THREAD ...
Earlier this year I was working on a story about the "third wave" of COVID in Colorado. Not an investigation, just a look at the craziness the state found itself in: cases rising, Polis tests positive, counties want stay-at-home, etc.
Suddenly that changed ...
THREAD: Colorado’s vote by mail for all system is regularly held up as the gold standard of elections.
Indeed, for the vast majority of voters, it’s convenient and secure.
However ...
THREAD:
This stat shocked me: Colorado now suffers about 4,000 wildfires a year. Everything from a small brush fire in the metro area to a huge forest fire in the mountains.
So what is starting these fires? Are they escaped campfires? Or lightning? Or arson?
I took the data directly from the federal source, and looked at it myself.
Not only was Colorado double the national average in nursing home deaths in Dec, but it was the
#1
state for deaths per bed between Thanksgiving and Christmas.
It started as a mystery in the news community. Top reporters and editors resigning one by one from The Denver Post. Where were they going?
Now we know:
I stumbled onto the AARP dashboard. It tracks federal data from nursing homes. I was shocked at what I saw.
The red line is Colorado. Purple is US average.
Even public health experts were shocked. Dr. Mark Johnson, the now former JeffCo Public Health director:
"These numbers, I have not seen these graphs before. And that is, that is rather startling."
So we decided to dig into how this happened. We spent more than $1,000 on records (thousands of page), spoke with dozens of experts, reviewed call recordings and transcripts not open to the public.
THREAD: Ever wonder why Colorado is so far behind on COVID-19 testing? A CPR News investigation found that the roots of the problem started back in March.
THREAD: The 10 year anniversary of the Aurora theater shooting is in a few months. Twelve people were killed. It's the first and only time I felt like I was reporting from a war zone. Survivors in shock, some covered in dried blood.
This is the story of what happened after...
For reasons that aren't totally clear Polis refused to move the counties for 15 days after that plea, despite the collapse of testing and contact tracing.
Polis would not talk to us. We asked him three times over several months.
So, let's go back to Oct 1. That was Lee Gonzales' birthday. And the last day she saw her husband alive. He was living in the Four Corners nursing home in Durango.
These are the hallmarks of virus containment. Test to identify positive cases. Find close contacts to limit the spread.
What Polis and his health department CDPHE didn't tell you was those systems were in collapse within weeks.
We obtained an Oct. 28 transcript of a call CDPHE had with local public health directors. Our attorney had to fight for it after CDPHE denied the recording.
The state lab was "largely maxed out." The state lab handled almost all nursing home testing.
As someone who primarily walks around Denver, I think only one of these things can be true: the report itself is BS or walkability in every city is in dire shape.
A week later, on Nov. 4, at another CDPHE/county call, the state dropped a bomb. Contact tracing was now overwhelmed. Rachel Herlihy, the state epidemiologist:
SHORT THREAD: When Gov. Jared Polis does a press conference lately, there’s always a question about if he’ll order people to stay at home again as COVID cases skyrocket.
It turns out county public health directors are asking the same question...
We examined four elections, the last two general (2016 and 2018) and last two primaries (both this year).
What we found was more than 100,000 rejected ballots. Enough uncounted votes to fill Mile High, Pepsi Center and have 5,000 in the parking lot.
CDPHE crammed that news into the last seven minutes of the call. Later that day, county public health directors were freaked out. On a call we obtained Joni Reynolds, the Gunnison County public health director, was emotional.
So, given all this new information, surely the state would start to lock down counties. But no.
By Nov. 4, JeffCo was in the "red," in terms of COVID cases, but CDPHE, in a letter signed by Jill Hunsaker Ryan the director thought that wasn't right...
Polis eventually put counties into a modified red level. And that worked, cases started to decline. But outbreaks at nursing homes had doubled in those 15 days of delay.
This came as a shock to the Durango public health officials. No boots on the ground help was on the way. On Dec. 15 Lee Gonzales got a call that he husband was dead.
24 people died at Four Corners, so many that the county coroner had to use a freezer truck to store the bodies.
Elections officials say voters can fix a signature that doesn’t match. And they can even do it on their phone. They have until 8 days after the election to do it.
But the vast majority of people do not cure their ballot. And so thousands of votes go uncounted.
And it was too late for the many nursing homes.
Also on Nov 20, an email came into the public health office in Durango. The Four Corners nursing home had its first case. Two hours later, the second. Within weeks nearly the entire facility was infected.
