic universities can no longer be accused of violating academic freedom when they terminate teachers who espouse things contrary to the faith. CUA
2
9
43
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
I have read parts of the 1998 book by Cardinal Fernandez that has been leaked to the press. The parts that I have read are indeed graphic. But I do not detect anything that you could call heretical. To me it reads like the stuff from the early Christopher West on steroids.
28
5
44
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
My latest interview. This one was with the wonderful Brant Pitre. We discuss his excellent new book, "Jesus and Divine Christology". The book makes the claim that the New Testament, including the Synoptics, do present us with a historical Jesus who made divine claims for
3
4
43
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@carleolson He is such a despicable hack. And it is a sign of the utter intellectual bankruptcy of the Catholic Left that this guy is considered credible. He shares the typical blindspot of those on the Left for their own incendiary rhetoric and their condoning of actual violence.
3
4
41
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@FeserEdward It truly is! I was thinking that exact thought as the priest was droning on and on in his secular therapeutic mode. I could handle and appreciate a little ferverino drawn from a saint or a doctor of the church. But this therapeutic garbage is indeed a penance.
2
0
41
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@JLLiedl One theory was that Fiducia was meant as a way to get ahead of some of the Europeans on this issue. So, unless there are disciplinary measures against bishops like this then it would seem that theory holds no weight.
9
0
36
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
21 days
@kalezelden Shocking really how theologically shallow the pope's remarks are. This is indeed a throwback to the pluralism of religions theology of the 70's. It was the academic wing of felt banner Catholicism.
4
4
38
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
1
0
38
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
Finally joined this crazy platform. I hope I don’t live to regret it.
19
1
37
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@EduardusUrsus His belief that he still has influence in Rome shows that he has not been disabused of this belief by his fellow American bishops. He should have been shunned and shamed by his brother bishops and told to remain hidden, silent, and in a state of prayer and penance. But of
1
2
37
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
29 days
Rome “synodals” while the world burns – Catholic World Report
3
9
34
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
My latest in The National Catholic Register. I was asked to write a brief essay on Sacrosanctum Concilium. There is obviously a lot more that could be said...
5
5
32
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
My latest interview. This one is with Dr. Eduardo Echeverria of Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit. We discuss the deceptive and problematic nature of the ministry of Fr. James Martin.
1
4
31
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@amywelborn2 Perfectly expressed. The problem with all of this is precisely that it is a way of speaking that gets us used to equating sexual pleasure with spiritual fulfillment and getting closer to God. Rupnik did this with vulnerable adult women, but other priests have groomed their
1
3
30
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
Why I signed “An Open Letter from the Americas to Pope Francis” – Catholic World Report
1
5
31
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
My latest interview. This one is with my old friend and former seminary classmate, Bishop James Conley of Lincoln Nebraska. We discuss Bishop Conley's just released pastoral letter on Catholic education. It is a truly wonderful letter. A great conversation on an important topic
2
6
30
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
My latest interview. I had the honor of interviewing Dr. Scott Hahn as we discuss his recent article in Communio on the approach to biblical exegesis in the thought of Pope Benedict.
0
4
30
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
4 months
Tweet media one
2
1
29
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
17 days
@carleolson @firstthingsmag Saw this. Sad. Such hate and bitterness. A disturbed soul.
4
1
29
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
@FrHarrison I too saw his comment on this and cringed. Shocking that someone who claims to represent the Christian faith would be cheering on the attempted murder of immigrants no matter how illegal their attempts at entry might be. This is excessive force pure and simple and should be
4
2
27
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@JLLiedl I think the key here is in your point about "dying European churches". The national episcopal bodies which have presided over the death spiral of their churches have no right to hold their views up as models for all others to follow.
4
2
27
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
Yesterday I compared the lurid and graphic nature of Tucho’s book to the early work of Christopher West “on steroids”. This led many to think I was dismissing its seriousness. Far from it and the opposite. I should have realized that many on here are not aware of the deeply
6
0
28
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
6 months
Linked is my latest interview. It is part of a new series in which I am collaborating with the journal Communio: International Catholic Review (North American edition). In every issue of Communio I will be interviewing one of the author's of an article in that edition. My very
5
1
28
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
5 months
My latest in the Register. Inspired by Tracey Rowland's recent article in Communio on the topic, I wrote a brief essay on the misuse of the "people of God" metaphor by leaders of the Synod and the destructiveness of its false notion of a more "democratic" Church.
3
3
27
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@Sophiologist_ @NewsJennifer @TheAtlantic This is how you circumvent democracy by forcing the validly elected candidate out of office thereby nullifying votes, and then installing a new candidate chosen by back room deals.
6
0
26
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
21 days
@ddeanetheology Well said yourself! This stupid notion that there is this genus called "religion" and then below that are the various "species" of religion is beyond silly. No serious scholar of religion buys into that idea. Only certain kinds of Christian theologians do -- the kind who are
1
3
25
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@BishopBarron This was amazing and wonderful! Welcome to the Catholic faith Shia!
