‘When in doubt, follow the money.’ This principle guides all our work. Our independent newsroom digs deeper and uncovers the stakes.
For Dutch:
@FTM_nl
Follow the Money started a cross-border investigation with more than 15 partners from various European countries, researching the cash flow of the EU Covid-19 recovery fund.
We present the
#RecoveryFiles
👉
A new year, a new place for our Brussels Bureau. (We can almost look into the offices of the European Parliament.)
And a lot of new plans for investigations in 2022. Follow this account and stay up to date.
@FTM_nl
@LiseWitteman
@lauraabels96
@jessepinster
To make it through the winter without Russian gas, the European Union is searching for new suppliers. Recently, the European Commission struck a deal with a country that has a dubious reputation regarding corruption and human rights: Azerbaijan.
The global pandemic is paving the way for the digital ID-card. This card can be helpful, but the technology behind it stores personal information which can’t be erased.
Together with 80 journalists from 24 other media outlets in Europe and the US, we started hunting down assets belonging to Putin’s friends. So far we found 16 billion euros worth of yachts, planes and other assets.
#RussianAssetTracker
Male calves are born as ‘byproducts’ of the Dutch dairy industry and are literally treated as waste. Follow the Money has followed the life of a male dairy calf and describes the money flows that determine his life.
Thanks to the corona vaccine and because it pays only 9.3 per cent tax, Pfizer registered a record profit of 21.6 billion dollars. Its tax rate is far below the global minimum rate of 15 per cent.
Between 1932 and 1945 70.000 young women were taken from internment camps and put to work as ‘comfort women’. Research by Follow the Money shows that both the Dutch state and the royal family profited from this brothel money.
1/ Our publication of today is part of the MEP Misconduct Investigation. An investigation together with journalists from all over Europe.
#MEPmisconduct
The Netherlands can hit Putin in his wallet. Billions of euros and dollars from Russian state-owned enterprises flow through Dutch companies into the rest of the world.
In 2020, Emmanuel Macron urged the EU to be transparent about who would receive money via the Recovery Facility. But somehow, the Member States managed to bar transparency.
That's why we follow the money with our international partners. 👉
#RecoveryFiles
Residents of Bonaire, Saba and St. Eustatius have been Dutch citizens since 2010. However, they don't have the same rights as European Dutch people. Almost half of BES islanders live in poverty because minimum wage and benefits fall below the poverty line.
Researchers from the Erasmus MC in Rotterdam worked together with Chinese scientists on a controversial DNA study. We found ten studies which were financed by the Chinese police, and which can be used to suppress Uyghur and Tibetan minorities.
Early in the financial crisis of 2008, ABN Amro was saved with 30 billion euros of taxpayers’ money. Soon after, the bank set up an aggressive financing structure which may have cost the Dutch treasury hundreds of millions.
How will the hundreds of billions in the EU Covid-19 recovery fund be spent? Brussels refuses to share records about it, despite its transparency pledge. It does so on ‘absurd’ grounds, experts claim.
#RecoveryFiles
We are asking for information on assets of Russian oligarchs in the Netherlands and Europe, especially in the oil and gas sectors and shipbuilding. Don’t hesitate to contact us with valuable information:
The German Chancelor Scholz wants to stop the Nord Stream 2 project temporarily. At first, the Netherlands and Germany supported the Russian pipelines, even though the MH17 airplane was shot down.
Members of the European Parliamentcan use the Parliament’s website to publicly declare that they have spent their taxpayers’ money legitimately. Less than 4 percent of the 705 MEPs made use of that opportunity.
It has been made virtually impossible to check how the first tens of billions from the covid Recovery and Resilience Facility are spent and who benefits from it. Several European Member States are doing their utmost to avoid public scrutiny.
#RecoveryFiles
One man did more than anybody to put hydrogen on the map in the EU and open the doors to billions of state funding. A Dutch professor used his ties to a top EU official and the hydrogen lobby to convince Brussels to embrace the contested energy carrier.
The EU has set up a 723.8 billion fund to help member states recover from the corona crisis. But how is the money spent? It turns out national parliaments had limited involvement in the reform plans required to get access to the funds
#RecoveryFiles
Do you consciously invest in 'green' funds, so your money does not end up with major polluters? Then it is worth reading the fine print: more than half of the sustainable funds invest in companies such as Shell, BP and Lufthansa.
With
@_investico
.
Just two days left! We’re investigating Europe’s most obscure cash flows, and we need your help. Submit a research proposal or vote for somebody else’s!
#PitchEurope
Political parties in the EU received almost a billion euros worth of donations between 2019 and 2022. But the origin of almost three quarters of those funds is unknown.
As elections approach, we explore the
#TransparencyGap
in Europe.
Days before Putin's invasion of Ukraine, the Dutch cabinet appointed former Kremlin lawyer Alexander van der Voort Maarschalk to the counsellor of the Supreme Court, the highest judicial body in the Netherlands.
Xiaomi smartphones transmit massive amounts of user data to their own servers, which can be accessed by the Chinese government. Experts fear that the Dutch government isn’t going to do anything, due to our economic dependence on China.
Ten months after Russia invaded Ukraine, eleven oligarchs who belong to president Putin's inner circle have still not been sanctioned by the European Union. ‘Brussels’ does not want to explain why.
The Recovery Files is a pan-European project, led by Follow the Money, that will investigate the EU's Covid recovery fund for the months to come. Journalists and media from over 10 member states join together for this investigation.
#RecoveryFiles
Can text messages sent by EU officials be considered a document, which needs to be preserved? Officials call the internal record-keeping rules ‘vague’. And while Von der Leyen’s texts remain secret, staff actually want to register instant messages.
These Brussels billions have been earmarked to accelerate the green transition. Problem is, part of these automotive investments could actually extend fossil fuel use, and with it, the stifling dependence on Russian gas and oil.
#RecoveryFiles
Money decides everything, but almost nobody understands the system behind it. We have therfore created a map to help people explore the world of big finance, using the metaphor of water.
Big companies producing wind, solar or nuclear energy make record profits due to high energy prices. The EU wants to skim off those surplus profits to finance energy relief packages.
What is going on? 🧵[1/7]
A large part of the carbon credits that hundreds of companies bought from South Pole turn out to be a paper reality. Even after the company found out the offsets were falling short, it continued to sell them to its customers.
NEWS: Almost 1 in every 5 politicians running for the EU elections has been or still is involved in a scandal. Cases range from enhanced resumes to shameless bribery. And their parties are not worried about it.
#EUMisconduct
Passport for sale! The Caribbean island of Dominica is providing money launderers, spies, and oligarchs access to 113 countries, including 27 member states of the European Union.
#passportsofthecarribean
Every year, Dutch farmers receive hundreds of millions of euros in European agricultural subsidies. Where does that money go? Based on a database built by Follow the Money, we can see who gets the most money and what happens to it.
#FarmSubsidies
Under the leadership of Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission has become more secretive. In this article, we discuss the top things it’s hiding from you, including Von der Leyen’s vaccine texts and Pegasus hacking documents.
Fraud, misconduct, or corruption: nearly a quarter of the current Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) have been involved in a scandal or violated the law at some point.
Anti-democratic parties in the EU are getting more funding than ever before. A total of 150 million euros from private donors have gone to populist and extremist parties’ accounts.
#TransparencyGap
Sustainable clothing brand Patagonia wants ‘fairly’ manufactured clothes and calls ‘a living wage’ a priority. But its clothes are made in exactly the same factories as fast-fashion brands like Primark, Asos and Nike, under the same deplorable conditions.
The China Science Investigation, a consortium of 11 European newsrooms, combed through 350,000 scientific publications. They uncovered that European universities are helping China build the world’s most modern army.
#ChinaScienceInvestigation
Read more 👉
Europe is generously distributing the billions of euros from its Covid-19 recovery fund, but a deal on how to pay off these borrowed billions is still far away.
#RecoveryFiles
Hundreds of thousands of euros from EU taxpayer funds have been channelled to controversial companies tied to Marine Le Pen's RN via the far-right ID group last year. Transparency concerns are mounting, but the Parliament has limited oversight.
Millions of Russians require an independent source of information. And Meduza could soon be their last. However, because of sanctions and censorship they lost 30.000 subscribers. Please consider supporting them, so they can keep reporting.
#defendthetruth
Journalism is indispensable in democracies: it holds power accountable. But as democracies are under pressure, freedom of the press is undermined. It is therefore important to support independent media in other countries, argues editor in chief Eric Smit.
He enjoyed free accommodation in luxury resorts. Then he was remarkably positive about the Emirates. A prominent European Commissioner likes to be pampered. He’s not breaking any laws, but his job seems difficult to reconcile with his behaviour.
1/ Our publication today is part of the
#OffsideDeals
. Led by Follow the Money, this is the first international investigation into football transfers with Russia since 2022.
Putin can no longer rely on the support of the far-right parties in the European Parliament. After the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the Kremlin’s old friends suddenly try to hide their love for Russia.
Hungary is no longer a democracy, according to the European Parliament, and the European Commission wants to withhold 7.5 billion euro of funds. Political scientist Tommaso Pavone thinks it's exemplary for the Commission’s approach to rule of law issues.
