Brooklyn College/
@GC_CUNY
history professor.
Former Fulbright professor at
@telavivuni
Former track announcer at Scarborough Downs & the VT State Fair.
The campus environment created by the 2011 Dear Colleague letter has generated hundreds of lawsuits from accused students. In
@NYUJLPP
,
@samk_harris
& I analyze the resulting developmentsin federal courts:
Remarkable exchange:
@RepKiley
: If you were talking to a prospective Jewish student's family right now, could you look them in the eye and tell them that their son or daughter would be safe & feel safe & welcome on your campus?
Harvard pres. Gay won't give a yes-or-no answer.
Hamas just executed two Palestinians in the city of Tulkarem in the West Bank in accusation of collaborating with Israel.
They hung their bodies on an electricity pole for everyone to see and all gathered to picture it.
Hamas is responsible for killing thousands of Palestinians.
From Harvard Hillel: Wednesday classes disrupted by students with bullhorns chanting "globalize intifada" and "river to the sea."
Statement: "protests of this nature have become increasingly normalized on our campus."
Urges univ to enforce--as it hasn't done--its own rules.
Another example of the odd phenomena of Ivy League protesters who seem to believe they have a right to protest in public, but without anyone seeing who the protesters are.
Today, in my capacity as a reporter for
@PrincetonTory
, I covered a Pro-Palestinian Walkout on Princeton's campus. I stood at a distance, gathering footage and audio of the protestors, but protesters continued to stalk and harass me.
Striking deposition from
@Mizzou
TIX official--male student asking female student for a date (which she didn't want) violated TIX policy b/c male student in position of "power and authority" since he was physically larger.
And now a second message to the Harvard alumni list--this one from the incoming president--deeming today a "hard day": not because the Supreme Court found that the university had engaged in discrimination, but because the university no longer will be able to do so.
Just in: blistering, from Cal. appellate court, overturns lower court in
@ucsantabarbara
due process case: "It is ironic that an institution of higher learning, where American history and government are taught, should stray so far from the principles that underlie our democracy."
.
@DanaBashCNN
to Jayapal: "With respect, I was just asking about the women [who were raped], & you turned it back to Israel."
Jayapal's demand for "balance" is extraordinary--as Bash points out, no evidence exists of IDF soldiers raping Palestinian women.
Obviously a class element here, since it applies only to parents who were able to work from home. But Zoom allowed parents to get a sense of...fashionable...curricular trends that wouldn't have been possible pre-2020.
Not a good look for CUNY, to put it mildly.
(The memory-holed article celebrated the legal acumen of a 2015 Hunter grad, the daughter of two immigrants from the Dominican Republic, who had worked on the Depp case.)
Extraordinary statement, signed at moment by 75 full-time
@CUNY
faculty, describing the Hamas massacre of civilians as a "military operation":
"[T]here is also no equivalence between the October 7 military operation by Hamas [and] subsequent military attack by the Israeli state."
Obviously voting records aren't everything, but voting with Biden 100% of the time (per 538 tracker), including on all Biden nominees, is an unusual record for a straight-news story to describe as having taken a "hard turn to the right."
Once a staunch progressive, Arizona’s senior senator has taken a hard turn to the right. On the surface, that appears to have been an effort to make her more electable by courting moderate and conservative voters.
If so, she may have overcompensated.
And now the
@washingtonpost
, in almost 3000 words on the allegation against Biden, doesn't mention the standards Biden helped impose on college students, or criteria for addressing sexual assault allegations he articulated then, or in Kavanaugh hearings.
@jpodhoretz
Have listened to hundreds of hours of LBJ tapes. He could be coarse, sometimes extremely so (though he generally wasn't). But casual, off-hand racism? No. (Nixon, yes.)
The NYT's decision to contextualize its article through the Trump allegations--rather than Biden's own record & statements regarding the criteria for evaluating sexual assault claims--is hard to explain.
Four progressive teachers in Washington’s Mukilteo School District wanted to protect students from a book they saw as outdated and harmful. The blowback was fierce.
Stanford Law dean: "[W]e cannot function as a law school from the premise that appears to have animated the disruption of Judge Duncan’s remarks -- that speakers, texts, or ideas believed by some to be harmful inflict a new impermissible harm justifying a heckler’s veto."
Wow:
@RollingStone
co-founder on the retracted Sabrina Rubin Erdely
@UVA
article: other than its narrative spine, "the rest of the story was bulletproof."