0
1
23
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@FeserEdward The Pope also approved of the document issued by the DDF in 2021 on the topic, but then apparently grumbled about it immediately. It seems that this Pope likes to set fires but then gets mad when they start to consume his own house, and then looks around immediately for someone
3
0
22
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@gailfinke Yes, even for her. And that is a low bar
0
1
23
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
The Big Synod in Rome did not achieve the goals the progressives wanted. Critics of the Synod who thought the Synod was a stalking horse for something else were told we were attacking a straw man. Question: how “synodal” is FS? Straw man? How about a little fire scarecrow?
1
2
22
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
Cardinal Fernandez has now said that what some European dioceses are doing with gay blessings goes too far and is contrary to Fiducia. Perhaps, therefore, instead of issuing Fiducia he should have enforced the 2021 DDF decree that said ... you know... "stop doing that". And
3
4
20
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
8 months
In our ten years on our Catholic Worker Farm we have never done a fundraiser. But circumstances now warrant one. We are an official non profit. The link below explains the details:
0
4
21
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
@JordanW41069857 I agree. Every word of his I don’t know I write down, look up, and try to use again
1
0
21
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@dianemontagna Wow. Just wow. What crazy times we live in. I honestly do not know what to think about this. I am no fan of Lofton's show and a big fan of Cardinal Zen. But one wonders if this is the best way to address things.
8
0
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@M_P_Hazell Don’t mind at all!
1
0
20
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
8 months
My latest podcast interview. This one was on the intellectual legacy of the late, great, David L. Schindler. I am joined by his son, David C. Schindler and the poet/playwrite/theologian, Reuben Slife of New Polity. I am also joined by my former colleague, Rodney Howsare.
1
5
20
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
I am assuming that these wonderful blessings are also available to LGBTQ folks. Why isn’t James Martin talking about this? Seems like a wonderful opportunity.
1
0
21
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@DJimRussell Well, that is how I read it. And I will tell the truth no matter how it can be spun by others. It is graphic and what is scandalous is that it comes from the head of the DDF. But what it is, is a bastardization of the TOB. Should Fernandez resign? Yes? And if he does not, should
3
2
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
6 months
My latest interview. This one is with Dr. Paul Seaton. We discuss political theory with a focus on Pierre Manent, Remi Brague and Joseph Ratzinger
1
4
20
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@EdwardPentin So, so spot-on. What I would not give for this man to be the next pope.
1
0
20
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@M_P_Hazell The issues you raise are all valid. I was given a 1200 word limit. Yikes. Hard to embrace all of the complex nuances of this topic in 1200 words!
1
0
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
9 months
@dianemontagna Oh to be a fly on that wall!
0
0
18
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@JMWSPT I never engage him since he is so manifestly stupid, as are the other "writers" at NCR. Heidi Schlumpf, for example, is a complete moron. And Michael Sean Winters is just vicious, tedious and idiotic. This article is par for the course. However, at the very least it acts as a
2
1
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
@DawnofMercy @gloria_purvis And yet you throw your support behind an equally awful party that was once home to most Catholics. The descent of that once proud party into its current sorry state began with McGovern in 1972. You seem blissfully untroubled by your party’s support for child surgical mutilation,
3
2
18
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
5 months
Latest interview. A great conversation with Kale Zelden on Vatican II as a "hyper object". We also discuss the AP story last week on the surging numbers of young and conservative Catholics.
5
3
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@JLLiedl An enormously important article Jonathan. Excellent work!
1
0
19
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
10 months
So what is new here? It is the assertion that there is a new class of blessings that is now official: blessings for those in "irregular unions" who need not express a desire for repentance before receiving a blessing. It is a don't ask don't tell" blessing.
2
2
17
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
Sad and telling
1
1
18
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
I am puzzled about something. I know President Biden has Covid. But his doctor says he is doing fine and is on the mend. That is great news. So why has he not made a public appearance? Heck, even Reagan and John Paul, after they were shot and in hospital, waved at reporters and
6
0
17
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
7 months
My latest interview which is with the Dominican, Fr. Peter Totleben. We discuss many topics relating to the current state of the Church.
2
1
17
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@ProfessorName I am no fan of this papacy at all. For many, many reasons. But he is still the Pope and could still do a lot of damage between now and the end of his papacy. Therefore, I think it behooves us, no matter how painful, to acknowledge when they do something good
1
0
15
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
1 month
@JordanW41069857 I am reading his new book. Loving it
0
0
16
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
2 months
@sitsio John Paul
1
0
16
@LarryChappGS22
Larry Chapp
3 months
@Frankenhouse5 Dorothy Day and von Balthasar would have heaped scorn on Millies. Ever read some of Balthasar’s jeremiads against the Catholic Left? Scorched earth. And how is what I wrote “tribal ideology?” Pointing out the fetid hypocrisy of the Left does not imply that I endorse the Right.
2
0
16