*PAKISTAN SOVEREIGN DEBT* —
A THREAD 🧵:
This is an eye-opening depiction of how successive govt’s have mismanaged debt in
#Pakistan
.
85% of 🇵🇰’s tax revenues are now used to service debt.
Under the circumstances,
#GOP
&
@PTIofficial
have a few options that they can employ:
Munir Doctrine: where the army chief and his institution will now play a formal, direct role in facilitating foreign investment into the country.
Salute to all the geniuses who came up with this idea!
Agha Hasan Abedi — legendary banker & founding President of
#BCCI
(Bank of Credit & Commerce International) — the world’s 7th largest privately owned bank.
A bank run by Pakistanis 🇵🇰 & financed by the Ruling Family of Abu Dhabi 🇦🇪 & prominent family offices of Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦.
I think Dr.
@MiftahIsmail
was completely stumped by Dr. Jaipal’s very valid question. After all, wasn’t the import of BMWs allowed when he was FM? The question didn’t leave Miftah much room to manoeuvre. He figured let’s adopt Indian NSA Ajit Doval’s strategy: offensive defense.
So here’s how self-assumed nemesis of elite capture, & supreme enemy of the 1% privilege, respond to a gentle question by a certain Dr JaiPal about BMW import policy:
“HOW DARE YOU!! YOU SIT DOWN”.
Yup, Let’s reimagine Pakistan this way!
(Please do hear Dr JaiPal question too)
#PAKISTAN
GOLF COURSES 🧵:
Shall we compare the number of golf courses ⛳️ in
#Pakistan
vs. the number of golf courses in comparable countries that have high populations similar to us with a minimum GDP criteria of $350 billion?
#Pakistan
has plenty of golf ⛳️ courses & polo grounds 🐎 for the elite (mostly funded directly or indirectly by taxpayer money).
But very few parks left for the public. I remember quite a few parks in my childhood where we used to play cricket 🏏. Most of them taken over now.
Someone please update
@MiftahIsmail
that
#Russia
🇷🇺 is willing to sell any sovereign, independent, self-respecting, energy-hungry nation its heavily discounted oil.
Someone also update him that 3 x
#Pakistani
refineries can refine Russian crude. Refined oil can also be imported.
A day after the EU imposed a 90% ban on Russian oil, Pakistan's Finance Minister
@MiftahIsmail
tells me if Russia were to offer Pakistan oil at a cheaper rate without incurring sanctions, he would consider it.
This man
@husainhaqqani
is lying 🤥 (once again). I have it on record that both Mian Nawaz Sharif and Maulana Fazal-ur-Rehman refused to sit across the table with Imran Khan, whereas Imran Khan had agreed to the request of the civil society group known as “The Mediators”.
I have it on good authority that army chief did not say what is attributed to him in this thread. While we are talking about people’s temperament, it is important to note that Imran Khan, who refuses to talk to political rivals, lacks the temperament for parliamentary democracy.
The moral of the story is that it is time for you guys to retire. Play golf ⛳️, enjoy the riches 💰 stashed away in Dubai & London, whilst we the younger generation are left to deal with the gigantic debt burden & economic mess that you all will leave behind for us to deal with.
*
#PAKISTAN
UPDATE*:
In the 2017 Census,
#Balochistan
’s population was = 12.34 Million.
In the 2023 Census, Balochistan’s population is = 20.09 Million.
In 6 years, Balochistan’s population has grown by a staggering 63%! Probably never happened anywhere else in the world.
Project Bilawal in South Punjab is beefed up with new joinings from PTI and PMLN & others.
Project Reimagine Pakistan is also in full swing.
Both Projects launched by Company to counter PTI.
These tactics won’t work as we the masses are now aware of Political Engineering.
What an embarrassment for
@CMShehbaz
to visit 🇶🇦 to attend a conference on Least Developed Countries (LDC’s).
I’ve never seen the kind of enthusiasm & shamelessness in any other country’s top leadership as I have seen in 🇵🇰’s leadership when it goes on begging trips abroad.