One more side note to this story: about halfway through the third wave, with the CDPHE's state lab overwhelmed, suffering it's own COVID outbreak, Colorado suddenly switched to an unproven, experimental testing provider called Curative.
Within days nursing homes were alarmed.
Back to the "strike force" for a moment. Force implies more than one person. But according to a Oct. 21 org chart, Myers was the only full time employee.
Young voters are most likely to have a ballot rejected for signature mismatch. More than 10x more likely than older voters.
Why? They have fewer signatures on file. And the top signature may be from DMV digital pad, which is difficult to match to their pen and paper signature.
The local public health department called CDPHE looking for help from the much-hyped "strike force" for nursing homes.
Polis had praised it as a national model. Turns out it wasn't a strike force at all ... according to the guy who leads it at CDPHE, Peter Myers.
Weld and Adams have significant differences in technology, budgets, and ... demographics.
Studies have found Hispanics have much higher rates of rejected ballots. And Adams has double the Foreign-born population of Weld.
Denver area mayors, 26 of them, sign a letter to Polis, urging him to do more to respond to COVID-19.
“...nine months into this crisis, there is widespread agreement that we must improve communication and coordination.”
We found that about 20 Colorado police departments, with a recent shooting, do not utilize body cams. Including Westminster PD, which had an unusually high rate of shootings.
Most large departments, like Denver, do use body cams. Some smaller PDs cite cost as a barrier.
The transparency piece is addressed in this bill, requiring cops to wear body cams and requiring that body cam videos get released within 14 days of an incident. This also requires that state officials track these incidents in a transparent way.
I called him up. We talked about how he was hiking and heard a gunshot, then saw smoke. Colton took detailed notes of his time out there.
Did an investigator ever call him?
A year after the largest fire in state history, no one bothered to ask him what he saw he says.
The state says their review of nursing home death data shows that the Curative test didn't cause excess deaths. But here's an email from a doctor Columbine Health Systems, which manages long term care facilities.
The problem was false positives. The state insisted that the test was the gold standard PCR and had emergency approval from FDA. Sarah Tuneberg, CDPHE's former testing lead in an email responding to concerns from nursing homes:
CDPHE state epidemiologist, Rachel Herlihy, decided to go off label and use Curative for asymptomatic use. Based, at least initially on 14 patients of data from the company.
Here's Herlihy on the Oct 28 conference call where CDPHE also said the state lab was overwhelmed:
The state talks often about the glowing reviews for its strike force. AARP and Polis called it a national model in a Nov 2 press conference. In May, Nathaniel Rateliff handed the strike force a good government award.
Nursing homes continued to complain about false positives. CDPHE knew this, because the emails made their way to Tuneberg, Herlihy and Emily Travanty at the state lab. Their conversations though are heavily redacted.
On this episode of perpetually dangerous Denver intersections: 19th & California, where the pedestrian signal rarely changes, forcing people to run across the street.
And if you look closely the pedestrian signal is flipping you off.
@DenPublicWorks
He's in Colorado hunting, sees smoke, calls it in. He took photos and video. He leaves his cell phone. I call him.
Not only has an investigator never called him. He wasn't even warned to get off the mountain. He escaped that night with flames all around him, he says.
NBA star Chauncey Billups endorses Mike Johnston for mayor.
“Way before this campaign, he was there for the people of Park Hill when it wasn’t common for politicians to reach out to us. His dedication to my neighborhood and to every family in every neighborhood is inspiring.”
We also found big disparities. First between counties:
Adams county in the 2016 election had a ballot rejection rate that was almost 3x that of Weld County. The counties border each other.
A lot of former candidates (and more) for mayor at Civic Center park to endorse Mike Johnston for mayor.
-Ean Thomas Tafoya
-James Coleman
-Julie Gonzales
- Terrance roberts
- Al Gardner
- Jim Walsh
CDPHE paid Curative about $90 million. The company rarely met the contract turnaround times of less than 48 hours. Here's an email from Four Corners nursing home in Durango.
No matter which way this vote goes, there’s no denying
@BenteBirkeland
’s reporting helped alter the course of an entire session and some
#coleg
member careers.
In 1974 a pair of Boulder bombings killed 6 Chicano activists.
Recently, CU & the city supported sculptures & scholarships in their honor, martyrs for the cause of equity on campus. Sometimes hinting they may have been killed by authorities.
The full story has never been told:
I use public records frequently, and Colorado is the toughest state I've ever worked in to obtain documents and data. Massive fees, recalcitrant govts, privilege claims.
So I'm a *little* surprised when I hear there's a CORA bill ... and it's adding MORE roadblocks.