A mindboggling statement on proposed TIX regs from
@aclu
. Cross-examination by a lawyer is "inappropriately favoring the accused"? Ensuring both parties have access to training materials and evidence?
Does the ACLU now adopt those positions more broadly?
It promotes an unfair process, inappropriately favoring the accused and letting schools ignore their responsibility under Title IX to respond promptly and fairly to complaints of sexual violence.
Simply extraordinary: when evaluating a claim of campus sexual assault--even if there are no witnesses other than the parties--19 Senate Democrats maintain a "live hearing and cross-examination . . . is wholly unnecessary to determine what happened in a particular incident."
Fascinating development in MO, where St. Louis County NAACP backs GOP-sponsored bill to make campus TIX procedures fairer. Org's head: "The denial of due process at Missouri's colleges disproportionately impacts African American men."
Remarkable exchange, in an excellent summary of the
#1619Project
's shifting thesis.
A reminder of how the Wayback Machine & YouTube complicate Pravda-like memory-holing of earlier arguments that no longer fit an amended official narrative.
Good profile of
@aaronsibarium
, who has broken more key stories on higher-ed--Stanford Law, Yale Law, Princeton, DEI matters--in the last18mos or so than virtually any other reporter, at any publication.
Long overdue: NC Gov. Roy Cooper pardons Darryl Howard, wrongly convicted of murder due, in part, to Mike Nifong (then an ass't DA in Durham) withholding exculpatory DNA evidence. The move allows Howard to receive compensation for being wrongly imprisoned.
Coverage of the CAIR head's celebration of October 7 in Fox, NY Post, National Review, Jewish & Israeli media--but so far nothing in NYT, Washington Post, Politico, CNN.
Ill-informed comments about policy from AOC are par for the course, but she might have found the time to read even one of the 150 university court setbacks on this issue before tweeting.
Hey Mr. President, remember when you bragged about sexually assaulting women, talking about feeling their breasts and genitals, because “when you’re a star they let you do it?”
And then you imposed DOE policies to make it harder for sexual assault survivors to report assault?
@jamestaranto
Here are internal Rolling Stone emails--first denying the need for any statement responding to critics, then trying to find a sympathetic MNSBC host to spin their failure.
Puzzling response to
@DavidAFrench
here. In 2006, a gang rape allegation at Duke was taken so seirously by "our culture" that the Duke adm/faculty & much of the national media rushed to judgment & accepted wildly implausible allegations as true.
A both-sides missive from the
@Columbia
dean to alumni and parents. (An unaware reader might believe that campus has been awash in Islamophobic rhetoric.)
A 21-year-old Israeli soldier was killed when he was struck in the head by a heavy rock as his unit was completing a nighttime arrest mission in a Palestinian village near Jenin, in the northern West Bank, the army said
Just remarkable.
@UMichiganNews
' Schlissel--who spent years fighting tooth & nail to uphold a TIX adjudication system multiple federal courts deemed unfair to acc'd students--is fired b/c of an inappropriate relationship with a subordinate.
Stanford antisemitism committee unanimously concludes: "antisemitism exists today on the Stanford campus in ways that are widespread and pernicious."
Also: "Whether one equates anti-Zionism with antisemitism by definition, these two biases are in fact closely intertwined."
@jessesingal
@mattyglesias
It's also very hard to imagine how abortion bans "disproportionately" harm the LGBTQ community. If anything, they should be less affected?
Perceptive from
@bariweiss
, on how the aftermath of Oct. 7. shows that abolishing DEI is the answer, "not for the Jewish community to plead its cause before the intersectional coalition, or beg for a higher ranking in the new ladder of victimhood."
@HotlineJosh
"One recent producer of the Oscars, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss confidential metrics, said minute-by-minute post-show ratings analysis indicated that 'vast swaths' of people turned off their televisions when celebrities started to opine on politics."
The Columbia antisemitism support suggests a deeply flawed campus culture: “One student captured more than 750 antisemitic online posts written by Columbia students and organizations.”
"Students reported being told 'Kill your fucking self. And I’ll fucking kill you.'”
Superb, from
@EmilyYoffe
on
@JoeBiden
: "If Joe Biden were a college student, [his actions]—ambiguous as those actions might be—could easily result in his being investigated by the Title IX office, and subjected to education-disrupting punishment."
Another remarkable exchange w/Harvard pres. Gay.
@RepStefanik
: did univ decline request to fly an Israeli flag after 10/7?
Gay: "standard protocol at the university for years" to only fly the US flag--only to concede after followup Q that Harvard flew the Ukraine flag last year.