Just reached Doha 🇶🇦 on the invitation of my brother HH Sheikh Tamim Bin Hamad Al-Thani, the Amir of Qatar to attend the 5th UN Conference on Least Developed Countries (LDCs). I will share Pakistan's perspective on the socio-economic challenges facing LDCs in Asia & Africa. 1/2
No. This is not a full apology. What “Dar Sb’s abilities” are you talking about? Even a child knows Dar is incompetent and a conman. Enough with the hypocrisy!
I apologize to the poor people of Pakistan for this tweet. You always learn from your experience, No doubts on Dar sahbs abilities, it's just that SS government replacing Miftah at the wrong time was unnecessary . Miftah deserves an apology too. May Allah have mercy on us !
Which journalist was forced to flee
#Pakistan
to save his / her life during
@ImranKhanPTI
’s government? 🤔
Asking this, since
@Razarumi
here is equating the two eras…
Here’s some interesting troll maths:
My each tweet gets on average about 300 troll replies. Since these trolls are typically paid per tweet, it costs them around Rs 200 per reply.
So my tweets cost PTI social media team around Rs 6,000 per tweet. If I do 200 tweets per month..
@NajamAli2020
Najam Sb, the middle class comprises mostly of law-abiding & largely tax-paying salaried + SME business-owning citizens of Pakistan.
They do not engage in hero worship, but they are guilty of yearning for change after 30+ yrs of political & economic mismanagement in our country.
#China
🇨🇳 more or less decided to dump
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 after 2022’s
#RegimeChangeOperation
. Pakistan’s Establishment has proven to be an unreliable ally/vassals of the
#US
🇺🇸.
China is now focussed on forging an alliance with
#SaudiArabia
🇸🇦 &
#Iran
🇮🇷 who are both serious players.
😂 A govt. that doesn’t have 💵 to pay back existing
#Chinese
debt wants to start new multi-billion dollar infrastructure projects as part of “
#CPEC
”.
This man
@Fahdhusain
knows exactly what I’m talking about but will not admit it due to intellectual dishonesty. What a shame.
Khan’s tax czar
@SShabbarZaidi
wanted documentation.
Khan, being the principled boss that he is, promptly filed his tax returns & paid due income tax on sale receipts.
In the meantime, like everyone else & their Aunt since the past week, Uzair just wanted to make a point 👇🏼
I believe Voting PPP is the best shot for this term, they have the provincial gov, they are in the federal too and if voted in Local bodies, there shouldn't be any hurdle in development of Hyderabad & Karachi. Baaqi apki Marzi ha !!
#PAKISTAN
PETROL SUBSIDY 🧵:
@MiftahIsmail
bhai, enough with the hypocrisy.
Petrol subsidy was given by
@PTIofficial
on 28 Feb-2022. It lasted for 42 days, cost PKR 96 bn.
Whenever
#PTI
raised petrol prices, you used to lambast them in the media. Apparently it was wrong then.
1. Shaukat bhai but you did violate the agreement you made with the IMF. You agreed to increase Sales Tax to 17% but reduced it to zero. You agreed to raise Petrol Levy every month by Rs 4 to Rs 30 but brought it to zero. You agreed to not give amnesty but gave one anyway.
#Pakistan
’s Finance Minister Ishaq Dar (popularly known as
#DollarDar
) and his sons have turned out to be international money launderers, according to
@Intel_Online
.
Intelligence Online has done a deep dive into the shadowy business empire of Dar & Sons.
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar’s sons run a business in Dubai that is said to provide discreet investment advice and other services to Pakistani intelligence and military officials.
The ones you refer to increased 🇵🇰’s exports to $32bn.
Increased remittances to $31bn+. Increased tax collection to Rs. 6.2 trillion. Instituted revolutionary Sehat Card. Operationally launched Mohmand, Bhasha, & Dasu Dams. The list is long, without any major corruption scandal.
And those who accused others of misruling Pakistan for 30 years, misruled it with impunity and without shame. They are more guilty than anyone else. We trusted them and they betrayed us. Take a look at IK cabinet and you will see the corrupt and the incompetent on one table.
Someone tell this dude that Rs. 20 billion is peanuts 🥜 and can be raised in a 2-minute T-bill auction by the Government of
#Pakistan
from the flush-with-liquidity commercial banks if it actually wants to.
The people of Pakistan are being treated like fools & idiots by
#PDM
.
