Standing Up, Standing Out: This
#Diwali
, we asked reporters what is unique about writing for Article 14.
Help us spread the light. Subscribe or gift a subscription to support independent journalism that functions without fear or favour.
“With just 1 toilet for 125-150 inmates, smell of their sweat & urine mixed with heat due to electricity cuts makes life a living hell here:” Kafeel Khan, jailed under the NSA for 157 days now. “Usually entire night is spent sitting, waiting for morning.”
In jail for 42 days,
#NodeepKaur
came to India’s attention after
@meenaharris
tweeted about her. The Dalit labour organiser’s story reveals govt crackdown on young, educated workers demanding legal rights amidst India’s economic decline
@anumayhem
reports
96% of sedition cases filed against 405 Indians for criticising politicians & govts over the last decade registered after 2014: 149 accused of making “critical” and/or “derogatory” remarks against
#Modi
, 144 against
#Yogi
: Our new database, launched today
Facing 14 cases,
#Bihar
's Hemant Kumar is in jail since March. He exposed a
#Maoist
surrender as fake, police paraded him with a sign around his neck calling him a molester. Our story on
#NitishKumar
govt's war on
#RTI
& murder of 17 activists
Police in
#Tripura
registered an FIR & did not allow reporters
@Samriddhi0809
&
@Jha_Swarnaa
to leave their hotel early this morning after
@VHPDigital
complaint against them, after they reported the burning of a mosque, contradicting police &
#BJP
claims
Around 95 people, mostly
#Muslim
, have been arrested in
#Khargone
in connection with the violence where private property, a mosque and vehicles were set ablaze.
#MP
govt demolished properties mostly belonging to Muslims, to recover damages from rioters the next day
Aliya Asadi, 17,
#Karnataka
state karate gold medalist, went to nationals 5 yrs ago, sole
#Muslim
contestant with a
#hijab
. Udupi teen is among those at centre of
#hijabrow
, now has trouble sleeping, parents say she cries in sleep
@afra_abubacker
reports
For 30 yrs,
#SudhaBharadwaj
helped Adivasis win back land illegally taken over, workers to get dues. She taught law, addressed judges, was invited to be a high court judge. Today, she’s been in jail 2 yrs without trial, reports
@ChitrangadaC
A bunch of accounts has been withheld by
@TwitterIndia
based on a "legal demand" that has not been made public. Among the accounts is
@thecaravanindia
, the first media account to be so blocked. Others include accounts tweeting about
#FarmersProtest
& those of writers & bloggers
6
#Hindus
calling on video for
#murder
, violence in
#Delhi
, get bail in < 2 months; 15 anti-CAA
#Muslim
protesters, accused in
#Delhi
riots on similar charges—but scant evidence—denied bail for 13 to 21 months.
@kaushikrj6
tracks 4 cases of unequal justice
Indore police chief praises Hindu vigilantes for being “active & alert”, tells
@kunalpurohit
"it didn’t really matter" if comic
#MunawarFaruqui
& 5 friends made no jokes about Hinduism. Police base case on rehearsal jokes vigilantes claim they overheard
In the past 2 years, journalists in Kashmir have been: Detained without warrant, sometimes at gunpoint; interrogated for hours; raided; threatened/slapped by police for reporting facts; charged with the
#UAPA
; monitored/profiled by security agencies. They share their worries.
"He was beaten. Then, later on, he was mocked. Nobody was there to ask about his well-being"
A neighbour told
@vipulizm
&
@kaushikrj6
that Mohammad Ishaq, 22, was killed on suspicion of stealing a banana from a Ganesh mandap on 26 Sept.
.
@free_thinker
says whether
@zoo_bear
& he win the Nobel Peace Prize or not, the attention they have received raises the profile of fact-checkers & foregrounds the misinformation crisis they are battling in India.
@jyotiithakurr
&
@HananZaffar
report. 1/2
#UP
‘bans’ pvt labs from testing, restricts hospitals, refuses to accept CT-scan as proof. But unless deaths are certified
#Covid19
+ve, they don’t count. “So, we are forced to write viral pneumonia in death certificates,” local doc M Sharma to
@ashubh
As
#sudhabharadwaj
completes 900 days in jail without trial,
#NIA
description of her as shadowy leader of banned Maoist party, smuggling arms, planting booby traps, contrasts sharply with her life of public service among India’s most exploited people
“When children hear of such acts it will have a positive impact. They will think not all Hindus are a certain type or Muslims a certain type. That’s all I want, I just hope a little change happens in society”:
#AkshayYadav
on offering his property for Jumma
#Namaz
in
#Gurugram
"I used to eat biryani, I will eat khichdi. If I don’t have money at least I will be able to eat khichdi"
#MunawarFaruqui
tells
@kunalpurohit
. Six of the stand-up comic's shows have been cancelled after Hindutva groups reportedly threatened the organisers.
On 18 Sept we ran a story about police intimidating some Twitter users in Kashmir. The next day, our reporter was summoned by police of the cyber wing, slapped & intimidated for over 5 hrs. His account
“It’s my right, whenever I want I will wear a hijab and whenever I want to remove it I will remove it.” Aliya, a protesting
#Muslim
student from
#Udupi
,
#Karnataka
, who has been kept out of class for 20 days by the school administration.
96% of sedition cases filed against 405 Indians for criticising politicians & govts over the last decade registered after 2014: 149 accused of making “critical” and/or “derogatory” remarks against
#Modi
, 144 against
#Yogi
: Findings of our new database
Article14 addresses threats to & failures of justice in India; we track successes & discern patterns in the justice system. Welcome to a pioneering effort between lawyers, journalists & academics.
“If a Muslim wants to offer namaz on open land, there is an FIR, but the majority religion can do it without persmission”
@MRShamshad
on how the rights of minorities are being subjugated to cater to majoritarian sentiments
#newIndia
. Watch:
“We thank all who helped us but not the PM…it was his responsibility, his duty, There will be no thank you to Modi or his govt.” Ruldu Singh Mansa, member of core team Sanyukt Kisan Morcha, state pres of Punjab Kisan Union and nat pres of All India Kisan Mahasabha. By
@iyerkavi
We stand by our story. The SP, quoted in the story, has not pointed to any inaccuracy, except the original photo, apparently of an older office of the cyber cell. Intimidating journalists is hardly professional or legal & only proves the point of the story
#JournalismIsNotACrime
Today, a UP advisory board confirmed detention of Dr Kafeel Khan under the NSA, law meant to control terrorists. Legally, a rash driver is more of a threat to public order than the doctor who has endured 3 jail spells totalling nearly a year: our analysis
Bail plea of
#UmarKhalid
, in jail for 38 months, moved from Justice A S Bopanna's bench to Justice Aniruddha Bose's bench to Justice Bela Trivedi's bench—violating SC rules & convention
@OfficialSauravD
reports how 7 sensitive cases moved to her bench
“I have loved this country so much but it did not love my brothers Junaid & Faizan when they needed it. Why should I prove my love? Why can't India prove it loves me?” Hate hunter
@alishan_jafri
to
#PriyaRamani
on Muslims’ changing relationship with India
5 journalists, 4 of them Muslim,1 on assignment for
@Article14live
, have been taken by police to the Mukherji Nagar police station in Delhi after a mob at
#Hindu
#dharamsansad
(for which the police had declined permission) discovered their religion, attacked them & deleted videos
“The plan is on. This time he will be totally circumcised… he'll need a pipe to urinate:” Threats to
@zoo_bear
after he busts fake news about
#Bihari
migrant murders in TN. Others warn of “Akhlaq-like” action, “lone-wolf” attacks.
@alishan_jafri
reports
"He is very strong & spirited. He still has faith in the judiciary even though we feel hopeless and exhausted"
Relative of Mahesh Raut, youngest
#BhimaKoregaon
detainee, who completes 5 yrs in jail without trial today
@ChitrangadaC
's July 2020 profile
1/5
To study religious bias in rental markets, Housing Discrimination Project interviewed 340 brokers, tenants & owners over 3 yrs. They found rampant exclusion of
#Muslims
in India’s top cities, writes Mohsin Alam Bhat, law professor &
@article14live
editor
“This year, I have been dragged to police stations & courts for doing my job of asking questions. And this is the experience of many journalists like me”
@prajwalmanipal
on being a journalist in
#Karnataka
&
#NewIndia
at a time of declining media freedom
Multiple fractures. Torn toe nails. Psychological distress. Over 40 days,
#ShivKumar
—visually challenged colleague of labour organiser
#NodeepKaur
—“mentally & physically abused in the police (sic) remand”: report from govt doctors. By
@anumayhem
While
#MunawarFaruqui
was released on 7 Feb, 2 friends—Nalin Yadav & Sadakat Khan, languish in prison 53 days after their arrest. Their crimes unclear, evidence non-existent , arrests have plunged their families into turmoil.