From
@TheAtlantic
: "The videos show pure, predatory sadism; no effort to spare those who pose no threat; and an eagerness to kill nearly matched by eagerness to disfigure the bodies of the victims."
@MichaelSocolow
It's such an extraordinary change. And it creates a feedback loop of diminishing interest in foreign affairs; or approaching the topic only through a domestic partisan lens.
Eighteen full-time
@Princeton
faculty (all in humanities or related fields) pen open letter endorsing BDS, right of return. No condemnation of Hamas, or concern for hostages.
Seems to leave Dartmouth as only Ivy League school not to have an embarrassing faculty response to 10/7.
Fifteen years ago today, the Group of 88 released its statement about the Duke lacrosse case. The Duke profs affirmed that something "happened" to the accuser & told protesters-who had, among other things, urged the castration of the lacrosse captains-"thank you for not waiting."
Just in: In lawsuit against Cal. com. college DEI personnel requirements, magistrate judge R&R recommends granting preliminary injunction: DEI "undoubtedly is important" but Cal "regulatory scheme....is contrary to the First Amendment’s guarantee of freedom of speech" in academy.
"Lincoln is not someone that I typically tend to admire."
One after another, mindboggling responses by the head of the SF school board.
The indifference to factual accuracy--by someone setting education policy--is depressing.
Unanimous decision from 3-judge panel notes that absence of due process harmed both the acc'd and the accuser: "Notably absent was even a semblance of due process."
A depressing yet, as always from
@MattiFriedman
, perceptive exploration of a "core myster[y]" of October 7: "why an historic massacre of Jews, even before the Israeli response got underway, triggered a powerful wave of hostility not toward the attackers—but toward Jews."
Another
@Mizzou
TIX official suggests students unsure whether asking fellow student for a date could be a TIX violation could call the TIX office for "clarification"--before admitting that the office might not provide the necessary clarification.
The Alabama Law School story doubless would have played differently if Culverhouse, in his initial public statement, had admitted he demanded (in writing!) return of $10m b/c he wanted to dictate a hiring decision at the school.
Rematkable to see this news analysis passage in NYT, which for years has downplayed the issue: "All three institutions have in recent years punished or censored speech or conduct that drew anger from the left." Piece also notes FIRE's rankings & quotes
@1AMorey
on univ hypocrisy.
Of all the things we've seen on campus since Oct. 7, this is the one reaction that didn't even seem conceivable. Similar videos, obviously, at NYU, Baruch, Penn, VCU. It's hard to process the cruelty.
Greatest anger from
@sarahjeong
on Rolling Stone/UVA () reserved for the *journalists* from
@washingtonpost
&
@Slate
whose work exposed the hoax.
Her response to their journalism: "Fuck 'Slate is vindicated.'"
This admission--in a piece that's sympathetic both to Hannah-Jones and the
#1619Project
--is utterly damning.
Again: the Times has pushed the Project for use in HS curricula. & what can the Pulitzer board members who ignored Hahn's cautions now be feeling?
An Orwellian conception of "civil rights," to describe a figure who spent four years in office aggressively weakening accused students' procedural protections.
BREAKING:
@SenSchumer
just moved forward on the nomination of Catherine Lhamon to serve as assistant secretary for civil rights at the Department of Education.
We strongly urge all senators to support students’ civil rights by voting to
#ConfirmLhamon
to lead
@EDcivilrights
.
Remarkable quote on campus free speech from head of ACLU's free speech project, in detailed
@powellnyt
piece on the ACLU.
"'FIRE does not have the same tensions,' Mr. Wizner said. 'At the A.C.L.U., free speech is one of 12 or 15 different values.'"
More from the memory-holed article--which is filled with tips for other CUNY students who might want a future in law, but was removed, it seems, because of protests about the CUNY grad's client.
The limit of the "believe all survivors" ideology has apparently been reached: when video & medical evidence corroborates the allegations, but the victims are Israeli.
In the "mattress girl" case, Paul Nungesser "vehemently denied" Emma Sulkowicz's allegation. A one-sided TIX adjudication couldn't find enough evidence to sustain the claim. The NYPD didn't pursue charges.
Gillibrand's response? "I believe Emma."
The dean's "partial facts" claim would be more tenable if (a) there wasn't audio of the YLS student's exchanges w/the diversity bureaucrats; and (b) there wasn't subsequent reporting by
@TheFIREorg
&
@DavidLat
raising additional concerns w/how YLS acted.