The
#IMF
mission has apparently been particularly tough during ongoing negotiations to unlock an additional $1 billion in funding for
#Pakistan
.
They’ve essentially told
#GOP
that it has never approached the turnaround of Pakistan’s economy seriously.
#Pakistan
Banking Sector M&A —
A Thread 🧵
Interesting things happening in 🇵🇰’s banking sector related to
#GCC
-based sponsors.
Samba Bank is leaving 🇵🇰 🔜 after parent entity’s merger with NCB in Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦, & MergeCo Saudi National Bank’s decision to divest some assets.
#Pakistan
has plenty of golf ⛳️ courses & polo grounds 🐎 for the elite (mostly funded directly or indirectly by taxpayer money).
But very few parks left for the public. I remember quite a few parks in my childhood where we used to play cricket 🏏. Most of them taken over now.
They are after golf courses. These are not stealing dollars. Get your revenue & taxes but don’t eliminate these. Let the cities breathe. If you do, these will be converted into concrete jungles. Typical of them; ask them to mend their ways & they distract you so craftily
@ImranKhanPTI
& Bushra Bibi have zero involvement in the alleged secondary market deal between Umer Farooq & Farah Gogi / Shahzad Akbar. ZERO.
IK will sue Khanzada & IK has a strong case.
Now, moving onto more important matters, when is
@MIshaqDar50
bringing the PKR below 200?
#Pakistan
is missing out on approx. $10-20 billion in incremental liquidity because
#SBP
hasn’t allowed foreign entities owned by Pakistani nationals to open RDA accounts & invest in Naya Pakistan Certificates.
SBP should urgently allow offshore entities to open RDA accounts ‼️
Hearing: view within the Fauj is that there is no, absolutely no space for Imran Khan in any immediately foreseeable dispensation of government in the near future
Thinking: The Fauj is interested in the economy and thinks that Khan doesn’t fit the “economy first” bill
Bilal has the audacity to blame the previous government for the gross mismanagement that he & his mentor
@MIshaqDar50
have burdened this hapless nation’s economy with since Apr-2022.
Economy in recession, exports crashing, PKR @ 315, interest rates @ 21%, inflation @ 42%! 👀
Amazed that you have the audacity to give sermons on the state of Pakistan’s economy and make delusional claims about PTI’s performance. You are part of IK’s so-called economic team which ran Pakistan’s economy into the ground for 4 years and then deliberately pushed the country
Both
@pmln_org
&
@MediaCellPPP
have the unique honour of overseeing the downgrade of Pakistan’s sovereign credit rating to CCC (negative) by
@SPGlobalRatings
starting in 1998, repeating in 2008, & now once more in 2022.
#PDM
was touted as: “Experienced Coalition”. No doubt! 🙄
Instead of blaming his former boss’s gross mismanagement of
#Pakistan
’s economy (Shehbaz Speed all the way to a negative 0.5% GDP growth & 38% inflation), Umar Saif lays the blame at the doorstep of this country’s bright young entrepreneurs. Pathetic.
Another $14.1 Million down the drain. Dear Pakistani entrepreneurs kindly think about building products and business models that go beyond a couple of years of burning VC money while it lasts …
@DrTazKhalid
@ImranKhanPTI
@SKMCH
And the propaganda begins. Remember it was
@ImranKhanPTI
who nominated
@AtifRMian
to a very important role within his Economic Advisory Council. Extremists within the country protested & he had to role it back, but PM-IK is the one who nominated Atif, despite knowing the reality.
The current leadership of
#Pakistan
(Establishment +
#PDM
) doesn’t give a damn about RDA, NPC, Remittances, Exports, or FX Reserves.
Why? Because most of their kids & monetary assets are abroad. Why care when you have a very small stake in the future & success of this country.
The heart break for Pakistan continues
RDA : Mar 23 only 12,769 accounts opened
| Apr- Mar23 (12m) : 2.04B$ ( Avg : 170m$ |
Mar 22 6m -avg: 252M$
Loss to Economy : 1 Billion US$
While the regime was celebrating reaching 6B$ we lost over 1 billion US $ in the last 12 m
Happy for you
@hoflolz
👏🏼
None of us need to provide any certificate of patriotism to anyone, especially not to touts of this fascist
#PDM
government that has crossed all boundaries of ruthlessness & oppression of ordinary Pakistanis.