@kunalpurohit
reports
"It is learned that
#MunawarFaruqui
is a controversial figure as he was been (sic) in controversial statements and on other religion Gods. Many states have banned his comedy shows..."
Instead of assuring security
@BlrCityPolice
"suggest" organisers cancel today's comedy act
Wrongfully arrested when 16, Mirza Nisar Hussain, 40, of Srinagar,
#Kashmir
, can’t find a job, received no compensation & is desperate to begin life anew after 23 years in prison--and a year of freedom that meant nothing. He tells
@MaqboolMajid
his story
Spate of online death threats & suggestions on how to murder
@zoo_bear
after leading Indian fact-checker calls out fake news about fatal attacks on Bihari migrant workers in
#TamilNadu
. Police unaware of threats.
@alishan_jafri
reports
A man who once campaigned against hatred has spent a year in jail, defending himself in three cases, including
#Delhiriots
conspiracy case, as he recovers from legs broken in custody.
@betwasharma
on story of Khalid Saifi
Delhi police use of sedition law against climate activist
#DishaRavi
violates clear
#SupremeCourt
guidelines & a judge’s action in granting police custody without hearing her lawyer violates spirit of the law, legal experts tell
@mohitmrao
Nalin Yadav was arrested in same case as
#MunawarFaruqui
, on statement by Hindu vigilante that he joked about 'pre-marital sex'. Bail rejected 3 times, he's been in jail 54 days. His teenage brother has taken part-time job to pay legal costs
@kunalpurohit
“Religion can give you an identity, it can't fill your stomach, get you a hospital bed or
#oxygen
cylinder, or help get the unemployed a job. Sooner rather than later people realize this:"
@srinivasiyc
to
@javedmansari
on
#Covid19
as political leveller
Charged with sedition, national security act, jailed 3 times, spent 133, 90 days in jail, freed by courts. Now Manipuri journalist Kishorchandra Wangkhem who runs FB show on freedom of speech is 1st Indian to receive notice under new digital media rules
"This is my 4th summer in prison, but the heat this time is unbearable..."
Read
@banojyotsna
's
#fieldnotes
on a frustrating conversation with activist
#UmarKhalid
about how inmates are coping with record heat conditions inside prison
A Bhil Adivasi, he was raised in a shack by a single mother, a farm labourer. Today
@IASRajBharud
is a doctor, running a remote, tribal district that has a nationally replicable template to address
#India
’s dire
#OxygenShortage
, reports
@ChitrangadaC
"The case against me was a lie, baseless & fictitious...I was kept without food & water for 5 days & tortured...I would like to thank the
#UP
special task force for not killing me in an encounter while bringing me from Mumbai to Mathura."
#KafeelKhan
after release from jail
Communal violence in
#Karauli
,
#Rajasthan
, on 2 April during
#Ramnavmi
followed familiar script: incendiary slogans by
#Hindu
extremists before a mosque, stone throwing, rioting, allegations of partisan police action
@arbabali_jmi
reports.
Police of 2 states & 4 magistrates violated a series of guidelines laid down by the
#SupremeCourt
, when
@zoo_bear
was called for questioning in a case in which he was protected from arrest, then held in another case, then 2 more.
@areebuddin14
reports. 1/5
As
#Modi
breaks silence on
#COVID2019india
-linked
#Islamophobia
, our investigation of 22 days of fake-news frenzy reveals how it began with his govt—which continues religious profiling—& cascaded into hate speech & crimes against Muslims.
6 years after the
#MP
police accused 17 Muslim men of celebrating Pakistan winning a cricket match, a court found the case was fabricated,
@KashifKakvi
&
@rishavtwts
report. The Hindu complainant & witnesses said they were forced to give false statements.
“I have worked as an
#anganwadi
worker for 28 years. Now, in this old age there is no pension or benefits I can receive. One day they just kicked me out saying I am uneducated and I can’t work anymore": Retired anganwadi worker protesting outside
#Delhi
@ArvindKejriwal
residence
#Delhi
Police probe into
#DelhiRiots
is criticised by one of India's most famous officers: Julio Ribeiro.
What we had found: evidence mainly limited to ordinarily inadmissible confessions; riot victims as accused; & incitement by BJP leaders ignored.
“If govt cannot stop
#lynchings
, they should remove all judges, close all courts and police stations, hand over power to vigilantes & ask them to govern”
A teacher, cousin of one of 2
#Muslim
youth found in burnt car, to
@meerfaisal01
&
@vipulizm
. Watch:
"You should say action should be taken against those who made the video viral”
“You don't want anything but peace"
In
#Muzaffarnagar
,
@kaushikrj6
&
@vipulizm
saw a reporter trying to tutor father of
#Muslim
boy, slapped by classmates on teacher's urging
Nisara Begum, 67, a
#Kashmiri
sweeper, has been paid Rs 25/month for 2 decades, unpaid for 7 yrs, keeps working for 2 reasons: to provide for her daughter & her commitment to keep a school clean. There are thousands like her.
@Sajidraina1
@basheer_seerat
From remote forest villages, thousands of Adivasis walk, some for 15 hrs, to a protest site in south Bastar, month after 3 were killed in police firing. There’s no electricity, scant phone signals, no
#Twitter
mobilisation or celeb support, reports
@ashubh
“Once a Muslim becomes the prime minister, in the next 20 years, 50% Hindus will convert”: Yati Narsinghanand speaks to attendees at the Hindu
#mahapanchayat
at
#Delhi
's Burari Ground on 3 April, flouting bail orders.
@arbabali_jmi
reports
When family of dead are
#Covid
positive & no one can perform last rites, Imdad Imam & friends give them dignified farewells in
#Lucknow
, regardless of religion,
@inker_salik
brings you stories of citizens filling
#India
's governance gaps
#CovidEmergency
"Every person has the right to free expression. He is trying to show that victim needs justice.. is that a crime in eyes of law?" --CJI U U Lalit
After 711 days,
#SiddiqueKappan
gets bail.
@MuhemmadSabith
&
@tarushi_aswani
examined his alleged crimes
Plan for 100-bed
#Delhi
govt hospital in Muslim-dominated Okhla cleared in 2007 was upgraded to 460 beds but never built. Meanwhile, 3 non-Muslim areas whose hospitals plans evolved 5 yrs after Okhla's have running hospitals:
@arbabali_jmi
&
@NehaWaila
When Dipika, with
#Covid
symptoms, went into labour & a hospital refused admission, panicked husband tweeted for help. Seva Sisters calmed him, found a gynec, hospital. At 9.30 pm that night, a healthy baby boy was born
@inker_salik
on citizens stepping up
"Jhoota hain ye"
Farmers at Tikri Kalan protest site on the furthest reaches of a west Delhi metro line celebrate, but tell
@iyerkavi
they
won’t return to their villages. Nobody trusts
#Modi
govt & want more clarity on parliamentary process before they leave
The Rs-35,000 Maulana Azad govt fellowship that Shamsher Singh, son of a Punjabi Sikh daily wage worker, received every month did more than fund his PhD. It threw a lifeline to his penurious family. All this has now ended. Follow this THREAD
1/12
Over a decade ago, 3,000 families in
#Odisha
stopped govt takeover of their land for S Korean steel company. 5 yrs later, govt to hand over same land to
@jswsteel
.
@spriyaranjan1
finds people exhausted by struggle, arrests, loss of successful betel farms
"My daughter told some people at the market that she was hungry. They gave us two jackfruits. That’s what we have.” Mohammed Kolimuddin, who lost his house in the
#AssamFloods
, told
@H_Mahibul
that his family was starving, but no govt relief had arrived.
Aligarh student
#SharjeelUsmani
not present at anti-
#CAA
protest for which he was arrested in Dec 2019, was not arrested from site, no illegal material recovered & he has no criminal record, his lawyer tells judge, who released him after 56 days in jail
A tale of 2 journalists: Kerala journo
#SiddiqueKappan
in jail for 41 days, his bail plea adjourned again by
#SupremeCourt
, after being adjourned for a month earlier.
#ArnabGoswami
, in jail for 7 days, was heard, given bail in a day, writes
@zaidwahidi
Indian embassies & consulates increasingly tasked with monitoring & stopping entry into
#India
of those who criticise or even tweet against
#Modi
, his govt &
#Hindutva
. Overseas Citizen cards cancelled, others blacklisted, reports
@VijaytaL
3 years & 3 months after arrest,
#UmarKhalid
is jailed without bail or trial. His bail petition, listed 10 times in 8 months, bounced b/w different
#SupremeCourt
judges
@betwasharma
reports on the year he was not heard by
#India
’s highest court.
2 FIRs; called by police 6 times; detained twice; anticipatory bail 3 times; bail denied in new case. “Every time I write something, I imagine I am in court, facing a judge:”
@tkwmag
editor
@pzfahad
to
@iyerkavi
as
#Kashmir
media crackdown goes national
“It’s absurd. You're a poor country & you're charging highest (prices) from your people. It makes absolutely no sense to me how these prices are being determined & why the government is helplessly watching:”
@sujakrao
ex India health secy to
@swagata_y
1/5
Chief Justice N V Ramana retires on 26 Aug, delivering during his tenure 29 lectures on guarding/improving
#India
’s laws &
#Constitution
. Yet, as
@OfficialSauravD
’s analysis found, he did not walk his talk, providing no hearings for vital cases. 1/11
"They tortured my husband. Whoever we phoned, they did not respond nor did anyone come [to our help]" 20 years since the
#Gujaratriots
, Zakia Jafri, widow of ex Congress MP, Ehsan Jafri, recounts the horrors she witnessed while hiding in her balcony.
A Muslim teen has now been 38 days in jail after he was beaten, arrested under
#UP
's
#lovejihad
law for walking with a Hindu friend. He will appear before a court in Bijnor tomorrow.
@Saurabhsherry
on how such cases collapse, but UP files them anyway 1/5
On 6 Nov, oldest accused in
#bhimakoregaon
case,
#StanSwamy
, 83, requested special
#NIA
court in Mumbai for a straw & sipper because his hands were unsteady from Parkinson's disease.
Court gave prosecution 20 days to respond.
@ChitrangadaC
's profile
“The plan is on. This time he will be totally circumcised… he'll need a pipe to urinate:” Threats to
@zoo_bear
after he busts fake news about
#Bihari
migrant murders in TN. Others warn of “Akhlaq-like” action, “lone-wolf” attacks.
@alishan_jafri
report
Muslim truck driver lynched in Bihar's Saran district on Wednesday.
In April, lawyer Savita Ali spoke to
@meerfaisal
&
@ubairulhameed
on unchecked anti-Muslim violence: "...it happened in Nalanda today, tomorrow it could be Patna & then somewhere else."
“We can even tolerate the abuses, but they beat him so badly he couldn’t even sit or stand on his own. They have done this to all detainees,” Sarfaraz, brother of arrested youth, Bilal, on the police brutality detainees faced in custody
@arbabali_jmi
reports
Hindu extremists hold 12 events over 24 months in 4 states calling for
#Muslim
#genocide
, insurrection, plan more. Events face no hindrance, police see no conspiracy, main instigators are free:
@kaushikrj6
&
@alishan_jafri
's connect the dots police do not
Police collected transport details of both reporters, insisted on
#Aadhar
, ostensibly to provide "security", but when they tried to check out, they were told FIR had been filed. They missed their flight, finally were allowed to leave but told to return to
#Tripura
...
Wasim, 17, sang ‘Jana Gana Mana’ & ‘Vande Mataram’ at school daily. But
#DelhiPolice
beat, abused & forced him & 4 other Muslims to sing national anthem to ‘prove’ patriotism. Despite viral videos, police FIRs name 'unknown persons'
@betwasharma
reports
On 7 Dec 2023, the Jammu & Kashmir High Court quashed the preventive detention of Aasif Sultan, the longest imprisoned
#Indian
#journalist
. Sultan has been in jail for > 5 yrs.
The court called the detention order “illegal & “unsustainable”
THREAD
1/7
Cofounder of
@AltNews
arrested by
#DelhiPolice
@iyerkavi
on how
@zoo_bear
—who brought global attention to the abuse of Islam’s Prophet by
#BJP
spokesperson—faced 5 cases, latest for referring to 3
#Hindu
extremists booked by police as ‘hate-mongers’
“This is their (Muslims) country too. India is everyone’s. It’s good when we live together. Why can’t we coexist?”
#Hindu
toy vendor to
@geevishnu
at
#Karnataka
temple fair where
#Muslim
vendors are now banned—at a temple founded by a Muslim 800 yrs ago