China uses illegal police stations abroad to pressure opponents and to engage in political influencing. Stations like these can be found in at least thirty countries. We discovered two in The Netherlands.
Hundreds of abandoned oil and gas platforms remain in the North Sea. Decommissioning would cost billions, postponing the cleanup job helps fossil giants to profit from their assets in the North Sea.
#NorthSeaInvestigations
Three months after its suspension, a consultancy firm that won millions of euros in EU contracts but was guilty of 'serious professional misconduct' is back working for the EU. This is possible due to a malfunctioning blacklist.
Since the Paris Climate Agreement, more than one trillion euros worth of fossil fuel bonds have been marketed. European banks helped these companies raise billions despite promises to stop financing the fossil industry.
#FossilFinance
With
@_investico
We need your help! We’ll dig in the past of our 705 MEP’s. Do you know something about them? Send us your tip so we can make an overview for the elections in 2024.
And our partner Iltalehti
@iltalehti_fi
from Finland writes: ‘RecoveryFiles project: Brussels secretly records billions in recovery despite promises’
#RecoveryFiles
The lobbies of the automotive and oil & gas industry declare that we are not ‘ready’ to go fully electric, but need ‘transition fuels’. But these transition fuels wanted by the fossil fuel industry are even less ready than electric itself.
Global consultancy firms will earn at least 300 million euros from the EU’s post-pandemic recovery fund. When including IT consultancies and smaller consultancies, the total sum is more than half a billion euros.
#RecoveryFiles
Dozens of EU football clubs, including Real Sociedad, Olympique Lyon, and PSV Eindhoven, have concluded transfer deals with Russian clubs since the invasion of Ukraine in 2022. In doing so, they risked violating sanctions imposed on Russia.
#OffsideDeals
How will the covid Recovery and Resilience Facility be spent? To get answers to this question, Follow the Money started the
#RecoveryFiles
. Together with media from 12 member states we will investigate the EU recovery effort. Read their articles below.
This is the publication of our Austrian partner ZackZack
@RedaktionZack
: ‘Brussels withholds correspondence on reconstruction billions’
#RecoveryFiles
Criminals, kleptocrats and white-collar criminals are always able to spend their bad money all over the world. But how? We interviewed Oliver Bullough, the journalist who found out how they spend this money.
🎧 You'll find the podcast over here. 👇
‘Non-profit start-up’ Thorn, founded by actor Ashton Kutcher, is a driving force behind the EU’s campaign to scan the net for child abuse material. We revealed the blurred boundaries between Thorn’s do-good public face and the powerful business behind it.
Former assistants of Members of the European Parliament have free rein to lobby on legislation they were involved with. Although the European Parliament can impose a temporary lobbying ban on them, it rarely does so.
The Dutch part of the North Sea is full of platforms. About 75 are supposed to be cleared away, but that intention seems to rest on quicksand. And the longer the platforms remain, the harder the costs and risks are to predict.
#NorthSeaInvestigations
Hundreds of thousands of European patients use a Philips apnea device that might be making them ill. Philips promised to replace the devices. France wants to be prioritized, they do so with the risk of putting patients in other countries at a disadvantage.
Even the European anti-fraud office OLAF did not know how much EU-money had been misused over the years. According to the European Chief Prosecutor, more than 90 percent of fraud cases remain undetected. The estimated damage: 5 billion euros in 2022.
1/ Today the
#RecoveryFiles
collective focuses on the promised reforms. This is part of our pan-European investigation, with more than 30 journalists from 20 countries, into the €723.8 billion of the EU recovery fund.
Read more about the project 👉
Over the past twenty years, the STAK foundation, once conceived to protect the assets of Dutch corporations and families, has become a popular tool for fraudsters, oligarchs and kleptocrats around the globe. They use it to disguise and move their assets.
During his stint as the European Commission’s chief competition economist, Pierre Régibeau saw the opening of the subsidy floodgates to European industry. In an interview with Follow the Money he tells about his views on the EU’s control over state aid.
The world’s largest forest protection project was supposed to protect Zimbabwean trees and support the local inhabitants. But the millions that Porsche, Gucci and Adyen invested in the project, did not actually reach the Zimbabwean people.
The European Parliament and the European Commission no longer want to be targeted by lobbyists from Russian companies. For months now, the Council of the European Union, chaired by France, has ignored this cry for help.
Big Pharma spent at least 11 million euros in 2021 on civil society organizations lobbying in Brussels. The European Commission wants to combat 'dark money financing' by non-EU governments, but remains blind to covert corporate interference.
Where do ‘green’ investments end up? To answer this question, FTM and
@_investico
started the
#GreatGreenInvestmentInvestigation
. Together with 26 journalists from 9 countries, we investigate Europe’s sustainable funds.
Read their articles below.
A judge will hear a criminal case against EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen over the purchase COVID-19 vaccines. A lobbyist filed corruption charges, aiming to uncover secret negotiations.
For years now, researchers of the Chinese police have been using products of Qiagen, a biotech company based in the Netherlands, in controversial studies involving the DNA of Uyghurs and Tibetans.
Our project the
#ChinaScienceInvestigation
has been shortlisted for the
@ECPMF
Investigative Journalism for Europe's Impact Award 2023. Thanks to all of our partners!
Find out more about this cross-border initiative:
Europe wants economic independence. Its industrial base has fallen behind, surpassed by China and the United States, and the EU has become extremely dependent on other countries for crucial resources. Who will benefit from these major ambitions?
2/ Our colleagues are publishing articles on their own platforms. From our Belgian partner Apache :
Kwart van Europarlementsleden kwam al in opspraak
#MEPmisconduct
@apache_be
Lithuania, mafia, Naples, Olympic Stadium Amsterdam. It may seem like a random list. But it's not. The money trails of a 2.6 billion money laundering operation lead to unexpected places.
Although KPMG and De Nederlandsche Bank had doubts, they did allow shady practices by state bank Fortis. With these fraudulent acts, the bank earned tens of millions at the cost of the German tax authorities.
Dutch bank Rabobank offers carbon credits to fund a project meant to protect forests in the Ivory Coast. Companies like Microsoft have invested in them from 2020. The Ivorian government, however, states that the bank sold credits it had no right to claim.
Former Dutch Minister of Finance Hoekstra said he hadn’t looked into the fiscal structure of a safari venture that he invested in via a shell company. But we did. We found all the signs of aggressive tax planning.
Some 40 per cent of European funds that call themselves sustainable invest in companies that get a substantial part of their revenue from fossil fuels.
#GreatGreenInvestmentInvestigation
1/ The
#ChinaScienceInvestigation
continues. Our pan-European collaboration, powered by Follow the Money, conducted by 11 newsrooms in 7 countries.
👇 You’ll find the articles of our partners below.
1/ Today the
#RecoveryFiles
collective is focusing on the automotive industry. This is part of our pan-European investigation where we are looking how the €723.8 billion of the largest EU stimules package ever will be spent.
More about the collective 👉
Investigative platform
@ftm_eu
(known for
#RecoveryFiles
) is looking for a journalist specialising in the EU to join our Brussels based team. If you love paper trails and collaborating with colleagues from all over the EU, we can offer you a full-time job.
IMF managing director Kristalina Georgieva has enlisted the help of a lobbyist in attempts to land high-level positions. In an apparent return of favours, she showed up at networking events organised by the lobbyist during the World Economic Forum.
Russian ships are prowling the North Sea. They are mapping essential pipelines and cables to sabotage or disrupt them. But European nations find their hands tied to intervene.
Read the latest from our
#NorthSeaInvestigations
with
@tijd
.
1/7 How will the covid Recovery and Resilience Facility be spent? To get answers to this question, Follow the Money started the
#RecoveryFiles
. Together with journalists from all over Europe, we investigate the EU recovery effort. Read their articles below
Martin Wolf, economics commentator at the Financial Times, thinks the marriage between capitalism and democracy is at risk. The political left, meanwhile, is more concerned with identity politics than with the causes of the rise of the radical right.
Last year, international media reported that former EU Commissioner Kroes had been secretly lobbying for Uber. Now, it is revealed that Kroes urged the Commission to be open about it. But instead the Commission played a game of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’
As an investigative journalist at Follow the Money you get the freedom to dig deep in European topics that matter: politics, lobbyism and many more subjects.
Do you want to be a part of well-known international investigative teams? Link down below.
Faassen denies the relationship. Are any of the rumors true? Which are fake news? Join us on our quest, past penthouses, Russian forums, Moscow highways, and UFOs.
Major commercial consultancy firms earn double from the EU corona recovery fund by helping to submit plans for recovery as well as implementing the reforms promised in those plans. A conflict of interest is looming.
#RecoveryFiles
Last year we revealed exploitation and low wages were common in Patagonia’s factories.
One year later, one Sri Lankan union leader claims working conditions have only gotten worse.
Did you miss this story? Read it for free today! ⏲️
After the 'Qatargate' bribery scandal, EU lawmakers called for more transparency, but the same politicians have consistently voted against new transparency measures. Especially the Christian Democrats and right-wing conservatives are obstructing the plans.
At Follow the Money, we think the crowd should have a say in what we investigate. With Pitch Europe, you can submit a proposal for an investigation or vote for somebody else’s. What is Europe’s most obscure cash flow? Let us know.
#PitchEurope