We gotta rip the band aid off. It is a sugarcoated surrender. Tigray ppl got betrayed by fellow Ethiopians, Africans, the world, and one fears, by God. Tigray stood its ground against the world & did it with exceptional code of valor one only hears in legends. 1/n
- U tried 2 go out of ur way 2 paint a picture of a senseless war where ppl butcher one another 4 no reason. Another African barbarism, right! In ur determination 2 feed into this Western bias u deliberately overlook the siege on the ppl of Tigray & their just cause 2 fight so 1/
This would be a good time to hear from General Tsadkan. He is not a member of TPLF. His candid demeanor and informed analysis of the current situation as well as his perspective on the peace process would certainly calm the waters. How about an interview
@MediaUmd
? 🙏
Tigray opposition insists that the current disaster of Tigray is due 2 TPLF’s political stagnation, its failure 2 change with the times. There is an element of truth in their claim. Perhaps the most fatal ‘failure’ on the part of TPLF that resulted in the present tragedy is [1/n]
I found this peace neither excellent nor a must-read. Behind a facade of neutrality, it is filled with blatant mischaracterization of crucial events and putting things out of context.
1. It gives the 'opposition' a non-existent relevance & popularity in Tigray. 1/n
Indep'ce isn't a fortnight project. It requires meticulous planning, otherworldly patience, & Machiavellian intrigues. We shouldn't panic whenever it isn't publicly affirmed. We ought not need reassurance everyday that its gonna happen cos it has already happened - in our hearts!
Tigrayan political figures & parties must be challenged to produce papers detailing a roadmap to get Tigray out of the present crisis. Those who prate in trash-talk, slanders, and lowly populism should hold their tongues! Let the clash of ideas begin!
It is time 2 start going beyond pleading 4 the attention of the diplomatic community into confronting & shaming z hypocrites in public. If they can't be moved by appeal 2 their conscience, then go after the thing they hold dear [political integrity] by exposing their hypocrisy👇
The reasons given by EOTC to demand autonomy from the Egyptian [Coptic] Orthodox Church was:
1. "Ethiopian Church had not benefitted from the union"
2. lack of education opportunities
3. "The Egyptian Church deserted her daughter [EOTC] during the Italian occupation" ...
PFDJ slowly waking up to the fact that it has unleashed a monster it can't control :) TPLF was the only Ethiopian political force that sincerely recognized Eritrea's sovereignty. Now, be it Abiy or another, Ethiopia is coming. The only question is when. & TPLF isn't gonna stop em
Over the past few months, many Ethiopians have been warning us about
@AbiyAhmedAli
's betrayal against those who stood with him through thick & thin, but we said nothing to avoid getting involved in their internal affairs, but we never crossed our minds that could happen to us.
1. You've ignored weaponization of the EOTC during the war but mercilessly condemned the post genocide natural drive of Tigray ppl 2 seek independent institutions
2. You criticize an imaginary TPLF meddling in the clearly grassroots movement 2 establish Tigray Church but then 1/4
Thread on the Dispute between EOTC and Tigray
1/The dispute between the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo Church (EOTC) and Tigray has emerged as a significant and multifaceted issue within the context of the ongoing conflict in Ethiopia.
@City_Chief
Ya right🙃 Is that why psg gk was being bombarded all night? Truth is, city absolutely destroyed psg defense. They just couldn't finish em off.
them the right to be part of 'a transitional government'. 10k tweets did earn Tigray ppl a few tears of sympathy, a pinch of 'concerned', and an ounce of political pressure, but ultimately, it was TDF that won Tigray its liberty & leverage to wrestle away its future through [5/n]
Theirs is a disgraceful victory; ours is an honorable defeat, 1 we shall tell our kids with pride. Let Tigray shine in z heart of every Tigrayan. Let every family ritualize the astonishing legend that unfolded before our eyes – legend that belongs 2 the realm of superheroes 10/n
Tigray's survival hinges on its military strength & solidarity of its ppl. West's sympathy is a mirage that is designed 2 hide the fact that they are the ultimate enablers of
#TigrayGenocide
. Right now, Tigray is an inconvenience 2 IC. But if Tigray overcomes attempts to subdue👇
The war didn't "resume" yesterday. Its been two weeks now. Why did you wait this long to tell us you are "deeply saddened"? While calling for peace is good the timing makes me feel they're, once again, being used for by Abiy to cover up ENDF's disastrous military campaign
#Catholic
Bishops in
#Ethiopia
“deeply saddened” By Resumption of Fighting in
#Tigray
“The Ethiopian Catholic Church, by her own and jointly with other religious institutes, has frequently called for all parties to avail for peace..."
