London Capital & Finance raised £237m from 11,605 savers before collapsing - Jan 2019. SFO are investigating. FSCS faced legal action. FCA was investigated.
The Chancellor should postpone Mr Bailey’s installation as Governor of the Bank of England until an independent inquiry into failures of financial regulation during Mr Bailey’s tenure as Chief Executive of the Financial Conduct Authority has taken place.
#TreasuryQuestions
LCF savers are taking legal action against
@FSCS
@TheFCA
and
@FSCS
have endorsed dodgy loopholes, attempted to re-label ISA accounts as “high risk mini-bonds” so as to blame investors and generally sought to wash their hands of the affair.
The City regulator is facing new criticism over its handling of the £237 million London Capital & Finance investment scandal from an independent commissioner.
Charles Randell tells
@rushanaraali
“the FCA aren’t the primary cause of harm but they made big mistakes”.
Their mistake was their failure to protect innocent savers and authorised a Ponzi scheme selling bonds and ISA’s. Savers did not buy mini bonds.
The irony!
13 Feb 2020 -
@TheFCA
updated LCF Q&A's which included: "consider the possible dangers of sharing your personal information and experience".
2 words are missing at the end: “with us”.
Former judge hits out at watchdog over delays to savings collapse investigation.
Protesters outside the FCA meet with the FCA's then CEO Andrew Bailey to make complaints about being victims of bank fraud on 6th Dec 2019.
Andrew Bailey jeered at during public meeting
The LCF spotlight burns brightly. Re Lendy,
@TheFCA
is “investigating itself” & putting itself in a position where it determines whether it’s own failure might give rise for the need for compensation.
If auditors are responsible for spotting fraud in company accounts, the assumption has to be that they don’t actually audit accounts at all. LCF Fraud was prolific. If it’s clearly obvious to bondholders- how could Ernst & Young &
@PwC
ignore it?
@ianbeckett
@premnsikka
@FRCnews
He added that he was only concerned by the Big Four’s stranglehold of the listed audit market [...] and insisted that auditors are responsible for spotting fraud in company accounts.
Following overwhelming support from MP’s, we have now written to
@JohnGlenUK
on behalf of the 2000+ LCF Bondholders in our group. The 17/12 announcement was vague leading to great anxiety. For many, time is now critical.
Can bondholders expect the return of their capital in full?
1. LCF was not a firm that flew under the radar. It advertised prominently & its bosses were well known. When its bonds started failing, investors shouted loudly. Yet regulators seemed to be blind & deaf to all the signs that something was going wrong.
Andrew Bailey &
@TheFCA
are facing even more criticism over regulatory failure.
@FT
has discovered something else that the FCA doesn’t do!
FCA cannot be trusted with its supervisory and enforcement activities. A government review is urgent as investors feel at risk.
1.
@FSCS
seriously misled savers with their email replies to the question “is LCF FSCS protected”. They stated “LCF are authorised by the FCA and therefore covered by the FSCS up to £50,000.
Having done due diligence with
@FCA
& FSCS, savers invested £000s in bonds & ISAs.
SCM's Alan Miller says Woodford debacle highlights need for independent ‘root and branch review’ of
@TheFCA
.
He believes investors are being ‘appallingly neglected’ under Mr. Bailey ‘who should do the honourable thing & resign’
via
@thisismoney
John Russell-Murphy of LCF and Surge always had a great deal to say when lying in person to 30 wealthy investors. He has now declined all invitations to meet the administrator who have now forced a meeting under S236 of the Insolvency Act.
@FSCS
@APPGbanking
@TheFCA
@retheauditors
@premnsikka
The Telegraph’s
@RachelMillardAS
’s piece today on the
#LCF
crews John Russell-Murphy .. we’ll be hearing a lot more very soon about the “dark world” of John Russell-Murphy and the remainder of the “Grosvenor Motley Crew” ..
Regulation is a word no longer trusted.
No matter how you spin the brave new word, it is not going to work unless the foundations of the FCA are changed.
Mini bonds shouldn’t be promoted in MSM.
@TheFCA
is still clearing up the mess in the wake of the London Capital & Finance scandal.