May you succeed wherever you are.
I tend not to respond to useless social media commentary about me, but I’m bored & have a lot of free time on my hand, so I’ll bite. There are 4 narratives commonly used to hate on me and bully me every time I try to speak about the rising fascism of our current government. 1/n
If only
@Faizankhaan91
had read a little to understand what
@Shell
Energy Retail actually does, he would’ve been able to make the informed decision NOT to compare it to Shell Pakistan.
Patwari’s been at it all day: “But Shell ⛽️ exiting from various markets.” 😂
@adeel_azhar
Wesay Sirf Pakistan nahe, they are closing retail business across UK,Germany & Netherland as well. Plus what if foreigner buys off their share? Will it matter then? Sastay RJ ki baaten sun lo bas
For everyone making a big deal out of (criticising) the
#TimHortons
record-breaking opening day sale in
#Pakistan
:
1) Intl. suppliers took this news positively
2) Perception is key - domestic buying power gives confidence to foreign investors
3) People spent their own money
The hike was 3% in the last MPC meeting, good that Kami bhai updated later.
These COAS + FM meetings with leading businessmen & industrialists of
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 (happening since Gen. Raheel & Gen. Bajwa era — especially Gen. Bajwa loved these meetings) are literally of no use.
Along with COAS Asim Munir FM Ishaq Dar during meeting with top leaders of business community revealed IMF wanted SIX PERCENT hike in discount rates and he some how,for the time being managed, 2 percent hike in the last MPC of the SBP
Interesting suggestion Dr.
@rezabaqir
.
We had made a comparison of
#Pakistan
’s 🇵🇰 remittances with the
#Philippines
🇵🇭 & presented our findings to FM Shaukat Aziz & then SBP Gov. Dr. Ishrat Husain back in 2000. At the time, Pakistan’s remittances were below $1 billion.
Can Pakistan learn lessons from how the Philippines developed a home grown reform program that generated so much foreign exchange that it prepaid all IMF obligations in one go and has not needed to go back to the IMF?
Name me 1 cabinet member of
@ImranKhanPTI
who became a $ billionaire during
@PTIofficial
’s tenure. What is IK’s net worth? Which properties & assets does he own abroad? Let’s compare his net worth to favourites Sharif Brothers & Bhutto-Zardari. Let’s compare to some Generals too.
@aamir_ashar
The monopoly and stranglehold on power in
#Pakistan
of the elite boomers is about to come to an end. The future belongs to the educated, forward-looking young generation who detest bribery, tax evasion, & corruption and it is this young generation that will save Pakistan 🇵🇰.
This is why I call
#DisasterDar
a “charlatan accountant”. The man is not only a liar but also incompetent to the hilt. Shame on everyone who had recommended, supported, and acted to appoint him (yet again) as the Finance Minister of
#Pakistan
.
ماہرہ خان کو مینٹل ہیلتھ پروبلم ہیں اور انور مقصود عمر کےاس حصہ میں شراب کےنشہ میں دھت رہتا ہے۔ان دونوں بےشرم کیریکٹر پر عوام کی لعنت ہو۔ماہرہ خان کےکردار پر تو کتابیں لکھی جا سکتی ہیں،یہ پیسہ کےلیےانڈین اداکاروں کی خوشامد بھی کرتی ہےاور انور مقصود تعصب سے بھرا ہوا لعنتی کردار ہے
IK is not a crook. IK is not a thug. IK is not a murderer. IK is not a fascist. IK is not a corrupt family dynast. IK is not the mafia.
Yet these hypocrites compare someone like IK to Pakistan’s version of the Sicilian Mafia (as aptly described by former CJP Asif Khosa).
PML-N has finally woken up to what Imran Khan realized a year ago.
Things will get much uglier. Both sides now rightfully realize that this is a war for their very existence.
If IK wins 2018-22 was nothing compared to what he will do to the opposition. 1/2
Unsurprising: the bloodlust of Maryam & her dad’s supporters!
IK survived an assassination attempt & is unable to file an FIR against his alleged assassins till-date. He has every right to defend himself. People are at
#ZamanPark
themselves.
