Poet, novelist, radiologist.
THREE METAMORPHOSES (Orison Books), IN THE MOTHER TONGUE (Knopf), THE GREAT GAME (Acre Books), BOOK OF DISCOVERIES (Penguin India)
Stereotypes of past Brahmins as bookish, constantly memorizing Sanskrit, ritualistic turn out to be false once you study actual British census data. Over 50% tilled the soil; thousands left the Raj as indentured laborers. They were also listed among the "martial races of India."
Upanishads, Hindu epics, etc were written with no notion of any rival religion--or of any "other" religion at all. no attempt to set up a collective immune system or establish group identity. contrast the first commandment & verses against nonbelievers. explains a lot.
Tulsidasa (an Indian poet, contemporary with Shakespeare) founded a wrestling school that still exists to this day in the holy city of Varanasi
Like Plato, Tulsidasa didn't believe physical fitness and spiritual fitness were separate things
wasn’t going to write about this…but then the folks over
@timesofindia
reached out
Is it possible, I wondered, to zoom out and place this event in context, and write something clear-eyed and meaningful about it?
Here it is. Let me know what you think
Ireland provided half the white troops in British India (and a quarter of the officers in the British military overall). Include the Scots and you realize India, in one sense, was colonized by the colonized. The Raj was a release valve for the UK’s prospectless young men.
What does it mean to "restore" a long-ruined temple, especially in a place like Kashmir?
Here's my meditation on the past, present, and future of the Hindu temple--and the fraught relationship between archaeological preservation and religious revival...
“Decolonization” is impossible. There’s no reversing the arrow of time, no purification process & no purity. Absorb the strengths & slough the weaknesses that made them the colonizers & you the colonized in the first place, & give thanks your ancestral tradition survived at all.
I wrote for
@Openthemag
about what I call the Great Disillusionment--how and why Western intellectuals fell out of love with Hinduism, and what can be done about it. Towards the end, when speaking of a renaissance, I was thinking of artists like
@abhiart
Based on my studies of classical paganism and its destruction, linking the priesthood to the State is a disastrous move. Historically, this religion in particular has survived due to its decentralized nature. Hinduism must not give its enemies a single head to cut off.
Indian Purohit-Archaka Service (I.P-A.S): An Idea Whose Time Has Come?
Dharmic civil servants can create a vibrant and distinguished assembly of priests that reflect the rich tapestry of India’s social fabric
@arvindneela
@omarali50
Right. Mangal Pandey who set off 1857 was a Brahmin for example. Recent Indian rhetoric regarding this group has wandered far afield from the motley reality
Vijayanagar did not innovate, says Naipaul—its architecture & sculpture deliberately resurrected 500 year old precedents—much like modern Hindu temple architecture that models itself on the distant past. Much like Renaissance art mimicking the classical world. Revival is survival
The Vedic civilization left no temples because the sacred Agni (Fire) was a portable sacred space. Sometimes archaeologists point out the absence of temple-like structures in the IVC sites but they may not realize what that implies
What if the greatest epic poem of all time were so vast it would take years to work through it? What if it were written in a challenging language, thousands of years ago? What if modern retellings always shortchanged it in some way, either whitewashing its ambiguities--or
several free verse poems recently accepted by various poetry journals. secretly tho it's iambic pentameter with a few irregular linebreaks & substitutions thrown in there to make it look contemporary. STEALTH MODE
"In Cambodia, lidar [laser mapping] helped locate the ruins of the legendary city Mahendraparvata, soon to become a national park, and revealed that Angkor Wat was not an isolated ceremonial center but a sprawling metropolis the size of Berlin."
The name MAJMUDAR literally translates to 'record keeper' or 'archivist', from the Arabic language majmua (مجموع/মজমুয়া) 'collection' + the Persian suffix -dar (دار/দার) 'possessor'.
Indian historians who rely on the whole "It wasn't in any Sanskrit sources, so it never really happened" school of politically motivated whitewashing might do well to recall that no Sanskrit source mentions the invasion of Alexander the Great, either. did that never happen, too?
Beautiful—Tulsidasa’s Hanuman Chalisa in one image! Dear Twitter, does anyone here who the artist is? I want to post this with the appropriate and much-deserved credit
A single thread on x from
@vjgtweets
is worth the entire op-ed output of well known columnists
Follow him for cleareyed takes on issues facing the Hindu diaspora, Indian civilization and the propaganda wars against it, and the occasional foray into basketball & classical Greek
This is now a specific genre of criticism: Specifically, with respect to movies from/about/or set in India, the position that the inclusion of hindu themes/imagery is inherently hindutva-adjacent. We saw the same brain-dead critique with RRR. 1/n
Olympic medalist describes how the Gita fosters focus by foreclosing future-oriented thought (worry, uncertainty) and centering the mind on the action at hand. predisposes to entering the "flow state" common to artistic & athletic performance.
It’s happened twice now, one convo w/
@vjgtweets
and one w/
@vik1857
– literary festival records a live convo but then refuses to release it online (unlike other guests’) bc of India/Hinduism related ideas we think are obvious but they think are dangerous. Total narrative control.