To assume that Mossad, one of the best spy agencies in the world, was taken by surprise by Hamas' attack is naive at best. They likely let it happen in order earn the indignation & the IC's consent necessary 2 finish off Palestinians & complete their conquest.
"I served in the [Israeli Defence Force] Gaza division during the 2014 Gaza war... Listen to me, and listen to me well: There's no way in the world that anyone can approach the border without us knowing about it."
unilateral declaration of independence going 2 do? I recognize frustrations by Tigrayans in TPLF's reluctance to advocate secession. But by keeping its cards firmly close to its vest TPLF has shown it is wise enough to exhaust all possibilities to maximize Tigray's future. [9/n]
@Teklai_Michael
Derartu isnt expected 2 publicly denounce Abiy & no1 has authority 2 demand it frm her 2 affirm allegiance 2 Tigray! That is the point. If she can help 3 Tigrayans achieve their potential, if she isnt working against us, she is a friend! Period! What's this obsession 2 vilify smh
I don't see it helping their claim 4 political power] TDF is firmly the product of TPLF both in political philosophy & praxis. The key pillars of the military victories - the notion of popular 'insurgency' struggle & experienced military leadership - are indisputable fruits [7/n]
In my opinion the 'unless you are with me all the way, you are against me!' mentality that's being displayed by some influential Tigrayan activists is self-defeating. The way we are going, we'll end up in complete isolation. Is that the vision we have for
#Tigray
?👇
The post-war crisis has created a haze, making it easier 2 traverse what were once clearly defined lines, as those boundaries have now become blurred. Traitors, who'd otherwise have concealed their treacherous identities, are shamelessly discarding their masks. 1/4
Having afforded the luxury of amnesty by no other than the mortal enemy of Tigray ppl, the couch warriors now lean back from the comforts of AA & presume 2 convince us of their relevance. They've the audacity 2 tell us tweeting a bunch of lines about
#Tigraygenocide
affords [4/n]
opposition & civic org 2 be included in ongoing efforts; 4 the infant opposition 2 show humility by recognizing that they need a lot 2 learn & aspire 4 long term takeover of power.
👉 Independence is a must but navigating towards it requires more wits than simple slogans
[end]
losing oneself? Can a nation at war with its historic values ever survive, let alone thrive? Regardless of the answers 2 these questions, 1 thing stands clear: the opp'n's drive 2 cast TPLF as imposer of alien values is as shallow as their claim to the indigenous politics.[end]
There is a difference between
[a.] being forced 2 work with a genocidal regime as a consequence of armistice [losing a war] &
[b.] working 4 the regime as a traitor for no other reason than self-interest.
I see more & more of us are finding it hard 2 distinguish the difference.
p.s. I'm not TPLF's supporter; I criticize several inadequacies displayed by its leadership & condemn many of its corruptive practices seen esp at lower levels. But I call 4 TPLF 2 clean its house & refine itself; give ears to outside voices; arrange some framework for the [10/n]
Why is it that Tigrayan nationalists seem ill-fated to lack tactical acumen, while the tacticians lack nationalist fervor? That we keep facing this conundrum merits serious examination. Otherwise, Tigray's aspiration to statehood is bound to stagnate.
Russian Patriarch Kirill's blessing for Moscow's invasion of Ukraine has caused the Ukrainian Orthodox Church to declare its independence.
👉If it is legitimate for Ukraine, it's even more legitimate for Tigray Church
#TOTC
#Tigray
@ColonelD8
@RAbdiAnalyst
Unless you play "it doesn't count" game, Ethiopia was actually defeated by the Italians during WWII which led to Haileselassie's pitiful exile. It was the British army that drove it out and reinstalled Haileselassie. As for the rest, it was Tigrayans who won Eth its victories.
Not going 4 the jugular - a recurrent theme in
#Tigray
's politics?