@PTIofficial
ain’t a biryani party.
@AnayaNKhan
Benazir Bhutto faced political imprisonment at 24, yet she never resorted to using human shields or sacrificing her workers. We have a 69 year coward who'd hold his workers as shields than face a mere minute behind bars.
#CourageVsCowardice
The current economic crisis
#Pakistan
is undergoing is like none other in the past. Don’t know if stakeholders in ISB, RWP, KHI, LHE, & PEW realise that.
All stakeholders must put their egos aside & sit together to save 🇵🇰. If they don’t, history will neither forgive nor forget.
During
@pmln_org
’s govt (2013-18), exports literally came to a standstill; in fact, dropped. Exports: single-most critical factor for
#Pakistan
’s nascent economy.
It is PML-N’s same finance & economic “managers” who wish to tell us how to turnaround Pakistan’s economy. Hmm 🤔
@Bilal952
@AzamAKhan2
1) A side gig, doesn’t matter how small or insignificant it may seem right now - get your spouse involved if married - or your siblings if not
2) Invest just 5% of your monthly income into equities - in a performing mutual fund, & once you gain knowledge, you can invest yourself
Pakistan’s GDP was $314b in 2018 when its currency was seriously overvalued (REER was 125).
Pakistan’s GDP is $296b today in 2021 when its currency is fairly (and at times undervalued) with REER of 100 or below.
This no one will talk about 👆🏼.
Total GDP for PK peaked at $314b in 2018, and then crash and burn to $263b, and then $296b now.
Supposedly 'highest ever increase' is still lower than even 2017 levels.
Like you have a good thing going on, why use random superlatives.
Tipu Sultan, King of Mysore, had many advisors who advised him to compromise 🙇♂️ with the British East India Company in 1799 (the Siege of Seringapatam).
Tipu s/o Hyder Ali never compromised. No one remembers those advisors or his enemies. Tipu’s name lives. He’s an Immortal.
@ImranKhanPTI
, all you need to do is pick up the phone & call
@rezabaqir
+ other senior SBP-BPRD officials & ask them to give you their honest feedback on ST. Ask them whether a banker who has run Silk Bank into the ground should potentially be
#Pakistan
’s next Finance Minister.
@ImranKhanPTI
, why did you let Dr. AHS go & bring in ST? What were you thinking? Did you not think it wise to undertake a market check? Did you not speak to the then SBP Governor
@rezabaqir
? He had the Silk Bank file on his desk! Do you plan on repeating the same mistake again?
@MirMAKOfficial
#UzmaKhan
had 2 choices:
1) Continue her fight against
#TheUntouchables
& risk unending legal fees, years of fighting the case with 0 result, & possible threat of physical harm
2) Cut a deal & go home safely - save both time & money
She’s a realist; she made the right choice.
Which means
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 should technically have only 6-7 golf courses at max if it were to be a good boy and conform with its comparable countries’ GDP factor ($350bn / $55bn).
But Pakistan has a staggering 49 golf courses. Holy smokes! Living beyond our means, are we? 😉
For those ardently defending elite privileges & living in a bubble, this is just one example that proves why 🇵🇰 may require sovereign & domestic debt restructuring with its 23rd IMF programme ongoing & less than $4bn in official central bank FX reserves. Have some shame people 🫢
#Crooks
in power in the largest province of
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 —
#Punjab
🚨⚠️
And then they ask why the young generation is willing to raise the stakes & why there is such a massive & unprecedented
#BrainDrain
happening as we speak.
A must-read thread 🧵 by the indomitable
@worqas
—
BREAKING/Exclusive:
Recently it was reported that the caretaker CM Punjab's tv channel, Channel24, is going to get 45% increase in govt ad rates. That means that the govt will pay Channel24 more money than ever before. But thats not the full story...keep reading.
Someone please update
@MiftahIsmail
that
#India
🇮🇳 has bought a record 34 million barrels of Russian crude since
#Russia
’s invasion of
#Ukraine
🇺🇦 on 24 February 2022.
No sir. It is an embarrassment and a possible sign of times to come for all those geezers and boomers out there who have — over the past 5 decades — through their incompetence, greed, and corruption, destroyed our beautiful, high potential country.
This is no embarrassment to
@CMShehbaz
. It’s an insult to the spirit of sportsmanship. It’s an embarrassment to the coaches. It’s an embarrassment to the sports academy training the young sportsman.
1) Ramp up tax revenue growth —
@NadraPak
has a list of 3 million top spenders of
#Pakistan
. Now is the time to act & hold tax evaders accountable.
@FBRSpokesperson
,
@shaukat_tarin
, and NADRA, in coordination, need to start knocking on some doors.
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 was never facing a default-like situation until the
#RegimeChange
Op. of Feb-2022.
Pakistan’s FX reserves in Feb-2022 were in excess of $22.6bn.
Today, reserves are barely at the $13.5bn level. That is a $9.0bn drop in less than 6 months! 😳
#ThankYouMiftahIsmail
Stamped, nailed.
Its mean allegations levied against estb and Gen Bajwa for removing khan's Govt were not correct.
Maturity demands mature behaviour from all leadership. Calling shots on apprehensions raises many qualms on the character of leaders
@NajamAli2020
1) Devalue PKR to 250+ level today
2) Exporters will rush to convert their $ inflows
3) REER will be < 100; exports to become competitive
4) Hundi / Hawala to become non-competitive, resulting in higher official-channel remittances
5) Imports to become expensive; demand to drop
And this is only 4 months of
#Pakistan
remittances data. Extrapolating for FY2023, we should end up around $2.5 billion+ short as compared to FY2022.
Took a lot of hard work & presentations at PM-level in 2019 to get reforms implemented. Painful to watch at a personal level 😢
The regime change operation in Pakistan has resulted in 927 million $ Drop in remittance YOY in FY 23 compared to FY 22 same period
Highest drop - 326 m$ in remittance from KSA
Total Drop in remittance from middle east 592m$ in 4 months FY 23 vs FY 22
@MoeedNj
What kind of a statement is:
“I am the first Army Chief to visit China after the pandemic.” Me, me, it’s all about me. Other chiefs don’t visit coz politicians visit instead.
Training standards need to be raised in the forces. Whether anyone likes it or not, was embarrassing.
@NajamAli2020
Najam Sb I believe it is time for some serious introspection & retrospection as to what actions & policies brought us here, rather than blaming those (who have suffered and have seen their net wealth erode drastically over the past 3 decades) for desiring change at all costs.
Currency-in-Circulation (CiC) & how it’s causing massive (40%+) inflation in a
#Pakistan
whose govt is absolutely unwilling to reduce its wasteful expenditure but more than willing to take on more loans to repay existing loans. No concept of
#DebtReduction
in 🇵🇰.
@meherbokhari
@DanielKRad
This is an Aqeeq ring. It’s a sign of camaraderie and brotherhood when it is put on as a gift on another fellow Muslim’s finger by his brother.
Reserves = $0 billion aka 🥚.
There’s a backlog of $4-5 billion in import payments, royalties, profit repatriations, airline payments, & other services payables currently stuck. Net payable of just these amounts is equal to
#Pakistan
’s total reserves. Let’s not fool ourselves.
The things these
#PDM
clowns 🤡 are having to do now to win brownie points 🎖️ for importing
#Russian
🇷🇺 crude oil ⛽️ into
#Pakistan
🇵🇰.
Why are they having to do all this buffoonery? Because they SABOTAGED
@ImranKhanPTI
’s efforts in Apr-2022 to procure at the steepest discount.
This oil went from
- Russia to India
- India to UAE
- UAE to Pakistan.
So, the Indian and UAE middlemen made a bunch of money.
Russia to India @ $52 per barrel, then India to UAE sold and bought by the same party @ $X, and then sold to 🇵🇰 @ not less than $69 per barrel.
At
This Lunday ka Wolverine just threatened an innocent Twitter handle with violence and harm. Wolverine de Gawalmandi wrote “Be afraid, be very afraid”. Report this
@pmln_org
tout and say NO 👎🏼 to
#Pakistan
’s version of the Sicilian Mafia.