Retail investors need to avoid mini bonds like the plague.
Freddie Garland, the founder of Freddie's Flowers, explains why he's launching a Flower Bond tomorrow to raise up to £10m to grow his flower delivery business. Investors must put in at least £2,500 and will be paid interest in either cash or flowers. See returns below...
To beat the scammers, everyone should read this by
@marymcdougall13
Don’t use Google for investments.
Financial crime is mushrooming & diligent savers are repeatedly getting caught up in sophisticated scams – don’t assume investment fraud is limited to naive people . . .
The
@FSCS
Facebook post “gloating” on compensation to just 159 LCF victims was incredibly insensitive with no empathy shown to the 11,000 thrown to the wolves. Such is their pursuit to portray a positive impression. it was neither fair or balanced.
Man found guilty of £13m investor fraud & will get a custodial sentence. Investors unknowingly put money into his “personal slush fund”
The Judge called it fraud on a shocking scale.
How would the LCF fraud of £237m be described?
Kevin Hollinrake launches bid to become the Treasury Select Committee's new chairman
Great news for LCF investors who he has supported as co-chair
@APPGbanking
. A genuine sense of fairness in a failing regulatory system is exactly what we need.
LCF - An enormous spider’s web of fraudulent and money laundering transactions overlooked by
@TheFCA
and auditors
@PwC
@EYnews
despite clear evidence as large as a rat crawling over their accounts.
Andrew Bailey will appear at the Treasury Select Committee on Wed March 4 at 10.15am, chaired by
@JohnGlenUK
His suitability as Governor of the
@bankofengland
will be scrutinised.
All financial victim groups can’t allow a whitewash.
Watch it live.
Supporting Thomas Donegan
@ShearmanLaw
on the LCF judicial review is a team of 3 barristers:
Jamie McClelland, Tim Johnston & Charlotte Thomas of
@brickcourt
For 8 months they’ve given up valuable time - free of charge on this intense & challenging case.
Administrative Court grants permission for London Capital & Finance bondholders’ judicial review against the FSCS to proceed, Jamie McClelland, Tim Johnston and Charlotte Thomas instructed by
@ShearmanLaw
for the claimants:
1. Antony Stanfeld's submission to
@CommonsTreasury
on economic crime.
Fraud is now costing the UK economy as much as the entire NHS. The annual figure for fraud given by the National Crime Agency is over £190Bn based on figures from 3 years ago. . .
@SteveBakerHW
@CommonsTreasury
raised the issue of consumers taking responsibility for investment decisions.
The risk of market changes, interest rate fluctuations are acceptable. The risk of an FCA regulated firm being a fraudulent ponzi was not an acceptable consumer risk.
EY has been threatened with court action over the collapse of LCF if they don’t cooperate with administrators. They overlooked clear evidence of fraud and money laundering as clear as a rat crawling over the accounts.
Sensational stuff here as London Capital & Finance administrators sue 13 executives for £178m. Lawyers tell me it could trigger further allegedly connected cases where pensioners lost big money
Following the toxic mix of shocking revelations & allegations in last weeks judgment on the LCF crew and their alleged nefarious activities, there are major questions for auditors BDO, EY, PWC .. major questions that MUST be answered ..
@retheauditors
@premnsikka
With more ICAEW members/FCA authorised ops/bods & lawyers involved than you can shake a stick at, we are left pondering after last weeks high court case judgement .. who (if any) filed SAR’s … and when ?
PwC overlooked a massive trail of fraud in the
#LCF
accounts and had a role to play in the loss of £millions of innocent investor savings. LCF investors consider
@PwC
tainted as well as
@TheFCA
Andrew Bailey admits
@TheFCA
warrants criticism but says he can’t stop risky products. But surely the risks can be massively reduced if the FCA didn’t authorise known fraudsters like the LCF directors.
FCA ex gratia payments for complaint delays are showing on bank statements as The Financial Con.
We agree with this honest and concise description of themselves.
1/2
56 Bondholders spoke at
@TheFCA
meeting with Dame Gloster today.The final observation was made by Neil Liversidge - the IFA who raised the initial warnings in 2015. He stated “Risk warnings are not the issue. The easiest way to commit fraud is to set up a bogus investment. .
The combination of
@MartinSLewis
and
@MarkTaber_FII
in a concerted campaign to STOP scam financial ads on social media will force
@TheFCA
and
@Google
to work together to prevent financial harm to consumers.
@MartinSLewis
@MartinLewis
@GoogleAds
@Moneybox
@paullewismoney
Thanks Martin - would love to join up on this. Only real solution is change to law so that platforms operating outside of UK (Google, FB etc. ) are covered by UK financial promotions laws which would make them liable for the ads they publish. Currently
@theFCA
is powerless.
Simon Hume Kendall - LCF Fraudster has tried to conceal documents by saying it’s privileged information with his lawyer. At court, the judge said otherwise.
The other 3 fraudsters - Andy Thomson, Elten Barker & Spencer Golding are tight lipped.
An undercover Times reporter exposed call handlers mocking victims. They were misled into thinking their reports were being taken seriously.
Victims including LCF victims were mocked as “morons” at the same time as they were being called “Greedy, ignorant OAPs” by
@TheFCA
The ridiculously named ‘Action’ Fraud to be replaced. It was a black hole in which fraud reported by the public disappeared. Fraud is now so huge the new body will need massive resources or suffer the same fate....
Stop Press - Solidarity protest at
@TheFCA
6 December
Meet at 10:00am onwards
Lloyds, CYBG, VirginMoney, Mortgage Prisoners, RBS,
Nat West, LCF Bondholders, Diylaw Personal Guarantees.
Join us if you want Andrew Bailey held to account.
Mini-bond victims confront FCA chief Andrew Bailey | Financial Times
Grant Walker, who lost a six-figure sum when LCF collapsed said that Andrew Bailey did not seem to care about victims and accused
@TheFCA
of inaction.
In addition to compensation for financial loss,
@financialombuds
can tell businesses to pay interest on top. For unreasonable delays in settling a complaint following a decision, the rate is 8%.
A rate that caused FCA to label LCF savers as greedy.
A great summary of the FCA Regulatory Perimeter and all its implications.
A key fact from Dame Gloster that is such a big issue for LCF savers is that
@TheFCA
DID have powers outside the regulatory perimeter. We were sick of hearing the excuse that it didn’t.
@ArmitageJim
@premnsikka
1/ As TheTimes/Guardian peddle the “play the man” spin-byte(in contrast to the Standard for eg), perhaps we should think about what Dame Gloster “DG” said about the FCA’s (FSA) impenetrable apparatchik fatcattery & it’s hundreds of thousands of victims.
Tens of thousands of documents have now been received by
@TheFCA
.
Eventually, they will prove gross regulatory failure as FCA missed multiple red flags that would have stopped LCF being authorised.
If Financial Experts are struggling to understand the arbitrary decision by
@FSCS
re Stocks & Shares vs Cash ISAs - how can investors? The FSCS is failing, made worse by a leaderless
@TheFCA
PWC and EY still need to be held to account for massive audit failure of LCF - ignoring a multitude of suspicious transactions, money laundering, fraud - as clear as the untrained eye could see.
@retheauditors
@premnsikka
UK’s big private companies brace for
#audit
scrutiny - Move to hold unlisted businesses to the same standard as public companies
Stella Creasy calls for inquiry into FCA over Wonga and QuickQuid | Business | The Guardian
@TheFCA
was meant to be keeping an eye. No doubt they were shut - like the LCF scandal that was ignored.
Of course, Andrew Bailey has career highlights but there is one basic question - would you employ a lorry driver with a perfect record till last year when he had 3 major collisions, fell asleep at the wheel, caused serious harm, is under investigation and driving under caution?
FCA could get more powers to stamp out bad practice -
@TheFCA
needs an overhaul - not just additional powers. Victims of huge financial scandals need immediate redress and compensation
@LendyAction
@markbishopuk
December
@TheFCA
update to LCF investors stated they would write before the end of January with regards to complaints.
Will FCA:
Deliver on their timeframe promise?
Compensate all bondholders given their catastrophic failure to regulate LCF?
Or is it all talk and no action?
The only grilling Andrew Bailey got at
@CommonsTreasury
hearing was from
@hbaldwin
.
Despite having to repeat the same questions about
@TheFCA
having the opportunity and powers to address LCF, no satisfactory answer was given.
@ArmitageJim
@premnsikka
1/ Tory MP Harriett Baldwin “HB” doing a good job on the Treasury select committee 2 days ago questioning former
@theFCA
head Andrew Bailey “AB”. HB stated (paraphrasing) “the FCA had both the opportunity & powers to address the nefarious activities ...
Outsourced Action Fraud call centre ‘not fit for purpose’ and in need of police control.
The hotline derided as “Inaction Fraud” is facing a demand for it to be overhauled and put directly into the hands of police.
1/2 Since the
@FSCS
announcement, we have learned that ISA stocks & shares are regulated but cash ISA’s aren't.
How many cash ISA's are there in the UK? The general public has no idea how unprotected they are.
@HMRC
say
@TheFCA
regulate. FCA say HMRC regulate.
Another 99 MPs contacted to request their support for LCF bondholder compensation since our letter was sent to
@JohnGlenUK
this week.
The 17/12 announcement was vague causing great anxiety. Time is critical for many.
Can bondholders expect the return of their capital in full?
The LCF Bondholder Facebook group now has 1840 members representing 3000+ investors. A very active group that shares info on the fraudsters money laundering plus administrator,
@TheFCA
&
@FSCS
updates. It’s an excellent means of collecting data for the FCA investigation &
@UKSFO
A 6 year jail sentence for an IFA stealing £600,000 to fund his lavish lifestyle. Now put that in perspective with the theft of £237m from 11,605 LCF Investors. Simon Hume Kendall, Andy Thomson, Elten Barker, Spencer Golding should be behind bars for a lot longer.
LCF Bondholders will never forget being labelled as “greedy, ignorant, OAP’s” by Andrew Bailey.
Every fact presented on policy and process failure was met with the same excuse: “It’s beyond the regulatory perimeter so beyond our control”.
Andrew Bailey’s tenure as CEO of
@TheFCA
is described as “A toxic cocktail of negligence, incompetence and indifference to the needs of ordinary depositors, investors and pensioners”.
The FCA has been accused by its own complaints commissioner of rushing through a plan to minimise liability for its failings.
Before the publication of 3 independent reviews, it has proposed a cap on the compensation available from FSCS.
The long awaited LCF civil case, filed on 25 August 2020 starts today - Feb 19. The judge has overturned the original court order to silence the media. The Press are free to report to ensure open justice.
Letters of support from MPs continue as no news is forthcoming from
@JohnGlenUK
“The Treasury must provide full compensation in a fair timescale with clarity on how it will be administered & restrictions - not plagued by the concerns of previous schemes like Equitable Life”.
The focus of the LCF mini-bond scandal has now turned to Google. They had a very big part to play in the £millions lost by Bondholders through misleading and deceptive ads. Google & Facebook are very easily manipulated by scammers and fraudsters.
LCF savers still anxiously await the Treasury announcement for those left behind by the random compensation made so far by
@FSCS
. The finance industry & general public anxiously await Parliament’s reaction - will they do anything to stop it happening again and again and again?
One of the LCF Fraudsters was accused by the judge of being manipulative and lying about the purpose of £129 million of investors money. It was meant to be loaned to SMEs as per LCF’s boiler room campaign.
@thisismoney
Call for 3 year ban on EY on public contracts - hot on the heels of the Financial Reporting Council investigation of failed audits re LCF due to dismissal of clear evidence of fraud.
The insolvency process is poorly regulated, insolvency law is in the era of the landed gentry and needs to be streamlined and designed for creditors, not dodgy directors shirking their responsibilities and liabilities. But a change in legislation is needed to rectify that.
Administration fees and costs grow to £13.7m but the prospect of refunds to most of the 11,600 investors who lost £237 million with London Capital & Finance seems as far away as ever.
On the
@FSCS
claim page-5 criteria must be met:
1. The firm failed ✔️
2. The firm was regulated ✔️
3. Investors suffered harm ✔️
4. We are individuals ✔️
5. A breach of the civil liability LCF had to investors
19 Bondholders have spoken of their experiences of FCA so far.
Despite forensic analysis by some before investing, different answers were given by different authorities. “Stunning incompetence instead of reassurance by the regulator”.
Sounds like LCF investigation is going well. Some very good questions and experiences being shared, particularly about the regulatory failures!
@LCFBondholders
@MarkTaber_FII
@bbcdanw
An almighty cock up by
@FSCS
The FSCS compensated another person with an identical name!
How is that possible with such strict data protection procedures and unique investment data?
The compensation process is out of control.
@ICOnews
@TheFCA
And here is evidence that this mega fraud could & should have been shut down by
@theFCA
&
@UKSFO
before
@theFCA
&
@HMRCgovuk
gave London Capital & Finance the authorisations it needed to take it to an industrial scale -
The Cape Verde companies don’t even own the land that the loans were supposedly secured against. How did the auditors and lawyers miss such obvious fraud?
two tables from administrators' report into LC&F tell you all you need to know: raised £237m via 10 separate bond issues - then siphoned 25% off to a marketing company & only actually lent to 3 groups ... & 50% of funds raised lent to one company!
@LCFBondholders
@LCFinvestor
New
@TheFCA
chief apportions blame for pension and mini-bond scandals - Nikhil Rathi questions Treasury’s timing in introducing both sets of new regulations
Google played a strategic role in “rinsing bondholders” - as the LCF crew described their objective. We now have the figure paid to Google: between £18 and £26 million.
Judge in
#LCF
trial asks - 'Has anyone added up now much was paid to
@Google
?'
Answer comes back £18 million - £26 million 👇
@GoogleUK
@dkweinstein
should return money to victims
From transcript (Day 10 / 5 March) kindly provided by
@MouseInTheCourt
at
Andrew Bailey is right about one thing -
@TheFCA
is almost unique. But not in the way he describes. It is unique in failing to protect innocent investors from the harm caused by financial criminals but also from the harm caused by gross regulatory failure.
Andrew Bailey discusses the challenges and achievements of the past year, and his time as Chief Executive on the
#fcapodcast
🎙️Listen to the full interview
Elten Barker has lost his court battle.
Another attempt by an LCF fraudster to stymy the administrators and delay any dividend payout to bondholders. Yet more legal costs for us to pay after Simon Hume-Kendall lost his earlier court case.
Both sets of warnings to
@TheFCA
about LCF in 2015 from
@NeilFLiversidge
and Blackmore in 2017 from
@Carlier_J87
could have protected savers from the harm done by financial criminals IF they’d been acted on. Innocent savers have lost £millions due to regulatory failure.
Andrew Bailey admits
@TheFCA
deserves criticism over LCF and other scandals. Investors should be able to rely on clear explanations of risk and not be misled.
@ianbeckett
@markbishopuk
FSCS have incomplete evidence resulting in arbitrary decisions. Compensation is being paid to savers who had no contact other than the website.
Transcripts of calls from FSCS say: “I've spoken to God, ISiS & Frankie Valli during my investment period and pulled my eyes out”!
Requesting an update from
@FSCS
today, a bondholder was told “we are more than half way through. All compensation claims will be completed in the 1st half of this year. There’ll be another update soon".
Only half way through the glitch-ridden Capita voice2Text process?
#Crapita
Charles Randell said that LCF Bondholders were being updated with progress.
Incorrect. Since FCA complaints started 2 years ago, there’s been no progress - just delays. No decisions.
If they are assessing every compensation, why didn’t they start in 2019?
27 MPs have now signed - urging
@JohnGlenUK
@hmtreasury
to urgently set out the terms of compensation to LCF Bondholders. It was agreed on December 17th.
. . Anyone in authority should know that bogus investments are “crimes in progress” specifically set up to commit fraud. But no one in authority ever listens.
The latest response from
@FSCS
admits they don’t have all the calls & emails exchanged with LCF. The info required by FSCS would come before the investment is made, not after, so any evidence to support many claims is missing.
Critical information isn’t being supplied.