Sihul Michael - takes Gondar but remains a regent
Yohannes IV - enters Shewa but leaves Menelik unscathed
#TPLF
-ENDF - defeats PFDJ but refrains from advancing on Asmara
TDF - returns from Debre Birhan
Alone against the world who conspired to ignore their plight, justified the horrific crimes committed on them & slid tools under the table to tilt the balance against them, there comes a point when they have to call it a day. The only other option is annihilation. 2/n
TDF withdrawal from N Wollo is a strategic masterpiece:
- It pacifies the Amhara & takes away any false justification for Abiy to pursue Tigray invasion or withhold aid [& this after crippling ENDF capability]
- By shifting battle hardened TDF units to the North, it seals off 👇
While its undeniable that many urban youth were enticed by the mushy nationalism of Mehari & co., they were toothless in practical politics. Presenting a bunch of political infants with absolutely no practical policy & totally oblivious 2 Realpolitik on equal terms [2/n]
and awful treason.
The price Eth paid for a victory has firmly planted the seeds of its self-destruction. Now both Eth & Eri will no longer have an enemy against whom they fuel the hate that sustains them. Now the conjured hate & lies will turn inward and eat the empire 5/n
Political hustle is all about staying relevant, enhancing your leverage, multiplying alliances, and making yourself indispensable. At present, the Amhara-Eritrea alliance has diversified its influence both locally and regionally, aiming to intimidate the Abiy into compliance.1/7
@RAbdiAnalyst
Following the Kobo debacle, Issaias is in charge of ENDF. Abiy no longer has the autonomy 2 commit 2 peace even if he wants 2. For Tigray, a ceasefire without WT is de facto siege & thus a failure. If west wants peace in HOA, they have 2 take practical action on the Asmara regime
with seasoned TPLF heavyweights is a joke.
2. Ignores important context: the 'opposition' effectively deserted Tigray ppl when it openly renounced the armed struggle in favor of the laughable idea of pursuing a peaceful struggle against a genocidal regime. [3/n]
This is the time 2 speak! This is the time 2 conduct peaceful protests & campaigns, both in
#Tigray
& abroad, in support of the See of Selama. We should show friends & foes Tigray ppl are behind their spiritual fathers. Abiy & TPLF need 2 be firmly told 2 back off. Now or never!
They are framing the situation as "Tigray bishops' refusal for reconciliation & unity".
Some, by arguing that we are right in rejecting their apology, are inadvertently falling into their trap.
This isn't about forgiveness but about preventing another round of genocide on 1/2
low morale among Tigrayans by quoting the most biased of sources [both have a vested interest 2 tell u TDF losses; aren't they in ENDF hands? duh!] so much 4 neutrality
- How about the part where u actually tell the other side of the story? Is it 2 difficult for ur lazy a** to 4/
In case I missed it, can anyone please tell me if the Tigray opposition parties have yet released a roadmap document on how to fix TPLF's blunders and get Tigray out of the current crisis?
@salsayweyaneti1
@HailuKebede_
@kibrom_zebib
Axis of fascism in HOA was funded by powerful external actors. TPLF led gov't fiercely resisted corporate takeover of the country’s assets for 3 decades and in doing so positioned itself as the long term foe standing in the way of the strategic interest of Western [3/n]
negotiation. [The opposition leaders who became 'tegadelti' been hiding in farmers huts & are now goofing around in Mekelle wearing 'keshuf'. While I find that admirable as it may have slightly inspired the youth to join the cause [the genocide primarily drove them to TDF], [6/n]
Getch’s next destination should be Semera. Afar-Tigray alliance is nt only a natural fit but also indispensable 2 both nations. This may require shaking hands with Awol Arba but Tigrayan indignation must recognize the unenviable position Mekelle finds itself in & also the endgame
of TPLF.
3. The opposition has presented no practical alternative 2 justify sitting on the table alongside TPLF. The transitional gov't hocus-pocus has absolutely no practical relevance in Realpolitik & only serves 2 show how immature & naive the 'opposition' is. What is a [8/n]
Some points to consider:
- Eritrea joined with Ethiopia 2 militarily suppress Tigray's pursuit of independence, yet Eritrea's own independence in 1991 was contingent on Tigray's [TPLF] recognition.
- Eritrea's hostility toward Tigray is driven by a ruthless rationality. [1/7]
The ‘Eritrean factor’ is a very complicated and complex geopolitical issue that needs a somber reflection on part of Tigray.
It should be independently analyzed and a new approach is critically needed to go forward. As a victim, a repeated and Usual calls for peace isn’t one of
Ethiopia may have won militarily 4 now. But scarred Tigray is a permanent testament that exposes the rotten foundations of Ethiopia's institutions. That Tigray continues 2 exist, albeit weakened & half destroyed, is Ethiopia’s defeat for it bears witness 2 its heinous crimes 4/n
Emperor Libna Dengel admits 2 Francisco Alvares, a Catholic monk who visited Abyssinia in 16c, that only the "country of Tigray" had been converted 2 Christianity by the Ethiopian Eunuch [mentioned in Acts 8] & that the rest of Ethiopia had been forcefully converted much later 😲
There is a misguided perception that if the cause is just, it'll lead to outright victory. Legal and PR battles are usually ignored until it is too late. This has cost Tigray on many occasions. It's not too late now & fortunately there's more than enough substance to go on.
War bn ETH & ERI appears imminent, which could mean total disaster if Tigray lacks a cohesive & ind'nt leadership unwaveringly committed 2 Tigray's interests. On the contrary, if Tigray manages 2 retain its autonomy, the war [though regrettable] can also be an opportunity. [1/7]
off from within. Tigray needs to salvage what it can, introspect like Japan, and wait patiently. For once, time will be on our side.
TPLF had no choice but sign its way into irrelevance. It was in a coma for a while; strategic foresight has long deserted it’s leadership. 6/n
Tigrayan legacy of defiant resistance against foreign encroachment. Strategically located bn the shore & midland, Tigray had long shielded Ethiopia from colonial ventures. In fact, its the Tigrayan in TPLF, not its Marxist dogmas, that was responsible 4 its instinctive [5/n]
Eritrea, the main antagonist, would love to drag the war indefinitely so that it can have an excuse to turn Tigray into a wasteland.
With this undignified deal, Tigray ppl will at least live to fight another day. Now they’ll get to live to tell their side of the story. 3/n
Let the history be properly written. Let our suffering and glory; our pain & our victory be engraved in every form of our individual & collective existence. Let the resistance live on in every Tigrayan home. Militancy isn’t the only way; the resistance can be expressed in 11/n
Lidetu was rightly praised by some Tigrayans 4 his recent interview with Mesay, wherein he eloquently explained the "indiscriminate" attacks directed at the Tigray ppl over the past 3 yrs & ESAT's role in it. However, unnoticed by the grateful public, 1/5
Barging into live shows & events with banners of
#Tigraygenocide
to break media silence & force our way into mainstream public discussion shud also be considered. Activism has to turn militant. We should create every form of 'inconvenience' 2 let them know we won't die quietly.
It is no accident that US yet again dragged its feet 2 make a statement or take measures to establish peace talks. It was waiting 2 see, once again, if Abiy&co. can achieve their goal through war. That US is now calling 4 peace talks only tells me the war isn't going its way.
The U.S. condemns the continuing TPLF offensive outside Tigray, the Ethiopian government’s airstrikes, and Eritrea’s re-entry into the conflict. We call on all parties to immediately halt military operations and redouble efforts to engage in peace talks.
What happens when a warmonger becomes a Patriarch? Proposing an administrative arrangement by thinking only of present realities is catastrophic. That was exactly how the TPLF ended up getting itself into a trap dragging the rest of the Tigray ppl along with it.
Tigray Suggests New Administrative Relations with EOTC
Abune Petros suggested a new administrative relation btw the
#Tigray
Orthodox Tewahedo Church and the genocidal Ethiopian church akin to the one that exists btw the Patriarchate of Constantinople and the Church of Greece. 1/
@FBedaso
I don't endorse the language. But it is undeniable that Tigrayans contributed immensely towards bringing equity among nationalities & with enormous cost in human life as that. No self-respecting Oromo would deny that. Now once again, Tigray is betrayed by other ethnicities who👇
that they may survive.
- The fighters interviewed 2 create false balance are an ENDF soldier & a "rogue" TDF fighter?! & both happen to tell a story showing TDF's 'staggering' losses? You seem determined to use your journalistic wizardry to somehow make us ignore what our eyes 2/
The position taken by some activists & Tigrayan media, projecting indignation when TIRA security forces take repressive measures while remaining silent when the opposition was calling for martyrdom and radical change, is biased and unhelpful. My stance is clear & unapologetic...
Abiy's handlers are executing a meticulous plan. The chaos is a facade for a ruthlessly rational set of moves that'll ultimately snuff out localized resistance & unveil HOA under total enslavement 2 foreign interests. [1/7]
#Ethiopia
: Blinken once again tells PM Abiy need for peaceful resolution to end
#Oromia
,
#Amhara
crises
Despite widespread concerns including from the International Commission of Human Rights Experts on Ethiopia (ICHREE) on the inadequacy of the
Tigray needs 2 diversify its political spectrum & have multiple actors, each with their respective roles, if the region is 2 overcome its current crisis. The current dynamics require both pro-independence & con/federalist parties, each capable of forming cross-border [1/6]
can see - 000s of ENDF POWs; their countless clearly genuine testimonies showing completely different picture; the full might of 2 nations with overwhelmingly superior manpower & weaponry failing 2 break the resolve of unequipped but determined ppl.
- What's more u try 2 show 3/
For the sake of impartiality, I expect Ethiopian religious and civic society leaders to come out and publicly show their support for the Ethiopian Defense Forces. Just saying :)
There was no protest in Western Tigray in 2016. The link states it took place "in the streets of Gondar".
@KjetilTronvoll
this piece needs to be updated.
[1/2]
One thing that has to be undoubtedly clear this time for Tigray leadership is that international laws & third party bargains are not trustworthy. We are living in an era when it is no longer secret that geopolitical interests are guided by the law of the jungle.
2 terms with the underlying principles which guide Tigray’s politics. 4 eons, Tigray’s political culture has prided itself on its fidelity 2 the path of truth [መንገዲ ሓቂ] & its role as guardian of the horn. Is it time 2 change? But how far does 1 embrace change before [8/n]
resistance 2 corporate vampirism.
In retrospect, 1 would thus be prompted to ask: should TPLF have simply yielded 2 western pressure 2 open its market to international corporations & saved itself? Its not particularly a Tigrayan thing 2 do though, is it? But apparently [6/n]
This is the ultimate litmus test for Tigray ppl resolve to achieve independence. The Tigray Orthodox Church stands on solid ground, free from any theological barriers, to proclaim its administrative autonomy. [1/4]
its obstinate refusal 2 embrace corporate colonialism [aka liberal democracy]. The plot that dethroned TPLF is 2 intricate, coordinated & supervised for it to be seen as a local development.
It has now become apparent that Abiy’s rise 2 power as well as the emergence of the [2/n]
4. You frame the war as the outcome of “TPLF rebellion” while ignoring the documented systematic alienation of Tigray & prolonged warplanning by Abiy, Amhara elites & Isaias hence essentially justifying
#TigrayGenocide
[3/4]
@WoldeYihun
Of course u wouldn't tesfish. Wouldn't make sense 2 recognize
#TigrayGenocide
u agitated 4. u guys thought u could erase Tigray & keep ur crimes hidden but now u've 2 settle 4 a deeply bruised neighbor who'll make sure posterity wont forget what u did. Abiy f*d u with Pretoria😳
A textbook example of winning the battle but losing the war. This dude just realized the Ethiopianist camp, in a vein effort 2 militarily erase Tigrayan nationalism, has ended up committing suicide. Ethiopianism has been purged from the minds of all; its now a bankrupt ...
አማሮቼ፣
Have mercy on this cat. This cat understood everything going on and is nervous.
Forgive him for resisting joining ethnic nationalism. Knowing ethnic nationalism is winning appears to literally make him sick.
The issue is beyond apology. A proper apology 4 complicity in genocide is good 4 closure & a peaceful separation but is not enough 2 rectify ties with Tigray. EOTC has made it clear Tigray ppl are not among its flock. It's time they get served by a church that actually care 4 em.
- Ordination of episcopates 2 proceed as scheduled
- visit of EOTC delegation won't alter TOTC plans
- sincere apology good 4 neighborly relations,
but nothing more
- IRA can't & won't meddle in TOTC affairs
- Fathers prepared 2 endure all hardship
His beatitude Abune Merhakrstos
As it stands, the TPLF is at its weakest, with its assets frozen by the fed, unable to generate income from its barely surviving members, and strangled by TIRA from siphoning gov’t funds. Furthermore, the backlash from losing a war, an economic & humanitarian crisis, [1/n]
@MarksSimon
@TomGardner18
@MarksSimon
, please change the term 'Tigray province' as there's no provincial system in Ethiopia. The Ethiopian constitution speaks of 'sovereign regional states' with their own flags and anthems. 'Rebels from the region' is also pregnant with bias; why not just 'Tigray forces'?
Some form of merger with PP is the most it can expect, something it could have done 2 years ago. TDF can still divorce itself from TPLF and continue the struggle. But that would be playing the enemy’s game as that would be an ideal excuse to impose what it considers its 7/n
Some of the reasons 4 TOTC's demand 4 autonomy:
- EOTC not only deserted Tigray ppl but campaigned, blessed & financed the genocidal war
- EOTC not only failed 2 call 4 peace but actively tried 2 sabotage efforts 2 end the war etc
Tigray Christians cause 4 autonomous church is...
every other form and on every field a Tigrayan ventures. They can only take Tigray from our children if we let them. If we manage to pass the torch of resistance to the next generation, we will be the ones who will ultimately triumph. 3nd
"I don't want the people of Tigray to bow their heads in shame. But if it means I have to humble myself so that they can lift up their heads & assert their full right to self-determination, I am prepared to do so."
- Big words 🤔
it is what the wise ass Tigrayan opposition are implicitly hinting it ought 2 have done [glide with the times]. A typically emotional response wd be: ‘who cares about ungrateful Ethiopia, they should've sold it off 2 highest bidder’. But the deeper issue at stake is coming [7/n]
Can't wait to read Tigrayan romance war novels. Hope aspiring Tigrayan novelists are putting the final touches on their literary masterpiece somewhere. No doubt there are many magnificent stories of our war heroes of love, bravery, sacrifice & loyalty waiting to be immortalized.
The enemy wanted Tigray to be history. let's not forget
#TigraySiege
is imposed cos subduing/erasing it didn't work. This is not a time 4 ego but one 4 humble reflection, sober-minded analysis & cautious decisions. Survival now precedes & assures the independence of tomorrow.
It has now become apparent that the fed is deliberately delaying the demobilization of TDF combatants. while the more immediate reason for this is to lessen the pressure for not fulfilling its end of the bargain, i.e. restoring Tigray's territories & repatriating IDPs, [1/2]
Reflections on the fed-Tigray dialogue [tread]
1. Both the political leaders [TPLF] & the military leadership are intimately aware of & are involved in the US mediated behind closed doors negotiations [potential deal] between the fed & Tigray government.👇
ultimate triumph - erasing Tigray.
Now Tigray ppl need 2 abandon the military aspect of the war. The truce affords them limited yet crucial room to sustain their existence. They ought not expect 2 much from the political settlement as there are few chips left to bargain with 8/n
@tigistAA
@reda_getachew
What
@reda_getachew
is doing 2 TPLF is from the same playbook as Abiy did 2 EPRDF. Anyone who still doesn't see that is blind. Whether that's good depends on the person. I'm seeing lately that some consider it a success if TPLF is gone even at the expense of destroying Tigray.
Right now, TPLF-IRA is locked in a fierce political battle with the fed. Tigrayan christians must stand behind the fathers to protect their cherished Tigray Orthodox Church from being used as a bargaining chip for political gains.
@wdavison10
What's interesting is how Ethiopians refrained from exposing it 😜 They would rather grant it to Sudan than acknowledge the embarrassment of operation Alula
That is not to say they shouldn’t wrestle for every dime they can get out of it. They would need to adapt to current reality and transform their energy to build a state no enemy can conquer, a state not limited by territory or confined by politics. 9/n
Forgiveness is a must.
Our forgiveness ought not hinge on quality of the apology or sincerity of the repentance but on the teachings of the Lord,
We forgive so we don't remain entangled in toxic ties, so we can move on,
But we mustn't forget so that it never happens again [1/2]