Heather Gerken, the Dean of Yale Law School, has emailed the entire law school about my story last week. She suggests our reporting was based "on partial facts" and announces that she has asked Deputy Dean Ian Ayers to "assess the situation."
Powerful, in
@TheAtlantic
, from
@conor64
on ACLU & new TIX regs: "The ACLU issued a public statement that constituted a stark, shortsighted betrayal of the organization’s historic mission: It vehemently opposed stronger due-process rights for the accused."
Striking aside in this (v. well-reported) CNN piece on Harris: "And implicit racism and sexism have been constant."
The only evidence in article seems to be two quotes from Harris aides. Plausible theory, but shouldn't reporters include evidence for such a provocative claim?
Diversity statements in faculty hiring positions are troubling enough.
Brown is proposing adding a diversity statement to Ph.D. applications as well.
cc:
@JohnDSailer
Stanford official: university procedure allowing students to file anonymous complaints against fellow students is intended to help everyone get along. Remarkable.
Not the usual message from a major university president in today's environment:
"The goal of a public research university...is to open the minds of our students, expose them to different perspectives and beliefs...That doesn’t happen in an echo chamber."
104 House Democrats sign letter to DeVos denouncing new TIX regs for allowing hearings w/x-exam by a lawyer, who could be a "criminal defense lawyer." Representatives claim that such a policy "flies in the face of common decency."
A remarkable assertion.
Stanford Law Students trying to parse the merits of "the vast majority of students' shouting" is quite a line of defense.
(The praise of the DEI dean's "care and compassion" would work better if there was no video of her intervention.)
As w/Biden in the aftermath of the Reade allegation, I suspect that Cuomo will quickly set aside the one-sided approach to such claims he imposed on NYS college students now that he faces an allegation himself.
That
@ACLU
teamed with a prominent accusers' rights group in its lawsuit to block the new TIX regulations speaks volumes as to the organization's concern (or, in this case, lack thereof) w/due process on campus.
That even Bernie Sanders is significantly more pro-Israel than the dominant student & faculty opinions we've seen on most elite campuses since 10/7 gives a sense of just how ideologically isolated on Israel elite campuses remain.
Bernie Sanders on Face The Nation:
“I don’t know how you can have a permanent ceasefire with Hamas who has said before October 7 and after October 7 that they want to destroy Israel and they want a permanent war. I don’t know how you have a permanent ceasefire with an attitude
The obvious Q: as this statement anticipates add'l allegations, through what procedures does Biden think they should be evaluated? Should, for instance, the same guilt-tilting approach he's championed for accused college students should apply to him?
Unanswered Q in
@NewYorker
piece: why, right after so many Israeli civilians were murdered, did the Harvard statement ringleader "rush[] to her friend’s apartment, still in pajamas, to compose 'an emergency statement' on behalf of Palestinian allies on campus"?
Excellent piece from
@sullydish
: "The problem with defending due process in a case like Biden’s [is]...Biden himself...You can listen to Biden’s strident speeches and rhetoric on this question and find not a single smidgen of concern with the rights of the accused."
Harvard president Gay issues her second clarifying statement on her House testimony: “Substantively, I failed to convey what is my truth.”
(The "my truth" was a nice touch.)
Oh dear. I’m speaking at Lewis & Clark Law School tomorrow at noon. Several student groups are planning to protest the presence of a “known fascist” on campus. Demanding my invitation be rescinded. Wish me luck.
"Factual, accurate journalism that is written, edited, and published in accordance with Times standards does not create a hostile workplace."
Very strong letter--and lots of top-flight Times journalists signed onto it.
Beyond 20% of 18-29yos who agree that the Holocaust is a myth, *another* 30% neither agree nor disagree.
So half of 18-29yos (at minimum) aren't certain the Holocaust occurred.
Hard to imagine that lots worry that admitting the Holocaust occurred is somehow sympathizing w/Israel.
Quite extraordinary, from J. Ginsburg. Have to imagine this rhetoric will find its way into some of the campus due process complaints & perhaps even a decision or two:
.
@RepJimBanks
: why did Penn invite Roger Waters to speak?
Pres. Magill: Antisemitism has no place at Penn.
Banks: Why did you invite Roger Waters?
Magill: Antisemitism has no place at Penn.
Banks: Why did you invite Roger Waters?
Magill: Antisemitism does not have a place at Penn
Quite an exchange yesterday b/w Judge Lewis Kaplan and Columbia's lawyer, on the Dear Colleague letter: "somebody, with a different sort of backbone than I understand Columbia had at the time" could have simply said no to the Obama-era OCR's demands.