Who is this appeal to? Are IK supporters and sympathisers appealing and pleading for a foreign intervention? Do they want an international conspiracy in their favour? Hum koi ghulam hain ka kya ho ga? PTI has maryam phobia and so they should. Be afraid, be very afraid.
@MIshaqDar50
caused the Mother of All CAD Crises due to an infatuation with a strong PKR (2018).
@shaukat_tarin
oversaw an Unmanageable Trade Deficit (2022) due to a “growth at any cost” strategy.
Unfortunately for Pakistan, neither
@pmln_org
nor
@PTIofficial
learnt any lesson.
I have consulted 3 x exchange company owners & a few private bankers in
#Pakistan
🇵🇰.
Their estimates vary, but the numbers are mind-boggling. They estimate that resident
#Pakistanis
are holding anywhere between $6-20 billion in FCY cash (💷💵) in 🇵🇰 OUTSIDE the banking system.
A large number of Pakistanis have investments worth Billions abroad & Pakistan is close to bankruptcy. For sake of your motherland please dispose off part of these, at least, & invest in Pakistan.
#Pakistan
Shahbaz Rana wants
@StateBank_Pak
to intervene in the FX market, injecting precious USD reserves (already depleting) through an OMO in order to artificially prop up the PKR.
It is a failed strategy practiced by one infamous Mr. Dar in the past, & SBP must avoid it at all costs.
Value of Dollar in interbank market has touched Rs188. Is SBP a partner in crime and deliberately closing its eyes to massive manipulation going on right now?Does SBP want rupee to touch Rs190 to a dollar before weekend? SBP must clarify it’s position
Very few young
#Pakistanis
know that Ghulam Ishaq Khan Institute of Engineering Sciences & Technology (
#GIK
) was financed by
#BCCI
in order to assist
#Pakistan
in establishing a state-of-the-art tech university that would provide support & human capital to 🇵🇰‘s nuclear program.
Auto players (primarily
#Japanese
🇯🇵) who haven’t fully localised even after operating in
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 for 40+ years are shutting down their plants coz they depend on imports for most of their high-value parts & even others indirectly imported through vendors. Always been a scam.
Times were tough for 🇵🇰🇵🇰 Auto Industry in 2022 but things will get much worse going forward‼️
Auto industry was operating at 60-70% quota in 2022, SBP priority list for imports and $$ shortage has relegated them to last in line
SMEs operating as auto vendors will also suffer
This is a dangerous & highly divisive statement. Especially at a time when the political temperature needs cooling down & national unity must be forged amidst
#PakistanFloods2022
.
Not surprising it comes from someone based abroad with probably little to no stakes in
#Pakistan
.
3) Circular debt to be tackled head-on, with urgency —
Electricity theft everywhere. I visited a desert palace in 🇵🇰 once & was shocked to see 2 dozen A/C’s on in all rooms. Upon inquiry, I was told “who cares, it’s not as if we have to pay the bill”.
Senior members of Armed Forces, Judiciary, Opposition, & NAB should be invited in order to bring everyone on the same page. Once all are convinced, a transparent & public privatisation process should be run & loss-making PSE’s should be auctioned & sold.
It is beyond any doubt that the vast majority of RDA inflows & NPC investments materialised due to the comfort that Overseas Pakistanis had in
@ImranKhanPTI
as the Prime Minister of
#Pakistan
🇵🇰.
Make him PM again today, & you will see these NPC outflows reversing! 💯
Overseas Pakistanis sold $660 Million of Naya Pakistan Certificates (NPC) from 31st March to 30th September!
*Data by State Bank 🏦
Seems like overseas Pakistanis, who started investing in NPC through Roshan Digital Accounts are taking their money out.
2) Stop the bleeding from Public Sector Enterprises (PSE’s) —
Prioritise the privatisation of entities that are bleeding the most. A presentation to this effect & why privatisation has become so critical for Pakistan’s economic security should be given by
@ImranKhanPTI
himself.
For those who think that the 🌍 hasn’t changed &
#GCC
Arabs will continue bailing Pakistan out endlessly.
I’ve repeatedly highlighted to those in power that 🇸🇦🇦🇪🇶🇦 are no longer interested in doling out free funds. If you don’t stop going there, they’ll even start avoiding you.
What an embarrassment for
@CMShehbaz
to visit 🇶🇦 to attend a conference on Least Developed Countries (LDC’s).
I’ve never seen the kind of enthusiasm & shamelessness in any other country’s top leadership as I have seen in 🇵🇰’s leadership when it goes on begging trips abroad.
@javedhassan
is right. Is this what these guys mean by “Reimagining Pakistan”?
They should change their slogan to “Imagining Purana Pakistan”.
Because this is how they respond to a legitimate question from an elderly gentleman in a Literary Festival! 😯🤯
Thanks Dr. Jaipal 🙏🏼
#UAE
🇦🇪 is forging ahead, succeeding in the region like never before whilst giving globally-talented or moneyed individuals Golden Visas.
#Portugal
🇵🇹 has managed to become the global headquarters for Agha Khan’s Ismaili Imamate.
And here in
#Pakistan
🇵🇰 we have these jokers:
People with dual nationalities should neither be allowed to vote nor contest in any elections of Pakistan. They should not be allowed to take part in any political activity either. In fact , the law of dual nationality needs to be abolished. Either you are a Pakistani or not.
99% of the population of
#Pakistan
is barred or restricted 🚫 from entering these vast & spacious (elite) golf courses and polo grounds.
People often wonder why 🇵🇰 has stopped producing great sportsmen. This exclusivity & elite capture 🕸️ of parks is one of the major reasons.
To privatise
#PIA
& offer 49-51% with management control to
@etihad
🇦🇪,
@emirates
🇦🇪, or
@qatarairways
🇶🇦 in a G2G deal would be an excellent move by
#Pakistan
🇵🇰.
My view is simple. If no govt in 30 yrs has been able to fix PIA, let those who know this business do it for you.
Qatar Airways owns a 25.1 per cent stake in BA owner International Airlines Group (IAG).
The Pakistani government plans to offer 51% operational control in PIA - Pakistan International Airlines (PK, Islamabad Quaid-e-Azam Int'l) to Qatar.
@MIshaqDar50
, when are you taking a flight ✈️ to 🇨🇳 to meet with
@MFA_China
to discuss a $30bn+ debt restructuring proposal with
#China
’s leadership?
When are you apologising to
@IMFNews
for your insensitive remarks?
When are you letting go of your crazy PKR < 200 infatuation?
None of
#Pakistan
’s recent Finance Ministers (The Usual Suspects) were able to come up with any out-of-the-box ideas as their focus remained on how to please their Prime Minister & the Establishment along with business lobbies. None implemented any major cost-reduction measures.
@WaqasMu26855687
@developingpak
China’s whole economy was based on the copy-paste model for many years. Pakistan should expedite copy-pasting everything it can as per import substitution model until it can innovate independently. This is the least we can do which we haven’t done on a large-scale till-date.
Not true.
Two reasons why SFIC formed:
1) Army wants full control / oversight of future FDI investment in 🇵🇰
2) Geopolitics is different to Geoeconomics. If they were the same, we’d have received the $2bn from 🇸🇦 & $1bn from 🇦🇪 by now. MBS & MBZ not your typical GCC 👑’s
Do not forget that the COAS has some serious contacts and access in the GCC
- He served in KSA as a one-star (rare)
- He spent time in the region after his promotion to three-star rank (rare)
- He was in GCC during and after May 9th (coincidence, sure, but didn't return home
4) Wasteful government expenditure to be identified & cut quickly —
Example: I once visited a Federal Employees Pension office in the capital & was surprised to see hundreds of employees in just one of the buildings. Paperwork & files were everywhere and computers were scarce.
Someone also update him that non-nuclear Islamic country
#Bangladesh
🇧🇩 is putting in place the mechanism to begin purchasing
#Russian
crude as it is in its stated national, economic, & energy security interests.
The
#RegimeChange
Operation of April 2022 has destroyed
#Pakistan
’s 🇵🇰 economy. It will take years for this country to recover from the economic, political, and social damage that former Army Chief General Bajwa and his associates have recklessly wreaked on this nation.
Although PTI was using an expansionary policy that promoted consumption, it seems now that our exports and remittances cumulative $6bn/m could've sustained the supercycle pressure. Pakistan's economy could've been in much better position if VONC hadn't happened.