I medaled! No, not in the Olympics…. TWIN A placed as a finalist in the Indie Book Awards Memoir category. Many thanks to
@SlantBooks
@Gregory_Wolfe
!
Get your copy here:
Something mysterious is happening in my reading life right now. Randomly selected or even browsed books are referring to one another, this is happening several times a day. Uncanny convergences far beyond the workings of chance. Something is about to happen.
Sanskrit “janma” and Greek “genesis” have a common Proto Indo European root, *gen-, related to birth/origin. In 1911 the same root gave birth to the modern word “gene”
Babur conquered India using European artillery he got third-hand from the Ottomans--the First Battle of Panipat had nothing to do with "prowess," just a classic case of taking advanced military tech into a virgin environment
@raagatodi
many paths were always present, but I am saying they were *written* without the notion of rival/other religion
tbh whether those rishis had a sense of "religion" at all (the way we use the English word today) remains something of a mystery to me, it is by no means certain
after extensive study years ago I concluded that the Sanskrit word "dharma" is interchangeable with no English word (not "religion," not "righteousness," not "duty") and when translating the Gita (Godsong, 2018) I didn't translate that word but used it as its own separate thing
Naipaul predicted, fifty years ago, that with the decline of British prestige, the Indian elites would next begin to mimic either the Russians or the Americans. We can see how that played out
@TiwariNivedita
this video shows us his ego-dissolution during his creative flow state--hence generations of the best Hindu temple and murti sculptors have been anonymous--unlike the great European sculptors (going back to Phidias) they did not sign their own transient names to the work
What is said of the Mahabharata in the usual descriptions--how it is very long, and full of digressions and treatises--always leave out how it is very tightly plotted, with everything interlinked across those vast stretches: vows & curses are fulfilled, identities revealed, etc.
METER WAS CREATED at the time of Creation itself, says the Rg Veda
And very early at that: Meter was created before the sun, the moon, or even people
Because metrical speech was the only kind acceptable to the ears of the Gods
You cannot communicate with the Gods in prose
On this Hanuman Jayanti, I am thrilled to announce a new book: The Later Adventures of Hanuman, forthcoming soon from
@PenguinIndia
. I have imagined a whole new mythological cycle for Hanuman—after Rama enters the Sarayu river, and the immortal Monkey is all alone….
Hong Kong, Mumbai, Singapore—astonishing how many major world cities were seeded in unpromising backwaters by the British Empire. Truly a pollinator nation
“Grendel and his mother were indigenous Britons, and Beowulf was a Danish imperialist whose legacy must be purged” may sound like a stretch, and just plain silly—but that is the level of discourse about Hindu epics that gets platformed in universities. I wish I were exaggerating.
One of the Ramayana's main themes is a rather unusual one in epic literature--intramarital true love. Valmiki emphasizes the parted couple's grief. In the Iliad, Menelaus seeks to recapture Helen, but neither the husband nor the wife actually miss each other.
Read this. Worth many a conventionally published think piece.
@vjgtweets
is the sharpest analyst of the Indian American predicament out there. A Naipaul for the social media age, as it were. Honored to call this guy a friend 🫡
@MythiliSk
Yes, I read your piece, and I've read countless others like it over the last decade. That Indian Americans are a "model minority" is not a myth, it's a statement of fact that is apparent to anyone who has taken even a cursory look at the community's social/economic outcomes in
Wilfrid Owen is a really good poet--so much more than the one poem everyone anthologizes
going to post some lesser known ones as I discover them
for now, this beautiful haunting string of consonantal semirhymes....
A distinctive trait of the Iliad, compared to epics from other traditions, is exacting anatomical descriptions of battle wounds--where the spear went in, where it came out. connects to the same culture's uniquely detailed sculptures of human bodies. You don't find this elsewhere.
Such a generous appreciation from Joe Hoover, S.J., the poetry editor of
@americamag
, a magazine which has welcomed poems for 114 years. This truly brightened my day—so unexpected, so kind. 🙏🏽✍🏼
Interestingly at the time of the Gita, only 3 Vedas existed. The Atharva Veda was unknown to Krishna, Rama, and the sages of the Upanishads. Reminds us that the most sacred and canonical things exist as living things in constant evolution and accretion
earliest strata of Valmiki’s Ramayana (earlier of the 2 Indian epics) dates roughly the same as Homer
Yet after the conquest of Lanka, there is no enslavement of the vanquished, no plundering. Rama puts Ravana’s brother on the throne
A different ideal of victory
Sanskrit first names that are so commonplace and used unthinkingly often have profound, abstract meanings, like Amit—Limitless, Ananth—Endless, Rupa—Form
Haven’t been to all the great places in North America yet, but so far the Canadian Rockies have given me the deepest feeling of a sacred landscape. I even saw ancient faces in the mountainsides, as here. (You may not see them, but I do.)
Shri Krishna on the nature of sacred offerings.
From “Nature/Worship: Dharmic Environmentalism in a Time of Climate Change,” in Black Avatar (
@acre_books
, 2023), available in the US here: